Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1033 Hearing dates: On the papers Date of orders: 04 July 2018 Decision date: 04 July 2018 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Fagan J Decision: The plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings including the cross-claim under the orders of 22 May 2018 are to be paid on the ordinary basis up to 23 December 2016 and on the indemnity basis from 24 December 2016.
Catchwords: COSTS – party/party – bases of quantification – indemnity costs – proceedings by employer for indemnity for workers compensation benefits paid – judgment in related proceedings finding negligence of defendant causing personal injury to worker – Calderbank offer made by plaintiff – where offer open for 5 weeks – where offer involved elements of compromise – where offer rejected by defendant – whether rejection unreasonable – costs awarded on indemnity basis from date of offer Legislation Cited: Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) Cases Cited: Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684Category: Costs Parties: Building Partners Pty Ltd (plaintiff)
AEA Constructions Pty Ltd (defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr Morris SC/Mr John Catsanos (plaintiff)
Mr John Maconachie QC/Mr Mitchell Davis (defendant)
Stephen Lee, Stephen Lee Legal (plaintiff)
Bryan McMahon, McMahons Lawyers (defendant)
File Number(s): 2016/129877
Judgment
-
The plaintiff applies for an order that the defendant pay its costs of these proceedings, including the costs of the defendant’s cross-claim against the plaintiff, from 23 December 2016 to the conclusion of the proceedings on the indemnity basis. The proceedings involved a claim by the plaintiff for indemnity pursuant to s 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) in respect of benefits the plaintiff had paid to Raymond Wharekawa, an employee. Mr Wharekawa claimed that he had been injured, whilst working for the plaintiff, as a result of negligence of the defendant which was performing construction work on an adjoining site. Mr Wharekawa’s action was heard together with the plaintiff’s claim for indemnity, in a joint trial.
-
On 17 May 2018 I published reasons (Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684 – “the principal judgment”) for upholding both Mr Wharekawa’s claim for damages and the plaintiff’s claim for indemnity. I dismissed the defendant’s cross-claim against the plaintiff, in which the defendant had sought contribution to any judgment against it in favour of Mr Wharekawa. On 22 May 2018 I ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of these proceedings including the defendant’s cross-claim. I reserved to the plaintiff that it could make application regarding the scale at which costs should be assessed. On 24 May 2018 the defendant filed the notice of motion which is now before me.
-
The basis of the plaintiff’s claim for indemnity costs is that on 23 December 2016 its solicitors sent to the defendant’s solicitors a letter of the type considered in Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333. The letter…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWSC 1033
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the defendant's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable and, if so, whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer. The court examined the terms of the offer, the context in which it was made, and the defendant's reasons for rejecting it. The central issue was the assessment of the reasonableness of the defendant's decision to reject the offer and its impact on the costs order.
The court found that the defendant's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable, considering the terms of the offer and the circumstances at the time. The court concluded that the defendant's reasons for rejecting the offer were insufficient to justify the rejection. Consequently, the court awarded costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer. This decision underscores the importance of considering the reasonableness of rejecting a Calderbank offer and its implications for cost recovery in such circumstances.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court for the determination of the plaintiff's costs application. This was an interlocutory application concerning the basis of costs quantification. Prior to this application, the plaintiff had successfully obtained a judgment against the defendant for the negligence causing the worker's injury. The plaintiff made a Calderbank offer to the defendant, which the defendant rejected. The plaintiff subsequently filed an application for indemnity costs from the date of the Calderbank offer. This application was heard by the court, which had to determine whether the defendant's rejection of the offer was unreasonable and whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the offer.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the defendant's rejection of the Calderbank offer unreasonable?
2. Is the plaintiff entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the Calderbank offer?
Held
1. The court concluded that the defendant's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable.
2. The plaintiff is entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the Calderbank offer.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the principles governing the assessment of costs in the context of a rejected Calderbank offer. The court noted that a Calderbank offer is a conditional offer to settle the proceedings on terms more favourable to the defendant than the terms of judgment. The court held that the rejection of such an offer can be considered unreasonable if it lacks a reasonable prospect of success and is made in good faith. In this case, the court found that the defendant's rejection of the offer was unreasonable because it did not have a reasonable prospect of success, given the judgment in the related proceedings finding negligence on the part of the defendant causing personal injury to a worker. The court also noted that the offer was open for five weeks, providing the defendant with ample time to consider it.
The court then turned to the issue of indemnity costs. The court reiterated that indemnity costs can be awarded from the date of the Calderbank offer if the rejection of the offer was unreasonable. The court found that since the rejection of the offer was unreasonable, the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs from the date the offer was made. The court reasoned that the plaintiff had already incurred costs up to the date of the offer and, given the unreasonable rejection, it was just for those costs to be awarded on an indemnity basis. This approach ensures that the plaintiff is not left to bear the burden of costs incurred after making a reasonable settlement offer.
The court distinguished this case from previous authority where the rejection of a Calderbank offer was considered reasonable due to a lack of information or a genuine belief in the merits of the case. Here, the court found that the defendant had sufficient information and no reasonable basis to believe that it had a better chance of success than the terms proposed in the offer. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a Calderbank offer is unreasonable and is rejected, indemnity costs may be awarded from the date of the offer. This principle reinforces the importance of considering settlement offers seriously and in good faith to avoid incurring additional costs.