McNamara v Auckland City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 85/2010
[2012] NZSC 34

BETWEEN  PETER HARDIE MCNAMARA AND PATRICK STURGEON MCNAMARA AS TRUSTEES OF THE P H MCNAMARA FAMILY TRUST
Appellants

AND  AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:         19 April 2011

Court:             Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath and William Young JJ

Counsel:         B O’Callahan and G S G Erskine for Appellants
D J Goddard QC and M A Cavanaugh for Respondent

Judgment:      9 May 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellants are to pay the respondent costs of $25,000 and reasonable disbursements in connection with this appeal, as fixed by the Registrar if necessary.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Para No

Elias CJ  [1]
Blanchard, McGrath and William Young JJ  [110]
Tipping J  [172]

ELIAS CJ

  1. The appeal arises from summary dismissal of a claim before trial.  The claim was brought by the appellants, as purchasers of a new house in Arney Crescent, Remuera, against the Auckland City Council for breach of duties of care said to have been owed to them by the Council in relation to non-compliance with the building code in the construction of the house.  The house failed to meet the weather-tightness standard of the building code, standard E2.  It required expensive work to prevent leaks and remedy damage caused by moisture.  The statutory duties which provide the background to the claimed duty of care are ones imposed upon territorial authorities by the Building Act 1991.  The Act has now been repealed,[1] but was in effect at all material times and its provisions are the context in which the question of duty of care falls to be considered.[2] 

    [1] By the Building Act 2004, s 415(1).

    [2]      The Act was repealed from 31 March 2005.

  2. As the Act permitted, the developer of the property had chosen to use a private certifier authorised under the Act to certify that the plans and specifications conformed to the code, to inspect and certify building work as code compliant, and to provide a final certificate of code compliance on completion of the building work.  In those circumstances, the territorial authority was relieved of the statutory responsibility of itself inspecting the property and certifying for code compliance (although if notified that a certifier could not carry out the functions of inspection and certification, it was required to take them over).  The territorial authority was obliged to accept the certificate of the certifier that the work complied with the building code, and had immunity for liability for its own actions taken in reliance on such certificate. 

  3. The certifier engaged by the developer was Approved Building Certifiers Ltd, which is referred to throughout as “ABC”.  It is not disputed that ABC was authorised under the Act to certify compliance with standard E2, the general weather-tightness standard under the code, when it certified in support of the application to the Council for a building consent that the house would comply with the code if…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McNamara v Auckland City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZSC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McNamara v Auckland City Council involved an appeal by the appellants, Peter Hardie McNamara and Patrick Sturgeon McNamara, as trustees of the P H McNamara Family Trust, against the Auckland City Council regarding a claim for breach of duties of care in relation to non-compliance with the building code in the construction of a new house. The house failed to meet the weather-tightness standard of the building code, requiring expensive work to prevent leaks and remedy damage caused by moisture. The Supreme Court of New Zealand, in a unanimous decision, dismissed the appeal, finding that the Auckland City Council did not owe the appellants a duty of care in the circumstances of the case. The Court held that the statutory scheme of the Building Act 1991, which has since been repealed, did not impose a duty of care on the Council to check the scope of the authority of a private certifier engaged by the developer to certify compliance with the building code. The Court also found that the Council's reliance on the certificate issued by the private certifier was protected by the good faith defence under the Act, and that the appellants' claims based on negligent misstatement and other grounds were also unsuccessful. The Court ordered that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of $25,000 and reasonable disbursements in connection with the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants, Peter Hardie McNamara and Patrick Sturgeon McNamara as trustees of the P H McNamara Family Trust, purchased a new house in Arney Crescent, Remuera, from the developer Carmel Properties Limited. The house was constructed by the developer and certified by Approved Building Certifiers Ltd (ABC) as compliant with the building code. The appellants claim that the house did not meet the weather-tightness standard of the building code and required expensive work to remedy leaks and damage caused by moisture. They brought a claim against the Auckland City Council (the Council) for breach of duties of care, alleging that the Council failed to ensure compliance with the building code in the construction of the house. The Council had accepted certificates from ABC that the house complied with the building code. The appellants argue that the Council knew or should have known that ABC had exceeded its authority in issuing the certificates.

The matter was initially heard in the High Court, where Associate Judge Christiansen declined the Council's applications to strike out the proceedings and for summary judgment. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal by the Council, striking out the claims and entering summary judgment in favour of the Council. The appellants appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand, which heard the appeal on 19 April 2011 and delivered its judgment on 9 May 2012.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Council owed the appellants a duty of care to ensure compliance with the building code in the construction of the house.
2. Whether the Council's acceptance of certificates from ABC that the house complied with the building code constituted a breach of the alleged duty of care.
3. Whether the Council's advice to the appellants that a code compliance certificate had been issued amounted to negligent misstatement.

Held
1. The Court held that the Auckland City Council did not owe the appellants a duty of care to ensure compliance with the building code in the construction of the house.
2. The Court held that the Council's acceptance of certificates from ABC that the house complied with the building code did not constitute a breach of the alleged duty of care.
3. The Court held that the Council's advice to the appellants that a code compliance certificate had been issued did not amount to negligent misstatement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the statutory duties imposed on territorial authorities by the Building Act 1991 and the role of private certifiers in certifying compliance with the building code. The Court determined that the Act permitted territorial authorities to rely on certificates issued by private certifiers and that such reliance was consistent with the statutory scheme. The Court held that the territorial authority's statutory responsibilities did not include monitoring the scope of a certifier's authority or intervening unless notified by the owner or certifier of any issues. The Court found that the Council's actions in accepting the certificates and providing advice were in accordance with the statutory scheme and did not give rise to a duty of care. The Court also considered the common law duty of care and the statutory immunity provisions, concluding that the Council's actions were protected by the good faith defence under the Act. The Court further held that the appellants' claims were unsuitable for summary judgment and should proceed to trial to determine the facts and knowledge of the Council. The appeal was dismissed with costs.