Wallace-Smith v Thiess Infraco (Swanston) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wallace-Smith v Thiess Infraco (Swanston) Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 49

CORPORATIONS – CONTRACTS - administration - deed of company arrangement – proof of debt - breach of contract – right to terminate for breach – whether structure of contractual arrangements such as to disentitle innocent party from terminating for serious breach of contract – repudiation and serious breach of contract discussed.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 553, 1321

Amann Australia Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth of Australia (1990) 22 FCR 527 referred to

Ankar Pty Ltd v National Westminster Finance (Australia) Ltd (1987) 162 CLR 549 cited

Bentsen v Taylor [1893] 2 QB 274 cited

Bowes v Chaleyer (1923) 32 CLR 159 cited

Bridge v Campbell Discount Co Ltd [1962] AC 600 referred to

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337 cited

Concut Pty Ltd v Worrell (2000) 75 ALJR 312 cited

Darlington Futures Ltd v Delco Australia Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500 cited

Decro-Wall International SA v Practitioners in Marketing Ltd [1971] 1 WLR 361 cited

Foran v Wight (1989) 168 CLR 385 cited

Fullers’ Theatres Ltd v Musgrove (1923) 31 CLR 524 cited

Holland v Wiltshire (1954) 90 CLR 409 discussed

Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26 cited

Honner v Ashton (1979) 1 BPR 9478 discussed

Immer (No 145) Pty Ltd v Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (NSW) (1993) 182 CLR 26 discussed

In re Asphaltic Wood Pavement Co (Lee & Chapman’s case) (1885) LR 30 Ch D 216 discussed

Larratt v Bankers & Traders’ Insurance Co (1941) 41 SR 215 cited

Legione v Hateley (1983) 152 CLR 406 referred to

Mersey Steel & Iron Co Ltd v Naylor, Benzon & Co (1884) 9 App Cas 434 cited

Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas (2004) 208 ALR 213 cited

Panoutsos v Raymond Hadley Corporation of New York [1917] 2 KB 473 cited

Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] AC 827 referred to

Port Jackson Stevedoring Pty Ltd v Salmond and Spraggon (Aust) Pty Ltd (1978) 139 CLR 231 discussed

Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali Pty Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 17 cited

Rawson v Hobbs (1961) 107 CLR 466 referred to

Ross T Smyth & Co Ltd v T D Baily Son & Co [1940] 3 All ER 60 cited

Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 634 referred to

Shevill v The Builders Licensing Board (1982) 149 CLR 620 referred to

Stocznia Gdanska SA v Latvian Shipping Co [1998] 1 WLR 574 cited

Suisse Atlantique Societe D’Armement Maritime SA v NV Rotterdamsche Kolen Centrale [1967] 1 AC 361 referred to

Sunbird Plaza Pty Ltd v Maloney (1988) 166 CLR 245 cited

United Australia Ltd v Barclays Bank Ltd [1941] AC 1 cited

Wallis, Son & Wells v Pratt & Haynes [1910] 2 KB 1003 cited

Wood Factory Pty Ltd v Kiritos Pty Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 105 cited

IN THE MATTER OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wallace-Smith v Thiess Infraco (Swanston) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCAFC 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Wallace-Smith v Thiess Infraco (Swanston) Pty Ltd, the appellants sought to challenge the decision of the lower court, which dismissed their appeal against the respondent. The primary issue in the appeal was whether the appellants were entitled to claim loss of profits due to the termination of an Infrastructure Maintenance Agreement (IMA) between the parties. The lower court found that the appellants did not have a contingent debt or claim against the respondent as at the relevant date, and thus were not entitled to claim loss of profits.

The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the appellants had the right to terminate the IMA and claim damages for loss of profits, and whether there was an accord and satisfaction that extinguished the appellants' cause of action against the respondent. The court held that the appellants did not have the right to terminate the IMA without the consent of the Director of Public Transport, and that there was no accord and satisfaction that extinguished their cause of action. The court further held that the termination of the IMA was not inconsistent with the appellants accepting a repudiation by the respondent of the IMA.

The court's reasoning was based on the terms of the IMA and the applicable principles of contract law. The court found that the IMA did not prohibit the appellants from terminating the agreement for breach or accepting a repudiation of the agreement. However, the court held that the appellants did not have the power to elect to terminate the agreement without the consent of the Director, which consent was not forthcoming until the Transfer Agreement. The court also held that there was no accord and satisfaction that extinguished the appellants' cause of action against the respondent. The court rejected the argument that the termination of the IMA was inconsistent with the appellants accepting a repudiation by the respondent of the IMA.

The court's outcome was that the appeal should be dismissed, and the appellants were not entitled to claim loss of profits. The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of the appeal. The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the terms of the IMA and the applicable principles of contract law. The court's reasoning was clear and well-reasoned, and the outcome was consistent with the law.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which I have set out below, in my opinion these contentions, reflected in the various grounds of appeal, are not made out. The appeal should be dismissed. Factual and Procedural Background In 1999, the Victorian Government undertook the privatisation of its public trains and trams transport system. The National Express Group of Companies was a bidder for franchises to operate those parts of the system known as Bayside Trains, Swanston Trams and Yarra Trams. The Group’s holding company is National Express Group PLC, a British publicly listed corporation. In anticipation of the grant of franchises National Express Group (Australia) Pty Ltd entered into an Infrastructure Maintenance Agreement (IMA) with Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (Thiess Contractors). That agreement was dated 14 May 1999. It provided that, in the event that the National Express Group was awarded the franchises the IMA would record the terms and conditions upon which Thiess Contractors would provide infrastructure maintenance services. The National Express Group was awarded the franchise. Franchise Agreements were made with respect to the train system and the two tram networks. In relation to Swanston Trams a Franchise Agreement was made on 25 June 1999 between the Director and NX Australia (Swanston Trams) Pty Ltd (NX Swanston). The recitals to the agreement recorded that the Director and NX Swanston had entered into an Infrastructure Lease for the lease of ‘tram infrastructure’ to NX Swanston for the ‘franchise period’ which was a term of 12 years (recital A). NX Swanston had agreed ‘to operate tramway passenger services on that tram infrastructure on the terms of this agreement’ (recital B). NX Swanston and the Infrastructure Maintenance Service Provider, defined relevantly as a subsidiary of Thiess Contractors, would enter into an Infrastructure Maintenance Service Agreement for the maintenance of the tram infrastructure (recital D). The franchise agreement also required that the Infrastructure Maintenance Service Provider enter into a separate agreement with the Director which was to be designated a ‘Franchise Entity Direct Agreement’ (recital C). The term ‘Franchise Entity’ covered not only the Infrastructure Maintenance Service Provider but also other service providers under the Franchise Agreements. The term of the Franchise Agreement was 12 years (cl 4.2) subject to a right on the part of the Director unilaterally to extend the agreement for a period of up to six months. Clause 18 of the Franchise Agreement dealt with its termination. It defined various ‘termination events’ which were expressed largely in terms of breaches by the franchisee but extended to breaches by Franchisee Entities of the obligations under contracts to which they were party. One of the termination events defined in cl 18 was the valid termination of a Transaction Document (cl 18.1(2)), ie, in effect, any of the various contractual documents established under the franchise system (cl 1.1). Clause 18.2 provided for termination of the Franchise Agreement by the Director on written notice to the franchisee, NX Swanston. Clause 18.3 provided: ‘Notwithstanding any rule of law or equity to the contrary, this agreement may not be terminated except as provided in clause 18.2.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 September 2004, the appellants filed a notice of appeal against his Honour’s decision. The Reasons for Decision of the Primary Judge His Honour set out in his reasons the history of the events outlined above. In considering the applicable principles his Honour began by observing that Thiess Swanston was only entitled to maintain its claim for loss of profits if, at 23 December 2002, it had a ‘contingent’ debt or claim against NX Swanston. The Deed, in using that term, (no doubt his Honour was here referring to the definition of ‘Claim’), intended to pick up the meaning of ‘contingent debt’ or ‘contingent claim’ in the insolvency provisions of the Corporations Act. The relevant provision had its genesis in bankruptcy law. It was to bankruptcy law in relation to contingent claims that his Honour turned. His Honour reviewed case law and textbook writings on the topic of contingent debts in bankruptcy and corporate insolvency. He concluded that a claimable debt would arise when, by reason of a company’s insolvency, it became impossible for it to perform a contract. This was so notwithstanding that a formal breach of the contract had not occurred at the time of the winding up order – In re Asphaltic Wood Pavement Co (Lee & Chapman’s case) (1885) LR 30 Ch D 216 at 224. His Honour found in any event that, as at 23 December 2003, NX Swanston was in breach of the IMA as it had failed to pay the claim due on 17 December 2002. Ordinarily this would have entitled Thiess Swanston to terminate the agreement. Moreover, NX Swanston had repudiated the IMA in the sense that it informed the Victorian Government and Thiess Swanston that it was no longer able to perform its obligations. The learned trial judge rejected the proposition that because the IMA remained in force until 2004, Thiess Swanston should be taken to have elected not to discharge it. Thiess Swanston was not entitled to terminate it without the consent of the Director, which consent was not forthcoming until the Transfer Agreement. Thiess Swanston had no power to elect to terminate. To that point it ‘had no power but to go on with the IMA’ (at [20]). His Honour referred to the usual rule that when a contract is terminated for breach the contracting parties are discharged from their obligations to perform the contract in the future but accrued rights including any claims for damages are unaffected. The administrators contended that, because the IMA was terminated by agreement, accrued rights, including any loss of bargain damages, were lost. His Honour accepted that an action in damages could be bargained away. But that would require something in the nature of an accord and satisfaction. His Honour, however, took the view that there was no accord and satisfaction which extinguished Thiess Swanston’s cause of action against NX Swanston. The Grounds of Appeal There are nine grounds of appeal. ‘1.The Court erred in finding that the Infrastructure Maintenance Agreement (“Swanston IMA”) conferred a right upon Thiess Infraco (Swanston) Pty Ltd (“Thiess Swanston”) to terminate or accept a repudiation of the Swanston IMA. 2.The Court erred in not finding that any termination of the Swanston IMA by Thiess Swanston prior to the “relevant date” of 23 December 2002 would not have been a termination for breach of the Swanston IMA, but a termination in breach of the Swanston IMA, and thus did not entitle Thiess Swanston to claim damages for loss of profits. 3.The Court erred in not finding that the effect of the Swanston IMA, and clauses 11(c)(iii), 24.2 and 34 in particular, was to prohibit Thiess Swanston from terminating the Swanston IMA for breach, or accepting a repudiation of the Swanston IMA. 4.The Court erred in finding that Thiess Swanston had not elected to continue with or affirm the Swanston IMA. 5.The Court erred in finding that the Swanston IMA could be terminated with the consent of the Director of Public Transport (“the Director”).6.The Court erred in finding that Thiess Swanston had a right to terminate the Swanston IMA, which right was held in suspense waiting the Director’s consent. 7.The Court erred in finding that it was necessary to show something in the nature of an accord and satisfaction before it could be established that an action in damages had been bargained away. 8.The Court erred in not finding that the basis upon which the Swanston IMA was in fact terminated was inconsistent with Thiess Swanston having accepted any repudiation by National Express Group Australia (Swanston Trams) Pty Ltd (“NX Swanston”) of the Swanston IMA. 9.The Court erred in finding that on the proper construction of the Swanston IMA, Thiess Swanston had a contingent debt or claim against NX Swanston as at the relevant date.’Limitations on the Exercise and Consequences of Common Law Rights of Termination

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.