SYNGENTA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD and COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

SYNGENTA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD and COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS [2023] AATA 1475

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/4961

Re:SYNGENTA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

APPLICANT

AndCOMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date:29 March 2023

Place:Sydney

The Comptroller General’s 29 June 2021 internal review decision is affirmed.

..................................[SGD]......................................

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS – tariff concession order - whether substitutable goods were produced in Australia and put, or capable of being put to a use that corresponds with a use of the goods subject to the tariff concession order – substitutable goods found – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Code Act 1994 (Cth)

Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Code 1994 (Cth)

Customs Act 1901 (Cth)

CASES

Alstom Transport Australia Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs [2020] FCAFC 43

Becker Vale Pty Ltd v CEO of Customs [2015] FCA 525

Brand Developers Aust Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2015] AATA 215 

Chief Executive Officer of Customs v Toyota Material Handling Australia Pty [2012] FCAFC 78

Cohns Industries Pty Ltd v DCT (1979) 24 ALR 658; 37 FLR 508

Comptroller-General of Customs v Alstom Transport Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 109

Dow Agroscience Australia Limited and Chief Executive Officer of Customs and Nufarm Australia [2012] AATA 568

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Jack Zinader Pty Ltd (1949) 78 CLR 336

General Merchandise & Apparel Group Pty Ltd v CEO of Customs [2009] AATA 988

In re Searles Ltd (1932) 33 SR (NSW)

Kenso Marketing (M) SDN BHD and Chief Executive Officers and Nufarm Australia Limited [2008] AATA 42

Kenso Marketing (M) SDN BHD and Chef Executive Officer of Customs [2011] FCAFC 26

Nufarm Australia Ltd v Dow AgroSciences Australia Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 757

Re Bag & Jute Company (Tamworth) Pty Ltd v Comptroller General of Customs (1995) 38 ALD 357

Re Downer EDI Rail Pty Ltd v Chief Executive of Customs (2010) 118 ALD 454

Re Thirco v Comptroller of Customs [1994] AATA 293; (1994) 35 ALD 665

Re Vulcan Australia Pty Ltd v Comptroller General of Customs [1994] AATA 150; (1994) 34 ALD 773

Toro Australia Group Sales Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2014] AATA 18

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

29 March 2023

  1. Syngenta Crop Protection AG (“Syngenta AG”) is a Swiss company that manufactures “Reflex”, an agricultural herbicide. Its’ subsidiary company, Syngenta Australia Pty Ltd (which I will refer to simply as “Syngenta”) imports Reflex and distributes it in Australia. 

  2. Syngenta’s importation and sale of Reflex in Australia is the subject of a March 2021 registration and approval by the Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority (“the APVMA”)[1] under the Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Code 1994 (Cth) (“the Agvet Code”) – sections 14 & 15.[2] 

    [1] The APVMA is a corporation, established under that name, by the Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals (Administration) Act (Cth)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SYNGENTA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD and COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOM... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1475
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Syngenta Australia Pty Ltd sought review of a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs concerning a Tariff Concession Order (TCO). The dispute centred on whether certain herbicides manufactured by Nufarm constituted "substitutable goods" for the purposes of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), specifically under section 269B(1). The Senior Member, Mr P W Taylor SC, considered the appeal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether the Nufarm herbicides, which were approved for use against certain weeds, could be characterised as "substitutable goods" in relation to the goods subject to the TCO, identified by Syngenta as Reflex. This required an assessment of whether the Nufarm products had a "reasonable" actual or potential use that "corresponds" with the use capacity of Reflex, considering factors beyond mere herbicidal efficacy against some common weeds.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the interpretation of "substitutable goods" under the Customs Act. While the Comptroller-General had initially found that common herbicidal efficacy against particular weeds was sufficient, Syngenta argued that a more detailed comparison was necessary. Syngenta contended that differences in the approved weed spectrum targets, permissible crop usage, and application timing between Reflex and the Nufarm herbicides meant they did not have corresponding reasonable uses. The Tribunal acknowledged that APVMA approval restricts lawful supply and promotion but noted that this does not necessarily delimit actual efficacy, pointing to residual effects and potential uses in other jurisdictions as examples of factors that might inform the assessment of corresponding use.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The essence of the Comptroller General’s 8 April 2021 decision reasoning was that the fact of herbicidal efficacy against particular kinds of weeds, where it was common to both the TCO goods and Nufarm’s products, sufficed to characterise the latter as “substitutable goods” for the purposes of CA1901 section 269B(1).THE MAY 2021 INTERNAL REVIEW REQUEST AND JUNE 2021 DECISION Despite the generic wording of the description in the 10 March 2021 gazettal (see paragraph 7 above), Syngenta’s 11 May 2021 internal review request explicitly identified Reflex as “the goods described in the TCO”. The request then complained that the Comptroller General had incorrectly identified the “reasonable” actual/potential uses of both Reflex and the Nufarm herbicides. The substance of Syngenta’s contention involved the propositions that (i) the reasonable use of each of the four herbicides was limited to a combination of weeds, (ii) there was no known weed resistance to Group G herbicides, (iii) there was known resistance to Group D and I herbicides, (iv) consequently, the reasonable use of Reflex was either limited to, or only appropriate for, a weed combination target that included weeds that were resistant to the Nufarm herbicides. The essence of Syngenta’s argument was that the mere fact Reflex and the Nufarm products were approved as effective herbicides in controlling or suppressing some of the same kinds of weeds, was insufficient to justify characterising any of the Nufarm herbicides as “substitutable goods”. Rather, it was necessary to compare their approved herbicidal efficacy[7] in relation to both their respective weed spectrum targets, and the permissible timing of their application (particularly relative to crop sowing). Syngenta contended that, when those kinds of comparisons were made, the Nufarm products had (i) a weed spectrum efficacy that significantly differed from, and had only a limited overlap with, that of Reflex, (ii) differences from Reflex in the types of permissible crop usage and, (iii) an application time restricted to the period prior to crop sowing. Those differences were said to lead to the conclusion that the Nufarm products could not be regarded as “substitutable goods”. They did not have a “reasonable” use that “corresponds” with the use capacity of Reflex. [7] This composite expression has some relevance. APVMA approval for particular applications and purposes, does restrict the lawful supply and promotion of herbicides to the terms of the approval:- see paragraph 26 below. However, the approval does not necessarily delimit the actual efficacy of the particular herbicide. The point may be made by reference to two considerations. The first is that both Reflex, and at least some of the Nufarm herbicides, whilst restricted to “pre-emergent” applications, were known to have significant “post-emergent” residual effects. The second point is that Reflex, for example, has additional efficacious uses approved in other jurisdictions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established