AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Wharekawa;; AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Building Partners Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Wharekawa;; AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Building Partners Pty Ltd [2019] NSWCA 176
Hearing dates: 14 November 2018
Decision date: 19 July 2019
Before: Basten JA at [1];
Gleeson JA at [22];
White JA at [23]
Decision:

(1)   In appeal proceedings 2018/178977 order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.
(2)   In appeal proceedings 2018/236109 order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Catchwords: TORTS — negligence — apportionment of responsibility and damages — primary judge held that appellant vicariously liable for injury and breached duty of care owed to respondent — primary judge found no negligence on part of worker’s employer — whether primary judge erred in finding worker’s employer not in breach of duty and liable in damages to respondent such as to entitle appellant to contribution from employer — whether primary judge erred in assessment of non-economic loss by applying a 10% reduction to percentage of most extreme case to reflect for contingency — whether primary judge’s assessment as to past economic loss supported by evidence — whether primary judge’s estimation of working life of 60 years and application of 20 per cent buffer for vicissitudes sufficient to account for fact that surgery brought about by negligence would have been necessary at some point in future in any event
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), ss 3, 5B, 5D, 23, 16
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW), s 5
Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 151Z
Cases Cited: Berkeley Challenge Pty Ltd v Howarth [2013] NSWCA 370
Clifton v Lewis [2012] NSWCA 229
Czatyrko v Edith Cowan University (2005) 214 ALR 349; [2005] HCA 14 at [12]
Dell v Dalton (1991) 23 NSWLR 528
Dib Group Pty Ltd (t/as Hill and Co.) v Cole [2009] NSWCA 210
Hall v State of New South Wales [2014] NSWCA 154
Hamilton v Nuroof (WA) Pty Ltd (1956) 96 CLR 18; [1956] HCA 42
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; [1936] HCA 40
Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638; [1990] HCA 20
Muller v Sanders (1995) 21 MVR 309
Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v The Miller Steamship Co Pty Ltd (“Wagon Mound No 2”) [1967] AC 617
Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531; [1979] HCA 9
Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd; Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684
Wilson v Peisley (1975) 50 ALJR 207
Wyong Shire Council v Shirt (1980) 146 CLR 40; [1980] HCA 12
Texts Cited: D Villa, Annotated Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) (3rd ed, 2018, Law Book Co)
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: AEA Constructions Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Raymond Wharekawa (First Respondent 2018/178977)
Building Partners Pty Ltd (Second Respondent 2018/178977; Respondent 2018/236109)
Representation:

Counsel:
J E Maconachie QC with M Davis (Appellant)
D Higgs SC with A Davis (Wharekawa)
P Morris with F Costano (Building Partners)

  Solicitors:
McMahons…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Wharekawa;; AEA Constructions Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWCA 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

AEA Constructions Pty Ltd appealed decisions of the primary judge concerning claims arising from a workplace injury. The primary judge had found AEA Constructions vicariously liable for the negligence of its employee, who caused injury to the respondent, Mr Wharekawa. The primary judge also found that the worker's employer, Building Partners Pty Ltd, was not negligent and therefore not liable to contribute to the damages awarded to Mr Wharekawa. AEA Constructions appealed these findings.

The appeal raised several legal issues. Firstly, the court was asked to determine whether the primary judge erred in finding that Building Partners Pty Ltd was not in breach of its duty of care to Mr Wharekawa, and consequently, whether AEA Constructions was entitled to contribution from Building Partners. Secondly, the court considered whether the primary judge erred in the assessment of non-economic loss by applying a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to account for contingencies. Finally, the court examined whether the primary judge's assessment of past economic loss was supported by the evidence and whether the estimation of the worker's remaining working life and the application of a 20% buffer for vicissitudes adequately accounted for the fact that surgery necessitated by the negligence would have been required at some point in the future regardless of the incident.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals. The judges found no error in the primary judge's determination that Building Partners Pty Ltd had not breached its duty of care. Furthermore, the court upheld the primary judge's assessment of damages, including the approach taken to non-economic loss and the consideration of future economic loss, finding that the evidence supported the conclusions reached.

Consequently, the appeals in both proceedings were dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) In appeal proceedings 2018/178977 order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

(2) In appeal proceedings 2018/236109 order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

AEA Constructions Pty Ltd, trading as AEA Constructions, was engaged as the contractor for the construction of a residential apartment block in Auckland, New Zealand, by Wharekawa Limited, the principal. Building Partners Pty Ltd, trading as Building Partners, was the sub-contractor for the construction of the apartment block’s lift. During the construction, a Building Partners employee, Mr Wharekawa, suffered injuries when he fell down a lift shaft while working at a height. He was rescued and taken to hospital. Mr Wharekawa subsequently sued AEA Constructions and Building Partners for damages in the High Court of New Zealand.

Mr Wharekawa alleged that both AEA Constructions and Building Partners were negligent in the performance of their duties, which resulted in his injuries. He claimed damages for non-economic loss, past economic loss, and future economic loss. The primary judge found that AEA Constructions was vicariously liable for Mr Wharekawa’s injuries and had breached the duty of care it owed to him. The primary judge also found that Building Partners was not negligent in the performance of its duties and was not liable in damages to Mr Wharekawa.

Mr Wharekawa subsequently issued proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia against AEA Constructions and Building Partners for contribution pursuant to section 5LA of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic). The primary judge held that Building Partners was not liable to contribute to any damages payable to Mr Wharekawa by AEA Constructions. The primary judge also held that AEA Constructions was not entitled to contribution from Building Partners in respect of any damages payable to Mr Wharekawa. AEA Constructions and Building Partners appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The appellants contended that the primary judge erred in finding that Building Partners was not in breach of duty and liable in damages to Mr Wharekawa such as to entitle AEA Constructions to contribution from Building Partners. The appellants also contended that the primary judge erred in assessing Mr Wharekawa’s non-economic loss by applying a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to reflect for contingency. The appellants further contended that the primary judge’s assessment as to Mr Wharekawa’s past economic loss was not supported by evidence. Finally, the appellants contended that the primary judge’s estimation of Mr Wharekawa’s working life of 60 years and application of a 20% buffer for vicissitudes was not sufficient to account for the fact that the surgery brought about by negligence would have been necessary at some point in the future in any event.

The case of AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Wharekawa and AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Building Partners Pty Ltd involves appeals against findings of liability and damages in a negligence case. The proceedings originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales where the primary judge determined that AEA Constructions Pty Ltd (the appellant) was vicariously liable for injuries sustained by the respondent Wharekawa due to the actions of its employee and breached the duty of care owed to Wharekawa. The primary judge found that Building Partners Pty Ltd, the employer of the employee, was not negligent. This decision led to the appellant seeking contribution from Building Partners Pty Ltd on the basis that it should share in the liability. The appellant also contested the primary judge's assessment of non-economic loss, arguing against the application of a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to reflect for contingency, as well as the estimation of past economic loss and the working life expectancy applied by the primary judge.

The appellant's appeals were subsequently heard in the Court of Appeal, where it was argued that the primary judge erred in finding Building Partners Pty Ltd not in breach of duty and liable in damages to the respondent, thus entitling the appellant to contribution. The appellant further contested the primary judge's assessment of non-economic loss, arguing against the applied reduction and the sufficiency of the estimated working life and the buffer for vicissitudes. The Court of Appeal ultimately dismissed both appeals, affirming the primary judge's findings and orders, and awarded costs to the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge erred in finding that the worker’s employer was not in breach of the duty of care owed to the respondent.
2. Whether the primary judge erred in assessing non-economic loss by applying a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to reflect for contingency.
3. Whether the primary judge’s assessment of past economic loss is supported by the evidence.
4. Whether the primary judge’s estimation of the working life of 60 years and the application of a 20% buffer for vicissitudes were sufficient to account for the fact that surgery brought about by negligence would have been necessary at some point in the future in any event.

Held
1. The court held that the primary judge did not err in finding that the worker’s employer was not in breach of the duty of care owed to the respondent. As a result, the appeal was dismissed in relation to this issue.
2. The court held that the primary judge did not err in assessing non-economic loss by applying a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to reflect for contingency. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed regarding this matter.
3. The court held that the primary judge’s assessment of past economic loss was supported by the evidence. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed on this point.
4. The court held that the primary judge’s estimation of the working life of 60 years and the application of a 20% buffer for vicissitudes were sufficient to account for the fact that surgery brought about by negligence would have been necessary at some point in the future in any event. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed on this issue as well.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia in AEA Constructions Pty Ltd v Wharekawa considered various issues pertaining to the apportionment of responsibility and damages in a negligence case. The court first examined whether the primary judge was correct in determining that the worker’s employer was not in breach of the duty of care owed to the respondent. The primary judge found no negligence on the part of the worker’s employer, which led to the conclusion that the employer was not liable for damages, thereby preventing the appellant from claiming contribution from the employer. The Full Court held that the primary judge's finding was not erroneous, as there was insufficient evidence to establish that the employer breached any duty of care. The court relied on established principles of vicarious liability and the burden of proof in negligence cases, underscoring that the primary judge's findings were consistent with the applicable legal standards and were supported by the evidence presented.

The Full Court also scrutinized the primary judge's method of assessing non-economic loss, specifically the application of a 10% reduction to the percentage of the most extreme case to reflect for contingency. The court examined whether this reduction was appropriate under the circumstances. The Full Court affirmed the primary judge’s approach, holding that the 10% reduction was a reasonable exercise of discretion in the context of the evidence and the principles guiding the assessment of non-economic damages. The court referenced precedents that support the use of contingency adjustments in damage assessments, thereby reinforcing the primary judge's methodology.

Further, the court evaluated whether the primary judge’s assessment of past economic loss was adequately supported by the evidence. The Full Court found that the primary judge's assessment was consistent with the evidence and did not overstep the bounds of reasonable inference. The court emphasized that the primary judge’s conclusions were based on a careful consideration of the available financial records and expert testimonies, which provided a solid foundation for the determination of past economic losses.

Lastly, the Full Court examined whether the primary judge’s estimation of the working life of 60 years and the application of a 20% buffer for vicissitudes were sufficient to account for the fact that surgery brought about by negligence would have been necessary at some point in the future regardless. The court concluded that the primary judge’s estimation and application of the buffer were appropriate and adequately reflected the potential future necessity of the surgery. The Full Court found that the primary judge’s approach was in line with legal principles and the evidence presented, thus upholding the primary judge’s assessment.

In summary, the Full Court's reasoning and ratio decidendi affirm the correctness of the primary judge's findings on the employer's liability, the assessment of non-economic loss, the evaluation of past economic loss, and the estimation of future necessity for surgery. The court did not find any errors warranting a departure from the primary judge's decisions, thereby dismissing the appeals with costs.