Auckland City Council v McNamara

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA457/2009
[2010] NZCA 345

AND BETWEEN             AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL
Appellant

ANDPETER HARDIE MCNAMARA AND PATRICK STURGEON MCNAMARA AS TRUSTEES OF THE P H MCNAMARA FAMILY TRUST
Respondent

Hearing:19 May 2010

Court:Hammond, Arnold and Baragwanath JJ

Counsel:D J Goddard QC and M A Cavanaugh for Appellant
B O'Callahan and G S G Erskine for Respondent

Judgment:3 August 2010 at 9.30am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed.

B        Summary judgment is entered in favour of the appellant.

CThe respondents must pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements in the Court of Appeal.

DThe respondents must pay the appellant costs on a 2B basis and disbursements in the High Court.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Baragwanath J)

[1]       This is a leaky building case, concerning the liability of the appellant territorial authority where an independent building certifier has purported to certify compliance with the building code made under the Building Act 1991.[1]  The building certifier, although duly appointed and authorised to certify compliance with a broad range of building work, could certify compliance with the Building Code’s external moisture provisions only if the building complied with Approved Standard E2/AS1, which the respondents say it did not.  Is there a residual liability on the authority under the principles stated in Invercargill City Council v Hamlin[2] and Sunset Terraces[3] for negligence in the inspection or otherwise?

The scheme

[1]      Now repealed.

[3]      Sunset Terraces [2010] NZCA 64.

[2]       The Act forbade the performance of building work except in accordance with a building consent issued by the territorial authority.[4]  All building work was required to comply with the building code.[5]  Once it was completed the owner was required as soon as practicable to advise the local authority of that fact.[6]  The Act contemplated that a satisfactorily completed building would be the subject of a code compliance certificate (CCC) issued to the owner.[7]

[4]      Section 32(1).

[5]      Section 7(1).

[6]      Section 43(1).

[7]      Section 43.

[3]       The Act provided two alternative means by which a CCC could be obtained.  One was by paying the authority its charge for satisfying itself that the building work complied with the building code and so should receive a CCC, in which case the CCC was issued by the authority.  In such case it was the responsibility of the authority to exercise reasonable care to satisfy itself that issue of the CCC was justified.  That would require it either to carry out its own inspections or to receive from a building certifier building certificates vouching for the due performance of the work.   In the latter event the italicised portions of s 50 applied:

(1)  A territorial authority shall accept the following documents as establishing compliance with the provisions of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Auckland City Council v McNamara and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZCA 345
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Auckland City Council, the appellant, appealed against the decision of the High Court, which refused to strike out a claim against it by Peter Hardie McNamara and Patrick Sturgeon McNamara as trustees of the P H McNamara Family Trust, the respondents, in negligence. The respondents had purchased a property that leaked and sought to recover their loss from various defendants, including the appellant Council. The property had been built by a developer who had engaged Approved Building Certifiers Ltd (ABC) to inspect and certify the property. The BIA had restricted ABC’s ability to certify compliance with the Building Code, but ABC had certified that the cladding system complied with Approved Standard E2/AS1 when, according to the respondents, it did not. The respondents sought to recover the loss they incurred in repairing the property. The Council contended that it was not liable for the certifier's actions. The appeal raised two issues: first, whether the certifier’s certificate was invalid; and second, whether the statutory scheme required the Council to treat it as valid and accept it on its face. The Court found that the certifier’s certificate was invalid because ABC had not been authorised by the BIA to certify compliance with Approved Standard E2/AS1. The Court also found that the statutory scheme did not require the Council to treat the certificate as valid and accept it on its face, and that the Council could be liable in negligence for accepting the certificate. However, the Court held that the Council was not liable in this case because the respondents had chosen to rely on the certifier instead of the Council, and the Council had no obligation to monitor the certifier’s authority or the building work. The Court allowed the appeal and entered summary judgment in favour of the Council. The Court also ordered the respondents to pay the Council costs on a band A basis and usual disbursements in the Court of Appeal, and costs on a 2B basis and disbursements in the High Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents, the Messrs McNamara in their capacity as trustees of the P H McNamara Family Trust, purchased a recently-built property in Remuera in 2004. The property leaked, and the respondents sought to recover the loss incurred from the Auckland City Council, which had overall responsibility for administering the Building Act and Code. The developer had engaged Approved Building Certifiers Ltd (ABC) to inspect and certify the property. At the time, ABC had general authority to issue code compliance certificates (CCCs) in respect of domestic dwellings. However, on 4 December 2002, the Building Industry Authority (BIA) restricted ABC's ability to certify compliance with Approved Standard E2/AS1 (External Moisture), which it did not do. Despite this restriction, ABC inspected the property between December 2002 and April 2004 and on 16 April 2004, purported to issue a CCC in respect of the property. ABC certified that the cladding system complied with E2/AS1, which, according to the respondents, it did not. The BIA removed ABC from its register of building certifiers on 7 September 2004. The trustees' purchase of the property was subject to a Land Information Memorandum (LIM) condition, which noted that no code compliance certificate had been issued. The Council accepted ABC's certificate as evidence of compliance and on its strength issued a LIM stating that a CCC had been issued. Once the trustees received ABC's certificate, the sale contract went unconditional. After the leaks appeared, the trustees repaired the property and now seek to recover the loss incurred.

The trustees sued the Council and some 18 other defendants, although not ABC, in negligence in the High Court. The Council applied to strike out the claim against it, and in the alternative sought summary judgment against the trustees. Associate Judge Christiansen refused both applications. The Council then appealed to this Court against the refusal of summary judgment. Due to a misunderstanding of the relevant procedure by the Council's solicitors, the Council applied out of time to the High Court for review of the Associate Judge's decision not to strike out the proceeding against it. Lang J granted an extension of time to seek review. The Council also sought an order transferring the application for review to this Court, to be heard alongside the summary judgment appeal. Venning J granted that application. The Council contends that the Associate Judge erred in refusing to strike out the proceeding against the Council, and alternatively in sending the case to trial rather than granting summary judgment to the Council.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the Council entitled to summary judgment as there was no basis for the trustees' claim against it?
2. Should the Council be held liable for the failure to explore whether or not the certifier lacked authority and to draw the lack of authority to the owner’s attention?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed.
The Court grants summary judgment in favour of the appellant, the Auckland City Council.
The respondents are ordered to pay the appellant costs for the standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements in the Court of Appeal.
The respondents are also ordered to pay the appellant costs on a 2B basis and disbursements in the High Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This case pertains to a leaky building issue and the liability of the Auckland City Council (the Council) under the Building Act 1991. The respondents, Peter Hardie McNamara and Patrick Sturgeon McNamara as trustees of the P H McNamara Family Trust, purchased a property that leaked after construction. They sought to hold the Council liable for damages in negligence, claiming the Council failed to ensure compliance with the Building Code and should have known that the building certifier lacked authority to issue a code compliance certificate (CCC). The Council, however, argued it was statutorily required to accept the building certifier's certificate and could not be held liable for doing so.
The Court found that the statutory scheme did not place a duty on the Council to monitor the scope of the authority of building certifiers or to determine if a particular building work fell outside a certifier's authority. The role of the Council was limited to receiving and recording the owner's advice of completion of work and the certifier's CCC, unless the certifier or owner notified the Council under section 57 of the Act. The Court held that the Council could not be held liable for acting in accordance with the statute, even if the building certifier exceeded its authority. Therefore, the Court allowed the appeal, granted summary judgment in favour of the Council, and ordered the respondents to pay the Council's costs.