Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 4) [2023] FCA 1172

File number: WAD 127 of 2022
Judgment of: COLVIN J
Date of judgment: 29 September 2023
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - disposition of relief following trial judgment in which claim of oppression upheld - where judgment in favour of plaintiff - where parties disagree about final orders - orders made to remove consequences of oppressive conduct against plaintiff and not afford plaintiff a windfall gain - orders made for transfer of shares for nominal consideration
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 232

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 100-25, 104-10

Cases cited: Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 920
Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 25
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr MC Goldblatt with Mr JC Slack-Smith
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Hall & Wilcox
Solicitor for the Defendants: Bennett

ORDERS

WAD 127 of 2022
BETWEEN:

AHMAD WALID OBAID SHARIF

Plaintiff

AND:

VITRUVIAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 630 548 846)

First Defendant

JONATHAN CHARLES GREGORY

Second Defendant

J & S GREGORY PTY LTD (ACN 163 712 598)

Third Defendant

VFORMTRAIN PTY LTD (ACN 641 497 323)

Fourth Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

COLVIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 SEPTEMBR 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), within three business days from the date of this order:

(a)the third defendant deliver to the plaintiff a share transfer form executed by it, as transferor, for the transfer of 3,000,000 unencumbered fully paid ordinary shares in the first defendant to the plaintiff for the consideration of $1.00; and

(b)the plaintiff deliver to the third defendant a completed and executed Deed of Accession in the form set out in Schedule 4 to the Vitruvian Shareholders Deed, dated 11 February 2022, subject to the option 'Other Shareholders' being completed in cl 3(a) and (b) of the Deed of Accession.

2.Within three business days of receipt of the share transfer form, the plaintiff deliver to the third defendant the share transfer form executed by him, as transferee.

3.Within five business days of receipt of the executed share transfer form from the plaintiff, the third defendant lodge the executed share transfer form (which, if required by law, will be duly stamped), the Deed of Accession and the necessary share certificate(s) at the registered office of the first defendant for registration of the transfer of the shares from the third defendant to the plaintiff.

4.Within five business days after the lodgement by the third defendant of the documents referred to in order 3, the first defendant register the transfer of the 3,000,000 shares in the first defendant, the subject of the executed share transfer form, from the third defendant to the plaintiff.

5.The parties have liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of these orders.

Note:   Entry of orders is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1172
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 4), the plaintiff, Mr Sharif, sought relief under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) after a trial judgment found that oppressive conduct had been established against him by the defendants. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate final orders to address the consequences of the oppressive conduct without providing an undue advantage to the plaintiff. The primary dispute between the parties centred on the consideration for the share transfer and the terms of the deed of accession. The court considered the arguments from both parties and ultimately decided that the share transfer should occur for a nominal consideration of $1.00 to prevent any windfall gain to Mr Sharif. The deed of accession should be executed to reflect Mr Sharif's acquisition of the shares as an 'Other Shareholder'. The final orders were made to ensure that the relief provided would remove the consequences of the oppressive conduct without unfairly benefiting the plaintiff.

The legal issues before the court involved determining the appropriate relief to be granted under s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) after a finding of oppressive conduct under s 232. The court had to consider whether the share transfer should reflect any financial consideration, particularly the value of $210 as proposed by Vitruvian, and the terms of the deed of accession. Vitruvian argued that a transfer without consideration could result in capital gains tax implications that would unfairly benefit Mr Sharif. However, the court concluded that the appropriate relief was to reinstate Mr Sharif's previous shareholding without any financial consideration, and the deed of accession should reflect his status as an 'Other Shareholder'.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the need to provide equitable relief that addressed the oppressive conduct without creating an unintended financial advantage for the plaintiff. The court recognised that a transfer for a nominal consideration of $1.00 would reinstate Mr Sharif's shareholding and remove the oppressive conduct's consequences. The court also considered the potential capital gains tax implications but determined that the primary objective was to ensure fairness and equity in the relief provided. The court's decision to execute the deed of accession under the 'Other Shareholders' option was to accurately reflect Mr Sharif's status and ensure that the relief granted was appropriate and fair.

The final orders made by the court included the transfer of three million shares to Mr Sharif for a consideration of $1.00, with the deed of accession executed to reflect his status as an 'Other Shareholder'. The orders also specified the timeline for the execution and registration of the share transfer and provided the parties with the liberty to apply for further orders regarding the implementation of these final orders. The court's decision aimed to provide equitable relief that addressed the oppressive conduct without unfairly benefiting the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), within three business days from the date of this order:

(a) the third defendant deliver to the plaintiff a share transfer form executed by it, as transferor, for the transfer of 3,000,000 unencumbered fully paid ordinary shares in the first defendant to the plaintiff for the consideration of $1.00; and

(b) the plaintiff deliver to the third defendant a completed and executed Deed of Accession in the form set out in Schedule 4 to the Vitruvian Shareholders Deed, dated 11 February 2022, subject to the option 'Other Shareholders' being completed in cl 3(a) and (b) of the Deed of Accession.

2. Within three business days of receipt of the share transfer form, the plaintiff deliver to the third defendant the share transfer form executed by him, as transferee.

3. Within five business days of receipt of the executed share transfer form from the plaintiff, the third defendant lodge the executed share transfer form (which, if required by law, will be duly stamped), the Deed of Accession and the necessary share certificate(s) at the registered office of the first defendant for registration of the transfer of the shares from the third defendant to the plaintiff.

4. Within five business days after the lodgement by the third defendant of the documents referred to in order 3, the first defendant register the transfer of the 3,000,000 shares in the first defendant, the subject of the executed share transfer form, from the third defendant to the plaintiff.

5. The parties have liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of these orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In those circumstances, the appropriate relief is that the deed of accession provide for Mr Sharif to acquire his shares as an 'Other Shareholder'.Conclusion The other aspects of the final orders being agreed (save for orders as to costs which are to be addressed separately), there should be orders generally in the terms proposed with the consideration for the share transfer being $1.00 and the deed of accession to be executed on the basis that Mr Sharif acquire his shares as an 'Other Shareholder'. I will reserve liberty to apply as to the implementation of the orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties have proposed separate minutes of orders to give effect to the Principal Reasons. They are in dispute as to two aspects of those orders, namely:(1)whether the share transfer form should state a consideration of $210 or any other amount; and(2)the terms in which a deed of accession should be executed by Mr Sharif.Consideration for the share transfer The conclusion reached as to the relief that should be ordered was expressed in the following terms in the Principal Reasons at [330]:… The application by Mr Sharif for orders as provided for in s 233 on the basis of oppressive conduct contrary to s 232 should be allowed. The appropriate order to be made is to require J & S Gregory Pty Ltd to transfer three million shares in Vitruvian to Mr Sharif before the issue of any further shares by Vitruvian. The transfer should occur without consideration payable by Mr Sharif. There should be an order for costs in favour of Mr Sharif but that order will need to allow for the extent to which claims were not pursued. It should have regard to materials that the parties have been directed to file as to the question of costs. Vitruvian seeks an order that would state the consideration for the transfer of the three million shares as being $210, alternatively a nominal amount. The consideration of $210 would reflect the nominated value at the time of issue to Mr Sharif of his shares in Vitruvian that were subsequently cancelled. Shares were also issued to J & S Gregory at the same time so it might also be viewed as the consideration for those shares. The figure of three million shares was determined to be the shares that would have been held by Mr Sharif as a result of a share split if his shares had not been cancelled. The share split was an event that involved no further payment of consideration. In substantive terms, the finding as to relief in the Principal Reasons simply reinstates Mr Sharif's previous shareholding, albeit that the share split means that the appropriate shareholding is 3,000,000 shares. J & S Gregory points to the possible capital gains tax consequences of the relief to be granted to Mr Sharif. The shares are a 'CGT asset' for the purposes of the capital gains tax provisions of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth): see s 100-25(2)). If there is a change in ownership of shares then there will be a 'disposal of a CGT asset': s 104-10. J & S Gregory submits that if the transfer of the three million shares occurs without any identified consideration then it will be taken to have received the market value of the shares. The consequence in that event, so it is submitted, is that J & S Gregory will be treated as making a capital gain because the market value will be greater than the cost base. Also, Mr Sharif would be treated as having a cost base for capital gains tax purposes that is at least equal to the market value of the shares at the time of transfer. Therefore, his capital gains tax liability on any future sale of the three million shares, will be determined on the basis of the market value at the time of transfer of those shares to him. This, it is said, will give rise to a windfall gain to Mr Sharif.