Richard McDonnell & Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd v Karl Dawson

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Richard McDonnell and Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 2090214 (classes 9, 35 & 38) – puggle post - in the name of Karl Dawson

Delegate:

Tracey Berger

Representation:

Opponents: Dr Anthony Place of Patentable

Applicant: Andrew Petale of YIP Legal Pty Ltd

Decision:

2023 ATMO 58

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – ss 44, 58 and 60 considered – s 58 established for class 9 goods – no grounds established for services in classes 35 & 38 – opportunity to amend – application amended – trade mark to proceed to registration in classes 35 and 38

Background

1. This decision concerns an opposition under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] by Richard McDonnell and Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd (‘Opponents’) to registration of the following trade mark:

[1] Unless otherwise stated, each reference to a regulation below is a reference to a regulation in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’) and each reference to a section is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’).

Trade mark number:          2090214 (‘Application’)

Trade mark:  puggle post (‘Trade Mark’)

Applicant:Karl Dawson (‘Applicant’)

Filing Date:    21 May 2020

Specification:  Class 9: Electronic publications including those sold and distributed online; weekly publications downloaded in electronic form from the internet (‘Applicant’s Goods’)

Class 35: retail services; online retail services; retail of gift sets; product marketing; provision of an online marketplace for buyers and sellers of goods and services; retail of gift baskets

Class 38: electronic transmission (uploading, posting or displaying) of data, information, pictures, images, audio and/or video via online forums; providing online forums; providing user access to a global computer network and online sites containing information on a wide range of topics; transmission of information on a wide range of topics, including online and over a global computer network

(collectively the services claimed in classes 35 and 38 are referred to as the ‘Applicant’s Services’)

2.  The Trade Mark was examined and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 22 October 2020.

3.  On 9 November 2020, the Opponents filed a Notice of Intention to oppose the Trade Mark, followed on 24 November 2020 by its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’), which was subsequently amended in September 2021 to add s 58 as a ground of opposition and amend some of the particulars of the other grounds.  The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend the opposition on 10 March 2021.

4. The parties then proceeded to file their evidence in accordance with the Regulations with the Opponents filing evidence in support (‘EIS’) on 1 September 2021, followed by the Applicant’s evidence in answer (‘EIA’) on 28 February 2022 and concluding with the Opponents’ evidence in reply (‘EIR’) on 29 April 2022.

5.  Once the evidence had been filed, the parties were given…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richard McDonnell & Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd v K... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ATMO 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an opposition by Richard McDonnell and Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd (the Opponents) to the registration of a trade mark by Karl Dawson (the Applicant). The dispute centred on the Opponents' claim to prior rights in the mark PUGGLE, which they alleged was used in connection with books, toys, and merchandise since the early 1980s. The Opponents asserted that these rights were maintained through various activities, including the operation of retail stores, the establishment of websites and social media pages, and the sale of digital versions of their books.

The primary legal issue before the Registrar of Trade Marks was whether the Opponents had established a ground of opposition under section 58 of the relevant legislation, which relates to prior use of a trade mark. This required the Registrar to determine the extent to which the Opponents' claims of prior use and reputation in the PUGGLE mark were substantiated, and whether this use conflicted with the Applicant's proposed registration for goods and services.

The Registrar found that the Opponents had established a ground of opposition under s 58 in respect of the Applicant's goods, but not in respect of the Applicant's services. Consequently, the Registrar indicated an intention to refuse registration of the trade mark unless the specification of goods was amended to exclude class 9 (goods). The Applicant subsequently amended the application to cover only services, and the trade mark was permitted to proceed to registration in classes 35 and 38.

As both parties achieved some measure of success in the proceedings, the Registrar declined to award costs to either party. The decision also included a direction that registration should not occur until any appeal had been decided or discontinued.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following evidence was filed in these proceedings:EISDeclaration of Richard McDonnell, director of the Opponents, made on 31 August 2021 with Exhibits RM01 to RM04 (‘McDonnell 1’).Declaration of Richard McDonnell, made on 31 August 2021 with Exhibits RM05 to RM17 (‘McDonnell 2’).EIADeclaration of Karl Dawson, Applicant, made on 24 February 2022 with Annexures KD-1 to KD-6 (‘Dawson Declaration’).EIRDeclaration of Richard McDonnell, made on 29 April 2022 with Exhibits RM018 TO RM25 (‘McDonnell 3’).Opponents’ Evidence10. Mr McDonnell attests that the term PUGGLE was coined in the early 1980s when Anthony A. Barber published a book named ‘The Puggle Tales’ about a PUGGLE. Mr Barber also used the mark PUGGLE in relation to a soft toy version of the book’s character. In 1989, Mr Barber published a book named ‘The Lost Forests’ about the PUGGLE character and its ecosystem. 11. In 1989, Mr Barber and Mr McDonnell’s family formed a joint venture through the company Zipper De Doo Dah Pty Ltd to promote the PUGGLE toys and characters. The PUGGLE range of toys expanded to 13 different characters featured in 13 different books (‘Puggle Books’) and by the 1990s, the business had expanded to 19 ‘The Lost Forest’ retail stores located in Australia, the USA and New Zealand selling PUGGLE toys, books and merchandise. Mr McDonnell has provided an estimate of the annual revenue generated from these stores during the 1980s and 1990s and percentage of revenue attributable to PUGGLE merchandise which was substantial. As records were not computerized at that time and due to the length of time that has passed no documentary evidence of these sales is available. 12. According to McDonnell 1[4], in 1992, the McDonnell family acquired ownership of Zipper De Doo Dah Pty Ltd including the rights in the PUGGLE brand and copyright in the Puggle Books, which rights were assigned to Beaumont Management Services Pty Ltd (‘BMS’) in April 2001. Mr McDonnell claims that BMS have maintained those rights and the PUGGLE brand to the present time. Any reference to the Opponents in this decision includes a reference to its predecessors in title.[4] Exhibit RM-03.13. In 1995, ‘The Lost Forest’ stores were closed and it appears that the Opponents’ business ceased for some years.[5] [5] McDonnell 2 Exhibit RM15.14. The Opponents claim that despite the temporary closure of the Opponents’ stores, it maintained a reputation in its PUGGLE mark. For example, a past customer established a Facebook account titled ‘Bringing Back Puggles and the Lost Forest Stores’ in 2012.[6] The Opponents also undertook their own activities to maintain a reputation including establishing a website in 2007 and ‘The Lost Forests’ Facebook page in 2013 to promote the Opponents’ PUGGLE brand.[7][6] Ibid Exhibit RM05.[7] Ibid Exhibit RM1115. In 2017, the Opponents opened a new ‘The Lost Forest’ store in the Docklands, Melbourne and established the present website at (‘Opponents’ Website’) to sell and promote PUGGLE products. The Opponents established social media accounts on Instagram, Facebook, Flickr and YouTube to promote its PUGGLE range and the Opponents’ Website. Various extracts from the Opponents’ Website using the Wayback Machine, for example from 4 December 2018 and 9 August 2019, are provided[8] as well as extracts from the Opponents’ The Lost Forests YouTube account including an image of a video on the channel dated 26 May 2008 about PUGGLES characters. The Puggle Books were also digitally remastered and offered for sale as ebooks on the Opponents’ Website and eBay. Details of sales of PUGGLE books, toys and accessories from 2017-2020 are provided.[8] Ibid Exhibit RM10.16. McDonnell 1 and 3 attest to various trade marks in the name of BMS, a number of which were filed after the Relevant Date, but including the following trade marks which have an earlier prior date than the Relevant Date (‘Opponent’s Marks’):

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 provides:55 Decision (1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide: (a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. The Opponent has established a ground of opposition under s 58 in respect of the Applicant’s Goods. None of the grounds of opposition have been established with respect to the Applicant’s Services. On 1 May 2023, I informed the Applicant that it was my intention to refuse to register the Trade Mark unless class 9 was deleted from the Application. On 8 May 2023, the Applicant availed itself of the opportunity to amend the specification and the Application now covers the Applicant’s Services. The Trade Mark may now proceed to registration in classes 35 and 38 one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the application should otherwise be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. Both parties sought an award of costs. As both parties have had some measure of success, I decline to award costs. Tracey BergerHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks11 May 2023

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established