IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2013-404-5022 [2014] NZHC 968
BETWEEN CHRISTOPHER HORTON
Applicant
AND
BRIAN PATRICK COWLEY and GARTH WILLIAM COWLEY First Respondents
CALVIN BLAKLEY WEST Second Respondent
BRIAN PATRICK COWLEY Third Respondent
BRIAN COWLEY SURVEYING LIMITED
Fourth Respondent
On thepapers: 9 May 2014 Appearances:
K T Glover for the Liquidator
R S Pidgeon for Second Respondent, C B West
E J Werry for First, Third and Fourth RespondentsJudgment:
9 May 2014
COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL
This judgment was delivered by me on 9 May 2014 at 4:30pm
pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
...................................
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Solicitors:
Dukesons Business Law (Steven Dukeson), Auckland, for Liquidator
Simpson Dowsett Mackie, Auckland, for First, Third and Fourth RespondentsPidgeon Law, Auckland, for Second Respondent
Counsel:
R S Pidgeon, Auckland, for C B West, Second Respondent
E J Werry, Auckland, for Cowley interests – First, Third and Fourth Respondents
K T Glover, Auckland, for Liquidator
HORTON v COWLEY and WEST [2014] NZHC 968 [9 May 2014]
[1] Following my decision of 31 January 2014, the liquidator and the Cowleys have filed submissions as to costs. In my decision I fixed the liquidator’s remuneration and expenses and ordered the Cowley interests to make a top-up payment. I also gave directions for Mr Horton to pay Mr West for his claim in the liquidation. I made no orders for costs for or against Mr West. I held that the Cowley interests were entitled to costs against Mr Horton, but did not fix costs.
[2] The Cowley interests have separately sought an order for costs against Mr West. They say that my decision that no order should be made for or against Mr West applies only in respect of the contest between the Cowleys and the liquidator, but does not apply to other issues in contention between them and Mr West. This decision does not deal with that matter.
[3] The Cowleys calculate total costs of $39,969.00 under category 2. They have provided separate calculations for the scales in force before and after 13 June 2012. They also claim increased costs under r 14.6 by way of an uplift of 50 per cent. Their disbursements come to $6,968.50.
[4] In reply, Mr Horton first submits that there should be no order for costs but that costs should lie where they fall. He also takes issue with some parts of the costs claimed by the Cowleys and with one of the disbursements.
[5] As to there being no order for costs, that submission invites me to revisit my decision that the Cowleys should have costs against the liquidator. I held that as the Cowleys had succeeded, they were entitled to costs under r 14.2(a).1 Mr Horton has not raised any sound basis for reconsidering that finding. In particular, no grounds for recall have been made out. My decision that the Cowleys should have costs still
applies.
1 High Court Rules r 14.2(a).
[6] Whereas the Cowleys…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Horton v Cowley and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 968
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the Cowleys were entitled to costs against Horton, as they had succeeded in the proceedings. The court allowed the Cowleys 5.4 days for costs up to 13 June 2012, fixing costs at $10,152.00. For costs after 14 June 2012, the court allowed 7 days, fixing costs at $13,930.00. The court rejected the application for increased costs under rule 14.6, stating that the litigation arose out of mistakes made at the outset, and that an unsuccessful applicant ought not to be ordered to pay increased costs simply for error of judgment in starting a proceeding. The court also rejected the claim for increased costs on account of the way the litigation was conducted, stating that there was an element of chance in the outcome of the proceeding. The court awarded the Cowleys disbursements of $6,968.50.
The court awarded the Cowleys costs against Horton in the sum of $24,082.00 plus disbursements of $6,968.50, a total of $31,050.50. The court disallowed certain costs claimed by the Cowleys, including appearances on specific dates and the preparation of a bundle for the hearing. The court also disallowed the costs for preparing a memorandum of costs and the preparation of submissions at a specific time, as those matters were covered by the costs award made in a previous minute. The court allowed the claim for 2 days for further evidence, stating that it was not unusual for parties to be put to extra preparation when a case is adjourned part heard. The court also rejected the application for increased costs under rule 14.6, stating that the litigation arose out of mistakes made at the outset, and that an unsuccessful applicant ought not to be ordered to pay increased costs simply for error of judgment in starting a proceeding. The court also rejected the claim for increased costs on account of the way the litigation was conducted, stating that there was an element of chance in the outcome of the proceeding.