Details
- Case
- [2014] AATA 18
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In ABCD v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the Applicant, born in the Philippines on 1 January 2013, sought to establish that JM, an Australian citizen, was his legal parent at the time of his birth, thereby making him eligible for Australian citizenship under section 16(2)(a) of the Act. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the relationship between JM and the Applicant demonstrated the requisite degree of connection and intense commitment necessary to conclude that a legal parent/child relationship existed as at the date of the Applicant's birth. The facts of the case revealed that JM and the Applicant's mother, M, had an online relationship starting a year before the Applicant's birth, with JM visiting M in the Philippines on multiple occasions. Despite not being present at the Applicant's birth or christening due to work commitments, JM had shown a significant level of involvement and commitment to the Applicant, as evidenced by various documents including the Applicant’s Birth Certificate, Baptismal Certificate, and an Affidavit of Acknowledgment of Paternity.
The Tribunal assessed the evidence presented, including JM's sworn document, the various certificates, and numerous emails and cards indicating JM's acknowledgment of the Applicant as his son. The evidence suggested that although JM was not the biological father, he had established a parental relationship with the Applicant. The Tribunal concluded that JM was the Applicant’s parent within the meaning of section 16 of the Act, despite the absence of biological connection. The Tribunal found that the combination of JM's social and legal acknowledgments of the Applicant, along with the documentary evidence, sufficiently demonstrated the requisite parent-child relationship.
The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection had previously refused the application for citizenship based on a DNA test indicating that JM was not the biological father. However, the Tribunal found that the biological relationship was not the sole determinant of parental status for the purposes of the Act. Instead, the focus was on the nature and extent of the relationship between JM and the Applicant. Consequently, the Tribunal allowed the Applicant's appeal, ruling that JM was indeed the Applicant's legal parent, thereby making the Applicant eligible for Australian citizenship.
Background
Background to the litigation
The issue before the Tribunal is thus whether the evidence establishes, as a matter of fact, the “requisite degree of connection” and “intense commitment” between JM and the Applicant to justify a conclusion, as a matter of law, that a “legal parent/child relationship” existed as at the date of the Applicant’s birth, such that, as at that date, JM was the Applicant’s “parent” within the meaning of section 16(2) of the Act.The facts The facts of this matter were not materially in dispute. The Applicant was born in the Philippines on 1 January 2013. About a year prior to his birth, his mother (M), who lived in the Philippines, and JM, an Australian citizen, established a relationship by “chatting” to each other online. At the time, M was married (albeit estranged from her husband). JM and M first met in person when JM travelled to the Philippines on 2 May 2012, returning to Australia on 23 May 2012. Thereafter, JM made the following trips to the Philippines:(a)departing Australia on 18 January 2013 and returning on 28 January 2013;(b)departing Australia on 15 March 2013 and returning on 5 April 2013;(c)departing Australia on 18 June 2013 and returning on 22 June 2013. JM gave evidence during the course of the hearing before the Tribunal. Attached to these Reasons for Decision and marked “A” is a document which JM prepared and confirmed on oath as being true and correct (Document). With one exception (which is not presently relevant), JM was not cross-examined as to the Document. There was nothing in JM’s evidence, either in its substance or the way it was given, that caused me to have any reservation about the honesty or accuracy of his evidence. Indeed, quite properly, no submission was made by Counsel for the Respondent which was inconsistent with that. In the circumstances, and given that the Document is not inconsistent with other evidence which was tendered, the Tribunal makes findings of fact in the terms of the Document. In cross-examination, JM was asked why he was not present at the Applicant’s birth. JM’s response, which I accept, was that he was not present because he was not able to obtain leave from his work to travel to the Philippines to be present at the Applicant’s birth. JM was also cross-examined as to why he was not present at the Applicant’s christening. Again, JM’s response, which I accept, was that he would have been there, but for the fact that he could not get leave from work. Amongst the large number of documents tendered on behalf of the Applicant were the following:(a)the Applicant’s Birth Certificate, noting JM as his “father”;(b)a “Baptismal Certificate” dated 3 February 2013, noting JM as the Applicant’s father;(c)an “Affidavit of Acknowledgment/Admission of Paternity” sworn by JM on 21 January 2013 by which JM deposed to the fact that he had allowed the Applicant, described as “my herein son”, to use JM’s surname;(d)numerous emails passing between JM and his father, both prior and subsequent to the birth of the Applicant, relating to the Applicant’s birth, including attaching photos of the Applicant as a newborn and prior to the Applicant’s birth, informing JM’s father as to M’s health and results of her ultrasounds;(e)a card “Congratulations on the arrival of your beautiful baby boy” on which various persons, including his aunties, wrote congratulatory comments to JM “on the birth of your baby boy”;(f)a “Certificate of Divorce” in the Republic of the Philippines evidencing that M was divorced from her former husband by judicial decree dated 15 July 2013.
Decision
Reasons for decision
By decision dated 21 May 2013, a delegate of the Minister refused the Application (reviewable decision). The delegate concluded that the Applicant had failed to establish that he “had a parent who was an Australian citizen at the time of (his) birth”, stating “based on the DNA testing report showing that the sponsor, (JM), is not the biological father of the applicant …”. On the evidence before the Tribunal, the Tribunal also finds that JM is not the biological father of the Applicant. The evidence does establish, however, that JM is the Applicant’s “parent” within the meaning of that word as it appears in section 16 of the Act and as construed by the Federal Court of Australia.The issue As noted above, section 16(2)(a) of the Act provides that a person born outside Australia on or after 26 January 1949 is eligible to become an Australian citizen if “a parent of the person was an Australian citizen at the time of the birth”. It was not in dispute that in determining whether JM is a “parent” of the Applicant at the time of the Applicant’s birth – it also not being in dispute that JM was at that time an Australian citizen – the Tribunal may have regard to and apply the relevant Ministerial Policy, namely the Australian Citizenship Instructions (ACIs) that were published on 1 July 2013, see, for example, Drake and Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634 at 643 and 645. In this regard, the ACIs relevantly provide as follows:“19.2.2 FraudAn application requires additional scrutiny if one or more of the following circumstances apply:· the person stated to be the child’s mother travelled by air in what would have been a very advanced state of pregnancy (most airlines will not carry a passenger after the 28th week of pregnancy)· the person stated to be the child’s mother is of mature age and the birth certificate shows the child to be her first born· the person stated to be the child’s mother claims to have had no prenatal attention from a doctor in Australia· a person stated to be a parent is not contactable· the person stated to be the child’s mother claims she had no antenatal care· an application is lodged by a responsible parent in Australia and the child is off-shore· the birth certificate was issued many years after the birth· the travel movements of the persons stated to be the parents indicate that they could not have been together at the time the child would have been conceived· a child notionally eligible for citizenship applied for a visa before seeking citizenship or evidence of citizenship.There have been fraudulent attempts to register adopted children for citizenship by descent. This is often difficult to detect because in many countries a new birth certificate is issued without any reference to the natural parents or the fact that the child has been adopted.Any fraudulent attempt to obtain citizenship or evidence of citizenship should be reported to the Citizenship Helpdesk so that details can be included on MAL.…19.4.2 Factors to be taken into accountFor citizenship by birth (s12), the parent-child relationship between the Australian citizen or permanent resident and the applicant must have existed at the applicant’s time of birth. Similarly, for citizenship by descent (s16), the parent-child relationship between the Australian citizen and the applicant must have existed at the applicant’s time of birth. The applicant (or, if applicable, their responsible parent) should be asked to provide evidence of the length and nature of the Australian citizen’s or permanent resident’s parental relationship with the child.Note: Evidence of the length and nature of the relationship between the claimed parents may corroborate the evidence of the relationship between the applicant and the Australian citizen parent, but is not in itself evidence of the parent-child relationship.It is unlikely that any one piece of non-biological evidence would be sufficient to prove the required parent-child relationship. The decision maker more likely will be required to weigh up any relevant factors, including social and legal, to reach a finding of fact as to whether the claimed parent is (was) or is (was) not a parent of the applicant at the relevant time.Evidence that the claimed parent-child relationship existed at the time of the applicant’s birth may include, but is not limited to:· anything which would show the Australian citizen’s inclusion as a parent on the birth certificate was done with their prior consent· evidence that the Australian citizen was involved in providing care for the unborn child and/or the mother during the pregnancy, for example, emotional, domestic or financial support, making arrangements for the birth and prenatal and postnatal care· evidence that the child was acknowledged socially from or before birth as the Australian citizen’s child, for example, the child was presented within the Australian citizen’s family and social groups as being the Australian citizen’s child and· when a child is born through a surrogacy arrangement – a formal surrogacy agreement entered into before the child was conceived and lawful transfer of parentage before or at time of birth in the country in which the surrogacy was carried out.Evidence that the Australian citizen treated the child as their own from some point in time after birth would not by itself be evidence that they were the child’s parent at time of birth, but would lend weight to evidence of the types mentioned above.”