Devany v Wellington City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-11281 [2015] NZHC 1087

BETWEEN

PAUL ALEXANDER DEVANY,

ANNABEL FRANCES JONES AND DIANE MYRA COPE

Plaintiffs

AND

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL Defendant

DON THOMSON CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED

First Third Party

DONAL MACLEAN THOMSON Second Third Party

Hearing: 12 February 2015

Counsel:

P Bremer and S J Baldwin for Plaintiff
G M G Joe for Defendant

Judgment:

20 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J

Introduction

[1]      This  is  an  application  by  the  defendant,  Wellington  City  Council  (the Council), to strike out part of the plaintiffs’ claim against it in negligence relating to the construction and repair of a “leaky home” owned by them.

Facts

[2]      In April 1998 the Council granted a building consent for the construction of a house in the Wellington suburb of Newlands (the House).

DEVANY v WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 1087 [20 May 2015]

[3]      In August 1998 the plaintiffs, as trustees of a family trust (the Trustees), contracted with Kingdom Residential Housing Limited (struck off) (Kingdom) to purchase the House, which was then under construction.   Kingdom finished construction of the House in February 1999, and in that month the Council issued a code compliance certificate (a CCC) for the House.

[4]      The House is the home of two of the Trustees, Paul Devany and Annabel

Jones. They have lived in the House since it was built.

[5]      In February 2003, after leaks were discovered in the House, the Trustees lodged a claim (the 2003 WHRS Claim) with the Weathertight Homes Resolution Service (WHRS).  A WHRS survey report of 13 October 2003 confirmed a range of weathertightness and associated structural issues which meant that the House had “shortcomings in its ability to comply with Clauses E2 External Moisture and B2

Durability of the Building Code”.   That report identified the causes of those shortcomings.   It also identified needed repairs (the 2003 Recommended Repair Work), confirmed that the 2003 WHRS Claim met the criteria of s 7(2) of the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2002 (the 2002 WHRS Act), and said that the parties to that claim should be the Council, Kingdom and the builder and roofer involved.

[6]      After  mediation,  the  2003  WHRS  Claim  was  terminated  pursuant  to  a settlement agreement made, as provided for by s 17 of the WHRS Act, between the Trustees, the Council and Kingdom on 29 October 2004 (the Settlement Agreement). The Council was to pay an undisclosed amount to Kingdom, and Kingdom was to carry out repairs to address identified weathertightness issues and meet certain of the Trustees’ costs.  Those repairs (the 2004 Agreed Repair Work) were summarised in a handwritten note, and in a more detailed schedule, both of which were attached to the  Settlement Agreement.    That  more  detailed  schedule,  headed  “Summary  of Remedial Work”,  comprised  a  list  of  repair  work  which  would  appear  to  have originally been prepared for the Trustees and may, I infer, have reflected the 2003

Recommended Repair Work. As appended to the Settlement Agreement, that list had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Devany v Wellington City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1087
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Devany v Wellington City Council is a case concerning a claim for damages by the plaintiffs, trustees of a family trust, against the Wellington City Council for negligence in the construction and repair of a house in Newlands, Wellington, which has been leaking since its construction in 1999. The plaintiffs argue that the council failed in its duties to ensure that the house was built and repaired in compliance with the Building Code. The council applied to strike out certain parts of the plaintiffs’ claim, arguing that the claim was statute-barred, precluded by the terms of a settlement agreement, and based on novel and untenable duties of care.

The court considered the arguments and found that the plaintiffs’ claim, while not well pleaded, was not so defective as to warrant a strike-out. The court held that the circumstances leading to the settlement agreement and the terms of the agreement itself created a different situation for the council in terms of the duties it owed to the plaintiffs. The court found it at least arguable that the council's duties in these circumstances were not limited to its actions in consenting to and certifying the repair work as complying with the Building Code, but rather could extend to ensuring that the repair work satisfactorily remediated the house's weathertightness issues. The court declined the council's application for a strike-out and ordered that the plaintiffs' claim be repleaded. Costs were reserved.