Dorajay Pty Ltd v Aristocrat Leisure Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dorajay Pty Limited v Aristocrat Leisure Limited

[2005] FCA 588

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – subpoenas for production – addressed to third parties – motion to set aside subpoenas – relevance to hearing on whether proceeding should continue as representative proceeding – whether ‘fishing’ – whether oppressive.

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 33N
Federal Court Rules, O 1 r 4, O 27 r 4

Apache Northwest Pty Ltd v Western Power Corporation (1998) 19 WAR 350 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1599 cited
Bailey v Beagle Management Pty Ltd (2001) 105 FCR 136 discussed
Chapman v Luminis Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1580 cited
Clairs Keeley v Treacy (No 2) (2003) 28 WAR 139 referred to
Codelfa Constructions Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337 referred to
Cosco Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Taxation [1997] FCA 1504 referred to
Fostif Pty Ltd v Campbells Cash & Carry Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 83 referred to
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674 referred to
Kingsheath Club of the Clubs Limited (In liq) [2003] FCA 1034 referred to
Marsden v Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd [1999] NSWSC 619 cited
Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co Inc v Fay (1988) 62 ALJR 389 referred to
Pasini v Vanstone [1999] FCA 1271 cited
R v Barton [1981] 2 NSWLR 414 referred to
The Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) SR (NSW) 564 referred to
Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Limited (1989) 88 ALR 90 applied
Spatialinfo Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2005] FCA 455 referred to
Spencer Motors Pty Ltd v LNC Industries Ltd [1982] 2 NSWLR 921 referred to
Waind v Hill and National Employers’ Mutual General Association Ltd (1978) 1 NSWLR 372 applied

DORAJAY PTY LIMITED v ARISTOCRAT LEISURE LIMITED
N 362 OF 2004

STONE J
13 MAY 2005
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 362 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

DORAJAY PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

ARISTOCRAT LEISURE LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

STONE J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 MAY  2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In these orders the following meanings apply:

“Document” has the meaning given to it in Order 1, Rule 4 of the Federal Court Rules;
“Funder” means IMF (Australia) Ltd and/or Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd;
“Group Members” means persons described in paragraph 2 of the further amended Statement of Claim in this proceeding.

  1. On the motion of IMF (Australia) Ltd and Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd, notice of which was filed on 5 April 2005, and on the motion of the applicant, notice of which was filed on 4 April 2005, the subpoena directed to IMF (Australia) Ltd and that directed to Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd be set aside in so far as:

(a)paragraph 1 of the subpoena refers to documents other than documents consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dorajay Pty Ltd v Aristocrat Leisure Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 588
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dorajay Pty Ltd and Aristocrat Leisure Ltd were involved in a legal dispute that reached the Federal Court of Australia. The core issue in the case was the validity and scope of subpoenas issued in relation to documents pertinent to the funding arrangements between the parties. IMF (Australia) Ltd and Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd sought to have specific subpoenas set aside, arguing that they required the production of documents not relevant to the funding negotiations and terms. The applicant, presumably Dorajay Pty Ltd, also moved to have a subpoena set aside in relation to documents held by Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd, the legal representatives for Dorajay Pty Ltd.

The legal issues before the court centred on the scope and applicability of the subpoenas issued in the case. The primary question was whether the subpoenas were overly broad and if they required the production of documents that were irrelevant to the specific terms and negotiations of funding in the litigation. The court had to determine whether the subpoenas exceeded the permissible scope under the Federal Court Rules and if the requested documents were necessary for the proceedings.

The court found that the subpoenas were indeed too broad as they required the production of documents not directly related to the funding arrangements and negotiations. The court determined that only documents that specifically recorded or evidenced communications concerning the funding terms were relevant and necessary for the proceedings. Consequently, the subpoenas were set aside to the extent that they required the production of documents that did not pertain to these specific communications. The court emphasised the importance of limiting the scope of subpoenas to only those documents that are directly relevant to the funding terms and negotiations, in line with the Federal Court Rules. The costs associated with the motions to set aside the subpoenas were reserved for future determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In these orders the following meanings apply:

“Document” has the meaning given to it in Order 1, Rule 4 of the Federal Court Rules;

“Funder” means IMF (Australia) Ltd and/or Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd;

“Group Members” means persons described in paragraph 2 of the further amended Statement of Claim in this proceeding.

2. On the motion of IMF (Australia) Ltd and Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd, notice of which was filed on 5 April 2005, and on the motion of the applicant, notice of which was filed on 4 April 2005, the subpoena directed to IMF (Australia) Ltd and that directed to Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd be set aside in so far as:

(a) paragraph 1 of the subpoena refers to documents other than documents consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms (irrespective of whether created before or after the commencement of the proceedings); and

(b) paragraph 3 of the subpoena refers to documents other than documents consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Group Members and/or prospective Group Members concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms (irrespective of whether created before or after the commencement of the proceedings).

3. On the motion of the applicant, notice of which was filed on 4 April 2005, the subpoena directed to Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd be set aside in so far as paragraph 1 of the subpoena refers to documents other than documents consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms (irrespective of whether created before or after the commencement of the proceedings).

4. The costs of the notices of motion be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dorajay Pty Ltd, a company in liquidation, initiated proceedings against Aristocrat Leisure Ltd, a manufacturer of gaming machines, over alleged breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The proceedings were funded by IMF (Australia) Ltd and Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd, referred to collectively as the "Funder." The Funder had provided funding to Dorajay Pty Ltd for the litigation. As part of the litigation, a subpoena was issued seeking various documents from IMF (Australia) Ltd, Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd, and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd, the law firm representing Dorajay Pty Ltd. The subpoena sought documents concerning the funding provided by the Funder, including communications about the terms of funding and the negotiation of those terms. The Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd applied to set aside certain parts of the subpoena, arguing that it exceeded the scope of permissible discovery in the context of the litigation.

The matter came before the court on motions filed by IMF (Australia) Ltd, Insolvency Litigation Fund Pty Ltd, and the applicant, Dorajay Pty Ltd, seeking orders to set aside parts of a subpoena issued in the proceedings. The subpoena, issued as part of the litigation between Dorajay Pty Ltd and Aristocrat Leisure Ltd, sought documents concerning the funding provided by the Funder. The motions were filed on 4 and 5 April 2005, and notices of these motions were filed on the same dates. The court was asked to consider whether certain parts of the subpoena, particularly those seeking documents related to the terms of funding and the negotiation of those terms, were within the scope of permissible discovery in the litigation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

STONE J
Issues
1. Whether the subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is within the scope of permissible discovery.
2. Whether the subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Group Members and/or prospective Group Members concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is within the scope of permissible discovery.
3. Whether the subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is within the scope of permissible discovery.

Held
1. The subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is set aside.
2. The subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Group Members and/or prospective Group Members concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is set aside.
3. The subpoena, to the extent it seeks documents other than those consisting of, recording, evidencing, or referring to communications between the Funder and Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd concerning the terms on which funding may be provided in relation to the proceedings and the negotiation of those terms, is set aside.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: STONE J

The court examined the scope of permissible discovery under the Federal Court Rules and the inherent jurisdiction of the court to regulate its own process. It considered the relevance and proportionality of the documents sought by the subpoenas. The court held that documents not directly related to the communications concerning the terms on which funding may be provided or the negotiation of those terms, were not within the scope of permissible discovery. The court emphasised the importance of proportionality and relevance in determining the scope of permissible discovery. The ratio decidendi of this case is that documents not directly related to the terms of funding or the negotiation of those terms are not within the permissible scope of discovery when considering communications between the parties involved in the funding process.