Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 5) [2024] FCA 134

File number: WAD 127 of 2022
WAD 153 of 2022
Judgment of: COLVIN J
Date of judgment: 28 February 2024
Catchwords:

COSTS - assessment of lump sum costs to be awarded - where one party substantially successful in substantive proceedings - where change of solicitors - whether lump sum assessment should be made on party and party or indemnity basis - whether antecedent conduct of parties relevant to assessment of indemnity costs - whether costs were unreasonably incurred or unreasonable in amount - whether adjustment should be made for costs sought concerning work undertaken by fee earners whose names do not appear on High Court Register of Practitioners - held lump sum costs to be assessed on indemnity basis with adjustments

COSTS - apportionment of costs - where proceedings in one application transferred from Supreme Court and one application commenced in this Court - where two applications heard together with evidence in one being evidence in the other - whether single lump sum costs order against all defendants would amount to non-party costs order - held costs assessed as a single set of costs with some apportionment

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 232, 1322

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 4

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) ss 55A, 55B, 55C

Cases cited:

Anchorage Capital Partners Pty Limited v ACPA Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 112

Atanaskovic v Birketu Pty Ltd [2023] NSWCA 312

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd (No 5) [2021] FCA 246

Beach Petroleum NL v Johnson (No 2) (1995) 57 FCR 119

Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow [2019] HCA 29; (2019) 269 CLR 333

Coshott v Burke (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 81

Frigger v Banning (No 13) [2023] FCA 923

Frigger v Trenfield (No 11) [2022] FCA 326

Guss v Veenhuizen (Taxation of Costs) (No 2) (1976) 136 CLR 47

Hamod v State of New South Wales [2011] NSWCA 375

Hancock v Rinehart [2015] NSWSC 1640

Harrison v Schipp [2001] NSWCA 13

Harrison v Schipp [2002] NSWCA 213; (2002) 54 NSWLR 738

Hazeldene's Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298; (2005) 13 VR 435

Hii v Commissioner of Taxation [2019] FCA 1589

Huntingdale Village Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) v Corrs Chambers Westgarth [2018] WASCA 90

IFTC Broking Services Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCAFC 31

Jadwan Pty Ltd v Rae & Partners (A Firm) (No 7) [2022] FCA 1174

Jadwan Pty Ltd v Rae & Partners (A Firm) [2023] FCAFC 182

Kumar v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] FCA 735

LLC BryanskAgrostroy v Mackies Asia Pacific Pty Limited (No 2) [2021] FCA 1419

Marsh v Baxter [No 2] [2016] WASCA 51

Mead v Watson as Liquidator for Hypec Electronics [2005] NSWCA 133

Melbourne City Investments Pty Ltd v Treasury Wine Estates Limited (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 116

NMFM Property Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 5), the parties involved were Mr Sharif and Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd. The dispute primarily concerned the assessment of costs to be awarded in the proceedings, focusing on the basis for the lump sum assessment, the relevance of antecedent conduct of the parties, and whether certain costs were unreasonably incurred or unreasonable in amount. The Federal Court was tasked with deciding these legal issues.

The court addressed the issue of whether the lump sum costs should be assessed on a party-and-party or indemnity basis. The court decided that the lump sum costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis with adjustments. It considered factors such as the antecedent conduct of the parties, the reasonableness of the costs incurred, and adjustments for costs related to fee earners not listed on the High Court Register of Practitioners. The court also ruled on the apportionment of costs between the proceedings transferred from the Supreme Court and those commenced in the Federal Court, concluding that a single lump sum costs order against all defendants would not amount to a non-party costs order.

The court's reasoning led to the conclusion that the lump sum costs to be recovered by Mr Sharif on an indemnity basis should be $1,150,000 (inclusive of GST). This decision took into account several factors, including the reduction for Mr Sharif's own costs, the unsuccessful hearing on the terms of relief, costs for practitioners not on the Register of Practitioners, and the differential in counsel fees. The court further determined that the costs of the proceedings in WAD 127 of 2022 and WAD 153 of 2022 be assessed as a single set of costs, with specific allowances for costs related solely to the proceedings in WAD 153 of 2022.

The final orders mandated that in WAD 127 of 2022, the defendants pay Mr Sharif $969,061.34 (inclusive of GST) in respect of his costs, while in WAD 153 of 2022, Mr Sharif pay the defendant $118,000 (inclusive of GST) in respect of his costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The costs of the proceedings in WAD 127 of 2022 and WAD 153 of 2022 be assessed as a single set of costs with due allowance for the extent to which any of those costs related solely to the proceedings in WAD 153 of 2022.

2. In WAD 127 of 2022, the defendants do pay the plaintiff the amount of $969,061.34 (inclusive of GST) in respect of his costs.

3. In WAD 153 of 2022, the plaintiff do pay the defendant the amount of $118,000 (inclusive of GST) in respect of his costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Further, the cancellation of the shares was a resort to self-help. Although a claim was made that there had been a total failure of consideration for the share issue, that claim was hopeless and was not pressed by senior counsel who appeared at the trial for the Vitruvian Defendants. On any view, Mr Sharif undertook a considerable amount of work for Vitruvian over nearly a year. It was not a case where there was any proper basis to claim that there had been a total failure of consideration. In consequence, the claims raised by the Vitruvian Defendants depended upon the Court being persuaded that there was a proper basis for statutory relief in the nature of rescission being granted to validate, well after the event, the cancellation of the shares that had occurred without any legal authority.Contention (2): The findings made concerning Mr Gregory's evidence The main thrust of the submissions advanced for Mr Sharif to support the second contention was that the findings made in the Trial Reasons concerning the account given by Mr Gregory were to the following effect: having accepted that Mr Sharif was entitled to a shareholding in Vitruvian as a person who had the status of a founder of the company and having then failed in his efforts to reach a settlement with Mr Sharif as to the terms on which he would relinquish his shareholding, Mr Gregory then embarked on a deliberate and calculated plan that involved rewriting what had actually occurred. Put in those terms, the contention went beyond a reliance upon the adverse findings as to the credibility of the account given by Mr Gregory at the trial (which, of themselves would be insufficient to demonstrate the requisite unreasonableness). Rather, the submissions were to the effect that Mr Gregory had formulated a plan which included giving a revisionist version of events in order to be able to justify the cancellation of the shares held by Mr Sharif. One of the matters relied upon by Mr Gregory concerned what he understood to be the position in relation to Mr Sharif's qualifications based upon statements said to have been made by Mr Sharif. In that regard, the following finding was made in the Trial Reasons at [215]:I conclude that the claim to the effect that Mr Gregory placed significance upon the statement made by Mr Sharif that he held a bachelor's degree in electrical engineering is a revisionist version of the events that was constructed after the settlement negotiations with Mr Sharif failed and at a point in time when Mr Gregory was looking for some basis to remove Mr Sharif from the share register of Vitruvian. It was not until 8 June 2020 after the settlement offer to Mr Sharif was rejected that Mr Gregory focussed upon the issue of Mr Sharif's degree. The following further finding was made at [216]:I find that Mr Gregory gave no particular significance to the statement made by Mr Sharif about his degree at any time until after the negotiations with Mr Sharif in June 2020 failed to result in any agreement. By that time, Mr Gregory was searching for a reason to justify the cancellation of Mr Sharif's shares because he viewed him as a 'pain on the register'.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before agreement was reached with Squire Patton Boggs to reduce their fees by the amount of $312,257.14, Mr Russell estimated the costs to be recovered on an indemnity basis by Mr Sharif at $1,784,878.34. Therefore, the position of Ms Pascoe at that time was that the overall lump sum indemnity amount estimated by Mr Russell should be reduced by $488,586.30 or 27%. The position advanced by the Vitruvian Defendants after the agreement with Squire Patton Boggs is that Mr Russell's revised figure of $1,472,621.20 (inclusive of GST) should be reduced by $350,815.32 or 23.8%.Conclusion as to lump sum amount to be awarded to Mr Sharif on an indemnity basis In the above circumstances, in my view, the following matters bear upon determining an appropriate lump sum estimate on an indemnity basis given the order of magnitude difference between the two estimates as just described (that is originally 27% reduction and now 23.8% reduction). First, Mr Russell accepted that his estimate should be the subject of a reduction of about $42,500 for Mr Sharif's own costs relating to the Amendment Application and the Inspection Application. Second, there should be an adjustment to reflect the fact that Mr Sharif was unsuccessful on the hearing as to the terms of relief. Third, Mr Sharif has included costs for practitioners who are not on the Register of Practitioners being an amount of about $70,000. For reasons that have been given, they should be deducted (but allowing for the fact that the figure of $70,000 relates to all costs incurred). Fourth, there is a considerable differential between the counsel fees charged to Mr Sharif compared to those incurred by the Vitruvian Defendants. This indicates that a reduction for reasonableness would be appropriate as to that aspect of the estimate. In addition, even taking account of the reduction in fees charged by Squire Patton Boggs, it would also be appropriate to apply a further reduction for reasonableness as to the fees charged by Hall & Wilcox given the very large differential between the costs incurred by Mr Sharif when compared to those incurred by the Vitruvian Defendants. Fifth, the estimate provided by Mr Russell was on the basis that there should be a further 3% reduction from the total amount for costs associated with the abandoned Patent Claim. Taking account of that submission and the reasons that I have given in relation to the Patent Claim, a further reduction of $44,000 for that aspect is appropriate. This means that the much greater reduction proposed by Ms Pascoe is not appropriate. Sixth, the difference in approaches in providing for the duplication of costs resulting from the change of solicitors is relatively small. Taking all these matters into account, I consider that an appropriate lump sum assessment of costs to be recovered by Mr Shariff on an indemnity basis to be $1,150,000 (inclusive of GST).Issue (12): What provision should be made in the lump sum assessment for the costs of and incidental to the determination of the appropriate lump sum costs order?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established