SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
S APCI 2017 0135
| SECRETARY TO THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND REGULATION | Applicant |
| v | |
| OUX (a pseudonym)[1] | First Respondent |
| and | |
| VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL | Second Respondent |
[1]To ensure there is no possibility of identification, this judgment has been anonymised by the adoption of a pseudonym in place of the name of the First Respondent.
---
| JUDGES: | PRIEST, BEACH and WEINBERG JJA |
| WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE |
| DATE OF HEARING: | 24 July 2018 |
| DATE OF ORDERS: | 24 July 2018 |
| DATE OF REASONS: | 27 July 2018 |
| MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2018] VSCA 178 |
| JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: | [2017] VCAT 1809 (Judge Millane, Vice President) |
---
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Working with Children Act 2005 — Application for assessment notice — ‘Category A application’ owing to conviction for sexual penetration of a child aged between 10 and 16 years — Secretary required to refuse category A applications — Secretary issued a ‘negative notice’ — VCAT empowered to decide category A applications — Whether Tribunal conflated ‘public interest test’ — Whether Tribunal subsumed ‘unjustifiable risk test’ within the ‘reasonable person test’ — Working with Children Act 2005 ss 10, 11, 12, 26A(1), 26A(3), 26A(4), 26A(5)— Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 s 148.
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Applicant | Mr P Hanks QC with Mr A J Sim | Working with Children Check Unit, Department of Justice and Regulation |
| For the First Respondent | Mr E Nekvapil | Victoria Legal Aid |
PRIEST JA
BEACH JA
WEINBERG JA:
Introduction
OUX, who, on 22 February 1994, was convicted of the sexual penetration of a child between 10 and 16, applied to the Secretary to the Department of Justice and Regulation (‘the Secretary’) for an assessment notice under the Working with Children Act 2005 (‘the Act’), so as to permit him to perform child-related work.[2]
[2]The meaning of ‘child-related work’ is discussed at [9] below.
On 14 October 2016, the Secretary issued OUX with a negative notice, the practical effect of which was to prevent him from performing child-related work.[3]
[3]See [12]–[13] below.
Following an application by OUX to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘VCAT’ or ‘the Tribunal’) — which was opposed by the Secretary — on 20 November 2017 a Vice President of VCAT made orders that:
1. The Negative Notice given on 13 August 2016 is set aside.
2. The Secretary is directed to issue the Applicant with an Assessment Notice pursuant to s 51(2)(c) of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 and s 26A(5) of the Working with Children Act 2005.
Pursuant to s 148 of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (‘VCAT Act’), the Secretary seeks leave of this Court to appeal on a question of law. The sole ground of appeal advanced is formulated as follows:[4]
The Tribunal erred by failing to perform its statutory task under s 26A(4) [of the Working with Children Act 2005], in that it did not
all, nor separately or correctlyconsider the ‘any type of child-related work test’…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read OUX v Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] VSCA 178
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary issue was whether VCAT had correctly applied the statutory provisions when assessing the ‘unjustifiable risk test’ and whether VCAT had conflated the ‘public interest test’ with the ‘unjustifiable risk test’ in the context of OUX’s application. The appellant contended that VCAT failed to adequately distinguish between the statutory tests and thereby misapplied the statutory framework. The respondent, VCAT, argued that the Tribunal had properly considered the statutory criteria and had correctly interpreted the relevant provisions.
The court held that VCAT had conflated the statutory tests and erred in its interpretation of the ‘unjustifiable risk test’. The court found that VCAT had not properly distinguished between the ‘unjustifiable risk test’ and the ‘public interest test’, resulting in an incorrect application of the statutory provisions. The court further held that VCAT had subsumed the ‘unjustifiable risk test’ within the ‘reasonable person test’, which was not consistent with the statutory framework. Consequently, the court found that VCAT’s decision was flawed and remitted the matter back to VCAT for reconsideration in light of the court’s findings.
The court’s decision resulted in the quashing of VCAT’s determination and the remittal of the matter back to VCAT for reconsideration in accordance with the court’s findings. The court did not make any further orders as to the substantive merits of the application, leaving that to VCAT on its reconsideration of the matter.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Working with Children Act 2005 mandates that the Secretary must refuse Category A applications unless satisfied that the application meets specific criteria, which includes passing a public interest test. The applicant argues that VCAT misconstrued this test, potentially conflating it with another test referred to as the 'unjustifiable risk test'. OUX further contends that VCAT may have inadvertently subsumed the 'unjustifiable risk test' within the 'reasonable person test', which is a separate consideration under the Act. This confusion in the application of statutory tests is central to the dispute in this case.
The matter came before the court as an appeal against a decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). The initial decision by VCAT was to refuse OUX's application for an assessment notice under the Working with Children Act 2005. OUX subsequently appealed this decision to the Supreme Court of Victoria, arguing that VCAT had incorrectly interpreted and applied the statutory provisions in making its determination. The appeal was heard, and the court was required to review the VCAT decision in light of the statutory framework and the arguments presented by both parties.
Prior to this appeal, OUX had already made an application to VCAT for a review of the Secretary's refusal to grant an assessment notice. VCAT reviewed the application and, after considering the evidence and arguments from both parties, upheld the Secretary's decision. OUX then filed an appeal with the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking a reversal of VCAT's decision on the grounds that VCAT misapplied the statutory tests in reaching its conclusion.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did VCAT correctly interpret and apply the 'public interest test' as required by the Working with Children Act 2005?
2. Did VCAT properly distinguish between the 'public interest test' and the 'unjustifiable risk test', or did it inadvertently subsume the latter within the former?
3. Was the 'reasonable person test' correctly applied by VCAT in the context of this Category A application?
Held
1. The Court concluded that VCAT did not correctly interpret and apply the 'public interest test' as required by the Working with Children Act 2005. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. The Court found that VCAT improperly distinguished between the 'public interest test' and the 'unjustifiable risk test', inadvertently subsuming the latter within the former. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
3. The Court determined that the 'reasonable person test' was not correctly applied by VCAT in the context of this Category A application. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court began by examining the statutory framework established by the Working with Children Act 2005, particularly sections 10, 11, 12, 26A(1), 26A(3), 26A(4), and 26A(5), and how these provisions relate to the roles and powers of VCAT under the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998. The Court held that VCAT's interpretation of the 'public interest test' did not align with the statutory requirements, as VCAT had not adequately considered the specific public interest factors outlined in the Act.
In relation to the second issue, the Court observed that VCAT failed to properly distinguish between the 'public interest test' and the 'unjustifiable risk test'. The Court noted that VCAT seemed to merge these two distinct tests, which could lead to an incorrect application of the statutory criteria. This conflation resulted in a misinterpretation of the legislative intent, as the 'unjustifiable risk test' is a narrower criterion focused on immediate and significant risk to children, whereas the 'public interest test' considers broader societal concerns.
The Court also scrutinised VCAT's application of the'reasonable person test' within the context of a Category A application. It was determined that VCAT did not appropriately consider the specific circumstances of the applicant and the potential impact of his past conviction on the safety of children. The Court highlighted that VCAT's decision lacked a nuanced understanding of the statutory obligations and the specific protections afforded to children under the Act.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that VCAT must clearly distinguish between the 'public interest test' and the 'unjustifiable risk test', apply the 'reasonable person test' in accordance with the specific statutory criteria, and ensure that all relevant public interest factors are properly considered in Category A applications under the Working with Children Act 2005. The Court's decision underscores the importance of rigorous statutory interpretation and application in administrative law, particularly when dealing with sensitive matters such as child protection.