XENOPHON v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
[2000] SASC 327Full Court: Prior, Lander and Bleby JJ
1................ PRIOR J:........................ This application for judicial review and declarations has been referred to the Full Court for consideration upon affidavit evidence alone.
2 The applicant seeks to challenge the lawfulness of decisions made on behalf of the State to provide indemnities to a Minister of the Crown in respect of liability arising in two separate defamation actions brought by the applicant against the Treasurer personally. The Treasurer and the Attorney‑General are the second and third respondents to this application. They are named personally as was the case with the Treasurer in the defamation actions.
3 On 11 February 1999 the applicant issued proceedings in the Magistrates Court against the present respondent Lucas and another Member of Parliament, Mr Ingerson. Damages were sought for defamation alleged to have arisen from the circulation of a pamphlet in a parliamentary electorate on the letterhead of the respondent Lucas, as Treasurer of the State Government. The defendants consented to judgment in the full amount of the applicant’s claim and costs on 19 March 1999. Three days later, Mr Lucas’ solicitors advised that the State had indemnified Mr Lucas in respect of the total payment of $20900. An indemnity had been given in terms of a memorandum dated 25 February 1999, from the present respondent Griffin as Attorney-General to the respondent Lucas as Treasurer. The indemnity did not mention the second defendant to the claim for defamation, Mr Ingerson.
4 On 23 March 1999, the defendant’s solicitors were asked for payment. At the same time they were notified that the applicant had raised, with the Auditor‑General, an issue as to the propriety of the indemnity. A cheque for the full amount claimed was provided by the State and deposited in the Trust account of the applicant’s own legal firm on 22 April. The Auditor-General made a report to Parliament concerning the indemnity on 28 October. On 20 March 2000, the claim in the Magistrates Court was dismissed for want of prosecution.
5 A second defamation action was instituted on 6 May 1999 with respect to statements made by the Treasurer with respect to the settlement monies. It was claimed that those statements involved a re-statement of the defamatory statements made in the original pamphlet. It was also said that some remarks made by the Treasurer then were also defamatory of the applicant. This action is continuing in the District Court. On 17 August 1999 the Attorney-General advised Mr Lucas of a further indemnity with respect to those proceedings on the same terms as the earlier one.
6 The material before this Court establishes that funds to satisfy the indemnities had been provided by the South Australian Government Captive Insurance Corporation, a body established pursuant to the Public Corporations Act 1993. The Corporation has used funds derived from a source known as section 2 of the South Australian Government Captive Insurance and Risk Management Fund to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Xenophon v State of South Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 327
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court concluded that the granting of indemnities was a valid exercise of prerogative power. The court found that the practice of the Executive providing indemnities to ministers for costs and damages in legal proceedings is a common one. The decision to grant an indemnity was a matter of political judgment, not subject to judicial review. The court also determined that Xenophon lacked standing to bring the application as his interest in the proceedings was no greater than that of any member of the public in the expenditure of government funds on the payment of damages and costs for which a minister may become liable. Consequently, the application was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi