Residential Aged Care Services v Stonnington City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION
VALUATION COMPENSATION & PLANNING LIST

S CI 2017 02004

RESIDENTIAL AGED CARE SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 075 782 393) Plaintiff
v
STONNINGTON CITY COUNCIL Defendants
(and others according to the Schedule)

---

JUDGE:

GARDE J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATES OF HEARING:

12-13 September 2018

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

16 November 2018

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Residential Aged Care Services v Stonnington City Council

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2018] VSC 652

---

PLANNING – Residential aged care facility – Decision of Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal – Leave to appeal – Appeal – Mixed use zone – Heritage overlay control – Minimal change area – Failure to consider relevant matters – Unreasonableness – Disclosure of a path of reasoning – Denial of natural justice – Built form – Urban design – Heritage Guidelines – Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic), s 117(5), s 148; Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic), s 60(1), s 84B(1), s 84B(2).

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Ms S Brennan SC with
Ms J Sharp
Norton Rose Australia
For the First Defendant Mr G Peake Maddocks
For the 4th–8th, 11th–15th, 17th, 18th, 22nd–25th, 27th, 31st, 33rd-35th, 38th, 39th, 42nd-44th Defendants Mr A Walker Best Hooper
No appearance for other Defendants

HIS HONOUR:

Introduction

1 Residential Aged Care Services (‘the applicant’) seeks leave to appeal under s 148(1) of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic) (‘VCAT Act’) from a decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’). The decision affirmed the previous decision of the Stonnington City Council (‘the Council’) to refuse to grant the applicant a permit for a multi-storey residential aged care facility. The facility was to include 150 rooms, 33 independent living units and basement car parking (‘the proposed development’) on land in Greville Street and Charles Street, Prahran (‘the subject land’). The proposal involves demolition of about 40% of a corner shop at 70 Greville Street, and buildings at 42, 44–46 Charles Street.

2           The proposed development is intended to meet the needs of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (‘LGBTI’) community, and respond to a lack of residential aged care for LGBTI people.  It caters for people who identify as LGBTI or who are friends of the LGBTI community.

3           The subject land is in a Mixed Use Zone (‘MUZ’) under the Stonnington Planning Scheme (‘planning scheme’).  It was also subject to a Heritage Overlay (HO456).  The corner shop at 70 Greville Street has an A2 grading under the planning scheme, representing a building of regional or metropolitan significance.  The buildings at 42, 44–46 Charles Street all have a C grading.

4           The Tribunal was constituted by a senior planning member and an architect member.  During a six-day hearing:

a)the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Residential Aged Care Services v Stonnington City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] VSC 652
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Residential Aged Care Services and Stonnington City Council, the dispute centred on the approval of a residential aged care facility. The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) had previously ruled in favour of the applicant, granting approval for the facility, a decision which the council sought to appeal. The appellant, Stonnington City Council, argued that the tribunal had erred in its decision by not adequately considering certain aspects, including the mixed use zone, heritage overlay control, and minimal change area. The respondent, the aged care service provider, maintained that the tribunal's decision was correct and should be upheld.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the VCAT had failed to consider relevant matters and whether its decision was unreasonable. The appellant also argued that the tribunal had not provided a clear path of reasoning and had denied natural justice by not allowing the council to respond to certain issues. The respondent contended that the tribunal's decision was well-reasoned and that the council's arguments were without merit. The court had to determine whether the tribunal's decision was flawed and, if so, whether the appeal should be allowed.

The court found that the VCAT had indeed failed to consider certain relevant matters, such as the mixed use zone and heritage overlay control, and that its decision was therefore unreasonable. The court noted that the tribunal had not provided a clear path of reasoning and had denied natural justice by not allowing the council to respond to certain issues. The court also found that the tribunal's decision on the built form and urban design was flawed. However, the court found that the tribunal's consideration of the minimal change area was adequate. Ultimately, the court found that the appeal should be upheld, and the decision of the VCAT was set aside.

The court ordered that the matter be remitted to the VCAT for reconsideration in light of the court's findings. The court directed that the VCAT consider the mixed use zone, heritage overlay control, and urban design issues that it had previously failed to adequately consider. The court also directed that the VCAT provide a clear path of reasoning in its decision and ensure that natural justice was observed. The court's decision provided clarity on the legal issues involved and ensured that the VCAT would properly consider all relevant matters in its decision-making process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established