Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 4) [2009] FCA 675

CONTRACTS – breach of guarantee – damages claimed from respondents for breach of guarantee of profit shortfall of company – profit guarantee originally given by vendor companies in share sale agreement – respondents guaranteed any profit shortfall of company the subject of share sale agreement in 1998 and 1999 – applicants leased property from respondents - any profit shortfall to be made up by reduction of rent payable to applicants in respect of lease – profit shortfall claimed  by applicants in 1998 and 1999 – respondents failed to refund rent to purchaser company in amounts of profit shortfall – whether oral variation of agreed profit shortfall for year ending 1998 – whether audit report for 1999 compliant with machinery of calculation in share sale agreement – whether profit shortfall for 1998 understated – whether change in control of company discharged respondents from guarantee – whether acquisition of a new business by the company discharged respondents from guarantee – whether valid consideration for guarantee – whether written variations to the  principal  share sale agreement discharged guarantee – whether applicants’ claim statute barred – whether  managing director of first applicant represented that guarantee would not be enforced – Order 20 rule 2 of the Federal Court Rules – whether claim was abuse of process due to missing source financial material

EVIDENCE – whether audit report detailing profit shortfall in 1999 admissible – whether audit report akin to a banker’s certificate – whether provision for audit report in relation to profit shortfall in share sale agreement a “Dobbs Clause” – audit report on 1999 profit shortfall based on source financial source material now missing – whether audit report prejudicial to respondents and inadmissible under section 135 and section 136 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – whether audit report a business record under section 69 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – whether subsequent report created for the purpose of litigation and inadmissible under section 69(3) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

AGENCY – whether co-surety second respondent liable for 1998 profit shortfall guarantee amount orally varied by first respondent and the first applicant – whether first respondent had ostensible authority to bind second respondent to oral variation of profit shortfall amount for 1998

Held: application successful in part – first respondent liable for damages to applicants for 1998 profit shortfall in the amount of $127,284 – oral variation of profit shortfall for 1998 bound first respondent but not second respondent – first respondent did not have ostensible authority to bind second respondent to variation of guarantee – provision in share sale agreement for audit report on profit shortfall not a “Dobbs Clause” – audit report not akin to a banker’s certificate – impossible to test accuracy of audit report or whether it complied with machinery of calculation in share sale agreement because of absence of source financial documentation – no admissible evidence as to 1999…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 675
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 4) involved Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited and Forbes Engineering Australia Pty Limited, the applicants, and Mr. Mark Forbes and Mrs. Jennifer Forbes, the respondents. The dispute arose from a share sale agreement executed on 22 September 1997, where Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited purchased shares in Forbes Engineering Australia Pty Limited for $3.9 million. The applicants sought damages for alleged breaches of the Forbes Guarantee and Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee, which were clauses in the share sale agreement guaranteeing certain profits and that any profit shortfall would be met by way of waiving lease payments. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicants were entitled to damages for the alleged breaches of the Forbes Guarantee and Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee. The court had to consider the validity of the agreement between the parties regarding the profit shortfall for the year ending 31 December 1998, the admissibility of certain documents, and whether the applicants' claims were an abuse of process. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the applicants' cause of action was statute-barred and whether Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited was estopped from relying on the profit guarantees.

The court found that an agreement was indeed reached between the parties regarding the profit shortfall for the year ending 31 December 1998, and the applicants were entitled to damages in the amount of $127,284. The court also held that certain documents were inadmissible under sections 135 and 136 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Furthermore, the court dismissed the respondents' defences that the applicants' cause of action was statute-barred and that Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited was estopped from relying on the profit guarantees. Finally, the court ruled that the applicants' claims were not an abuse of process, despite the absence of source financial documentation.

In conclusion, the court ordered that the applicants were entitled to damages against the first respondent for breach of the Forbes Guarantee and the Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee in the amount of $127,284, plus interest. The court also excluded certain documents from evidence and dismissed the respondents' remaining defences. The issue of costs was to be decided on written submissions without the necessity for a hearing unless a party requested one or the Court scheduled a hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to the amended application filed 31 March 2006:

(a) the applicants are entitled to damages as against the first respondent for breach of the Forbes Guarantee and the Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee in the amount of $127,284;

(b) the first respondent is pay the applicants interest at the annual rate of 10% on the sum ordered to be paid in sub-paragraph 1(a) herein pursuant to section 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), to be calculated from the date the applicants’ cause of action arose;

(c) the application is otherwise dismissed.

2. In relation to the notice of motion filed 12 September 2007:

(a) pursuant to section 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) pages 130-192 of annexure “PK1” to the affidavit of Poh Kiat affirmed on 25 October 2005 are excluded from evidence admitted, or to be admitted, in this proceeding;

(b) the notice of motion is otherwise dismissed.

3. The applicants are to file and serve submissions as to costs, and copy them in electronic form to the associate, by 4.00 pm on 6 July 2009.

4. The respondents are to file and serve submissions as to costs, and copy them in electronic form to the associate, by 4.00 pm on 20 July 2009.

5. The applicants are to file and serve submissions as to costs in reply, and copy them in electronic form to the associate, by 4.00 pm on 27 July 2009.

6. The issue of costs is to be decided on written submissions without the necessity for a hearing unless either party should contact my chambers and the other party by 4.00 pm on 30 July 2009 and request a hearing or unless the Court schedules a hearing to hear oral submissions.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

I consider it appropriate to treat this aspect of the applicants’ claim as abandoned.BACKGROUNDRelevant Parties At all material times, the first applicant (“Forbes Asia”) was a company incorporated in Singapore, and a subsidiary of Teamsphere Ltd which was also a Singapore-based company. Mr Poh Kiat, who gave evidence on behalf of the applicants at the hearing of this matter, and who was a key witness in these proceedings for the applicants, was at all material times Managing Director of both Forbes Asia and Teamsphere Ltd. The second applicant (“Forbes Australia”) was, at all material times, a company incorporated in Australia which carried on business both within and outside Australia. Prior to September 1997, Forbes Australia was a specialised company based in Brisbane which provided services to the concrete industry, notably in relation to establishment of plants and the construction of equipment for transportation of concrete. After the sale of shares of Forbes Australia in September 1997 the company continued to carry on business in the same industry. Until September 1997 the owners of the shares in Forbes Australia were two companies, Pearlbunch Pty Ltd (“Pearlbunch”) and Talrate Pty Ltd (“Talrate”), both of which were controlled by the first respondent, Mr Forbes, as sole director. Mr Forbes was sole shareholder of Pearlbunch, and was also the sole director and (with Mrs Forbes) a shareholder of another company, Forbes Screens Pty Ltd (“Forbes Screens”). At the time of the share sale agreement executed by Forbes Asia as purchaser and Pearlbunch and Talrate as vendors on 22 September 1997 by which the shares in Forbes Australia were transferred to Forbes Asia (“share sale agreement”), Mr Forbes was the managing director and chief executive officer of Forbes Australia. He retained this position until 22 February 2000. At all material times Mr Forbes and Mrs Forbes were joint owners of certain property described as Lot 8 on RP 229240, County of Stanley, Parish of Toombul (“Lot 8”). Until 15 June 2000, Forbes Screens owned an adjoining property (“Lot 9”).Leases of Lot 8 and Lot 9 On 17 September 1997 Mr Forbes and Mrs Forbes entered into a lease of Lot 8 with Forbes Australia. On 22 September 1997 Forbes Screens entered into a lease of Lot 9 with Forbes Australia.Share Sale Agreement The shares in Forbes Australia were transferred to Forbes Asia on 22 September 1997 for a purchase price of $3.9 million. The share sale agreement took place following what appear to be extensive negotiations during July, August and September 1997 between the parties. The initial negotiations in respect of the acquisition took place primarily between Forbes Asia represented by Mr Poh, and the interests of the vendors of the shares in Forbes Australia represented by Mr Forbes. Formal discussions in the period prior to execution of the share sale agreement involved the parties’ legal representatives (including Mr Steven Grant for Mr Forbes and the vendors and Mr Freddy Chan for the purchasers) and accounting advisers. I shall return to consider these negotiations later in this judgment, because findings in respect of the negotiations are important in relation to a number of the applicants’ claims in this case.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In these proceedings, in summary:·In relation to the alleged profit shortfall for the year ending 31 December 1998 an agreement was reached by Mr Poh on behalf of the applicants and Mr Forbes as to the agreed profit shortfall. The absence of source financial documentation was, as I have already found, irrelevant in relation to the validity and enforcement of that agreement.·In relation to the alleged profit shortfall for the year ending 31 December 1999, while I consider that the absence of source financial documentation was a key issue for reasons I have already explained, I do not consider that the applicants’ claim with respect to alleged profit shortfall for that year was in any fashion an abuse of process. The applicants pleaded, inter alia, that the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu report satisfied the requirements of cl 3.3 and Annexure 1 of the share sale agreement akin to a certificate as discussed in Dobbs (1935) 53 CLR 643. In my view this was a legitimate claim, notwithstanding that this aspect of the applicants’ claim was unsuccessful.Admissibility of documents and section 135 and section 136 of the Evidence Act The respondents have also sought exclusion of the material in:·Pages 130-192 of annexure “PK1” to the affidavit of Poh Kiat affirmed herein on 25 October 2005. In summary, this material is the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu report, a letter from Freehills on behalf of the applicants to Mr Grant dated 6 April 2001, and a report prepared by Ernst & Young, apparently at the request of Mr Poh, dated 4 October 2001.·Paragraph 34 and para 35 of, and pp 13-54 of Annexure “PK2” to, the affidavit of Poh Kiat affirmed herein on 15 March 2006. In summary, this material is evidence of Mr Poh and working papers of Mr Poh including letters from Marsh & Partners.·The Expert Report dated 18 September 2006 prepared for the applicants. This refers to the expert report prepared by Mr Angus Blackwood. In relation to these documents:·For the reasons I gave earlier in this judgment, the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu report is inadmissible. It follows that the Ernst & Young report dated 4 October 2001 and the letter from Freehills on behalf of the applicants to Mr Grant dated 6 April 2001 are also inadmissible pursuant to s 135 of the Evidence Act. In the interests of completeness however I note that even had I not considered the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu report inadmissible in accordance with s 135 I would have made such an order in respect of the Ernst & Young report dated 4 October 2001 on the basis that:oWhile there is evidence that the original instructions from Mr Poh to Ernst & Young to prepare to the report were given in 2000 (and possibly prior to contemplation of litigation), evidence also demonstrates that 19 months passed before the report was delivered to the applicants during which time letters had been exchanged between the legal representatives of the parties.oFurther, in the covering letter dated 4 October 2001 from Ernst & Young to Mr Poh delivering the report, the author notes “... the procedures were performed solely to assist you in determining the quantum and importance of certain financial issues to be raised with the previous Managing Director, Mr Mark Forbes”.I consider an inference can be drawn from the surrounding circumstances that the Ernst & Young report was “a document prepared for or obtained for the purpose of conducting, or for or in contemplation of or in connection with, a proceeding” and accordingly excluded from the definition of “business record” by s 69(3)(a) of the Evidence Act.·I do not consider that an order pursuant to either s 135 or s 136 of the Evidence Act should be made in relation to para 34 and para 35 of, and pp 13-54 of annexure “PK2” to, the affidavit of Poh Kiat affirmed herein on 15 March 2006. I take this view because:oMr Poh’s evidence directly answered evidence of Mr Forbes in his affidavit sworn 16 December 2005 and Mr Brauer in his affidavit sworn 25 January 2006.oA letter from Marsh & Partners to the directors of Forbes Group Australia dated 16 February 2000 and a letter from Marsh & Partners to Mr Forbes dated 14 March 2000, both of which are exhibited to Mr Poh’s affidavit (and found within pp 13-54 of Annexure “PK2” to which the respondents object) are also exhibited to Mr Forbes’ affidavit sworn 16 December 2005 as Annexure “MF-4”. Accordingly, it is clear that the respondents were relying on some of the same material they now seek to impugn.oThe material is relevant to both the applicants’ claims concerning the 1998 profit shortfall and the respondents’ defence.·I do not consider that an order pursuant to either s 135 or s 136 of the Evidence Act should be made in relation to Mr Blackwood’s expert report. In my view no grounds have been substantiated by the respondents’ to support such an order.CONCLUSION

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
The respondents filed a third further amended defence on 13 February 2008. The respondents conceded that cl 3.3 of the share sale agreement was in the nature of a guarantee of performance by the vendors. Notwithstanding this concession, in substance the respondents plead as follows:·The share sale agreement did not permit any calculation, ascertainment or proof of the audited profit before tax of Forbes Australia by:othe mere fact of preparation of a document or documents (including documents styled as audited financial statements) in purported conformity with cl 3.3; orothe presentation or delivery of such document or documents;by Forbes Asia to any person who might be liable in respect of the guarantee under cl 3.3 (para 4B(ba)(i)).·The share sale agreement upon its proper construction permitted the parties who were potentially liable in respect of the guarantee under cl 3.3 to undertake their own assessment, and challenge any assertion as to, inter alia, the profit earned by Forbes Australia in each of the 1997, 1998, and 1999 calendar years (para 4B (ba)(ii)).·The guarantee under cl 3.3 was, upon its proper construction, premised on the continuation of certain matters set out in cl 3.1 of the share sale agreement, namely that the vendors were and remained entitled to control the make up of the board of Forbes Australia. This did not occur – instead Forbes Asia controlled the make-up of the board of Forbes Australia and appointed new directors as and when it saw fit. Accordingly, the guarantee under cl 3.3 was discharged (para 4B(c)).·Alternatively, prior to the formation of the share sale agreement, Mr Forbes provided profit forecasts to Forbes Asia in respect of Forbes Australia’s business as it then was, namely based entirely in Brisbane. Forbes Asia knew that the profit forecasts were based upon Forbes Australia’s Brisbane-based business as it then was. The profit guarantees in cl 3.3 of the share sale agreement were based on the Brisbane-based business of Forbes Australia. In 1999 Forbes Australia’s business was altered significantly and substantially by the acquisition of Favco. The acquisition of Favco rendered the profit forecasts originally provided by Mr Forbes inapplicable to Forbes Australia’s business after the acquisition. Accordingly, the acquisition of Favco was a fundamental alteration to the transaction guaranteed by the respondents and discharged the respondents from any liability under the profit guarantees (para 4B(d)).·The respondents deny that they incurred any liability under the Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee; alternatively that there was no valid consideration for it and accordingly it was void (para 4D).·While the respondents admit the existence of the deeds of variation to the share sale agreement:othe third deed of variation replaced the existing cl 2.3 of the share sale agreement with an entirely new and materially different clause. Neither of the respondents agreed to extend any existing guarantee or indemnity provided by them to Forbes Asia. The Forbes Guarantee was discharged by the third deed of variation or alternatively was unenforceable (para 4F(d));oalternatively, the fourth deed of variation substantially amended cl 2.3 of the share sale agreement which meant that the Forbes Guarantee was discharged or alternatively was unenforceable (para 4F(e)).·In defence of the entire claim the respondents say that the applicants’ cause of action arose more than six years prior to the commencement of the claim and is thereby statute barred (para 12 – see also TS p 16 and p 17).·Alternatively, the respondents say that Forbes Asia is estopped from relying on the profit guarantees in circumstances where:oon or about 15 or 16 September 1997, prior to the execution of the share sale agreement and the side letters in respect of Lot 8 and Lot 9, Mr Poh on behalf of Forbes Asia said to Mr Forbes that the profit guarantees would never be enforced by Forbes Asia and were just matters necessary to be included to satisfy the demands of its parent company Teamsphere Ltd;oin reliance on this representation Mr Forbes executed the documents;osubsequent to the execution of the documents, Mr Poh on behalf of Forbes Asia has repeated to the respondents that it would not enforce the Profit Guarantee thereby maintaining the representation.ISSUES FOR DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

The respondents submitted in summary:·Mr Forbes agreed with Mr Poh that the agreed profit shortfall for the 1998 calendar year was $127,284 but the agreement was founded upon a misapprehension on the part of Mr Forbes that there had been a proper accounting of all of Forbes Australia’s sales for the 1998 calendar year.·Forbes Australia had failed to record approximately $241,000 in sales, which sales had occurred in 1998 rather than 1997.·Although invoices were issued in November and December 1997, Forbes Asia asked for invoices to be re-issued to suit Forbes Asia, and therefore new invoices were issued in respect of the same goods in February 1998.·Forbes Asia, by its request for the issuing of credit notes in respect of those sales, knew that the sales had occurred in 1998. Had those sales been taken up on Forbes Australia’s accounts for the 1998 calendar year, there would have been no profit shortfall that year.·The respondents submit that those sales should have been recorded in Forbes Australia’s 1998 calendar year accounts.·Notwithstanding statements of Mr Brauer and Mr Poh in relation to the accruals accounting basis of Forbes Australia:othere is no evidence as to whether Forbes Asia treated the sales as having occurred in 1997 or 1998;othe re-issued invoices state that title to the goods does not pass until payment for the goods is received (affidavit of Terrence Brauer filed 18 January 2008 exhibit “TB 5” invoices 23295 and 232396);oMr Lytras’ evidence, which was not tested or challenged, its that on the face of the relevant invoice documents it is not possible to tell without access to Forbes Australia’s books and records whether the sales should properly be attributed to the 1997 or 1998 calendar years (affidavit of Elia Lytras affirmed 11 February 2008 para 4 and para 5).·Accordingly, it would be unconscionable to permit the applicants to enforce the agreement formed on 14 January 1999.·In any event, the agreement formed on 14 January 1999 did not involve, and was not binding upon, Mrs Forbes.·Further and alternatively, it is an abuse of process to permit the applicants to enforce the agreement of 14 January 1999 because Forbes Australia has failed to maintain its financial records, meaning that the respondents cannot reasonably and properly identify Forbes Australia’s correct sales for the 1998 calendar year.Consideration For the moment placing to one side the issue of whether the basis on which the agreement was reached was flawed – it is clear from the evidence before the Court that an agreement was reached by Mr Poh and Mr Forbes at a meeting held on or about 14 January 1999. The agreement was to the effect that Forbes Australia had suffered a profit shortfall of $127,284 for the financial year ending 31 December 1998. It appears that this profit shortfall was calculated by Mr Brauer, the accountant for Forbes Australia, and Mr Kang Ching Hong, the internal auditor for Teamsphere Ltd, and accepted by Mr Poh and Mr Forbes. It also appears that at that meeting the parties discussed the method by which the profit shortfall would be remedied by Mr Forbes. Subsequently Forbes Australia recorded the sum of $127,294 as a prepayment of rent payable under the Lot 8 lease in the books of account of Forbes Australia. A clear inference may be drawn that this action was in accordance with both the Forbes Guarantee and the Forbes Lot 8 Lease Guarantee which as already noted provided respectively that Mr and Mrs Forbes guaranteed certain profits and that any profit shortfall would be met by way of waiving lease payments.