ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) V200600759-0764
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )Re:GENERAL MERCHANDISE & APPAREL GROUP P/L
Applicant
And:CEO OF CUSTOMS
Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) V200601106-1112
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )Re:GENERAL MERCHANDISE & APPAREL GROUP P/L
Applicant
And:CEO OF CUSTOMS
Respondent
And:AUSTRALIAN WEAVING MILLS
Party Joined
Tribunal: Deputy President S A Forgie
Place: Melbourne
Date: 16 February 2010
CORRIGENDUM TO DECISION [2009] AATA 988
The Tribunal amends its decision and reasons for decision published on 23 December 2009 as follows:
1.Delete paragraph 2(b) of the decision and replace with:
I set aside the respondent’s decisions:
(i)to revoke TCO 0511357; and
(ii)to revoke TCOs 0511358, 0511359 and 0511360 and to reissue them as TCOs 0613070, 0613067 and 0613064 respectively;
2.In paragraphs 349, 350, 352, 358, 359 & 360 replace all references to ‘valances’ with ‘sheets and pillow cases’; and
3.Delete the first two sentences of paragraph 87 and replace with:
“Even if Bruck were a producer in Australia of substitutable goods at the time it lodged its request for revocation, General Merchandise went on to contend that, had the relevant TCOs the subject of No V200600759-764 not been in force on that day but had an application for a TCO been lodged on that day, the CEO would have made the TCO. The GMSFC goes on to examine the evidence to support its contention that the application would have met the core criteria.”
S A FORGIE
Deputy President
CATCHWORDS – CUSTOMS – TARIFF CONCESSION ORDERS – applications for revocation - whether persons requesting revocation producers of substitutable goods – whether goods put or capable of being put to a use that corresponds with a use to which the goods the subject of the relevant TCOs can be put- whether goods meet local content test – whether goods meet substantial process test – whether core criteria would have been met if TCOs not in force on days and an application for them had been lodged – decisions set aside.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summons – grounds on which may be refused.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether Tribunal required to pursue all relevant material - whether parties required to produce all relevant material in their custody, possession or control.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - role of party joined - whether required to lodge material in support of the argument it wishes to make.
Acts Interpretation Act 1901, s 46
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 2, 2A, 3, 25, 30A, 32, 33, 35, 36, 36B, 36C, 37, 39, 39A, 42A, 43, 59A
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Amendment Act, s 25
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977, s 5
Broadcasting and Television Act 1942, ss 25, 92F, 94F
Corporations Act 2001, ss 9, 50, 50AAA, 124, 588V-X
Customs Act 1901, ss 132, 132AA, 269B, 269C, 269E, 269D, 269F, 269FA, 269H, 269J, 269L, 269M, 269P, 269Q, 269R, 269S, 269SA, 269SB, 269SC, 269SD, 269SE, 269SF, 269SH, 269SHA, 269SJ, 269SM, 273GA
Customs Tariff Act 1995, ss 3, 7, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22, Schedule 2
Evidence Act
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re General Merchandise and Apparel Group Pty Ltd and CEO, Cu... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] AATA 988
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court meticulously examined the statutory language of Sections 269SHA(1) and 273GA(6A), highlighting discrepancies in their scope and application. It noted that Section 269SHA(1) seemed to incorrectly reference Section 269SH(1), which does not pertain to the authority of the Chief Executive Officer to make decisions. Additionally, the court pointed out that Section 269SHA(1) allows any person who is an affected party to apply for review of a reconsideration decision, which contradicts the narrower criteria set by Section 273GA(6A). This discrepancy raised questions about the legislative intent and the proper interpretation of these sections. The court concluded that the provisions of Section 273GA(6A) were indeed narrower and more specific, requiring that the applicant not meet the criteria for reconsideration and must be adversely affected by the decision under review.
Ultimately, the court ruled that Section 269SHA(1) was not compatible with Section 273GA(6A) in the context of applications for review of decisions made under Section 269SH on a reconsideration of a decision made under Section 269P(1). The court's decision clarified the scope and application of these sections, ensuring that the correct criteria were applied in determining who could seek review of decisions made by the Chief Executive Officer of Customs. This ruling provided much-needed clarity on the process for judicial review of decisions related to trade practices under the Customs Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 269SHA(1) would appear to contradict s 273GA(6A) in so far as it concerns an application to the Tribunal in respect of a decision made under s 269SH on a reconsideration of a decision made under s 269P(1). Section 269SHA(1) provides:“For the purpose of an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal under section 273GA for review of a decision under subsection 269SH(1) or (4) (a reconsideration decision), application may be made by any person who is an affected person in relation to that decision within the meaning of subsection 269SH(13).” The first difficulty that I have with this provision is its reference to s 269SH(1). That subsection makes no reference to the CEO’s or anyone else’s being able to make a decision. All that it provides is that certain persons may apply to the CEO for reconsideration of a decision on either a TCO application or a request for revocation of a TCO. The CEO’s authority to make a decision comes in s 269SH(4). The second difficulty that I have with s 269SHA(1) is that it provides that an application for review in respect of a decision made under s 269SH(4) may be made to the Tribunal by any person who is an affected person within the meaning of s 269SH(13). Section s 269SH(4) refers to the decision made by the CEO when reviewing a decision made on an application for a standard TCO. A decision made on a TCO application must have been made under s 269P(1). Those who may apply to the Tribunal in respect of a decision under s 269SH on a reconsideration of a decision under s 269P(1) is already the subject of s 273GA(6A). The provisions of s 273GA(6A) and of s 269SHA(1) are not compatible. Those of s 273GA(6A) are much narrower in that the person must not meet the criteria required by s 269SH, and so those required by s 269SHA(1), but must also be adversely affected by the decision under review. I do not have the same difficulties in relation to an application to the Tribunal for review of a decision of the CEO reconsidering a decision made on a request for revocation of a TCO. There are two separate decisions made under ss 269SC(1) and (4). Reconsideration of them is the subject of s 269SH(5). Those who may apply to the Tribunal for review of the decision made on a reconsideration of them is the subject of s 273GA(6A) alone. No similar provision appears in s 269SHA(1) or elsewhere in s 269SHA. Section 269SHA(3) applies to persons who have not applied to the Section 269SHA(1) gave the term “reconsideration decision” the meaning of “a decision under subsection 269SH(1) or (4)”. As I have said, it seems to me that no decision can be made under s 269SH(1). If that is correct, the provisions of s 269SHA(3) can apply only to an application for review of a reconsideration of a decision made in respect of an application for a TCO. An application for reconsideration of a decision on a request for revocation of a TCO is the subject of s 269SH(5). Section 269SHA(5) again refers to proceedings before the Tribunal for review of a “reconsideration decision”. For the reasons I have given, it too must be limited to applications for review of a decision by the CEO reconsidering a decision under s 269SH(4) and so a decision on an application for review of a TCO.[94] Section 269SHA(5) provides:“Any document on which a party to proceedings for review of a reconsideration decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal intends to rely must, subject to the provisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975:(a)be filed with the Tribunal; and(b)be served on the other parties to the proceeding;not less than 28 days before the date set for hearing, unless the Tribunal makes an order permitting the document to be filed and served within a lesser period or to be introduced at the hearing without being so filed or served.”[94] Without analysing s 269SHA as I have in these reasons, I incorrectly assumed in Re General Merchandise and Apparel Group Pty Ltd and Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2007] AATA 1138 at [23] that the provisions of s 269SHA applies to all applications to the Tribunal under s 273GA.