Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1023
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 03 July 2018
Decision date: 03 July 2018
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Fagan J
Decision:

The plaintiff’s costs payable under Order 3 made 22 May 2018 shall not include any costs of or incidental to the interlocutory hearings on 10 and 11 October 2017 but otherwise shall be on the ordinary basis up to 15 April 2016 and on the indemnity basis thereafter.

Catchwords: COSTS – party/party – bases of quantification – indemnity costs – judgment for plaintiff in proceedings for negligence causing personal injury – offer of compromise and Calderbank offer separately made by plaintiff – where offers rejected by defendant – where damages awarded by judgment greater than plaintiff’s offer of compromise and Calderbank offer – where plaintiff prima facie entitled to indemnity costs unless Court otherwise orders – Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.14 – whether significant change in plaintiff’s case between date of offer and date of trial – where expert medical reports not served on defendant at time of offer – where plaintiff’s statement and other medical reports raising same evidentiary issues nevertheless served on defendant by the time of offer – costs awarded on indemnity basis from date of offer
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Nominal Defendant v Hawkins [2011] NSWCA 93
Raymond Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd (unrep, NSW Supreme Court, Fagan J, 11 October 2017)
South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service v King [2006] NSWCA 2
Vale v Eggins (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 12
Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684
Category:Costs
Parties: Raymond Wharekawa (plaintiff)
AEA Constructions Pty Ltd (first defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr David Higgs SC/Mr Andrew Davis (plaintiff)
Mr John Maconachie QC/Mr Mitchell Davis (first defendant)

  Solicitors:
Leslie Heinrich, RMB Lawyers (plaintiff)
Bryan McMahon, McMahons Lawyers (first defendant)
File Number(s): 2015/111482

Judgment

  1. The plaintiff applies for an order that the defendant pay his costs from 15 April 2016 to the conclusion of the proceedings on the indemnity basis. The plaintiff was successful in his claim for damages for personal injury. I published reasons for upholding the plaintiff’s claim on 17 May 2018 (Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 684 – “the principal judgment”). On 22 May 2018 I ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs. I reserved to the plaintiff that he could make an application regarding the scale at which costs should be assessed. On 23 May 2018 he filed the notice of motion which is now before me.

  2. The plaintiff’s application is supported by an affidavit of his solicitor sworn 23 May 2018 to which is annexed a letter dated 14 April 2016 written to the defendants solicitor. The letter enclosed an offer of compromise made pursuant to r 20.26 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (“UCPR”). The offer was to compromise “this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 1023
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the plaintiff, Wharekawa, and the defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd, concerning negligence leading to personal injury. The matter was heard and determined in the District Court of New South Wales. Wharekawa sought indemnity costs from AEA Constructions based on an offer of compromise and a Calderbank offer that were both rejected by the defendant prior to judgment being awarded in favour of Wharekawa.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff, Wharekawa, was entitled to indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rule 42.14. The court was required to determine if there had been a significant change in Wharekawa’s case between the time of the offer and the date of trial, which would affect the entitlement to such costs. This involved examining whether the expert medical reports were served on AEA Constructions at the time of the offer and whether the plaintiff’s statement and other medical reports served at the same time raised the same evidentiary issues.

The court found that Wharekawa was prima facie entitled to indemnity costs unless the court otherwise ordered. The court reasoned that despite the expert medical reports not being served at the time of the offer, Wharekawa’s statement and other medical reports had been served, raising the same evidentiary issues. Consequently, there was no significant change in Wharekawa’s case that would warrant denying indemnity costs. The court ordered that costs be awarded on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Wharekawa, brought an action against the defendant, AEA Constructions Pty Ltd, seeking damages for personal injury sustained due to the defendant's alleged negligence. Wharekawa claimed that the defendant was responsible for the injuries resulting from an accident at a construction site. The incident occurred when Wharekawa, a worker at the site, was injured due to what he alleged was the defendant's failure to ensure the site was safe and properly supervised. Wharekawa alleged that the injuries he sustained were severe and have had a significant impact on his ability to work and his quality of life.

During the course of the litigation, Wharekawa made an offer of compromise to the defendant, which was not accepted. Additionally, Wharekawa made a Calderbank offer, which is a formal offer of compromise with a promise of indemnity costs if the offer is not accepted and the plaintiff ultimately obtains a better outcome at trial. This offer too was rejected by the defendant. At trial, Wharekawa was awarded damages that exceeded the amount offered in both the offer of compromise and the Calderbank offer. The defendant argued that Wharekawa was not entitled to indemnity costs because there had been a significant change in the plaintiff's case between the time of the offer and the date of trial.

The matter was initially filed in the Local Court, where Wharekawa sought to recover damages for personal injury against AEA Constructions Pty Ltd. The defendant denied liability and the case proceeded to trial. During the litigation, Wharekawa made both an offer of compromise and a Calderbank offer, which were rejected by the defendant. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Wharekawa was ultimately awarded damages. The defendant contested the plaintiff's entitlement to indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.14, arguing that there had been a significant change in the plaintiff's case between the time of the offer and the trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Wharekawa is entitled to indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.14, for the period from the date of the offer of compromise and the Calderbank offer up until the date of the trial.
2. Whether there was a significant change in Wharekawa's case between the date of the offer and the date of trial that would disqualify him from receiving indemnity costs.

Held
1. The court held that Wharekawa is entitled to indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.14, for the period from the date of the offer of compromise and the Calderbank offer up until the date of the trial.
2. The court held that there was no significant change in Wharekawa's case between the date of the offer and the date of trial that would disqualify him from receiving indemnity costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the statutory provisions under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.14, which provide that a plaintiff is generally entitled to indemnity costs if they are the successful party in proceedings for damages for personal injury or death. The rule provides that unless the court otherwise orders, a plaintiff is entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the offer of compromise or Calderbank offer up until the date of the trial. The court recognised that a significant change in the plaintiff's case between the date of the offer and the date of trial could disqualify the plaintiff from receiving indemnity costs. However, the court found that no such significant change occurred in this case. The court noted that the expert medical reports were not served on the defendant at the time of the offer, but Wharekawa's statement and other medical reports raising the same evidentiary issues were served by the time of the offer. The court held that this did not amount to a significant change in the case, and Wharekawa remained entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the offer. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a plaintiff remains entitled to indemnity costs under r 42.14 if there has not been a significant change in their case between the date of the offer and the date of trial, even if some evidence was not served at the time of the offer.