SZQOG v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZQOG v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2013] FCCA 203
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial review – independent merits review – whether jurisdictional error by reason of failure to consider or address applicant’s claims – whether applicant denied procedural fairness because of failure to inform of adverse conclusions or inferences – whether jurisdictional error by failure to take into account relevant evidence – whether jurisdictional error because evidence misconstrued – whether jurisdictional error by exclusion from consideration of consistent and relevant evidence of persecution – whether jurisdictional error by failing to take into account relevant considerations concerning relocation.

Legislation:

Constitution (Cth), s.75(v)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2), 91R(1) and (2), 476

Cases cited:
Abebe v The Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 197 CLR 510; [1999] HCA 14
Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630; [2003] FCAFC 184
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond & Ors (1990) 170 CLR 321
AZAAA v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship & Anor (2009) 177 FCR 363; [2009] FCA 554
Craig v The State of South Australia (2003) 184 CLR 163
Darabi v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship & Anor (2011) 250 FLR 301; [2011] FMCA 371
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; [2003] HCA 26
DZABT v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2012] FMCA 489
Htun v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244; [2001] FCA 1802
Kopalapillai v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1998) 86 FCR 547
Li v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship & Anor (2008) 102 ALD 354; [2008] FCA 902
Li Shi Ping & Anor v Minister for Immigration, Local Government & Ethnic Affairs (1994) 35 ALD 225
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZJSS & Ors (2010) 243 CLR 164; [2010] HCA 48
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZMDS & Anor (2010) 240 CLR 611; [2010] HCA 16
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNVW & Anor (2010) 183 FCR 575; [2010] FCAFC 41
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Guo & Anor (1997) 191 CLR 559
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang & Ors (1996) 185 CLR 259
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Indatissa& Anor (2001) 64 ALD 1; [2001] FCA 181
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Rajalingam & Ors (1999) 93 FCR 220; [1999] FCA 719
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Respondents S152/2003 (2004) 222 CLR 1; [2004] HCA 18
Mukto v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1801
MZXIV v Minister for Immigration & Anor (No.2) [2006] FMCA 1454
MZYNK v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2011] FMCA 994
MZYOS v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2012] FMCA 422
NABE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (No 2) (2004) 144 FCR 1; [2004] FCAFC 263
NADR v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZQOG v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, SZQOG, sought judicial review of a decision by an independent merits reviewer (IMR) recommending that the applicant not be recognised as a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations under the Refugee Convention. The Minister for Immigration and Citizenship was the first respondent, and the IMR was the second respondent. The applicant sought a declaration that the IMR's recommendation was not made in accordance with law, an injunction restraining the Minister from relying on the recommendation, and costs. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia at Perth.

The court was required to determine whether the IMR made jurisdictional errors and denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to consider or address claims for refugee status and persecution based on a well-founded fear of persecution as a member of the Hazara ethnic and religious minority group. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the IMR failed to take into account relevant evidence supporting these claims, including country of origin and documentary evidence. The applicant also contended that the IMR failed to consider specific provisions of section 91R of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) concerning the essential and significant reasons for persecution, the involvement of serious harm, and systematic and discriminatory conduct.

The court's reasoning involved considering numerous objections to affidavits tendered by the applicant. Objections were upheld regarding paragraphs of affidavits that dealt with the interpretation of interviews and country information not before the IMR, as the court found this material irrelevant to the judicial review of the IMR's decision. However, an admission against interest regarding potential contact with the Taliban was deemed admissible. The court applied the principle that an IMR is not obligated to consider all available country information, but rather to determine which information it relies upon. The court found that the applicant's claims regarding persecution as an ethnic and religious minority were not adequately substantiated or were undermined by inconsistencies and implausible denials of knowledge, leading to a finding that the applicant was not credible.

The application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The application be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AT PERTH

SYG 1845 of 2011

SZQOG

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

LUKE HARDY, IN HIS CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Application

1.

This is an application under s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“Migration Act”) for a declaration and injunction in relation to an independent merits reviewer’s (“the IMR”) decision (“IMR Recommendation”) at Court Book (“CB”) 161-189 finding that the applicant does not meet the criterion for a protection visa set out in s.36(2) of the Migration Act, and recommending that the applicant not be recognised as a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (“Convention”).

The grounds of the application

2.

There are seven separate grounds for the application, each particularised, as further amended by the applicant’s Further Amended Grounds for Judicial Review filed by leave on the day of hearing. Each ground was the subject of extensive written submissions by the applicant (62 pages in total) and the respondent (29 pages in total). Each ground is set out and dealt with separately and fully below.

Relief sought

3.

The applicant seeks the following relief:

a) a declaration that the IMR’s IMR Recommendation was not made in accordance with law, by reason of the grounds of this application;

b) an injunction restraining the Minister, by himself or by his Department, officers, delegates or agents, from relying upon the IMR Recommendation; and

c) costs.

Jurisdiction

4.

The application, which seeks injunctive relief in this Court in relation to the still to be completed decision-making process by the Minister in relation to the IMR Recommendation, is within this Court’s jurisdiction for relief in relation to a migration decision: Migration Act, s.476(1); Plaintiff M61/2010E & Anor v The Commonwealth of Australia & Ors (2010) 243 CLR 319 at 334, 344-345 and 358-360 per French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ; [2010] HCA 41 at paras.8, 50-52 and 99-103 per French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ (“Plaintiff M61”); Darabi v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship & Anor (2011) 250 FLR 301 at 308 per Nicholls FM; [2011] FMCA 371 at para.31 per Nicholls FM.

Background facts

5.

The background facts are as follows:

a) the applicant was born on 31 December 1974 in Voruzgan Province in Afghanistan: CB 33 and 64;

b) the applicant’s current wife is 32 years of age, and the applicant has six sons aged between three and 17 years, as well as two nephews aged 12 and 14, who are dependent upon him: CB 6, 42-43 and 46;

c) the applicant worked in Iran from 2000 to 2002: CB 9;

d) the applicant arrived at Christmas Island by boat on 24 April 2010: CB 1, 37 and 87;

e) an entry interview was conducted with the applicant at Christmas Island on 7 May 2010: CB 1, 19 and 30;

f) a Refugee Status Assessment (“RSA”) was requested by the applicant on 10 October 2010: CB 31 and 55;

g) the applicant made a statutory declaration on 10 October 2010 (“Applicant’s Statutory Declaration”) in support of the RSA: CB 59-60;

h) an RSA interview (“RSA Interview”) was conducted with the applicant on 14 October 2010: CB 162; affidavit of Shayla Marie Strapps affirmed 14 April 2012 (“Ms Strapps’ First Affidavit”) at para.3;

i) the RSA was determined on 26 November 2010 (“RSA Determination”): CB 87-97, and the applicant was informed of the negative RSA Determination by letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (“Department”) dated 26 November 2010: CB 85-86;

j) the applicant’s solicitors made a request for independent merits review on behalf of the applicant on 7 December 2010: CB 103-107; and

k) a 49 page submission by the applicant’s solicitors (“Applicant’s Solicitors’ Submissions”) was made in support of the applicant’s request for an independent merits review and emailed to the IMR on 29 March 2011: CB 108 (email), CB 109-157;

l) the applicant was interviewed by the IMR on 7 April 2011: (“IMR Interview”): CB 171-175 at paras.40-74; and

m) the IMR Recommendation was given on 29 July 2011: CB 161-187, and the applicant was advised of the IMR Recommendation on 2 August 2011: CB 159-160.

The IMR’s summary of the applicant’s claims

6.

The claims made by the applicant and the bases for those claims were summarised in the IMR Recommendation as follows:

a) the applicant was resident in Afghanistan at the time of the events alleged to constitute persecution for a Convention reason or reasons;

b) the applicant is an ethnic Hazara Shi’ite Muslim: CB 183 at para.101;

c) the Taliban persecute Hazaras by reason of their ethnicity, and may stop a Hazara (including the applicant) on the road and kill them for being a Hazara: CB 182 at para.98 and 186 at para.114;

d) the Taliban persecute Hazaras because they regard them as religious infidels, because they are Shi’ite Muslims: CB 182 at paras.98 and 100 and CB 183 at para.101;

e) the Taliban tormented the applicant on a number of occasions, and targeted him for working with the Afghanistan government or foreign interests, and may stop the applicant on the road and kill him for suspected complicity with the Afghanistan government or foreign interests: CB 182 at para.98, CB 183 at paras.101-104 and CB 186 at para.114; and

f) the applicant’s village was surrounded by Kuchi nomads who had threatened to kill the population of the village, and the applicant had been the subject of constant threats by Kuchi nomads to kill him, and the Kuchi nomads had destroyed the applicant’s crops: CB 185 at para.110.

7.

Relevant aspects of the applicant’s claims are expanded upon further below, where necessary.

Summary of the IMR Recommendation

8.

The IMR Recommendation recommended that the applicant not be recognised as a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations under the Convention: CB 187 at para.120. The IMR’s reasons for making that recommendation are summarised below:

a) the applicant was not credible and:

i) gave inconsistent evidence and introduced significant new claims at a late stage: CB 182 at para.97, CB 184 at paras.105-106, and CB 185 at paras.110 and 112; and

ii) made implausible denials of knowledge about his family circumstances in Qalai Shada: CB 185 at para.112;

b) save for the time spent in Iran, the applicant was a farmer in or around Barkar from about 1987 to 2008, and appears to have been a type of leaseholder or share-farmer not owning the land upon which he farmed, but devoted most of his time during this period to taxi driving and derived little income from farm work: CB 184 at para.108;

c) the applicant regularly drove taxis, possibly as early as 2002, or at least by 2004, until 2008, and was still driving and delivering during 2009: CB 184 at paras.109;

d) the applicant opened and ran a shop in Barkar in or around 2009 but that activity did not bring him into contact with the Taliban: CB 185 at para.109;

e) there is no sufficiently compelling evidence that as at mid-2010 the Taliban were about to invade the Jaghori district: CB 182-183 at para.100;

f) the applicant had lived and worked in Daikundi since his return from Iran in 2002: CB 185 at para.113 and CB 187 at para.117;

g) the applicant will be readily recognised by the Taliban as a Shi’ite Hazara because of his looks and because he also spoke like a Shi’ite Hazara: CB 183 at para.101;

h) the applicant had had no encounters with the Taliban: CB 183 at paras.101-104, CB 184 at paras.106-107 and 109; and CB 185 at para.109;

i) the applicant did not work (as he had alleged) for the World Food Programme (“WFP”) or any related entity: CB 183 at para.105 and CB 184 at paras.107 and 109;

j) no community in which the applicant lived, nor the applicant himself, faced any significant difficulty with Kuchi nomads, and if they did, it was not for a Convention related reason: CB 185 at para.110;

k) the applicant had moved almost his whole family to Qalai Shada in Ghazni City, a move inconsistent with the applicant’s claims for persecution, in circumstances where:

i) the applicant makes no Convention related or other relevant claims about the family’s circumstances in Qalai Shada;

ii) the applicant’s children were going to school and his family was living an unremarkable life in Ghazni Province: CB 185 at paras.111 and 112, and CB 187 at para.117; and

iii) the Taliban did not have any effective presence in or near the part of Ghazni Province where the applicant installed his family: CB 187 at para.117;

l) the Taliban does not have any effective presence in or near the areas of Daikundi where the applicant had lived and worked since his return from Iran to Afghanistan: CB 185 at para.113 and CB 187 at para.117;

m) the applicant can travel safely to and practicably access Daikundi (where the applicant lived and worked) and Qalai Shada in Ghazni City (where the applicant’s family lives and his children go to school) from Kabul, despite the fact that people are occasionally kidnapped for ransom: CB 186 at paras.114-116, and also CB 184 at para.109;

n) the applicant would not face a Convention related risk of harm as a returned asylum seeker: CB 186-187 at para.117; and

o) the applicant’s reliance on an Afghanistan minister’s statement as evidence to support the claim of Convention related harm was not made out as the statement was mainly about humanitarian concerns: CB 186-187 at para.117.

9.

Relevant aspects of the IMR Recommendation are dealt with in more detail below in the consideration of each ground of review.

Objections to affidavits

10.

The Minister objected to the various affidavits sought to be tendered by the applicant, which, subject to the objections, were accepted into evidence on the basis that the Court would rule on the objections as part of its Reasons for Judgment.

11.

In relation to the affidavit of Hamidullah Wasim affirmed 9 May 2012 (“Mr Wasim’s Affidavit”) the Minister objected to paragraphs 5 to 14 which dealt with the interpretation of the entry interview and paragraphs 15 to 26 dealing with the interpretation of the RSA Interview. The basis for those objections was essentially that the accuracy of the entry interview and RSA Interview were irrelevant in the context of a judicial review of an independent merits review. Generally, the Court would accept that might be the case, save where:

a) the IMR relied upon the accuracy of the interpretation, with or without notice to the parties, in relation to critical or credibility issues, where it subsequently transpired that the interpretation was inaccurate; or

b) the accurate interpretation contains an admission by the applicant against interest.

12.

In this case the objections to paragraphs 5 to 14 relating to the entry interview, and paragraphs 15 to 25 of the RSA Interview are upheld. They are upheld on the basis that, in any event, their content is irrelevant to any matter which is properly in issue. Whilst there may be some minor discrepancies in relation to what was interpreted, and some minor discrepancies in terms of place names and positions, none of these appear to be directly relevant to, or dispositive of, any matter in issue, individually or cumulatively.

13.

Paragraph 26 falls into a different category in that the applicant makes an admission that he may have had “one or two contacts with Taliban”: paragraph 26(c), before he had the shop. That is a potential admission against interest critical to the outcome of ground 6 below, and the Court will therefore overrule the objection to paragraph 26.

14.

In relation to the affidavit of Robert Foote affirmed 17 May 2012 (“Mr Foote’s Affidavit”) only paragraph 7(a) and (c) are objected to on the basis that the interpreters there named interpreted the entry interview and RSA Interview (the former inferentially). In circumstances where nothing in Mr Wasim’s Affidavit indicates any error in interpretation of any relevance in the entry interview the objection to paragraph 7(a) of Mr Foote’s Affidavit is upheld. Likewise, save for the applicant’s admission against interest in the RSA Interview referred to in paragraph 26 of Mr Wasim’s Affidavit, there is nothing of any relevance or dispositive, individually or cumulatively, in the remaining alleged interpretation errors in the RSA Interview, and therefore the objection to paragraph 7(c) is upheld.

15.

In relation to Joanna Olga Tedeschi’s affidavit affirmed 17 April 2012 (“Ms Tedeschi’s Affidavit”) that affidavit consists of various maps of Afghanistan, or parts thereof, derived from the website known as Google Maps, length of journey calculations derived from the above maps, two charts said to be derived from country of origin documents listed in the RSA record, and Ms Tedeschi’s commentary on those charts.

16.

Save for an admission by the Minister as a model litigant that Annexure K, which is a chart setting out ethnicity and province of intended final destination, seemingly in relation to the assisted voluntary repatriation of UNHCR registered Afghans, which was a document before the RSA Officer, the remaining material was not before the RSA Officer or the IMR. There was no obligation on the IMR to have regard to the maps or any information derived from them. The choice of independent country information referred to by an IMR is solely a matter for the IMR, and there is no obligation on an IMR to make inquiry with respect to other or more recent country information than that to which the IMR is referred by the parties, or is otherwise independently obtained by the IMR: SZEUZ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs & Anor [2006] FMCA 1032 at para.7 per Driver FM (“SZEUZ”). The policy reason for this is obvious: the IMR could be engaged on a never-ending task of sourcing country information from all manner of government agencies, independent think-tanks, media and press reports, and information on the worldwide web, such that if obligated to do so, the task would be a never-ending one, and any applicant for judicial review could always point to other country information seemingly relevant and said not to be considered by an independent merits reviewer. It follows that the affidavit material related to the maps, length of journey derived from the maps, and the chart not before the RSA Officer are all inadmissible. Likewise, Ms Tedeschi’s commentary on both the chart which was before the RSA Officer (and which is admissible) and the chart which was not before the RSA Officer, are inadmissible. The admissible chart speaks for itself, and the other chart is inadmissible. In any event, without any evidence as to her qualifications or experience, and without any information as to prior employment other than her employment as personal assistant to the applicant’s pro bono Counsel, it might be said that Ms Tedeschi was not qualified to comment upon the charts, if any commentary was necessary. In the circumstances, the objections to Ms Tedeschi’s Affidavit are upheld, and therefore all but paragraphs 1, 43 and 44 and Annexure K of Ms Tedeschi’s Affidavit are inadmissible.

17.

In relation to Ms Strapps’ First Affidavit the Minister objects to Annexures D1 through to D6 inclusive being various maps of Afghanistan showing Taliban or insurgent activity in 2007, 2008, 2009, a figure showing insurgent areas of operation in Afghanistan, a map of mined areas in Afghanistan and a map of land mines or unexploded ordinance in Afghanistan. The annexures appear to be derived from accessing websites referred to in country of origin documents referred to in the RSA Determination. Thus they are documents secondary to the documents before the RSA Officer, and only accessible by accessing the websites referred to in the documents referred to in the RSA Determination. As such, the documents were not themselves before the IMR, and indeed, not before the RSA Officer. It was for the IMR to determine what country information it relied upon: SZEUZ at para.7 per Driver FM. Further, there is no basis for concluding that even if the IMR had accessed these documents via the website referred to in the document before the RSA Officer, that any different conclusion might have been reached. It is not the law that the IMR is obliged to look at every website referred to in a document referred to in the RSA Determination. Again, the policy reason is obvious: if there is an obligation to do this, then there must be an obligation to follow through and access websites referred to in the websites referred to in the RSA Determination, and the task of referring to websites would be a never-ending one for the IMR. Annexures D1 to D6 were not before the IMR, and strictly not before the RSA Officer. In the circumstances they are irrelevant, and not admissible.

18.

The Minister also objects to Annexures 1 to 4 of the further affidavit of Shayla Marie Strapps affirmed 20 June 2012: (“Ms Strapps’ Second Affidavit”). The documents referred to in Annexures 1 to 4 of Ms Strapps’ Second Affidavit are country of origin documents which were set out in the RSA Determination. As such, they were documents which were available to the RSA Officer in reaching his unfavourable assessment in the RSA Decision, and were documents taken into account by the IMR: CB 162 at para.7. In those circumstances, the objection to their admissibility is not upheld. It remains the case however that the use to which those documents might be put in relation to the country information contained therein is a matter for the IMR.

19.

It follows that where an objection has been upheld in relation to the above affidavits the relevant paragraphs and annexures are to be struck out of the relevant affidavit.

Ground 1

20.

Ground 1 is as follows:

(A) The second respondent made jurisdictional errors, denying the applicant procedural fairness by not considering or addressing the claims for refugee status and persecution based on his well founded fear of persecution, as he was a member of the Hazaras who are a group that are persecuted due to ethnic and religious minority of the group and the criterion stated in section 91R(1) & (2)(a), (b), (c), (d), (e) and (f) of the Migration Act 1958, which claims had been made by the applicant and by the second respondent failing to take into account relevant evidence supporting those claims.

(B) The second respondent made jurisdictional errors, denying the applicant procedural fairness by not taking into account when he could and should have the country of origin or documentary evidence readily available comprised by:

(i) Annexures D-1 to D-6 in the affidavit of Shayla Strapps of 16 April 2012;

(ii) Annexures A to L to the affidavit of Joanna Olga Tedeschi of 17 April 2012;

(iii) Annexures 1 to 4 to the further affidavit of Shayla Marie Strapps of 20 June 2012.

21.

Section 91R(1) and (2) of the Migration Act provides as follows:

(1) For the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person, Article 1A(2) of the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol does not apply in relation to persecution for one or more of the reasons mentioned in that Article unless:

(a) that reason is the essential and significant reason, or those reasons are the essential and significant reasons, for the persecution; and

(b) the persecution involves serious harm to the person; and

(c) the persecution involves systematic and discriminatory conduct.

(2) Without limiting what is serious harm for the purposes of paragraph (1)(b), the following are instances of serious harm for the purposes of that paragraph:

(a) a threat to the person's life or liberty;

(b) significant physical harassment of the person;

(c) significant physical ill-treatment of the person;

(d) significant economic hardship that threatens the person's capacity to subsist;

(e) denial of access to basic services, where the denial threatens the person's capacity to subsist;

(f) denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, where the denial threatens the person's capacity to subsist.

Applicant’s submissions

22.

The applicant’s submissions on ground 1 run to more than 26 pages. They are as long as the IMR Recommendation itself.

23.

The applicant alleges that he raised claims on at least six grounds referred to in s.91R of the Migration Act, and that being a member of a minority ethnic (Hazara) and religious group (Shi’ite Muslim) he has a well-founded fear of persecution due to a lack of protection by the State of Afghanistan.

24.

It is said that these claims were raised in the applicant’s entry interview, RSA Interview, Applicant’s Statutory Declaration, the Applicant’s Solicitors’ Submissions and the IMR Interview.

25.

The applicant then sets out submissions with respect to each of the “grounds” referable to s.91R of the Migration Act.

26.

With respect to a threat to a person’s life or liberty under s.91R(2)(a) of the Migration Act

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.