C & S Kelly Properties v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-001273 [2017] NZHC 1583

BETWEEN

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION First Defendant

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED Second Defendant

Hearing: 26, 27, 28 and 29 June 2017

Counsel:

N R Campbell QC and A J D Ferguson for Plaintiff B A Scott and N J Bruce-Smith for First Defendant C R Johnstone for Second Defendant

Judgment:

10 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF FAIRE J

This judgment is delivered by me on 10 July 2017 at 10.45 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Grant Shand, Auckland for Plaintiff

Chapman Tripp, Wellington for First Defendant

Wynn Williams, Christchurch for Second Defendant

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LTD v EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION & ANOR [2017] NZHC 1583 [10 July

2017]

CONTENTS

Para
BACKGROUND 1
THE JURISDICTIONAL BASIS FOR THE SECOND HEARING 5
The ruling setting out the basis for jurisdiction 7
Reasons for the jurisdiction ruling 9

The Doctrine of Issue Estoppel and its application to Mander J’s

judgment

23
Estoppel 1 and Estoppel 2 28
Estoppel 3 34
Estoppel 4 39
Estoppel 5 43
Estoppel 6 48
PRINCIPAL ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED IN THIS HEARING 51
DETERMINING THE SCOPE OF WORK 52
EXPERT EVIDENCE 54
Mr. Kearney’s evidence 54
Mr. Kearney’s proposed scope of work 81
Option 1 81
Option 2 83
Mr. Day’s evidence 85
Mr Davey’s evidence 95
BURDEN OF PROOF 103
STANDARD OF REPAIR 109
General Principles 110
NZS 3604 114
MBIE Guidance 121
Functionality, aesthetic quality and amenity value of the house 124
ANALYSIS 129
Assessing the merits of Mr. Kearney’s design 129
Estoppel 134
Assessing the merits of Mr. Davey’s and Mr Day’s strategy 140
CONTINGENCY 153
CONCLUSION 157
FINAL JUDGMENT 159
FURTHER CONFERENCE 162

Background

[1]      The  plaintiff  company  owns  a  home  at  2B  Vivian  Street,  Burwood, Christchurch.  It was the home of the shareholders and directors Suzie and Cameron Kelly (the Kellys). They lived there until the 22 February 2011, the time of the second Christchurch earthquake. Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited (Southern Response) insured the Kellys’ home.   It was also insured by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (the Act).

[2]      The Kellys’ home was damaged by the September 2010 and February 2011

Canterbury earthquakes.   Disputes arose between the Kellys, EQC and Southern Response as to the extent of the earthquake damage and as to the appropriate scope and cost of reinstatement. There was also a dispute as to whether EQC was entitled to settle the Kellys’ claim by undertaking reinstatement of the earthquake damage as opposed to making a payment.

[3]      The Kellys commenced this proceeding.  In it they sought a money judgment from both EQC and Southern Response. The proceeding was heard by Mander J who delivered a reserved judgment on 22 July 2015.  He concluded that save for the cost of releveling the floor the plaintiff is entitled to judgment for $53,768.50. He held that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C & S Kelly Properties v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1583
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a dispute between the plaintiff, C & S Kelly Properties Limited, and the Earthquake Commission (EQC) and Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited regarding the scope and cost of repairing earthquake damage to a residential property in Christchurch. The property was damaged in the 2010 and 2011 Canterbury earthquakes. The plaintiff sought a money judgment from both EQC and Southern Response for the cost of repairs. The case was initially heard by Mander J, who determined that the plaintiff was entitled to a monetary award of $53,768.50, with an option to require EQC to undertake the repair work. However, due to another earthquake in 2016, Mander J recused himself from completing the case.

The case was then heard by Faire J, who was tasked with determining the scope of work and cost to return the floors to the condition required under the Act and/or policy. Faire J issued a ruling setting out the basis for jurisdiction and the issues to be resolved. The court considered the doctrine of issue estoppel, which precluded the plaintiff from arguing certain points that had already been determined by Mander J. The court also assessed the expert evidence provided by three engineers and determined the burden of proof and standard of repair.

After evaluating the evidence and arguments presented, Faire J concluded that the defendants' proposed strategy was the most appropriate scope of work to relevel the house and achieve the required standard of repair. The court found that the defendants' strategy complied with the Building Code and addressed the overall and localised dislevelment, providing a durable outcome that restored the functionality, aesthetic quality, and amenity value of the house. Faire J also determined that an allowance for contingencies in relation to the scope of work was appropriate and set the cost at ten per cent.

The final judgment, incorporating the results of both Mander J's judgment and Faire J's conclusion on the special question, determined that the total cost of remediation, including GST, was $126,852.50. This amount did not exceed the EQC cap, resulting in no monies being payable by the second defendant. A telephone conference with counsel was scheduled to address any remaining areas of disagreement and to determine the form of judgment to be sealed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.