Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd; Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd; Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684
Hearing dates: 6-14 November 2017, 16 November 2017, 8 December 2017
Date of orders: 22 May 2018
Decision date: 17 May 2018
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Fagan J
Decision:

The orders of the Court in proceedings no 2015/111482 are:

 

1. The orders pronounced 17 May 2018 are vacated and the following orders are made in lieu.

 

2. Judgment for the plaintiff, Raymond Wharekawa, against the defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd for $1,486,783.

 

3. The defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd, is to pay the costs of the plaintiff.

 

4. Any application by the plaintiff, Raymond Wharekawa, with respect to the scale at which costs are to be paid under the costs order in his favour is to be made by notice of motion to be filed within seven days with a supporting affidavit and any written submissions.

 

5. The defendant is to file any affidavit and/or submissions in response within a further 14 days.

 

6. Upon AEA Constructions Pty Ltd filing its affidavit and any submissions in response to such applications with respect to costs, it is to notify the associate to Fagan J if it wishes to be heard in oral argument in opposition to the orders sought.

 

The orders of the Court in proceedings no 2016/129877 are:

 

1. The orders pronounced 17 May 2018 are vacated and the following orders are made in lieu.

 

2. Judgment for the plaintiff, Building Partners Pty Ltd, against the defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd for $433,084.66, being made up of recovery pursuant to s 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) in the sum of $365,085.66, plus interest in the sum of $67,999, on payments of workers compensation.

 

3. Noted that payment by the defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd, of the judgment in order 2 above will operate as a credit in the sum of $365,085.66 against the judgment in favour of the plaintiff, Raymond Wharekawa under order 2 made this day in proceedings no 2015/111482.

 

4. The defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd is to pay the costs of the plaintiff Building Partners Pty Ltd, of the proceedings.

 

5. Any application by Building Partners Pty Ltd with respect to the scale at which costs are to be paid under the costs orders in their favour is to be made by notice of motion to be filed within seven days with a supporting affidavit and any written submissions.

 

6. AEA Constructions Pty Ltd is to file any affidavit and/or submissions in response within a further 14 days.

 7. Upon AEA Constructions Pty Ltd filing its affidavit and any submissions in response to such applications with respect to costs, it is to notify the associate to Fagan J if it wishes to be heard in oral argument in opposition to the orders sought.
Catchwords: TORTS – negligence – personal injury – plaintiff struck by nail from…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd; Building Partners Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 684
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Wharekawa and Building Partners brought an action against AEA Constructions in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiffs sought damages for injuries sustained by Wharekawa, who was struck by a nail fired from a nail gun through a wall at a construction site. The plaintiffs argued that AEA Constructions was negligent in failing to warn Wharekawa of the risk of being struck by a nail from a nail gun. The case centred on several key legal issues, including whether the risk of being struck by a nail from a nail gun was "not insignificant" within the meaning of section 5B(1)(f) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), whether the risk was "obvious" within the meaning of section 5F of the Act, the scope of the exemption from the duty to warn of an obvious risk under section 5H, whether the risk was "inherent" within the meaning of section 5I, and whether Wharekawa was contributorily negligent. The court also considered whether AEA Constructions breached its duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk and whether the injury and incapacity to work would have materialised due to pre-existing conditions in any event.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales held that the risk of being struck by a nail from a nail gun was not insignificant and that the risk was not obvious. The court found that the exemption from the duty to warn of an obvious risk did not apply in this case. The court further held that the risk was not inherent and that AEA Constructions breached its duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk. The court found that Wharekawa was not contributorily negligent and that the injury and incapacity to work would not have materialised due to pre-existing conditions in any event. The court awarded damages to Wharekawa and Building Partners.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales made a judgment in favour of the plaintiffs, awarding damages to Wharekawa and Building Partners. The court held that AEA Constructions was liable for negligence and breached its duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk of being struck by a nail from a nail gun. The court found that the injury and incapacity to work would not have materialised due to pre-existing conditions in any event. The court awarded damages to Wharekawa and Building Partners, and the judgment was in their favour.

Background

Background to the litigation

Wharekawa was a labourer employed at a construction site owned by AEA Constructions Pty Ltd. While Wharekawa was working, another employee, an employee of Building Partners Pty Ltd, negligently fired a nail gun through a wall, striking Wharekawa in the face and causing serious injury. There was no warning given to Wharekawa prior to the nail gun being fired. Wharekawa subsequently sued AEA Constructions Pty Ltd and Building Partners Pty Ltd for negligence. AEA Constructions Pty Ltd argued that the risk of injury from the nail gun was an obvious risk and that there was no duty to warn Wharekawa. They also argued that Wharekawa was contributorily negligent. Building Partners Pty Ltd argued that the injury would have materialised due to pre-existing conditions regardless of the negligent act.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The court had to determine the liability of AEA Constructions Pty Ltd and Building Partners Pty Ltd for the injuries sustained by Wharekawa. The primary issue was whether the risk of injury from the nail gun was obvious and whether there was a duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk. The court also considered whether Wharekawa was contributorily negligent and whether the injury would have materialised due to pre-existing conditions. The court delivered judgment in favour of Wharekawa.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the risk of injury from the nail gun an obvious risk within the meaning of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5F?
2. Did the exemption from duty to warn of obvious risks under the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5H, apply to the circumstances of this case?
3. Was the risk of injury from the nail gun an inherent risk within the meaning of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5I?
4. Was Wharekawa contributorily negligent?
5. Did AEA Constructions Pty Ltd breach its duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk?
6. Would Wharekawa’s injury and incapacity to work have materialised due to pre-existing conditions in any event?

Held
1. The court concluded that the risk of injury from the nail gun was not an obvious risk within the meaning of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5F.
2. The exemption from duty to warn of obvious risks under the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5H, did not apply to the circumstances of this case.
3. The court found that the risk of injury from the nail gun was an inherent risk within the meaning of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 5I.
4. Wharekawa was not found to be contributorily negligent.
5. AEA Constructions Pty Ltd breached its duty to warn Wharekawa of the risk.
6. The court concluded that Wharekawa’s injury and incapacity to work would not have materialised due to pre-existing conditions in any event.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the definition of 'obvious risk' under s 5F of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) to determine whether the risk of injury from the nail gun was obvious. The court found that while the risk was not insignificant, it was not so obvious that a reasonable person in the plaintiff's position would have been aware of it. The court distinguished between risks that are obvious and those that require explanation or warning. It relied on the legislative intent behind s 5F, which is to protect individuals from unforeseeable dangers. The court then turned to s 5H to assess the exemption from the duty to warn of obvious risks. It held that the exemption did not apply because the risk was not obvious, thereby requiring a warning under the statute. Regarding the inherent risk under s 5I, the court concluded that the risk was indeed inherent, meaning it was an integral part of the activity involved in using a nail gun. The court examined contributory negligence under s 5R and found Wharekawa did not share in the responsibility for the injury. The court then addressed the breach of duty by AEA Constructions Pty Ltd in failing to warn of the inherent risk. It held that a duty to warn existed and was breached. Lastly, the court assessed whether Wharekawa’s injury and incapacity to work would have materialised due to pre-existing conditions. The court concluded that the injury was directly caused by the incident and not by pre-existing conditions. This case establishes that not all significant risks are obvious, that the duty to warn applies to inherent risks, and that contributory negligence may not be found where the risk was inherently dangerous and not obvious.