Osborne v Auckland City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA841/2011
[2012] NZCA 199

BETWEEN  JOHN ANTHONY OSBORNE AND HELEN OSBORNE
Applicants

AND  AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL (NOW AUCKLAND COUNCIL)
Respondent

Hearing:         3 April 2012

Court:             Ellen France, Harrison and White JJ

Counsel:         T J Rainey and J P M Wood for Applicants
C R Goode for Respondent

Judgment:      17 May 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

BThe applicants must pay the respondent its costs for a standard application on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.

___________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by White J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]

Background  [5]

Appeals to the Court of Appeal  [18]

An appeal to the Court of Appeal under the WHRS Act?   [36]

Summary[59]

Result[61]

Result

Introduction

[1]       Mr and Mrs Osborne have applied for leave to appeal to this Court under s 67(2) of the Judicature Act 1908 against a decision of the High Court[1] on appeal from the Weathertight Homes Tribunal.[2]  Their application for leave is made to this Court because the High Court has already refused leave.[3]

[1]Osborne v Auckland City Council HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-6582, 9 September 2011 [the appeal judgment].

[2]Osborne v Auckland City Council WHT TRI-2010-100-24, 10 September 2010 [the Tribunal decision].

[3]Osborne v Auckland City Council HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-6582, 30 November 2011 [the leave judgment].

[2]       The High Court refused leave on the ground that Mr and Mrs Osborne had no right of appeal to this Court because s 95(2)(b) of the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006 (the WHRS Act) provides that the determination of the High Court is “a final determination” of a claim under the Act.

[3]       In support of Mr and Mrs Osborne’s application for leave to appeal to this Court, it was argued that:

(a)s 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act does not preclude a second appeal to this Court;

(b)Mr and Mrs Osborne were therefore entitled to pursue their appeal under either s 66 or s 67 of the Judicature Act; and

(c)if they were only entitled to proceed under s 67, leave to appeal ought to be granted.

[4]       As, in our view, it is clear that s 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act does preclude a second appeal, we summarise the background briefly before referring to the submissions for Mr and Mrs Osborne in the context of the reasons for our decision.

Background

[5]       On 14 February 2007 Mr and Mrs Osborne filed a claim under the WHRS Act in respect of their leaky home.  In a series of decisions the Chair of the Tribunal decided that their claim was ineligible in respect of the construction of their house because it was not built within the 10 year limitation period under s 14(1) of the WHRS Act, but that it was eligible in respect of subsequent remedial work.

[6]       On 8 June 2010 Mr and Mrs Osborne filed an amended claim in adjudication proceedings under the WHRS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Auckland City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Osborne v Auckland City Council, the Court of Appeal considered whether the applicants, Mr and Mrs Osborne, had a right to appeal to the Court of Appeal against a decision of the High Court. The applicants had previously sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal against a decision of Woolford J in the High Court. Woolford J had dismissed their application for judicial review and their appeal against the Weathertight Homes Tribunal's decision. The applicants' appeal to the Court of Appeal was dismissed by Woolford J who held that the decision of the High Court on appeal was "a final determination of the claim" under s 95(2)(b) of the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006. The applicants argued that the statutory provision did not preclude a second appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal held that the statutory provision did preclude a second appeal and that the specific provisions of the Act prevailed over the general provisions of the Judicature Act. The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for leave to appeal and ordered the applicants to pay the respondent's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr and Mrs Osborne filed a claim under the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006 (WHRS Act) regarding their leaky home, which they believed was caused by design, construction, or alteration issues. Their initial claim was deemed ineligible by the Weathertight Homes Tribunal because their house was built outside the 10-year limitation period. They subsequently filed an amended claim in adjudication proceedings against the Auckland City Council, alleging negligence and negligent misstatement regarding building inspections and code compliance certificates. The Tribunal removed the Council from the proceeding, finding their claims against the Council were statute-barred. The Osbornes appealed this decision to the High Court, which upheld the Tribunal's ruling. They then sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal against the High Court's decision.

The matter began with Mr and Mrs Osborne filing a claim with the Weathertight Homes Tribunal. After the Tribunal decided their claim against the Auckland City Council was ineligible, they filed an amended claim and appealed the Tribunal's decision to the High Court. The High Court dismissed their appeal and judicial review application. They then applied to the High Court for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was refused. Subsequently, they applied directly to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal the High Court's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does section 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act preclude a second appeal to the Court of Appeal?
2. If so, does this specific provision override the general right of appeal under section 66 of the Judicature Act and the right to apply for leave to appeal under section 67 of the Judicature Act?
3. Are there any other grounds on which the Court of Appeal should grant leave to appeal?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that section 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act precludes a second appeal to the Court of Appeal.
2. Consequently, the specific provision of section 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act overrides the general right of appeal under section 66 of the Judicature Act and the right to apply for leave to appeal under section 67 of the Judicature Act.
3. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and Mr and Mrs Osborne were ordered to pay the respondent's costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal examined the statutory provisions governing appeals in the context of the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006 (WHRS Act). It was established that Parliament has the authority to limit or preclude rights of appeal from the High Court to the Court of Appeal through specific statutory provisions. This principle was supported by constitutional considerations, statutory interpretation principles, and precedents from various statutes that either precluded or limited further appeals. The Court found that section 95(2)(b) of the WHRS Act clearly stated that the decision of the High Court on an appeal from the tribunal was a "final determination of the claim," thereby precluding any further appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court rejected arguments that the word "final" should be interpreted differently or that the legislative history supported a different interpretation. The reasoning was grounded in the plain language of the statute, its purpose, and the principle that specific statutory provisions can override more general ones. This interpretation aligns with the legislative intent to provide a speedy, flexible, and cost-effective resolution process for claims under the WHRS Act, avoiding further delays and costs associated with additional appeals.