McCaig v A Professional Conduct Committee

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-001541 [2016] NZHC 306

IN THE MATTER OF

an appeal pursuant to Section 106(2) of the

Health Practitioners Competence
Assurance Act 2003

BETWEEN

TEMALESI SENITOVU MCCAIG Appellant

AND

A PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT COMMITTEE

Respondent

On the papers

Counsel

A H Waalkens QC for Appellant
D La Hood for Respondent

Judgment:

29 February 2016

JUDGMENT No 2 (Costs) OF PALMER J

This judgment was delivered by me on 29 February 2016 at 4:30 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           McBride Davenport James, Wellington (P McBride) Luke Cunningham & Clere, Wellington

McCaig v A Professional Conduct Committee [2016] NZHC 306 [29 February 2016]

Summary

[1]      Dr   McCaig   appealed   the   penalty   imposed   upon   her   by  the   Health Practitioners  Disciplinary  Tribunal.     The  parties  cannot  agree  on  the  costs implications of my judgment of 4 December 2015.1     The judgment resulted in a material reduction in the penalty.  I order costs in Dr McCaig’s favour.

Law Relating to Costs

[2]      Costs follow the event – a losing party pays a winning party a contribution towards their legal costs.   This is established by Rule 14.2(a) of the High Court Rules which provides that “the party who fails with respect to a proceeding or an interlocutory application should pay costs to the party who succeeds”.   It is characterised by the Supreme Court as a “fundamental principle”.2

[3]      Here, Dr McCaig claims to have been successful and to deserve a costs award on a 2B basis (and indeed a further award for this further round of argument).  The Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) claims to have been partially successful so that costs should lie where they fell.   Both parties cited the Court of Appeal’s judgment in Packing in Ltd (in liq) formerly known as Bond Cargo Ltd v Chilcott (“Bond”).3   There, the Court dealt with a case “where in broad terms each party has

had  similar  success”  and  set  out  the  factors  relevant  to  awarding  costs.4      The

Supreme Court has also found that a party which is successful in its submissions on the law but loses on the application of the law to particular facts may have had “a measure of success” meaning costs should not be awarded against it.5

[4]      The question of who has won and who has lost litigation is not always straightforward.   As with other costs issues the answer to this question is at the

discretion of the court (r 14.1) guided by the somewhat amorphous test of “the

1      McCaig v Professional Conduct Committee [2015] NZHC 3063.

2      Manukau Golf Club Inc v Shoye Venture Ltd [2012] NZSC 109, [2013] 1 NZLR 305 at [8].

3      Packing in Ltd (in liq) formerly known as Bond Cargo Ltd v Chilcott (2004) 9 NZCLC 263, (2003) 16 PRNZ 958 (CA).

4      Above n 3, at [5] and [6].

5      Environmental Defence Society Inc v New Zealand King Salmon Company Ltd [2014] NZSC

167.

interests of justice”.6    Since…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCaig v A Professional Conduct Committee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 306
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr Temalesi Senitovu McCaig appealed the penalty imposed on her by the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, and the matter came before Palmer J in the High Court of New Zealand. The primary issue before the court was the determination of costs implications following the judgment reducing Dr McCaig’s penalty. Dr McCaig sought a costs award on a 2B basis, arguing she was successful in achieving a significant reduction in her penalty, while the Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) contended for a costs order where it lay, considering itself partially successful. The court considered the principles of costs following the event, where the unsuccessful party generally pays the successful party's legal costs, and the nuanced balance between success on the merits and the interests of justice.

The court examined the extent of Dr McCaig’s success in the appeal, noting her achievement of an increased credit for a four-month suspension period and a reduction in the award of costs from $15,000 to $5,940. Despite not succeeding in quashing her suspension or fine or obtaining name suppression, the court found that the material reduction in penalty constituted a significant success for Dr McCaig. The court emphasized that while the PCC performed a public function, this did not override the principle that costs follow the event, particularly when the appellant achieved a material reduction in penalty. The court concluded that Dr McCaig was the successful party in the appeal, and thus, costs should be awarded in her favour.

In the end, the court awarded costs to Dr McCaig on a 2B basis for the substantive appeal and an additional $1,000 for the costs judgment. This decision underscores the importance of the extent of success in appeals of penalties for professional misconduct and reinforces the principle that costs should follow the event, even when considering the public function performed by the PCC. The court’s reasoning highlights the need for a realistic appraisal of the end result in determining the prevailing party in such cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.