FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd v Sharif [2023] FCA 471
ORDERS
WAD 153 of 2022 BETWEEN: VITRUVIAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 630 548 846)
Plaintiff
AND: AHMAD WALID OBAID SHARIF
Defendant
ORDER MADE BY:
JACKSON J
DATE OF ORDER:
15 MAY 2023
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The defendant's interlocutory application dated 26 April 2023 is dismissed.
2.Costs reserved.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
JACKSON J:
These reasons concern an interlocutory application by the defendant, Mr Sharif, for production of certain documents which the plaintiff, Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd, has discovered. Vitruvian claims legal professional privilege over the documents. Mr Sharif accepts that the documents were subject to legal professional privilege when they came into existence, but says that the privilege has since been waived.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vitruvian Investments Pty Ltd v Sharif and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 471
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court, having inspected the disputed documents, found that the documents did not directly pertain to the cancellation of shares or the plaintiff's state of mind when the shares were cancelled. The court determined that the privilege claimed over the documents was not compromised by the defendant's plea, as the waiver did not extend to the disputed documents. The court emphasised the importance of protecting the contents of the documents to preserve the privilege that was claimed. The court concluded that the privilege had not been waived and dismissed the plaintiff's application for discovery of the documents.
The court ordered that the defendant's interlocutory application dated 26 April 2023 be dismissed, and that costs be reserved. The orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The defendant's interlocutory application dated 26 April 2023 is dismissed.
2. Costs reserved.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case involves an interlocutory application made by Vitruvian to inspect and rely on documents that Sharif claimed were protected by legal professional privilege. The application was brought in the Federal Court of Australia. Prior to this application, Vitruvian had filed a proceeding against Sharif regarding the cancellation of his shares. During the proceeding, Vitruvian made a plea in their statement of claim that resulted in an implied waiver of privilege over certain documents. Sharif resisted Vitruvian's application to inspect the disputed documents, arguing that the waiver of privilege did not extend to them. The application was heard by a judge who inspected the documents in camera to determine whether they were subject to legal professional privilege and whether the waiver extended to them.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plea made by Vitruvian in their statement of claim constituted a waiver of legal professional privilege over the disputed documents.
2. If the waiver of privilege extended to the disputed documents, whether those documents are relevant to the cancellation of Sharif's shares and Vitruvian's state of mind at the relevant time.
Held
1. The plea made by Vitruvian in their statement of claim constituted a waiver of legal professional privilege over the disputed documents.
2. The waiver of privilege extended to the disputed documents, however, those documents are not relevant to the cancellation of Sharif's shares and Vitruvian's state of mind at the relevant time.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Sharif, in turn, relies on the subject lines of emails that are among the disputed documents, in order to submit that there is more than chronological coincidence between them and the formation of Vitruvian's state of mind.Consideration of the disputed documents The course that has led to this judgment - a different judge inspecting the documents - permits the application to be determined on a firmer footing than the making of inferences from headings or subject lines in emails, so it is not necessary to descend into the detail of the parties' submissions about those matters. But in the circumstances it is necessary to express reasons as to the specific documents in dispute only in the most general of ways, so as not to disclose their contents and so erase the privilege that is claimed. As such, and having inspected the disputed documents with the above principles in mind, I now express my reasons in relation to the documents that are the subject of the first part of the interlocutory application in summary form, using the numbers given to them in the schedule to the application (which starts at number 5):(1)Document 5 does not touch on cancellation of shares. It concerns a different proposal to resolve the situation (whether perceived or actual) between Mr Sharif and Vitruvian.(2)Documents 6 to 8 concern two further proposals to resolve that situation. The relationship between those proposals and Vitruvian's state of mind when it cancelled the shares is at most indirect.(3)Documents 9 to 13 and 15 concern the logistics of and the proposed subject matter of a meeting with a lawyer (and others). But they say nothing specific about the subject matter of the meeting, or what may have occurred at such a meeting. Document 16 is in the same vein and also contains a comment from Mr Gregory concerning a course of action he was contemplating that had nothing to do with the cancellation of Mr Sharif's shares.(4)Document 14 does record proposals that appear to have been discussed at the meeting which may have been intended, in part, to resolve the situation between Mr Sharif and Vitruvian. However, once again the relationship between those proposals and Vitruvian's state of mind when it cancelled the shares is at most indirect.(5)Documents 17 to 22 also concern proposals which may have resolved the situation, but also appear intended to address other matters. Once again, the relationship between these and Vitruvian's state of mind when it cancelled the shares is at most indirect.(6)Document 25 is Mr Gregory's draft proof of evidence. (There are no documents 23 or 24.). The contents of the draft proof do not bear directly on the cancellation of the shares and do not touch on Vitruvian's reasons for the cancellation or its state of mind at the time. Chronologically, it stops before the email pleaded in paragraph 48 of the statement of claim which is alleged to have led to the rescission of the Agreement and the cancellation of the shares. The proof therefore does not address the events which Vitruvian alleges led to the cancellation or informed its state of mind at that later time. Nor can I see any likelihood that the draft proof informed the unredacted advice dated 29 June 2020 from Bennett + Co to Vitruvian.(7)Document 26 is an email with the subject line 'Re: It's starting!'. On the face of the email, what was 'starting' had nothing to do with the cancellation of the shares. And, as Vitruvian's solicitors advised Mr Sharif's solicitors, the email chain also concerns intellectual property advice from a registered patent attorney. That advice had nothing to do with the cancellation of the shares.