Bropho v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bropho v Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission [2002] FCA 1510

HUMAN RIGHTS – application for review – publication of cartoon – uncontested findings of offensive behaviour – application of exemption – protecting certain forms of freedom of expression– no error of law in application of reasonableness and good faith test – no failure to take into account various matters

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5, 5(1)(e), (f) and (h), 5(2), 5(3)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) ss 18B, 18C, 18C(2)(a), 18D, 18D(a), (b) and (c), 18D(c)(ii), 25X

Racial Hatred Bill 1994 (Parliament of Australia, Senate Hansard, 28 November 1994, 3277)

Bryl & Kovacevic v Nowra & Melbourne Theatre Company (1999) (Commissioner Johnston, 21 June 1999, Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission) referred to

Western Aboriginal Legal Services v Jones (2000) NSW ADT 102 referred to
Re Dalton [1963] 1 Ch 336 referred to
Australian Postal Corporation v Pac-Rim Printing Pty Ltd (1999) 163 ALR 372 referred to
Cannane v J Cannane Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (1998) 192 CLR 557 followed
Re Tabrisky; ex parte The Board of Trade [1947] Ch 565 referred to
Re Boyce and Registrar of Firearms (1999) 55 ALD 319 referred to
Jones v Scully [2002] FCA 1080 referred to
Vines v Djordjevitch (1955) 91 CLR 512 considered

ROBERT CHARLES BROPHO v HUMAN RIGHTS & EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION and WEST AUSTRALIAN NEWSPAPERS LIMITED
W163 of 2001

RD NICHOLSON J
4 DECEMBER 2002
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W163 of 2001

BETWEEN:

ROBERT CHARLES BROPHO
APPLICANT

AND:

HUMAN RIGHTS & EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

WEST AUSTRALIAN NEWSPAPERS LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

RD NICHOLSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 DECEMBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for review of the decision of the first respondent constituted by Inquiry Commissioner G Innes made on 12 April 2001 be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the second respondent’s costs of the review.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W163 of 2001

BETWEEN:

ROBERT CHARLES BROPHO
APPLICANT

AND:

HUMAN RIGHTS & EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

WEST AUSTRALIAN NEWSPAPERS LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

RD NICHOLSON J

DATE:

4 DECEMBER 2002

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application to review a decision of the first respondent (“the Commission”) constituted by Inquiry Commissioner G Innes (“the Commissioner”) made on 12 April 2001.  In that decision the Commission dismissed the complaint made by the applicant and others (constituting the Nyungah Circle of Elders) against the second respondent pursuant to the provisions of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (“the RDA”). The applicant claims to be aggrieved by the decision of the Commission because he has suffered distress and hurt by the publication of a cartoon which was the subject of the complaint in question and in relation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bropho v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1510
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bropho v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, the dispute centred around a cartoon published in a newspaper that was alleged to have breached racial discrimination laws. The case was brought before the court to review a decision made by the Commissioner of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. The primary legal issues addressed by the court involved whether the publication of the cartoon was exempt from the provisions of the Racial Discrimination Act (RDA), specifically under sections 18C and 18D. The court had to determine if the exemptions outlined in section 18D were applicable to the cartoon, and whether the publication was made in good faith and reasonable circumstances.

The court meticulously analysed the evidence presented, particularly the testimony of Mr. Murray, the editor of the newspaper at the time, who had approved the cartoon for publication. The Commissioner had found that although the cartoon breached section 18C, it was exempt under section 18D because it was published in good faith and for a reasonable purpose. The court examined the Commissioner's findings and reasoning, focusing on whether the exemption criteria were correctly applied and if the Commissioner had properly considered all relevant factors. The court held that the Commissioner had adequately assessed the circumstances surrounding the publication and correctly applied the relevant legal provisions.

Concluding that the Commissioner's decision was neither an improper exercise of power nor based on an irrelevant consideration, the court dismissed the application for review. The court found no merit in the arguments that the Commissioner had failed to appropriately consider the exemption criteria or the good faith and reasonableness of the publication. The court confirmed that the Commissioner had correctly applied the law and that the decision to dismiss the complaint was justified.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the application for review of the Commissioner’s decision and to require the applicant to pay the costs of the review to the second respondent. This decision upheld the Commissioner’s dismissal of the complaint and affirmed the application of the Racial Discrimination Act in the context of the cartoon's publication.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review of the decision of the first respondent constituted by Inquiry Commissioner G Innes made on 12 April 2001 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the second respondent’s costs of the review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Commissioner concluded that whilst he was satisfied that the publication of the cartoon was in breach of s 18C of the RDA the complaint was not made out because of his findings in relation to the application to some of the exemptions set out in s 18D. Accordingly he dismissed the complaint.Evidence of Mr Murray The “Mr Murray” referred to in the reasons of the Commissioner was at the time of the publication of the cartoon the editor of the newspaper of the second respondent with responsibility for all editorial content in the newspaper (so found by the Commissioner). From among the paragraphs descriptive of his evidence in the Commissioner’s reasons the following too require repetition here:“He gave evidence that the newspaper had published articles on Yagan’s head prior to the publication of the articles referred to in the proceedings. He said that he intended the paper to look deeply into the divisions in the Aboriginal community, an issue in which he had background knowledge. He wanted to pursue the various associations claimed with Yagan. He co-wrote the editorial of 27 August 1997 and it expressed his views. His view was that the return of Yagan’s head was a crucial issue for Aboriginal people and for all West Australians. Mr Murray said that the disputation within the Aboriginal community in WA was damaging to the prospects of its return.The cartoon was the regular Saturday cartoon of Dean Alston. Mr Alston rang the witness on the Thursday night prior to publication and discussed the idea for the cartoon. Mr Murray said that he told Mr Alston that it would be “very controversial” and asked him to discuss it again the following day. On Friday, Mr Murray looked at the draft sketches and had another discussion with Mr Alston. He told the Commission that he said to Mr Alston that there would be some “flak” over the cartoon. However, he formed a view that the cartoon was a valid comment on recent events and when he was presented by Mr Alston with the final version, he approved it for publication.”In making findings of fact the Commissioner said in respect of Mr Murray’s evidence:“I accept the evidence of Paul Murray, confirmed by the complainants, that much material relating to the return of Yagan’s head had been published in The West Australian in the few weeks prior to the publication of the cartoon. The people referred to in the cartoon had been referred to on previous occasions. Some litigation had occurred regarding the matter, and the preparations for and trip of the delegation had received much publicity. The West Australian had, editorially, recognised the importance of the return of Yagan’s head as a means of unifying the Aboriginal community, and had been critical that its return had become the subject of further division.”Grounds of review The first ground of review is directed to the finding by the Commissioner that the second respondent “acted reasonably and in good faith”. The thrust of the ground is that the Commissioner should have found that the requirement for something to be said or done reasonably and in good faith was a positive requirement and not equivalent to a lack of finding of bad faith. Furthermore it is contended there was a failure to make findings or an absence of evidence to establish that those aspects of the cartoon which were offensive, insulting, humiliating or intimidating were said or done reasonably and in good faith.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner considered that the concept of a report would not include a cartoon so that this exemption would not apply. In the absence of any evidence in relation to the maker of the cartoon, no consideration was given to the application of the exemption contained in s 18D(c)(ii). He nevertheless set out views concerning his interpretation of the subsection. Commissioner’s conclusion The Commissioner concluded that whilst he was satisfied that the publication of the cartoon was in breach of s 18C of the RDA the complaint was not made out because of his findings in relation to the application to some of the exemptions set out in s 18D. Accordingly he dismissed the complaint.Evidence of Mr Murray The “Mr Murray” referred to in the reasons of the Commissioner was at the time of the publication of the cartoon the editor of the newspaper of the second respondent with responsibility for all editorial content in the newspaper (so found by the Commissioner). From among the paragraphs descriptive of his evidence in the Commissioner’s reasons the following too require repetition here:“He gave evidence that the newspaper had published articles on Yagan’s head prior to the publication of the articles referred to in the proceedings. He said that he intended the paper to look deeply into the divisions in the Aboriginal community, an issue in which he had background knowledge. He wanted to pursue the various associations claimed with Yagan. He co-wrote the editorial of 27 August 1997 and it expressed his views. His view was that the return of Yagan’s head was a crucial issue for Aboriginal people and for all West Australians. Mr Murray said that the disputation within the Aboriginal community in WA was damaging to the prospects of its return.The cartoon was the regular Saturday cartoon of Dean Alston. Mr Alston rang the witness on the Thursday night prior to publication and discussed the idea for the cartoon. Mr Murray said that he told Mr Alston that it would be “very controversial” and asked him to discuss it again the following day. On Friday, Mr Murray looked at the draft sketches and had another discussion with Mr Alston. He told the Commission that he said to Mr Alston that there would be some “flak” over the cartoon. However, he formed a view that the cartoon was a valid comment on recent events and when he was presented by Mr Alston with the final version, he approved it for publication.”In making findings of fact the Commissioner said in respect of Mr Murray’s evidence:“I accept the evidence of Paul Murray, confirmed by the complainants, that much material relating to the return of Yagan’s head had been published in The West Australian in the few weeks prior to the publication of the cartoon. The people referred to in the cartoon had been referred to on previous occasions. Some litigation had occurred regarding the matter, and the preparations for and trip of the delegation had received much publicity. The West Australian had, editorially, recognised the importance of the return of Yagan’s head as a means of unifying the Aboriginal community, and had been critical that its return had become the subject of further division.”Grounds of review

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the course of oral argument it was accepted by counsel for the applicant that this aspect was really part of the good faith argument previously addressed. Furthermore, it was not separately developed in oral argument. Additionally, I do not accept that in the Commissioner’s reasoning in relation to par (b) of s 18D he failed to take into account that he had previously made findings that aspects of the cartoon were unlawful within the proscriptions of s 18C. He related the view he reached to his consideration of the requirement of reasonableness and good faith in which those considerations had played a part. Improper exercise of power: failure to take into account relevant consideration Finally it is contended in the grounds that the relevant consideration not taken into account by the Commissioner was that the content of the cartoon was severable into parts some of which may have been for a genuine purpose in the public interest and parts which were not and that if there were parts which were not for a genuine purpose in the public interest, the exemption in s 18D did not apply. The subparagraphs of s 18D are required to be applied in respect of the thing said or done. It is all the circumstances in relation to that thing which are required to be taken into account in the application of the subparagraphs. The findings of the Commissioner necessarily meant he had taken into account, in the course of this reasoning, the adverse findings following from the application of s 18C. In the application of the subparagraphs of s 18D he was not required to separately isolate those findings to parts of the thing said or done. He was required to take into account those adverse findings and it is clear that he did so. The whole purpose of his consideration of the public interest issue was to consider whether the particular subparagraphs of s 18D involving that test were satisfied so that an exemption in respect of such conduct would be applicable. Conclusion For these reasons I consider that none of the grounds of the application have been made out and the application should be dismissed.