Shirley v Wairarapa District Health Board

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 10/2006
[2006] NZSC 63

BETWEENALAN JOHN SHIRLEY


Appellant

ANDWAIRARAPA DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD


Respondent

Hearing:1 June 2006

Court:Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath and Anderson JJ

Counsel:C J Hodson QC and C W James for Appellant


M G Ring QC for Respondent

Judgment:23 August 2006 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.          THE APPEAL IS DISMISSED.

B.The appellant must pay costs in this Court in the sum of $15,000 and reasonable disbursements.

REASONS

(Given by Anderson J)

Introduction

[1]       Mr Shirley, a surgeon employed by the Wairarapa District Health Board, carried out a vasectomy on a Mr Bensemann.  The vasectomy failed.  Mr Bensemann and his wife then sued the Board, claiming it was liable for negligent advice given to them by Mr Shirley when they were contemplating the operation.  The Board, with the consent of the Bensemanns, had Mr Shirley joined as a defendant and then cross-claimed against him.  The Board’s purpose in having Mr Shirley joined was:[1]

to bring Alan [Shirley] in and then to explore a settlement directly with the Bensemanns.  This would leave the case to continue against Alan without the hospital’s involvement.

[1] Noted in an email from the Board’s solicitors to Board members and forwarded to Mr Shirley    on 7 November 2002.

[2]       Several months later, before the case came to trial, the Bensemanns settled with the Board for $20,000 and filed a notice of discontinuance against it.  The Board filed a notice of discontinuance in respect of its cross-claim. The discontinuance against and by the Board does not affect the determination of costs.[2]  Mr Shirley consented to the discontinuances, but specifically reserved his position against the Board should he be unsuccessful at trial.  There was no reservation expressed in relation to a successful defence.  He went to trial and successfully defended the Bensemanns’ claim. 

[2] High Court Rules, r 476A(2).

[3]       The Bensemanns were legally aided and Mr Shirley has not been able to recover his costs from them.  He sought them instead from the Board.  His application related to costs he incurred after the discontinuances.  Whether the Board should be required to contribute to Mr Shirley’s costs is the principal issue in this appeal. 

[4]       Costs calculated in accordance with the High Court scale 2B amounted to $34,691.55 and Mr Shirley sought an order for 50% of that sum.  The trial Judge, Miller J, awarded 30%, which amounts to $10,407.47, plus disbursements.[3]  The Board appealed to the Court of Appeal which by a majority[4] allowed the appeal.[5] Leave to appeal to this Court was granted on the ground of whether the Court of Appeal should have differed from the High Court’s discretionary decision.  That will require an examination of the reasons of each of the Courts below.

The insurance arrangements of the parties

[3] HC WN CIV 2001-435-019 9 March 2005.

[4] Baragwanath and Heath JJ, Robertson J dissenting.

[5] (2005) 18 PRNZ 34.

[5]       The dispute is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shirley v Wairarapa District Health Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZSC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Shirley v Wairarapa District Health Board, the Supreme Court of New Zealand considered the issue of costs incurred by a surgeon, Mr Shirley, who was joined as a defendant in a medical negligence claim by the Board. Mr Shirley successfully defended the claim but sought costs from the Board, which had settled with the plaintiffs before trial. The principal issue was whether the Board should contribute to Mr Shirley's costs. The trial judge awarded Mr Shirley 30% of his costs, a decision that was appealed and subsequently reversed by the Court of Appeal. The Board's appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed.

The legal issues the court had to decide included the relevance of the insurance arrangements between the Board and Mr Shirley, the appropriateness of awarding costs against a party that was not unsuccessful in the litigation, and the proper exercise of discretion in awarding costs. The court found that the trial judge erred in several respects: he incorrectly attributed causation of Mr Shirley's costs to the Board, failed to consider the insurance arrangements, and departed from the principle that costs should follow the result.

The court held that an award of costs involves a principled discretion, not an arbitrary one. The discretion must be exercised in accordance with the rules of reason and justice, and generally in line with established principles such as the one in rule 47(a) of the High Court Rules, which states that the party who fails should pay costs to the party who succeeds. The court found that the Board's tactical decision to join Mr Shirley as a defendant did not warrant a departure from this principle. Moreover, the insurance arrangements were relevant as they represented an agreement that Mr Shirley would meet his own costs through insurance cover paid for by the Board. The court concluded that the Board should not be required to meet a cost for which it had already provided indemnification.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and ordered Mr Shirley to pay costs in the sum of $15,000 and reasonable disbursements. The decision underscores the importance of adhering to established principles in exercising the discretion to award costs and highlights the relevance of insurance arrangements in determining cost liabilities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established