PB Foods Ltd v Malanda Dairy Foods Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PB Foods Ltd v Malanda Dairy Foods Ltd [1999] FCA 1602

TRADE MARKS – application to register CHOC CHILL subject to “claim to vary” where mark applied to goods of other flavours – application opposed – opponent was unregistered proprietor of mark CHILL by virtue of prior use in Queensland and Northern Territory – at time of application applicant had used CHOC CHILL only in Western Australia – whether CHOC CHILL substantially identical to CHILL – whether honest concurrent use or other special circumstances made it proper to permit registration – delegate found special circumstances but not honest concurrent use – delegate decided to register applicant’s trade mark subject to limitation of registration to Western Australia - whether appropriate to impose geographical restriction on applicant and, if so, extent of such restriction.

Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth), ss 34(1), 40

The Shell Co of Australia Limited v Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Limited (1962)
109 CLR 407 applied
Bodyline Cosmetics Ltd v Brot Bodyline (1993) 27 IPR 315 applied

Carnival Cruiselines Inc v Sitmar Cruises Ltd (1994) 120 ALR 495 applied
Moorgate Tobacco Co Ltd v Phillip Morris Ltd (1980) 145 CLR 457 referred to
Moorgate Tobacco Co Ltd v Phillip Morris Ltd [No 2] (1984) 156 CLR 414 referred to

Olin Corp v Pacemaker Pool Supplies (1984) 4 IPR 526 referred to
Alex Pirie & Sons Ltd’s Application (1932) 49 RPC 195 and (1933) 50 RPC 147 referred to
John Fitton & Co Ltd’s Application (1949) 66 RPC 110 followed
Registrar of Trade Marks v Muller (1980) 144 CLR 37 referred to
Burger King Corporation v Registrar of Trade Marks (1973) 128 CLR 417 referred to
Karu Pty Ltd v Jose (1994) 30 IPR 407 followed
Somers v Greenbelt Pacific Pty Ltd (1998) 42 IPR 587 referred to
Microcom Pty Ltd v Microcom Systems Inc (1998) 41 IPR 163 referred to
Re Peddie (1943) 61 RPC 31 referred to

PB FOODS LTD v MALANDA DAIRY FOODS LTD

W 7 of 1999

CARR J
17 NOVEMBER 1999
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W7 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

PB FOODS LTD
Applicant

AND:

MALANDA DAIRYFOODS LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 NOVEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is allowed to the extent that the decision of the delegate on 15 December 1998 is hereby varied so that the period of two months in which the applicant may indicate its agreement to the territorial limitation of registration, referred to in that decision, is extended to two months from the date of this judgment.

2.The application be otherwise dismissed.

3.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W7 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

PB FOODS LTD
Applicant

AND:

MALANDA DAIRYFOODS LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE:

17 NOVEMBER 1999

PLACE:

PERTH

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PB Foods Ltd v Malanda Dairy Foods Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1602
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of PB Foods Ltd v Malanda Dairy Foods Ltd involved an appeal by PB Foods Ltd (formerly Peters (WA) Limited) against a decision of a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, who had refused PB Foods' application for the registration of the trade mark CHOC CHILL unless it agreed to limit such registration to the State of Western Australia. PB Foods sought orders for the registration of the trade mark without territorial limitation, or alternatively with less restrictive territorial limitation. Malanda Dairy Foods Ltd opposed the application, asserting its prior use of the trade mark CHILL for flavoured milk products in Queensland and the Northern Territory. The key legal issues revolved around whether the trade mark CHOC CHILL was substantially identical to the trade mark CHILL, whether there was honest concurrent use, and if there were special circumstances warranting the registration of CHOC CHILL.

The Federal Court considered the substantial identity of the trade marks CHOC CHILL and CHILL, noting that the marks were largely identical except for the prefix "Choc" in the applicant's mark. The court found that the marks were indeed substantially identical, as the difference in the prefix did not significantly alter the overall impression of the marks. Regarding honest concurrent use, the court examined the six established criteria, including the honesty of use, extent of use, degree of confusion likely to ensue, instances of confusion, relative inconvenience, and any conditions or limitations. PB Foods argued that once the honesty of use was established, other factors were of lesser importance. However, the court held that while the use by both parties was honest, the extent of use and the geographical separation of the markets were critical. The court found that the period of concurrent use was too short to justify registration on that basis alone. Nevertheless, the court identified special circumstances, such as the short period between the commencement of use by both parties and the similar extent of independent use in geographically separate regions, which allowed for the exercise of discretion under the Trade Marks Act. The court concluded that the registration of CHOC CHILL could proceed, subject to a limitation to the State of Western Australia.

The court varied the delegate’s decision by extending the period within which PB Foods could agree to the territorial limitation of registration to two months from the date of the judgment. The application was otherwise dismissed, and PB Foods was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is allowed to the extent that the decision of the delegate on 15 December 1998 is hereby varied so that the period of two months in which the applicant may indicate its agreement to the territorial limitation of registration, referred to in that decision, is extended to two months from the date of this judgment.

2. The application be otherwise dismissed.

3. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal, pursuant to s 51 of the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) (“the 1955 Act”), from the decision of a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks under s 50 of the 1955 Act. On 15 December 1998 the delegate refused the applicant’s application for registration of the trade mark CHOC CHILL unless the applicant agreed, within two months of her decision, to limit such registration to the State of Western Australia. The applicant seeks orders that the trade mark be registered without any territorial limitation, or in the alternative with a less restrictive territorial limitation. Factual Background The applicant was incorporated in Western Australia. At the time when it applied for registration of the trade mark CHOC CHILL, its name was Peters (WA) Limited. The applicant trades under the names of “Peters” and “Brownes”. It manufactures and sells ice-cream and other dairy products. Its dairy products division manufactures white milks, flavoured milks, cream, juices, custards, yoghurts, desserts, dips and cheeses. On 1 April 1992, the applicant first used the trade mark CHOC CHILL to market some of its flavoured milk products. It also started to use variants of that trade mark which varied in accordance with the flavour of the milk. Those variants included COFFEE CHILL, BANANA CHILL and BERRY CHILL. Since that date, the applicant has continued to sell flavoured milk in Western Australia under marks which included CHILL. On 7 May 1992, the applicant applied to register CHOC CHILL as a trade mark throughout Australia for all goods in class 29. The respondent is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Australian Co-operative Foods Limited, which trades under the registered business name “Dairy Farmers”. It operates the Dairy Farmers’ business in North Queensland. On 23 February 1992 (i.e. some five weeks before the applicant first used the mark CHOC CHILL) the respondent first used the trade mark CHILL to market the flavoured milk which it produced. Since then it has continuously sold flavoured milk under that name in Queensland and the Northern Territory. On 19 May 1994 the respondent filed an application (No 630247) for registration of the trade mark CHILL FLAVOURED MILK. In view of the descriptive nature of the second and third words in that mark, I have regarded that application as being one whereby the respondent seeks registration of its proprietorship of the trade mark CHILL. At the hearing in this Court, the applicant conceded that the respondent was the proprietor of the trade mark CHILL. Before the delegate, it had denied such proprietorship. When, on 7 May 1992, the applicant applied to register the trade mark CHOC CHILL throughout Australia, neither the applicant nor the respondent was aware of the other party’s use. The applicant claims, and the claim is not disputed, that it did not become aware of the respondent’s use of the trade mark CHILL until December 1992. On 2 February 1996, the respondent lodged a notice of opposition to the registration of the trade mark CHOC CHILL.The Delegate’s Decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
On 2 February 1996, the respondent lodged a notice of opposition to the registration of the trade mark CHOC CHILL.The Delegate’s Decision The delegate decided that the opponent, Malanda Dairy Foods Limited (the respondent in these proceedings) had succeeded in its claim to prior use of the trade mark CHILL. The delegate held that the respondent had established its claim to proprietorship as at the date when the applicant lodged its application. The delegate further held that the trade mark CHILL was substantially identical to CHOC CHILL, the trade mark which the applicant had sought to register. The delegate then turned to the question of whether there had been either honest concurrent use or whether there existed other special circumstances which made it proper to permit registration of CHOC CHILL. As a matter of convenience, I shall refer to that mark as “the applicant’s mark” or “its mark”. The delegate found that there had been honest concurrent use, but of limited extent. She further found that, given the substantial identity of the two trade marks and the fact that they were used on identical goods, there was a strong probability of confusion if the trade marks were to be used in the same market areas. However, if the use continued to be confined to the geographically remote markets of Western Australia and North Queensland respectively, the likelihood of confusion would remain at a very low level. But as, so the delegate found, each party wished to extend the area of use of its trade mark, the delegate felt that she should consider what, if any, geographical limitation might be fair and reasonable to impose on the subject application. On the question of inconvenience, the delegate held that neither party had a clear claim to be more inconvenienced than the other if they were able to continue use of their marks. The delegate concluded that the period of concurrent use was too short to provide a sufficient basis on its own to allow the applicant’s mark to proceed to registration. However, she considered that there were other special circumstances which would permit registration. The special circumstances which the delegate identified were the very short period separating the commencement of use by the two parties and the similar extent of the independent use which they had made of their marks in distantly separated regions. The delegate considered that if she refused to allow the applicant’s trade mark to proceed, it was likely that the respondent’s application 630247 (against which the application had been cited) might proceed to acceptance. The applicant could then re-apply and, on the basis of its use in the State of Western Australia during the period since 1992, was likely to obtain an acceptance limited to that State under s 44(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (“the 1995 Act”). The delegate considered that those were special circumstances which allowed her to exercise her discretion under s 34(1), which she was prepared to do. The delegate’s decision was that, provided that the applicant agreed, within two months, to a limitation of the registration to the State of Western Australia, she would register the application under the provisions of s 34(1).Grounds of Appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J

In my opinion, applying the test referred to in the authorities cited above, the marks are substantially identical. I now turn to the applicant’s alternative grounds of appeal. 2.Was there honest concurrent use making it proper to permit registration of the applicant’s trade mark?Applicant’s Contentions The applicant contended that the delegate erred in holding that it was not entitled to registration of CHOC CHILL on the basis of honest concurrent use. The applicant accepted the well-established six criteria in relation to justifying honest concurrent use of a mark. However, the applicant submitted that the list was not necessarily exhaustive. The list, which is derived from the decision in John Fitton & Co Ltd’s Application (1949) 66 RPC 110 (but which decision in turn was largely derived from Lord Tomlin’s speech in Alex Pirie & Sons Ltd’s Application (1933) 50 RPC 147 at 159-160), comprises: · the honesty of the concurrent use;· the extent of the use in duration, area and volume;· the degree of confusion likely to ensue; · whether any instances of confusion have in fact occurred; · the relative inconvenience which would be caused to the respective parties; and· any conditions or limitations. The applicant pointed out that it was not disputed that its use was honest. It was common ground that it did not know of the respondent’s trade mark CHILL until after it started using CHOC CHILL. The applicant relied upon authorities which, so it submitted, were to the effect that once honesty of use was established, the other factors were of lesser importance: Buler Trade Mark [1975] 92 RPC 275 at 289; Granada Trade Mark [1979] 96 RPC 303. As to the extent of use, the applicant referred to the period of its use between the launch of CHOC CHILL on 1 April 1992 and its application to register that name on 7 May 1992. It submitted that although the period was of relatively short duration, the use of the trade mark during that period was substantial. Furthermore, its use, so it contended, should be directly compared with the use by the respondent which was also of relatively short duration i.e. between 23 February 1992 and 7 May 1992. The applicant submitted that in relation to the degree of confusion likely to ensue, it could be seen that the use of CHILL by the respondent was quite different to the use of CHOC CHILL by the applicant. Even if the products were on the shelf side by side there was, so it was contended, little likelihood of confusion. The applicant referred to Exhibits JCN12 and JCN13 for that comparison. In any event, so the applicant submitted, the products of the applicant and the respondent have not and are unlikely to appear on the same shelf because the respondent had not sold any products under the trade mark CHILL outside Queensland. Further there was no evidence that the respondent intended to sell products under the name CHILL outside Queensland, whereas the applicant’s evidence is that it intended to sell its CHOC CHILL products throughout Australia.