D. FROM ORAL JUDGMENT
| =-̂ IC'. | , |
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT | OF AUSTRALIA ) |
)
| VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY | ) | V. NOS 3 | c% | 4 of 1980 |
| INDUSTRIAL DIVISION | ||||
| BETWEEN : |
| GEORGE PHILOPOULOS | Applicant |
| and |
| FARABRAM NOMINEES | PTY LIMITED | Respondent |
. REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
i
| KEELY J. | 1980 | 2 May |
| These are two applications under s.119 | of the Conciliation |
| and Arbitration Act 1904 (the Act) for the imposition | o f |
| penalties upon | the respondent for alleged breaches | of clause 31 |
of the Clothing Trades Award 1964 (the award). By consent the
two matters were heard together.
| At the commencement | of the hearing, Mr Nathan | of counsel |
| on behalf of | the applicant supplied particulars | of the alleged | I |
| breaches in answer to | a request by Fir Merkel of counsel, who |
appeared for the respondent.
| In matter V. No. 3 of 1980 the alleged breach was | of | .- |
| clause 31(b) | of the award, it being alleged "that on | 5 April |
| 1979 ... an authorised person, being | the applicant, was denied |
entry to the respondent's factory premises during the midday
meal break to conduct legitimate union business". The Court
- 2 -
| rejected an attempt by Mr Nathan | to supply particulars of an |
alleged additional breach of a separate provision of the award
| (clause 31(a)) which allegation | did not fall within the |
affidavit supporting the application and filed with it. This
| additional matter was referred | to in a later affidavit by the |
| applicant which was sworn and filed shortly before the hearing | - |
| and more than six weeks after the hearing of the summons | f o r |
| directions. | No application was made for leave to amend the |
| application in such | a way as to include the alleged additional | I |
| breach. | I . |
In matter V. No. 4 of 1980 it was alleged that, in breach
| of clause 31(a) of the award, on or about "the | 9th day of April |
1979 at Richmond the respondent denied an authorised person
| access to the wages books, or time sheets, | or records covering |
| its employees and refused | to make such wages books, time sheets |
| or records available for inspection | on demand". |
l
| On the evidence I find that at all material times: | ! |
| I |
| 1. The | respondent | was | incorporated. |
2. The respondent was a member of the Victorian Chamber
|
registered under the Act.
3. The award was binding on the Victorian Chamber of
| I | Manufactures and its members including the respondent | |
| ||
| 71 Balmain Street, Richmond where approximately twelve persons were employed. |
| I | ||
|
- 3 -
4 . The Clothing and Allied Trades Union of Australia (the union) was an organisation of employees, registered under the Act, which was affected by the alleged
|
5. The applicant was an officer of the union and authorised
|
union.
6. Clause 31 of the award provided as follows: "31 - Authorised Person…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Sarina; Ex parte Wollondilly Shire Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1980] FCA 66
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court’s reasoning hinged on the interpretation of the award's provisions and the evidence presented. The court found that the applicant's request during the meal break was not legitimate union business and was made outside the permitted times, thus no breach occurred. However, regarding the second allegation, the court accepted that the respondent had refused access to the wages books and records, which constituted a breach of the award. The court also dismissed arguments suggesting the award was not binding or that the breach was technical. The court emphasised the seriousness of the breach, particularly the manner in which it was carried out, and the importance of deterring similar conduct in the future. The penalty was set at $500, reflecting the seriousness of the breach while considering the respondent’s cooperation and the absence of prior breaches.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi