Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 5) [2009] FCA 873

COSTS – section 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – both parties partially successful – applicant successful in minor monetary claim and majority of issues – respondent successfully defended major monetary claim – defendants unsuccessful in majority of defences raised – principles for awarding costs – exceptions to the rule that costs follow the event – cost of respondents’ partially successful notice of motion – principles where a respondent not active in proceedings

Held: respondents entitled to costs of interlocutory application for non-party discovery – second respondent not active in proceedings and not entitled to award of costs for or against her – otherwise no other order as to costs for substantive proceedings or notice of motion of 12 September 2007

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 135, 136
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43

Australian Trade Commission v Disktravel [2000] FCA 62 cited
Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCAFC 107 followed
Elliott v Lord Rokeby (1881) 7 App Cas 43 cited
Emirates v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2) [2009] FCA 492 cited
Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes [2007] FCA 67 cited
Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 4) [2009] FCA 675 cited
Interim Advance Corporation Pty Ltd trading as Aussie Cash v Commissioner for Consumer Protection (2009) WASC 1 cited
Leading Edge Events Australia Pty Ltd v Kiri Te Kanawa (No 2) (2007) NSWSC 568 cited
New South Wales Dairy Corporation v Murray-Goulburn Co-Operative Company Limited (1989) 14 IPR 75 cited
The Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the Ritz Ltd (1989) AIPC 38,940 (90-567)

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED (COMPANY NO 1997 020 35N) and FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 832 023) v MARK FORBES and KAREN LEE FORBES

NSD 636 of 2005

COLLIER J
14 AUGUST 2009
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 636 of 2005

BETWEEN:

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED (COMPANY NO 1997 020 35N)
First Applicant

FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 832 023)
Second Applicant

AND:

MARK FORBES
First Respondent

KAREN LEE FORBES
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 AUGUST 2009

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants are liable for the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the application filed 18 January 2007.

2.Otherwise as between the applicants and the respondents there shall be no order as to costs.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 636 of 2005

BETWEEN:

FORBES ENGINEERING (ASIA) PTE LIMITED (COMPANY NO 1997 020 35N)
First Applicant

FORBES ENGINEERING HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 832 023)
Second Applicant

AND:

MARK…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 873
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited v Forbes (No 5) involved a dispute between the applicants and the respondents over damages claimed for profit shortfalls in 1998 and 1999. The matter was before the Federal Court of Australia, which had to decide on the allocation of costs between the parties, following the applicants' partial success in obtaining relief for the 1999 profit shortfall.

The legal issues the court had to resolve included the appropriate method for assessing costs given the applicants' partial success, the relevance and impact of certain interlocutory applications by the respondents, and whether the applicants' costs claim should be accepted or rejected based on their success rate. The respondents argued that the applicants should only be compensated for 7% of their claim, and that the applicants' costs claim was excessive given their limited success. The respondents also highlighted the importance of their applications for disclosure and to exclude evidence, which were critical to their defense.

The Court considered the discretionary power to award costs under the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, recognising that while costs traditionally follow the event, a fair result might warrant an issue-based apportionment. The Court noted that the applicants had succeeded in obtaining relief for only a small portion of their claim and that the respondents' successful defense of the majority of the claim warranted a costs order in their favour. The Court found that the applicants' costs claim should be rejected as it was disproportionate to their limited success. Additionally, the Court held that the respondents' interlocutory applications were crucial to their defense, and thus, the applicants should bear the costs of these applications.

The final orders made by the Court were that the applicants are liable for the respondents' costs of and incidental to the application filed on 18 January 2007. Otherwise, there shall be no order as to costs between the applicants and the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants are liable for the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the application filed 18 January 2007.

2. Otherwise as between the applicants and the respondents there shall be no order as to costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Forbes Engineering (Asia) Pte Limited (the applicant) sued Forbes (the respondents) in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging breaches of contract and seeking damages. The applicant claimed that the respondents failed to pay certain amounts due under a contract and sought damages for a profit shortfall in 1998 and 1999. The case involved complex financial transactions and disputes over the interpretation and performance of the contract terms. The applicant alleged that the respondents did not fulfil their contractual obligations, leading to a shortfall in profits. The respondents denied the allegations and argued that the applicant's claims were unfounded. The case proceeded to trial where evidence was presented on both sides, and the court made findings regarding the liability and damages.

The matter was initially filed in the Federal Court of Australia. Following the trial, the court delivered a judgment in favour of the applicant on certain claims and against the applicant on others, awarding damages of $127,284. The respondents appealed the decision, arguing that the applicant had only succeeded in 7% of its claim and should not be awarded any costs. The appeal was heard by the Full Court of the Federal Court, which reviewed the lower court's decision, the evidence presented, and the submissions from both parties. The Full Court considered the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
Issues
1. Whether the applicant is entitled to any costs from the respondents given the partial success on its claims?
2. Should the respondents be ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the application filed on 18 January 2007?
3. Should the applicant pay the respondents' costs of and incidental to the proceeding?

Held
1. The applicant is not entitled to any costs from the respondents given the partial success on its claims.
2. The respondents should not be ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the application filed on 18 January 2007.
3. The applicant should pay the respondents' costs of and incidental to the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

In summary the respondents submitted:·In that the applicants successfully obtained relief in the sum of $127,284 by way of damages, they succeeded as to 7% only in respect of their claim and had failed entirely against the second respondent.·Contrary to the submissions of the applicants, the greater part of the applicants’ claim centred on the 1999 profit shortfall. It is not true to say that most of the trial was directed towards the 1998 profit shortfall.·The applicants’ claim for costs based upon success in respect of 7% of its claim and against the first respondent only should be rejected.·There is no suggestion that any of the issues raised by the respondents but upon which they did not succeed were raised inappropriately by the respondents.·In relation to interlocutory applications in these proceedings:othe respondents’ application for disclosure from Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu was plainly relevant to the ultimate outcome in the action as it demonstrated the absence of critical documents in the possession of that firm;othe respondents’ application to stay the action as an abuse of process or for exclusion of evidence under s 135 and s 136 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) lay at the foundation of the respondents’ successful defence of the applicants’ claim in respect of the 1999 profit shortfall.·The applicants should pay all of the second respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding.·The first respondent’s successful defence of 93% of the applicants’ claim militates in favour of a similar order for costs in his favour; alternatively the applicants should pay the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to defending the applicants’ claim in respect of the 1999 profit shortfall, including payment of such costs on an indemnity basis from 26 September 2007.Consideration The Court has a discretionary power in each case to award costs. So far as relevant s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) provides as follows:(1)Subject to subsection (1A), the Court or a Judge has jurisdiction to award costs in all proceedings before the Court (including proceedings dismissed for want of jurisdiction) other than proceedings in respect of which any other Act provides that costs shall not be awarded.….(2)Except as provided by any other Act, the award of costs is in the discretion of the Court or a Judge. As a general proposition costs follow the event in the absence of circumstances justifying departure from that position. However in this case, to echo McLelland J in The Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the Ritz Ltd (1989) AIPC 38,940 (90-567) at 940, “the event” is a complex notion. While the courts caution against too ready a resort to apportionment according to issue-based outcomes (Australian Trade Commission v Disktravel [2000] FCA 62 at [3] (Full Court), cf Emirates v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2) [2009] FCA 492), more recently the Full Court has also observed that fairness should dictate how judicial discretion is to be exercised in respect of costs. Accordingly if an issue by issue approach will produce a result that is fairer than the traditional rule, it should be applied (Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCAFC 107 at [5]).