Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 920

File number: WAD 127 of 2022
WAD 153 of 2022
Judgment of: COLVIN J
Date of judgment: 8 August 2023
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS - where shares cancelled without complying with the statutory procedure for a selective reduction of capital - where relief sought by company under s 1322 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for Court to grant relief - where shareholder claims conduct in cancelling shares and other conduct to be oppressive under s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

CORPORATIONS - where plaintiff (in WAD153/2022) seeks relief under s 1322 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - where plaintiff claims statutory relief in the nature of rescission appropriate - where plaintiff alleged misleading and deceptive conduct - where plaintiff alleged agreement made on basis of a qualification the defendant did not have - where such factual finding not made - where complete disregard for statutory requirements - where continuing and blatant disregard for statutory requirements demonstrates dishonesty - where plaintiff acted as if statutory rescission was a self-help remedy - where plaintiff took no steps after being informed of failure to comply with statutory procedure - where not case that there is no substantial injustice - where significant delay in bringing claim - where requirements of s 1322 not met - claim dismissed with costs

CORPORATIONS - where plaintiff (in WAD127/2022) alleges cancellation of shares and other conduct was oppressive - where cancellation of shares found to be oppressive - where evidence of plan to oppress plaintiff - where only reason for cancellation is alleged misleading and deceptive conduct said to have induced agreement to issue shares - where alleged misleading and deceptive conduct not established - oppression established by company, director and shareholder cancelling shares and then issuing further shares to dilute shareholding if shareholding subsequently reinstated - appropriate relief is to require benefitting shareholding to transfer shares to the plaintiff - claim upheld

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) s 243

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 232, 233, 256B, 256C, 256D, 1322

Cases cited:

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; (2019) 238 CLR 304

Catalano v Managing Australia Destinations Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 55

G8 Communications Ltd, in the matter of G8 Communications Ltd [2016] FCA 297

Hall v Poolman [2007] NSWSC 1330; (2007) 215 FLR 243

Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (1988) 39 FCR 546

ICandy Interactive Limited, in the matter of ICandy Interactive Limited [2018] FCA 533

Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210

Kizbeau Pty Ltd v WG & B Pty Ltd (1995) 184 CLR 281

Queensland Bauxite Ltd, in the matter of Queensland Bauxite Ltd [2018] FCA 2113

RBC Investor Services Australia Nominees Pty Limited v Brickworks Limited [2017] FCA 756

Wilmar Sugar Australia Limited v Mackay Sugar Limited [2017] FCAFC 40

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 920
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sharif v Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (No 3), the dispute between Mr Sharif and Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd (Vitruvian) was brought before the Court to address the cancellation of Mr Sharif's shares and the broader conduct of the company, its director, and shareholder. The case involved two separate proceedings: one where Mr Sharif sought relief under section 1322 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), alleging misleading and deceptive conduct in the agreement that led to the issuance of shares; and another where he claimed that the cancellation of his shares and subsequent actions were oppressive under section 232 of the same Act.

The primary legal issues that the Court needed to address were whether the statutory requirements for cancelling shares were complied with and whether the cancellation and related actions constituted oppressive conduct. The Court had to determine if the cancellation of shares was lawful, if the actions of Vitruvian were oppressive, and if so, what relief was appropriate under the Corporations Act.

The Court found that Vitruvian had not complied with the statutory procedure for cancelling shares, which meant the cancellation was unlawful. However, the Court dismissed Mr Sharif's claim for rescission under section 1322 as it was not established that the agreement was made on the basis of a misrepresentation regarding his qualifications, and there was no demonstration of substantial injustice. The Court emphasised that the delay in bringing the claim and the failure to act on the knowledge of the non-compliance with statutory requirements were significant factors in dismissing the claim. On the other hand, the Court upheld Mr Sharif's claim of oppressive conduct, finding that the plan to dilute his shareholding and the oppressive conduct of cancelling shares and issuing further shares were established. Consequently, the Court ordered that J & S Gregory Pty Ltd transfer three million shares to Mr Sharif without any consideration.

The final orders of the Court included dismissing the claim under section 1322 with costs, allowing the claim under section 233 for oppressive conduct, and requiring the transfer of shares to Mr Sharif. The Court also directed the parties to file a minute of orders or competing minutes by a specified date and listed the matter for a case management hearing to determine the procedure for resolving any disputes regarding the appropriate terms of the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 4.00 pm on 14 August 2023, the parties do file a minute of orders to give effect to these reasons, alternatively competing minutes.

2. The proceedings be listed for a case management hearing at noon AWST on 15 August 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The other actions of the share split, establishing the employee share scheme and the rounds of capital raising by the issue of shares are not challenged on the basis that they had no proper commercial purpose. Rather, they are said to be part of the implementation of the plan to dilute any shareholding to which Mr Sharif may be entitled by first cancelling his shares such that (unlike Mr Gregory and Mr Larsen and their associated entities) Mr Sharif would not be able to participate in the issue of further shares for the purpose of Vitruvian raising necessary capital. Then, even if his shareholding was subsequently reinstated, his interest would have been substantially diluted.The evidence concerning the quality of the work done by Mr Sharif for Vitruvian The way the issues were joined gives rise to an aspect to the proceedings which it is appropriate to emphasise at this point due to its significance. For reasons that have been given, the abandonment of the claim that Mr Sharif breached the agreement that he made concerning his work for Vitruvian means that no issue arises as to whether his performance of the work fell short of what might reasonably have been expected. Consequently, the focus must be upon whether the agreement with Mr Sharif would not have been made had Mr Gregory known the true position concerning Mr Sharif's qualifications and, if so, whether statutory relief in the nature of rescission would be appropriate. At times, in the course of his testimony, Mr Gregory referred to respects in which he thought that Mr Sharif's abilities or the work that he undertook was not up to his expectations. However, that testimony (if accepted) remains only evidence of his personal view in a case where no claim was pressed to the effect that there was a representation made by Mr Sharif as to his skills or abilities nor that the work undertaken by Mr Sharif was defective in some way that meant he did not perform his agreement. The evidence is relevant only to reliance. The evidence as to the quality or significance of the work that Mr Sharif did was described in opening submissions for Vitruvian as being relied upon only to support the claim to relief under s 1322. The same position was put in written and oral closing submissions for Vitruvian. As has been noted, the case about alleged misleading or deceptive conduct was confined to the alleged representation concerning the bachelor's degree in electrical engineering. If Vitruvian had no lawful basis to cancel Mr Sharif's shares, it is difficult to see what to make of general evidence to the effect that, in the view of Mr Gregory, Mr Sharif did not do a good job. Nor is it apparent how some complaint about the work that he did that is not articulated as a basis for cancelling the shares could support relief under s 1322. There is no claim before the Court concerning the termination of Mr Sharif as chief executive officer. As will emerge, it was uncontroversial as between the parties that the agreement made was for the shares to be issued to Mr Sharif without conditions. Therefore, no issue arises as to whether there was any form of contractual basis for cancelling the shares. A claim that there had been a total failure of consideration was not pressed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In addition to the above, I make the following further findings which support the conclusion that the Vitruvian defendants have not established that the work done by Mr Sharif was in breach of the agreement he made:(1)Mr Sharif was engaged to develop the business by applying his sales experience, his energy and his ability to hustle;(2)Mr Sharif was not engaged to assist with the development of the product which was a task being undertaken by Mr Gregory;(3)Mr Sharif was not engaged to prepare an investor deck, however the task of preparing a draft investor deck was within the parameters of developing the business;(4)the draft investor decks prepared by Mr Sharif were considered by Mr Larsen and Mr Gregory to be suitable for the purposes of Vitruvian at the time they were prepared;(5)the complaints raised by Mr Gregory concerning the work done by Mr Sharif in preparing the investor decks were raised in retrospect and were not concerns that he had at the time that the investor decks were prepared by Mr Sharif;(6)Mr Sharif was not engaged on the basis that he would prepare an investor deck of the kind prepared by Mr Mactiernan or that he was capable of preparing such a deck;(7)Mr Sharif was not engaged on the basis that he would undertake financial modelling or that he was capable of doing so;(8)the arrangements made by Mr Sharif for interns and freelancers to assist in undertaking work for Vitruvian was due performance of his engagement to develop the business at a time when Vitruvian had limited financial resources;(9)it is not possible to reach any conclusion on the evidence as to who was responsible for bringing in investors to Vitruvian as such outcomes depend upon all activities undertaken and there was no particular focus upon that aspect at the hearing; and(10)Mr Sharif did take steps to put in place a shareholders' agreement and, as Mr Gregory himself noted, it was he who dropped the ball in progressing the shareholders' agreement.Conclusion and orders For the above reasons, the application by Vitruvian for orders pursuant to s 1322 of the Corporations Act must be dismissed with costs. The application by Mr Sharif for orders as provided for in s 233 on the basis of oppressive conduct contrary to s 232 should be allowed. The appropriate order to be made is to require J & S Gregory Pty Ltd to transfer three million shares in Vitruvian to Mr Sharif before the issue of any further shares by Vitruvian. The transfer should occur without consideration payable by Mr Sharif. There should be an order for costs in favour of Mr Sharif but that order will need to allow for the extent to which claims were not pursued. It should have regard to materials that the parties have been directed to file as to the question of costs. I will direct the parties to bring in a minute of proposed orders or competing minutes if they are unable to agree and I will list the matter for a case management hearing to determine the procedure for resolving any dispute as to the appropriate terms in which orders should be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established