CITIZENSHIP – application for grant of Australian citizenship by descent – insufficient evidence of parental relationship prior to birth of applicant - evidence fails to establish positive biological parenthood – decision affirmed.
GXVX and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship)[2015] AATA 829
H v Minister for immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2010] 188 FCR 393
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Citizenship Policy 1 June 2016
REASONS FOR DECISION
Mr W. Evans, Member
16 September 2016
INTRODUCTION
Mark Kislev Reyes Brinkman (the applicant) through his representative Ronald Henk Brinkman (Mr Brinkman), his alleged father, seeks review in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) of the decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (the Minister) on 21 December 2015 to refuse to grant him Australian citizenship under s 17(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act).
ISSUE
The issue here is whether Mr Ronald Brinkman is a “parent” of the applicant when he was born pursuant to s 16(2)(a) of the Act.
FACTS
The applicant was born at the Mary Chiles General Hospital in Manila, the Philippines on 11 February 2004 to Ms Normie Rivera Reyes, a citizen of the Philippines (T5, p46; T14, p103-105) and the then partner of Mr Ronald Brinkman.
On 6 March 2004, Mr Ronald Brinkman signed an Affidavit of Acknowledgement declaring that he was the biological father of Mark Kislev Brinkman born 11 February 2004.
Ms Reyes and Mr Brinkman later married at Baliuag, Bulacan in the Philippines (T14, p100) on 6 February 2010.
The applicant who is now 12 years old was, on 12 December 2014 granted a 3-month tourist visa (T5, p54) to visit Australia.
On 22 May 2015, some 11 years after the applicant’s birth, Mr Ronald Brinkman, listed as the applicant’s representative (T5, p44), lodged an Application for Citizenship by Descent (T5, p38-45). Mr Ronald Brinkman was listed as an Australian citizen, and the applicant’s father (T5, p39).
The respondent advised the Tribunal that between June and November 2015 Mr Brinkman submitted supporting documents to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) (T12, p66; T14, p91; T17, p150; T21, p197; T22, p203).
The respondent further advised that Tribunal that:
On 21 December 2015 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicant Australian citizenship by descent (T25, p220-231). The delegate was not satisfied that Mr Brinkman was a parent…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mark Brinkman and Minister for Immigration and Border Protec... and more:
This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by descent made by Mark Brinkman, the applicant, through his alleged father, Ronald Henk Brinkman. The core dispute revolved around whether Mr Brinkman was a "parent" of the applicant at the time of the applicant's birth, as required by section 16(2)(a) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth). The delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection refused the application, finding insufficient evidence to establish Mr Brinkman's parentage. Mr Brinkman sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.
The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the evidence presented sufficiently established that Mr Brinkman was the applicant's biological father at the time of the applicant's birth, and consequently, whether the applicant met the criteria for citizenship by descent. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider the weight to be given to various forms of evidence, including documentary records, affidavits, and family statements, in determining the existence of a parent-child relationship, particularly in the absence of DNA evidence. The Tribunal was also required to consider the relevant provisions of the Citizenship Policy, which outlined factors to be taken into account when assessing biological parent-child relationships.
The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the limited evidence provided to establish Mr Brinkman's parentage at the crucial time of the applicant's birth. While an affidavit of acknowledgment of paternity and the birth certificate listed Mr Brinkman as the father, the Tribunal found these, in conjunction with other submitted documents such as family letters and a maid's statement, to be insufficient to satisfy the requirements of the Act and the Citizenship Policy. The Tribunal noted the absence of direct evidence from the applicant's mother regarding Mr Brinkman's involvement during the pregnancy or social acknowledgment of the child as his from birth. Furthermore, the Tribunal observed that Mr Brinkman had been offered the opportunity to provide DNA evidence to definitively establish biological parentage but had not done so, and that this, in the context of other limited evidence, weighed against the claim.
Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision, finding that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to satisfy the Minister that Mr Brinkman was a parent of the applicant at the time of the applicant's birth. Consequently, the applicant was not eligible for citizenship by descent.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The issue here is whether Mr Ronald Brinkman is a “parent” of the applicant when he was born pursuant to s 16(2)(a) of the Act.FACTS The applicant was born at the Mary Chiles General Hospital in Manila, the Philippines on 11 February 2004 to Ms Normie Rivera Reyes, a citizen of the Philippines (T5, p46; T14, p103-105) and the then partner of Mr Ronald Brinkman. On 6 March 2004, Mr Ronald Brinkman signed an Affidavit of Acknowledgement declaring that he was the biological father of Mark Kislev Brinkman born 11 February 2004. Ms Reyes and Mr Brinkman later married at Baliuag, Bulacan in the Philippines (T14, p100) on 6 February 2010. The applicant who is now 12 years old was, on 12 December 2014 granted a 3-month tourist visa (T5, p54) to visit Australia. On 22 May 2015, some 11 years after the applicant’s birth, Mr Ronald Brinkman, listed as the applicant’s representative (T5, p44), lodged an Application for Citizenship by Descent (T5, p38-45). Mr Ronald Brinkman was listed as an Australian citizen, and the applicant’s father (T5, p39). The respondent advised the Tribunal that between June and November 2015 Mr Brinkman submitted supporting documents to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) (T12, p66; T14, p91; T17, p150; T21, p197; T22, p203). The respondent further advised that Tribunal that:On 21 December 2015 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicant Australian citizenship by descent (T25, p220-231). The delegate was not satisfied that Mr Brinkman was a parent of the applicant at the time of the applicant’s birth, and therefore was not satisfied that the applicant satisfied s 16(2)(a) of the Citizenship Act. Mr Ronald Brinkman, on 12 January 2016, lodged an application on the applicant’s behalf seeking review of the delegate’s decision (T1, p1-2). An email from Mr Brinkman attached to the application (T1, p3) states:I am disappointed and shocked that [the delegate’s] analysis is poorly founded and Mark Kislev Reyes Brinkman is my son.At all stages, I answered your questions faithfully. At no stage you insisted that I must do biological blood tests to support your analysis, if so, your wording on all your further queries that are very explicit that if you cannot provide the necessary documents, then you are required to do a DNA test. On 29 February 2016 Mr Brinkman filed with the Tribunal: (i)a covering letter dated 29 February 2016 (A2); (ii)a list of material he had provided to the Department titled ‘Appendix 1 Summary of his additional documents’; and (iii)a response to aspects of the delegate’s decision titled ‘Appendix 2 Comments on Mr Frederick Minson (sic) analysis’ (sic). On 6 May 2016 Mr Brinkman filed with the Tribunal: (i)a letter from Mr Brinkman’s mother dated 27 April 2016 (A4); (ii)a letter from Mr Brinkman’s brother dated 1 May 2016 (A5); and (iii)a letter from the applicant’s maternal grandmother dated 3 May 2016 (A3) sworn before a notary public in the Philippines on 4 May 2016.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
It addresses the following categories: (i)evidence pre-dating the applicant’s birth; (ii)evidence immediately post-dating the applicant’s birth; and (iii)evidence since the applicant’s birth. Summary of Evidence“24. While the Tribunal can have regard to evidence post-dating the applicant’s birth in determining whether Mr Brinkman was the applicant’s parent at the time of the applicant’s birth, that evidence may be given lesser weight than evidence concerning the months immediately before and after the applicant’s birth: GXVX and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 829 at [94]. Evidence pre-dating the applicant’s birth 25. The Department’s pregnancy calculation indicates that the applicant would have been conceived around 6 May 2003 (T11, p62). Mr Brinkman had a valid Philippine work permit from 2002-2004 (T12, p74 and 81), and passport records provided by Mr Brinkman confirm that he was in the Philippines from 3-28 March 2003, 31 March-15 April 2003, and 28 April-16 May 2003 (T17, p150).26.A letter from Mr Brinkman’s maid Ms Roslyn Regala indicates that Mr Brinkman hired Ms Regala around 4 months prior to the applicant’s birth to care for the applicant’s mother during her pregnancy. Ms Regala states that Mr Brinkman showed ‘compassion and care of his son during the pregnancy and whilst the son was growing up’ (T21, p197: T22, p203).27.Other than this letter, no evidence has been provided, pre-dating the applicant’s birth, demonstrating that Mr Brinkman provided emotional or domestic support to the applicant’s mother during her pregnancy with the applicant. In this regard, no evidence has been provided regarding the genesis or history of Mr Brinkman’s relationship with the applicant’s mother prior to the applicant’s birth. 28. Since applying to the Tribunal on the applicant’s behalf, Mr Brinkman has provided the following evidence relating to events pre-dating the applicant’s birth: 28.1.A letter from Mr Brinkman’s mother dated 27 April 2016 confirming that Mr Brinkman advised her that Ms Reyes was pregnant ‘some 2 months during the pregnancy in July 2003’, that she was ‘extremely excited to learn that I would be a grandmother again’, and that despite Mr Brinkman living abroad they are very close and talk on a weekly basis.28.2.A letter from Mr Brinkman’s brother dated 1 May 2016 stating that Mr Brinkman advised him that Ms Reyes was pregnant ‘some 2 months during the pregnancy in July 2003’, that he was delighted for his brother to have a new child in his life, and that despite living so far away ‘we are a close family and talk regularly of our family lives together’.28.3.A letter from the applicant’s maternal grandmother dated 3 May 2016, and sworn before a notary public in the Philippines on 4 May 2016, stating that her daughter ‘confirmed her pregnancy with Ronald H. Brinkman in June 2003’, that she was ‘extremely excited to be a Grandmother and the prospects of a future son-in law’ and that ‘due to Ron’s work, Normie spent most of her pregnancy living in Manila with Ron as this was very close to her sister’s residence’.Evidence immediately post-dating the applicant’s birth29. The applicant’s birth certificate (T5, p46; T14, p98): 29.1.states that the applicant was born in the Mary Chiles General Hospital in Manila at 12:13PM on 11 February 2004; 29.2.lists Mr Brinkman as the applicant’s father, and is signed by Mr Brinkman as informant on 11 February 2004;29.3.records the applicant’s parents as ‘not married’;29.4is stamped as having been prepared by a records clerk on 11 February 2004, and having been received at the Office of the Civil Registrar on 6 March 2004; and29.5.states at question 18 ‘DATE AND PLACE OF MARRIAGE OF PARENTS (if not married, accomplish Affidavit of Acknowledgment/Admission of Paternity at the back)’.30.No affidavit of acknowledgment or admission of paternity document was provided to the Department with the application for Australian citizenship. However, since applying to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision the applicant has filed an affidavit of acknowledgement made by Mr Brinkman on 11 February 2004 in which Mr Brinkman states that: 30.1.he is in a relationship with the applicant’s mother and that they have been living as husband and wife;30.2.the applicant was begot from that relationship; 30.3.he acknowledges that he is the biological and natural father of the applicant; and 30.4.he executed the affidavit to attest to the truth of these matters. 31.The applicant has also filed a certificate from the Manilla Regional Trial Court dated 27 May 2016 certifying that the affidavit of acknowledgment was entered into the Notarial Report of the witnessing notary public on 6 March 2004.32.The applicant’s ‘Newborn Admission Record’ does not record details of the applicant’s father. The details provided in the document appear to be incomplete (T14, p103).33.The applicant’s ‘Admission and Discharge Record’ records the applicant’s mother’s occupation as ‘H. wife’, records her admission to hospital on 11 February 2004, and lists her father as emergency contact (T14, p104).34.No photographs from the time of the applicant’s birth have been provided. Mr Brinkman states that non-digital photographs of the applicant were destroyed during flooding in 2006 (T14, p92), that emails/Facebook were not readily available and used in 2003 and 2004, and that he did ‘not have a Facebook account to share any emotion (sic) support’ (see Appendix 2 ‘Comments on Mr Fredericks Minson (sic) Analysis’ to Mr Brinkman’s letter dated 29 February 2016).35.Other than the letters discussed at paragraph 28 above, no evidence from the time of the applicant’s birth indicating social recognition of Mr Brinkman as the applicant’s father has been provided.Evidence since the applicant’s birth36.Mr Brinkman and the applicant’s mother were married in Baliuag, Bulacan province on 6 February 2010 (T5, p47). The applicant’s mother’s name is listed as ‘Normie R. Reyes’. The applicant’s mother’s passport issued on 15 March 2011 records her name at that point as ‘Normie Reyes Brinkman’ (T5, p49).37.Mr Brinkman has provided photographs of the applicant dating from 2006 to February 2015 including with members of Mr Brinkman’s family (T14, p127-135), and photographs of an Australian flag and Australian artwork at the family home in Bulacan (T21, p201-202).38.In response to the delegate’s statement that it was unlikely that a certain photo provided by Mr Brinkman was taken in February 2006 (T25, p229-230, photo at T14, p127), Mr Brinkman agreed that it is more likely that the photo was taken in December 2006 when the applicant was aged 2 years and 10 months (see Appendix 2 ‘Comments on Mr Fredericks Minson (sic) Analysis’ to Mr Brinkman’s letter dated 29 February 2016).39.In response to the delegate’s reference to a ‘lack of physical similarities’ between Mr Brinkman and the applicant, Mr Brinkman has stated ‘I disagree and accept that my son’s hair and eyes are more akin to my wife’ (see Appendix 2 ‘Comments on Mr Fredericks Minson (sic) Analysis’ to Mr Brinkman’s letter dated 29 February 2016).Minister’s contentions40.Other than the applicant’s birth certificate and Mr Brinkman’s affidavit of acknowledgment, there is limited evidence before the Tribunal from the months before and after the applicant’s birth addressing the relevant factors set out in the Citizenship Policy.41.No evidence (by way of written statement or otherwise) has been provided from the applicant’s mother regarding: 41.1.Mr Brinkman being the applicant’s biological parent, or the applicant’s parent (within the ordinary meaning of that word), at the time of the applicant’s birth; 41.2.Mr Brinkman’s involvement in providing emotional, domestic or financial support to her during her pregnancy; or41.3.the applicant being acknowledged socially as Mr Brinkman’s child from birth.42.Other than the letter from Ms Regala, no evidence has been provided regarding Mr Brinkman providing emotional, domestic or financial support to the applicant’s mother during her pregnancy. Even if it is accepted that communication via email or social media was not available to Mr Brinkman and the applicant’s mother during that period, it would be expected that some documentary evidence of Mr Brinkman’s and the applicant’s mother’s interaction during this period, and statements from Mr Brinkman and the applicant’s mother addressing Mr Brinkman’s provision of support during the pregnancy, could be provided.43.Further, while some photographic evidence has been provided indicating that Mr Brinkman and his family were involved with the applicant from around late 2006, limited evidence has been provided to indicate that Mr Brinkman acted as, and was socially acknowledged as, the applicant’s parent between the time of the applicant’s birth and 2006. Mr Brinkman has explained that his non-digital photographs were destroyed during typhoon flooding in Manilla 2006, however no explanation regarding the specifics of this flooding (including where and when flooding occurred, and where Mr Brinkman and the applicant were residing at the time) has been provided.44.The respondent notes that the applicant had not indicated that he intends to call the applicant’s mother, the applicant’s maternal grandmother, or members of Mr Brinkman’s family to give oral evidence (either in person or by telephone) at the hearing of the application for review.45.In these circumstances, and bearing in mind the significance of grant of Australian citizenship the Minister contends that it is appropriate for the Tribunal to rigorously scrutinise the evidence before it and approach the matter with some caution: ABCD v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 18 at [34]-[36]. DNA evidence46.On 20 October 2015 the Department advised Mr Brinkman that (T19, p192-194):46.1.further evidence of his parent-child relationship with the applicant during the applicant’s time of birth was required, including evidence that Mr Brinkman was involved in providing emotional, domestic or financial care, evidence that the applicant was acknowledged socially as Mr Brinkman’s child, and evidence that Mr Brinkman was responsible for the applicant’s long-term or day-to-day care; or46.2.alternatively, Mr Brinkman had the option of undertaking a DNA test to prove the family relationship.47.On 9 November 2015 Mr Brinkman advised the Department that he had just read the Department’s 20 October 2015 correspondence (T20, p195). Shortly afterwards, the Department received supporting documents from Mr Brinkman (being the letter from his maid Ms Roselyn Regala, and some photographs).48.In a letter to the Tribunal dated 29 February 2016 Mr Brinkman states that:“[DNA testing] was an option if we were unable to respond to the questions raised by [the Department]. At no time was DNA Testing refused by me as I responded to all the questions raised by the Australian Embassy.”49.Further, in his list of comments on the delegate’s decision, Mr Brinkman states his understanding that ‘DNA Testing was only a requirement if I did not respond to the question’ and that the questions raised by Australian Embassey [sic] did not require any non-biological testing on the proviso that all questions are responded’ (Appendix 2 ‘Comments on Mr Fredericks Minson (sic) Analysis’ to Mr Brinkman’s letter dated 29 February 2016).50.Notwithstanding the wording of the Department’s correspondence with Mr Brinkman, it is clear that DNA test results indicating a biological relationship between the applicant and Mr Brinkman would be highly persuasive evidence that the applicant satisfies s 16(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act.51.Mr Brinkman has not provided results of a DNA test establishing his biological relationship to the applicant. This fact alone may not necessarily give rise to any adverse inference regarding Ms Brinkman’s claim to be, and to have been at the time of the applicant’s birth, the applicant’s father. However, in the context of the limited evidence provided by the applicant, and taking into account the significance of grant of Australian citizenship, the Minister contends that in the absence of DNA evidence Mr Brinkman’s claim to have been the applicant’s father at the time of the applicant’s birth should be tested at hearing. 52.The Minister submits that it is open to the Tribunal, on the evidence currently before it, to not be satisfied that Mr Brinkman was a parent of the applicant at the time of the applicant’s birth, and that the applicant therefore does not satisfy s 16(2) of the Citizenship Act.”CONSIDERATION
Decision
Reasons for decision
Section 17 of the Act states: 17 Minister’s decision(1) If a person makes an application under section 16, the Minister must, by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen. (1A) The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 16(2) or (3). Australian Citizenship Instructions and Policy The respondent advised the Tribunal that the Department has developed policy in the form of the Citizenship Policy 1 June 2016 in support of the Act. The Citizenship Policy replaces the policy guidance content previously provided by the Australian Citizenship Instructions (ACIs). The “Introduction to Citizenship Policy” states the role of the new Citizenship Policy as: The role of Citizenship Policy is to support the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act). Citizenship Policy provides guidance on the interpretation of, and the exercise of powers under, the Act and the Australian Citizenship Regulations 2007 (the Regulations). Policy cannot constrain the exercise of delegated powers under the Act or the Regulations. A copy of Chapter 7 of the Citizenship Policy (regarding citizenship by descent) and Chapter 20 of the Citizenship Policy (regarding parents and parent-child relationships) was provided with the Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC). The respondent at para 17 of their SFIC states:Decision-makers should generally apply policy such as the Citizenship Policy unless the policy is unlawful or its application produces an unjust result in the circumstances of a particular case: Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634. The respondent submitted that there is “nothing in the applicant’s circumstances which indicates that the Citizenship Policy should not apply. This being the case, the Tribunal must have regard to the relevant parts at Chapter 20 (pages 214-215):Biological parent-child relationshipsA decision maker may be satisfied that the parent-child relationship is biological after considering, as a whole, evidence concerning matters such as: ·the nature of the relationship between the claimed parents·travel movements for the claimed parents around the date of conception·the applicant’s birth, registration of birth and the chain of custody post birth·physical similarities between the applicant and claimed parent. DNA testingIn cases where a person applies for Australian citizenship or evidence of citizenship on the grounds that they are the biological child of: · an Australian citizen (for descent) or· an Australian citizen or permanent resident (for birth onshore)and the decision maker is not satisfied that the person has such a biological relationship, the decision maker may suggest a DNA test.DNA testing facilities and procedures (how tests are conducted and details of recommended laboratories) is available in PAM3: Div1.2/reg1.12 - Member of the family unit - DNA testing.DNA evidence will be most useful in countries where there is a high incidence of document fraud or where official documentation is simply unavailable. It can also be useful where there is some doubt about the validity of the claimed relationships and/or credible documentation cannot be provided to substantiate claims. A DNA inclusiveness result of 99.5 or more may be taken as persuasive evidence of the biological relationship.If the opportunity to provide DNA evidence in support of an application has been offered and not accepted, the decision maker should consider the applicant’s reason/s for not accepting the offer and whether any adverse inference may be drawn.Decisions on applications should be made on the information available at the time. If the applicant declines to undertake a DNA test, or if the results of a DNA test do not support the applicant’s claims, the decision maker should assess the claimed parent-child relationship in the light of any other relevant factors. Non-biological parent-child relationshipsThe citizenship applicant may have a non-biological parent-child relationship with their claimed parent. In other cases, although a biological parent-child relationship was claimed, there may be insufficient evidence to support the claim of biological parentage.These cases may occur for a variety of reasons, such as: ·the applicant was born through a surrogacy arrangement that did not involve the contribution of genetic material by either commissioning parent·the applicant and their parent held a genuine but mistaken belief that they were biologically parent and child·the applicant acknowledges that there is no biological link to their claimed parent but contends that they nevertheless had a parent-child relationship at the relevant time (generally as of the date of the applicant’s birth). Factors to be taken into accountFor citizenship by birth (s12), the parent-child relationship between the Australian citizen or permanent resident and the applicant must have existed at the applicant’s time of birth. Similarly, for citizenship by descent (s16), the parent-child relationship between the Australian citizen and the applicant must have existed at the applicant’s time of birth. The applicant (or, if applicable, their responsible parent) should be asked to provide evidence of the length and nature of the Australian citizen’s or permanent resident’s parental relationship with the child.Note: Evidence of the length and nature of the relationship between the claimed parents may corroborate the evidence of the relationship between the applicant and the Australian citizen parent, but is not in itself evidence of the parent-child relationship.It is unlikely that any one piece of non-biological evidence would be sufficient to prove the required parent-child relationship. The decision maker more likely will be required to weigh up any relevant factors, including social and legal, to reach a finding of fact as to whether the claimed parent is (was) or is (was) not a parent of the applicant at the relevant time.Evidence that the claimed parent-child relationship existed at the time of the applicant’s birth may include, but is not limited to:·anything which would show the Australian citizen’s inclusion as a parent on the birth certificate was done with their prior consent·evidence that the Australian citizen was involved in providing care for the unborn child and/or the mother during the pregnancy, for example, emotional, domestic or financial support, making arrangements for the birth and prenatal and postnatal care ·evidence that the child was acknowledged socially from or before birth as the Australian citizen’s child, for example, the child was presented within the Australian citizen’s family and social groups as being the Australian citizen’s child and ·when a child is born through a surrogacy arrangement – a formal surrogacy agreement entered into before the child was conceived and lawful transfer of parentage before or at time of birth in the country in which the surrogacy was carried out. Evidence that the Australian citizen treated the child as their own from some point in time after birth would not by itself be evidence that they were the child’s parent at time of birth, but would lend weight to evidence of the types already mentioned.In the absence of satisfactory evidence of biological parentage, any other evidence provided should be closely scrutinised and verified to the maximum practical extent.