COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA v OBERDAN
[2000] SASC 428
Civil
1................ DUGGAN J....... This is an action commenced by the Commonwealth Bank to enforce three guarantees against the defendant as guarantor. The defendant has resisted the claim on a number of grounds including failure of the plaintiff to act in accordance with alleged representations made to the defendant, non-disclosure by the plaintiff to the defendant of information relating to co-guarantors, unconscionable conduct and misleading and deceptive conduct. The defendant was represented by counsel until shortly before the commencement of the trial. He was unrepresented throughout the trial.
At all relevant times, the defendant was a property developer and companies with which he was associated owned buildings in the city and metropolitan area of Adelaide. The three guarantees were provided by the defendant at the time of the purchase of various buildings owned or part owned by companies associated with him. The guarantees have been referred to throughout the trial as the St Christopher guarantee, the Haventide guarantee and the Edinburgh Castle guarantee.
The St Christopher Guarantee
In September 1987 the CBA building in King William Street was purchased by St Christopher Pty Ltd as trustee for the St Christopher Unit Trust for approximately $5.5m. The St Christopher Unit Trust was established by a syndicate formed for the specific purpose of purchasing the CBA building. The unit holders of the trust and their percentage holdings were V. Oberdan Pty Ltd as trustee for the Vincent Oberdan Family Trust No. 2 (25 per cent), Ginos Holdings Pty Ltd as trustee for the Ginos Trust (25 per cent), Augathella Pty Ltd (40 per cent) and V & G Piscioneri Investments Pty Ltd as trustee for the Piscioneri Family Trust (10 per cent). V. Oberdan Pty Ltd underwent a subsequent name change to Haventide Pty Ltd and will be referred to by that name throughout these reasons. This company was controlled by the defendant and his family. The Ginos family which controls the Ginos interests referred to above joined in various business undertakings with the defendant through Mr Zisis Ginos who was also a property developer. Augathella Pty Ltd was controlled by the Dimasi family who are related to the defendant through his sister. The Piscioneri family are also related to the defendant through another of his sisters.
The purchase of the CBA building was funded by moneys loaned to St Christopher Pty Ltd by the plaintiff. On 17 September 1987 the plaintiff, as creditor, and the defendant and Haventide Pty Ltd as guarantors, entered into the St Christopher guarantee. The guarantors guaranteed the payment of all moneys then and subsequently owed to the plaintiff by St Christopher Pty Ltd. However, the liability of these guarantors, which was joint and several, was restricted to the amount of $1.1m plus interest.
Guarantees were also given by the other parties involved in the syndicate. Ginos Holdings Pty Ltd and Mr Zisis Ginos became jointly and severally liable as guarantors to the extent of $1.1m. A guarantee…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Oberdan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 428
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary judge rejected the various defences relied upon by the defendant to avoid liability under the guarantees. The primary judge found that the evidence did not support the various representations made by the plaintiff that were alleged to have been relied upon by the defendant. The primary judge found that there was no duty on the plaintiff to disclose information about the financial circumstances of the co-guarantors. The primary judge found that there was no concluded agreement to vary the terms of the St Christopher guarantee. The primary judge found that there was no evidence to support the various representations relied upon to establish misleading and deceptive conduct. The primary judge found that the defendant was not in a position of special disadvantage and that the plaintiff had not acted unconscionably. The primary judge found that the properties were sold for their true market value. The primary judge dismissed the defendant's counterclaim for rectification of the guarantees and declarations that the guarantees are unenforceable in their present form. The primary judge gave judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $11,191,197.06 and dismissed the counterclaim.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi