Custom Street Hotel Limited v Plus Construction NZ Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK              

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA28/2017
[2017] NZCA36

BETWEEN

CUSTOM STREET HOTEL LIMITED
Appellant

AND

PLUS CONSTRUCTION NZ LIMITED
First Respondent

PLUS CONSTRUCTION CO LIMITED
Second Respondent

Hearing:

19 October 2017

Court:

Kós P, Harrison and Clifford JJ

Counsel:

R B Stewart QC, I Rosic and S S McMullan for Appellant
A R B Barker QC and J G Walton for Respondents

Judgment:

7 March 2018 at 2 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondents one set of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Kós P)

  1. This appeal concerns the meaning of default provisions in a standard construction contract called NZS 3910:2003 (the contract).  Each side has purported to cancel the contract, asserting breach by the other.  What is to happen in such a case?

Background

  1. The appellant, Custom Street Hotel Ltd (Custom), owns the former Reserve Bank building at 67 Customs Street East, Auckland (the site).  It wished to convert it into a hotel.  On 1 November 2013 it entered a construction contract with the respondents, Plus Construction NZ Ltd and Plus Construction Co Ltd (collectively, Plus) for $14.45 million plus GST. But problems overwhelmed the project.  Plus says that was because of Custom’s failure to obtain consents.  Custom says Plus could still have made progress, that it failed to resource the project adequately and that it simply abandoned the job.

  2. In July 2014 Plus stopped work on the site.  It advanced three claims, initially before an adjudicator, under the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA).  The adjudicator, Derek Firth, found fault on both sides.  In a decision dated 15 October 2014 he said “the fault for the shambles does not all lie at the door of Plus”.  But he also found there was much work Plus could have completed despite the relevant consents being incomplete.  Time was now at large.  Plus was entitled to a reasonable time to complete the work. 

  3. The last consent required was then obtained in November 2014.  The parties then discussed making a fresh start.  A new programme of works was canvassed.  Before these discussions ended, Plus complained about non-payment of some of its invoices.  On 27 January 2015 it issued a default notice for two outstanding payment claims totalling $258,508.  Part of that sum had been due since November 2014.  The notice was issued pursuant to cl 14.3.1(b) of the contract. If the principal’s defaults were not rectified within 10 working days, rights of suspension or termination arose.[1]  The 10-working-day period would expire at midnight on 11 February 2015. 

    [1]See below at [16] of this judgment.

  4. Before that, on 5 February 2015, the project engineer (the engineer) suspended work on the site on the basis of alleged breaches by Plus concerning site safety.  Plus was not operating on the site in any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Custom Street Hotel Limited v Plus Construction NZ Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Custom Street Hotel Limited (Custom) appealed against an arbitral decision in favour of Plus Construction NZ Limited (Plus). Custom challenged the validity of Plus's notice of termination of a construction contract and issued a notice of default itself. The parties had a dispute over whether Plus had validly terminated the contract. The appeal raised four questions of law regarding the nature of Plus's breach, whether Plus validly terminated the contract, whether Custom could recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works, and whether Custom could recover the additional cost of completion without first having its claim admitted and determined as to liability and quantum. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. The Court held that Plus was not disentitled from terminating the contract, formal suspension of the contract works by the engineer was not a precondition to the contractor's right to terminate, Custom could not recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works, and it was unnecessary to address whether Custom could recover the additional cost of completion without first having its claim admitted and determined as to liability and quantum. The Court also held that the appeal was dismissed and the appellant must pay the respondents one set of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Custom Street Hotel Limited (Custom) contracted with Plus Construction NZ Limited and Plus Construction Co Limited (Plus) for the conversion of the former Reserve Bank building in Auckland into a hotel. The construction faced numerous problems, leading Plus to stop work in July 2014. Disputes arose over the reasons for the project's failure and the respective breaches by both parties. Plus issued a default notice to Custom on 27 January 2015, demanding payment of two outstanding invoices by 10 working days. Before the period expired, on 12 February 2015, Plus sent a notice of termination to Custom, claiming Custom had not rectified the defaults. Custom did not pay the amounts within the period and issued its own notice of default against Plus on 20 February 2015, asserting that Plus had abandoned the contract. Custom then purported to terminate the contract on 11 March 2015 and sought to call on a performance bond. Plus sought an interim injunction to prevent Custom from claiming under the bond.

The matter initially came before an adjudicator under the Construction Contracts Act 2002, who found fault on both sides. The dispute then moved to arbitration, where the arbitrator found that Plus had validly terminated the contract and Custom could not rely on certain indemnity claims. Custom appealed to the High Court, which dismissed the appeal. Custom then appealed to the Court of Appeal on four questions of law. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and ruled against Custom on all four questions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Must the nature of Plus' breach be repudiatory before Plus is disentitled from terminating the contract?
2. Must Plus validly terminate the contract under cl 14.3.3 of, if applicable, the Contractual Remedies Act 1979?
3. Can Custom, on a proper interpretation of cls 14.2.4 and 14.2.5, recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works?
4. Can Custom recover the additional cost of completion without first having its claim admitted and determined as to liability and quantum?

Held
1. The court held that the nature of Plus' breach did not need to be repudiatory before Plus was disentitled from terminating the contract. The court also held that Plus had neither repudiated the contract nor breached an essential term at the time it gave notice of cancellation.
2. The court held that formal suspension of the contract works by the engineer was not a precondition to the contractor's right to terminate under cl 14.3.3.
3. The court held that Custom could not recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works on a proper interpretation of cls 14.2.4 and 14.2.5.
4. Since the court held in its answer to Question 3 that Custom could not recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works, it did not need to address whether Custom could recover the additional cost of completion without first having its claim admitted and determined as to liability and quantum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal reviewed the arbitrator's decision on four questions of law, which were appealed to the High Court and then to the Court of Appeal. The first issue addressed whether the nature of Plus' breach had to be repudiatory before Plus was disentitled from terminating the contract. The Court of Appeal held that the circumstances disentitling a party from cancelling a contract were not limited to repudiation of the contract; a breach of an essential term or other serious breach entitling the other party to cancel the contract under s 7 of the Contractual Remedies Act 1979 (CRA) would suffice. However, the Court found that Plus had not repudiated the contract or breached an essential term at the time it gave notice of cancellation.

The second issue was whether Plus validly terminated the contract under cl 14.3.3 or, if applicable, the Contractual Remedies Act 1979. The Court of Appeal concluded that formal suspension of the contract works by the engineer was not a precondition to the contractor's right to terminate under cl 14.3.3. The Court reasoned that cl 14.3.3 created a right to suspend, after 10 working days, but it was a right, not a requirement. The Court also considered that the purpose of cl 14.3.3 was clear and that it created a right to cancel once the right to suspend was triggered.

The third issue addressed whether Custom, on a proper interpretation of cls 14.2.4 and 14.2.5, could recover the additional cost of completion prior to completing the contract works. The Court of Appeal agreed with the arbitrator and held that any claim for damages based on the additional cost of completing the contract works was governed by cl 14.2.4 and that the quantum could not be assessed until completion of the contract works. The Court further reasoned that cls 14.2.3 and 14.2.4 provided a clear temporal sequence, and the latter clause applied only if the contract works had been completed.

Lastly, the Court of Appeal did not need to address whether Custom could recover the additional cost of completion without first having its claim admitted and determined as to liability and quantum, since the Court had already answered the third question in the negative.