Demasol Ltd v South Pacific Industrial Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA46/2022
 [2022] NZCA 480

BETWEEN

DEMASOL LIMITED
Appellant

AND

SOUTH PACIFIC INDUSTRIAL LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

16 August 2022

Court:

Katz, Wylie and Palmer JJ

Counsel:

AJB Holmes for Appellant
P J Crombie and P J Anderson for Respondent

Judgment:

13 October 2022 at 9:30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe orders made by the High Court are set aside.

CSPI’s application to set aside the statutory demand is dismissed.

DThe time for complying with the statutory demand is extended.  The statutory time period of 20 working days is to commence on the day following the release of this judgment.

EThe judgment of the High Court in respect of costs is set aside under rr 48(4) and 53J of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

FThe amount paid by Demasol to SPI for costs in the High Court is to be repaid by SPI to Demasol within five working days of the date of release of this judgment.

GThe issue of costs in the High Court is referred back to the High Court for consideration under s 57 of the Senior Courts Act 2016.

HSPI is to pay Demasol’s costs and disbursements in this Court on an indemnity basis.  The reasonable quantum of these costs is to be fixed by the Registrar in the event that counsel do not agree.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Wylie J)

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Demasol Ltd (Demasol), appeals a decision of Associate Judge Sussock setting aside a statutory demand it served on the respondent, South Pacific Industrial Ltd (SPI) under s 289 of the Companies Act 1993.[1]  The statutory demand sought payment of the amount claimed in payment claims served by Demasol on SPI pursuant to s 20 of the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (the CCA).

  2. Demasol seeks that this Court should set aside the Associate Judge’s orders and dismiss SPI’s application to set aside the statutory demand.  SPI supports the Associate Judge’s decision and seeks that her orders should not be disturbed.

Background

  1. SPI was the head contractor in respect of various demolition works at a redundant gas facility owned by a third party in Penrose, Auckland.  The facility to be demolished included a large bin tank which contained asbestos.  In October 2020, SPI put out a request for quotes for the demolition of the bin tank.

  2. Demasol specialises in asbestos removal.  It quoted a price of $100,000 plus GST for the work.  Its quote also recorded that “the only thing not included is the asbestos we cannot see”.  Following negotiations and an exchange of correspondence, Demasol was engaged by SPI as a subcontractor to demolish the bin tank.  The engagement was recorded in a purchase order issued by SPI dated 9 December 2020.  The purchase order recorded the quote and noted that additional amounts were payable by SPI depending on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Demasol Ltd v South Pacific Industrial Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 480
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Demasol Ltd v South Pacific Industrial Ltd, the Court of Appeal allowed Demasol's appeal against the High Court's decision to set aside Demasol's statutory demand against South Pacific Industrial (SPI). Demasol had issued a statutory demand to SPI for the amounts claimed in two payment claims, pursuant to s 20 of the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA). SPI applied to set aside the statutory demand on the basis that there was a substantial dispute as to whether the debt claimed by Demasol was owing or due, pursuant to s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act. The Associate Judge agreed with SPI and set aside the statutory demand. The Court of Appeal held that the Associate Judge erred in considering the merits of the payment claim. Instead, the Court of Appeal found that the payment claim complied with the statutory requirements of the CCA and that SPI had failed to provide a payment schedule or to pay the amount claimed. As a result, the statutory demand should not have been set aside. The Court of Appeal also held that Demasol was entitled to its actual and reasonable costs in the Court of Appeal, and that the issue of costs in the High Court should be remitted back to the High Court for consideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

South Pacific Industrial Ltd (SPI) was the head contractor for demolition works at a redundant gas facility in Penrose, Auckland. In October 2020, SPI requested quotes for the demolition of a bin tank containing asbestos. Demasol Ltd, specialising in asbestos removal, quoted $100,000 plus GST for the work, excluding unseen asbestos. After negotiations, SPI engaged Demasol as a subcontractor to demolish the bin tank, with the engagement recorded in a purchase order dated 9 December 2020. The purchase order noted additional payments would be made depending on the type and volume of asbestos removed and disposed of. Demasol carried out the works, claiming that the scope increased during the contract, resulting in seven variations. On 27 January 2021, Demasol served a payment claim for $114,425.00 inclusive of GST, and on 29 March 2021, a second payment claim for $276,572.29 inclusive of GST. SPI did not respond with payment schedules as required by the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA). Instead, SPI rejected most of the variations claimed and asserted claims against Demasol for non-performance. On 5 May 2021, SPI made a partial payment of $86,846.85, and on 6 May 2021, Demasol served a statutory demand on SPI for $304,997.29. SPI filed a notice of application to set aside the statutory demand on 20 May 2021 and made a further payment of $47,502.39 on 24 May 2021.

The case came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal from a decision of Associate Judge Sussock, who set aside a statutory demand served by Demasol Ltd on SPI. The appeal was brought pursuant to s 56 of the Senior Courts Act 2016. The Court of Appeal proceeded by way of rehearing, considering the agreed issues submitted by the parties. The appeal was heard on 16 August 2022, and the judgment was delivered on 13 October 2022.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is it reasonably arguable that payment claim 2 served by Demasol on SPI on 29 March 2021 was not a valid payment claim under the CCA?
2. Should the statutory demand served by Demasol on SPI be set aside under s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act on the basis that SPI has a genuinely arguable dispute as to whether it is liable to pay the amount claimed in payment claim 2?
3. Should the statutory demand otherwise be set aside under s 290(4)(c) of the Companies Act?
4. If payment claim 2 was a valid payment claim under the CCA and the statutory demand is not set aside, is Demasol entitled to its actual and reasonable costs in this Court (as well as in the High Court) under s 23(2)(a) of the CCA?

Held
1. It was not reasonably arguable that the payment claim served by Demasol on SPI on 29 March 2021 was not a valid payment claim under the CCA.
2. The statutory demand served by Demasol on SPI should not be set aside under s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act.
3. The statutory demand should not be set aside under s 290(4)(c) of the Companies Act.
4. Demasol is entitled to its actual and reasonable costs in this Court on an indemnity basis, and the issue of costs in the High Court is to be remitted back to the High Court for consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the appeal against the decision of the Associate Judge who had set aside the statutory demand issued by Demasol to SPI. The Court held that the statutory demand should not be set aside because payment claim 2 was valid under the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA). The Court found that the Associate Judge had erred in assessing the validity of payment claim 2 against the requirements of the construction contract and in considering the merits of the claim. Instead, the Court should only consider whether the payment claim complied with the statutory requirements of the CCA. The Court found that payment claim 2 complied with the statutory requirements and that SPI had failed to provide a payment schedule or pay the amount claimed, resulting in SPI becoming liable to pay the claimed amount. The Court also held that setting aside the statutory demand under s 290(4)(c) of the Companies Act would be contrary to the CCA and its purposes. Finally, the Court found that Demasol was entitled to its actual and reasonable costs in this Court on an indemnity basis, but the issue of costs in the High Court was to be remitted back to the High Court for consideration.