Toyota Finance Australia Ltd v Berro

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Toyota Finance Australia Limited v Youssef Berro [2022] FCA 497

File number(s): NSD 715 of 2021
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 6 May 2022
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – application by respondent to set aside sequestration orders and dismiss creditor’s petition – where no evidence of statement of affairs provided – where respondent failed to establish he is able to pay his debts as and when they fall due – application dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application by respondent to set aside orders made in his absence dismissing his interim application – where evidence indicates the respondent did receive notice of the hearing date – application dismissed

Legislation:

Acts Interpretations Act 1901 (Cth) s 29

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 40, 43, 44, 47, 52, 54, 58, 116

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 160

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 35A

Bankruptcy Regulations 2021 (Cth) r 102

Federal Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2016 r 7.05

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 39.05

Cases cited:

Bechara v Bates [2021] FCAFC 34; 388 ALR 414

Cain v Whyte [1933] HCA 6; 48 CLR 639

Civic Video Pty Ltd v Warburton [2013] FCA 934; 216 FCR 61

Clyne v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [1985] FCA 4; 5 FCR 1

Culleton v Balwyn Nominees Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 8; 343 ALR 632

Endresz v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (No 2) [2015] FCAFC 33; 228 FCR 334

Hardaker v Phair trading as Proctor Phair & Associates, in the matter of Hardaker [2002] FCA 1176

Harris v Caladine [1991] HCA 9; 172 CLR 84

Liang v LV Property Investments Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1057

Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd v Compton [2017] HCA 28; 261 CLR 132

Re Sarina; Ex parte Wollondilly Shire Council [1980] FCA 66; 30 ALR 266

Rozenbes v Kronhill [1956] HCA 65; 95 CLR 407

Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 11

Shaw v Yarranova Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 88; 252 FCR 267

Totev v Sfar [2008] FCAFC 35; 167 FCR 193

Wolff v Donovan [1991] FCA 222; 29 FCR 480

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 99
Date of hearing: 8 April 2022
14 April 2022
2 May 2022
Solicitor for the Applicant and the trustee in bankruptcy: Mr D Farrar of Farrar Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: The Respondent appeared in person

ORDERS

NSD 715 of 2021
BETWEEN:

TOYOTA FINANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED ABN 48 002 435 181

Applicant

AND:

YOUSSEF BERRO

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 MAY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Respondent’s interim application dated 21 March 2022 be dismissed.

2.The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the interim application dated 21 March 2022, they being costs of the administration of the bankrupt estate.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Toyota Finance Australia Ltd v Berro and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 497
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Toyota Finance Australia Ltd sought sequestration of Youssef Berro's estate based on a judgment debt. Berro contested the petition, arguing he was not served with the creditor's petition, did not owe the debt, and was solvent. The court had to determine if Toyota adequately proved the requirements for a sequestration order and if Berro met the burden to show he could pay his debts or there was another sufficient cause to refuse the order.

The court found that Toyota had provided sufficient evidence of the debt and service of the creditor's petition. Affidavits from Toyota's process server and legal staff confirmed Berro was served with the petition. Berro failed to provide evidence to counter Toyota's claims, and his assertion of lack of service was contradicted by the process server's affidavit. The court noted Berro's financial situation, including assets and income, but found he did not establish he could pay his debts as they fell due.

Regarding Berro's application to set aside the sequestration order made in his absence, the court held that there was evidence Berro did receive notice of the hearing. The court dismissed Berro's application to set aside the sequestration order and his application to review the decision, ordering Berro to pay Toyota's costs of the interim application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent’s interim application dated 21 March 2022 be dismissed.

2. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the interim application dated 21 March 2022, they being costs of the administration of the bankrupt estate.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Toyota and the trustee relied on affidavits of: (a) Perry Gamsby, process server, sworn on 23 September 2021 and 11 January 2022; (b) Huy Nguyen, head of legal at Toyota, sworn on 15 November 2021, 30 November 2021 and 8 April 2022; (c) Isaiah Soriano, legal secretary at the applicant’s solicitors, sworn on 20 July 2021, 15 November 2021, 19 November 2021, 29 November 2021, 30 November 2021, 31 March 2022 and 5 April 2022; (d) Mr Farrar, sworn on 20 July 2021, 2 December 2021 and 9 December 2021; and (e) Nicolle Greentree, accountant at Jones Partners, sworn on 11 January 2022,6 April 2022 and 29 April 2022. Mr Berro was given an opportunity to cross examine each of those witnesses, and elected to cross examine Mr Gamsby, Ms Greentree and Mr Farrar. The hearing was conducted on 8 April, 14 April and 2 May 2022. In large part, the fragmented hearing arose because Mr Berro sought additional time to obtain evidence to prove his case and was granted two adjournments.1.3 Background A brief chronology of events is set out below. On 10 June 2021, Toyota Finance Australia Ltd obtained judgment from the Local Court of New South Wales in amounts of $37,894.88 and $2,664.75 against Mr Berro. 16 June 2021 was the date recorded in the creditor’s petition upon which the Bankruptcy Notice No BN 253326 was served on Mr Berro. The date of commission of the act of bankruptcy by Mr Berro was found by the Registrar to be 16 July 2021. The creditor’s petition, in which Toyota contends that Mr Berro is the judgment debtor in the amount of $40,559.63 from a Local Court judgment on 10 June 2021 and a further $2,664.74 from a judgment of the same day, is dated 13 July 2021. Mr Gamsby contends that on 18 September 2021 he served the correct Youssef Berro with the creditor’s petition. On 30 November 2021, the Registrar ordered that the estate of Youssef Berro be sequestrated under the Act. The date when Mr Berro contends he first heard about the sequestration proceedings is 11 December 2021 when a person delivered a letter from Jones Partners telling him that he had been bankrupted and that Michael Jones had been appointed as his trustee in bankruptcy. On 21 December 2021, Mr Berro filed an interlocutory application pursuant to s 35A(5) of the FCA Act for the review of the decision of the Registrar and orders that the creditor’s petition be dismissed with costs. Mr Berro filed an affidavit on the same day, sworn on 21 December 2021. In this affidavit, Mr Berro claims not to have been served and that he had no knowledge of the judgment debt, the bankruptcy notice or creditor’s petition. Mr Berro further claims that the first he heard of the proceedings was on 11 December 2021 when he was delivered a letter from a process server telling him he had been made a bankrupt, and that he had not previously been served with a bankruptcy notice or a creditor’s petition. Mr Berro gives evidence that he did not know of the judgment debt entered by Toyota. Mr Berro gives evidence that he has resources to pay any debt by reason of owning his own home worth $1 million, with a mortgage of about $780,000, a car worth $35,000 and self-employed earnings of about $100,000 per annum.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 8 April 2022. Mr Farrar informed the Court that, despite the lifting of the stay, the trustee had taken minimal steps in the bankruptcy pending the determination of Mr Berro’s application.2. APPLICATION TO REVIEW THE SEQUESTRATION ORDER 2.1 Introduction It is convenient to consider the application to review the sequestration order before addressing Mr Berro’s application to set aside the orders made on 14 February 2022. Mr Berro contends that the sequestration order should be set aside because:(1)He was not served with the Bankruptcy Notice or the sequestration order, or with notice of the proceedings;(2)He does not owe a debt to Toyota;(3)He is solvent. 2.2 Relevant principles In Totev v Sfar [2008] FCAFC 35; 167 FCR 193 at [13]-[15], Emmett J (citing Harris v Caladine [1991] HCA 9; 172 CLR 84 at 124 (Dawson J), cited with approval in Bechara at [21]) said:[13]… the judge reviewing the order begins afresh and exercises for himself or herself any discretion exercised by the registrar. The parties commence the proceeding again, subject to any rules concerning the use of evidence adduced before the registrar. The hearing de novo involves the exercise of the original jurisdiction and the petitioner, in the case of a bankruptcy petition, must start again, call witnesses and make out the petitioner’s case.[14]… The judge who hears the review application must hear the petition afresh and must be satisfied as to the matters referred to in s 52 of the Bankruptcy Act. Thus, the reviewing judge must herself or himself be satisfied with the proof of:•the matters stated in the petition;•the service of the petition; and•the fact that the debt or debts on which the petitioning creditor relies is or are still owing.The reviewing judge must also exercise afresh the discretions conferred by s 52(2).[15]In particular, unless the Bankruptcy Rules are waived, the judge must have the affidavits referred to in r 4.06 of the Bankruptcy Rules, which must be sworn shortly before the hearing. Except in the case of a review on the same day as the sequestration order was made, the affidavits relied upon before the registrar would not satisfy r 4.06. Section 52(1) of the Act provides that the Court may make a sequestration order against the estate of a debtor if it is satisfied with proof of:(a)the matters stated in the petition …;(b)service of the petition; and(c)the fact that the debt or debts on which the petitioning creditor relies is or are still owing. The petitioning creditor has a prima facie right to a sequestration order once proof of the matters required by s 52(1) has been satisfied: Cain v Whyte [1933] HCA 6; 48 CLR 639 at 646 and 648 (Rich J, Starke, Dixon, Evatt and McTiernan JJ agreeing); Rozenbes v Kronhill [1956] HCA 65; 95 CLR 407 at 414 (Dixon CJ, Webb and Fullagar JJ). Nevertheless, the Court retains a discretion to refuse such an order if the debtor is able to pay their debts (s 52(2)(a)) or for “other sufficient cause” (s 52(2)(b)). The onus is on the debtor, Mr Berro, to establish either or both of the preconditions. The circumstances which may constitute “other sufficient cause” are variable, and it is inappropriate to catalogue or circumscribe them: Clyne v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [1985] FCA 4; 5 FCR 1 at 5 (Fisher, Morling and Wilcox JJ); Liang v LV Property Investments Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1057 at [52] (Beach J).