ZeroDensity Yazilim Anonim Sirketi v Apple Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by ZeroDensity Yazilim Anonim Sirketi to extension of protection under regulation 17A.33 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 of trade mark numbers 2044272, 2047868 and 2062975 (International Registration numbers 1493374, 1509007 and 1495633 respectively) (all in class 9) – REALITYKIT, REALITY COMPOSER and RealityKit, respectively - in the name of Apple Inc.

Delegate: Nicole Worth
Representation: Opponent: written submissions by Spruson & Ferguson Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Holder: Gabriella Rubagotti, counsel, instructed by Baker McKenzie
Decision: 2022 ATMO 152
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition to extension of protection under regulation 17A.29 – grounds of opposition under ss 44, 58, 60 and 42 – none established – extension of protection to Australia granted.

Background

  1. This is a decision in respect of oppositions under regulation 17A.33 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth)[1] to the extension of protection to Australia of three trade marks. Apple Inc (‘the Holder’) applied to extend protection to Australia of the following trade marks:

    [1] In this decision any references to the Regulations a reference to the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) and any reference to the Act is a reference to the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), unless otherwise stated.

Trade Mark No. 2044272 2047868 2062975
Trade Mark REALITYKIT REALITY COMPOSER RealityKit
Priority Date 7 March 2019 7 March 2019 3 June 2019
Filing Date 4 September 2019 6 September 2019 3 December 2019
International Registration No. 1493374 1495633 1509007
Goods Class 9: Downloadable and recorded software used in developing other software applications; downloadable and recorded application Class 9: Downloadable computer software used in developing other software applications; downloadable application development software; downloadable computer software providing a library of virtual objects for use in developing other software applications; downloadable computer software used in producing animation, audio, and three-dimensional effects for use in other software applications. Class 9: Computer software used in developing other software applications; application development software.

(collectively ‘the Holder’s Trade Marks’)

  1. The applications for extension of protection were accepted and advertised as such in the Official Journal of Trade Marks. ZeroDensity Yazilim Anonim Sirketi (‘the Opponent’) opposed the extension of protection to Australia of all three trade marks. It filed Notices of Intention to Oppose and corresponding Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGPs’) within the time allowed for filing those documents.

  2. Thereafter the parties filed evidence, discussed in more detail below. At the end of the evidence stages the Holder requested a joint hearing in respect of all three oppositions. The Opponent declined to appear at the hearing although it filed written submissions for the Registrar’s consideration.

  3. I heard the matters, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, by video conference on 7 June 2022. Ms Gabriella Rubagotti of counsel, instructed by Baker McKenzie, made verbal and written submissions on behalf of the Holder.

    Grounds, Onus and Relevant Dates

  4. The SGPs nominated grounds of opposition under ss 44, 60, 42…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZeroDensity Yazilim Anonim Sirketi v Apple Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ATMO 152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by ZeroDensity Yazilim Anonim Sirketi (the Opponent) to the extension of protection in Australia of three trade marks owned by Apple Inc. (the Holder). The Opponent sought to oppose the extension of protection on grounds including ss 44, 58, 60, and 42 of the relevant legislation. The decision was made by Nicole Worth, Hearing Officer and Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Opponent had established any of the grounds of opposition it nominated, specifically in relation to ss 44, 58, 60, and 42. The court was required to determine the relevant dates for assessing these grounds, which were identified as the priority dates of the applications for ss 44 and 60, and the filing dates for ss 58 and 42.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not established any of the grounds of opposition it had nominated. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer considered the evidence filed by both parties and applied the principles established in relevant case law regarding the determination of relevant dates for assessing trade mark opposition grounds.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer decided to extend protection in Australia of the Holder's trade marks for all goods specified in them. The Hearing Officer also awarded costs against the Opponent in accordance with the relevant regulations, with reduced costs awarded for two of the trade marks. The International Bureau was to be notified of this decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant dates at which the rights of the parties are determined for the purposes of ss 58 and 42 are the filing dates of the application[4] being 4 September 2019 (in respect of REALITYKIT), 6 September 2019 (REALITY COMPOSER) and 3 December 2019 (RealityKit). The relevant dates at which the rights of the parties are determined for the purposes of ss 44 and 60 are the priority dates of the applications being 7 March 2019 (in respect of REALITYKIT and REALITY COMPOSER) and 3 June 2019 (RealityKit). In any event none of the grounds of opposition in respect of any of the applications turns on the differences between the filing dates and the priority dates.[4] Southern Cross Refrigerating Co v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd [1954] HCA 82, [2] (Kitto J); see also the discussion of the relevant date for assessing s 41(6) in Apple Inc. v Registrar of Trade Marks [2014] FCA 1304, [32]-[59] (Yates J), the rationale of which I have followed, particularly at [45], in respect of provisions which do not specify a ‘priority date’.Evidence The declarations filed in respect of REALITYKIT (trade mark no. 2044272) are as follows:Evidence in supportMustafa Ulaş Kaçmaz, Founder and Vice President - Sales and Marketing of the Opponent, with exhibits A to K, dated 28 January 2021.Vivian Tran, solicitor with Spruson & Ferguson, with exhibits A to E, dated 29 October 2020.Evidence in answerThomas R. La Perle, Senior Director of the Legal Department of the Holder, with exhibits TRL-1 to TRL-14, dated 5 May 2021.Anthony Pasquale Guerrieri, paralegal with Baker McKenzie, with exhibits APG-1 to APG-27, dated 5 May 2021.Judith King, trade mark attorney with Baker McKenzie, with exhibits JK-1 to JK-5, dated 5 May 2021.Evidence in replyMethmet Ӧzkan, Founder and CFO of the Opponent, with confidential exhibits A and B, dated 2 June 2021. The declarations filed in respect of REALITY COMPOSER (trade mark no. 2047868) are as follows:Evidence in supportMustafa Ulaş Kaçmaz with exhibits A to K, dated 24 February 2021.Vivian Tran with exhibits A to E, dated 30 November 2020.Evidence in answerThomas R. La Perle with exhibits TRL-1 to TRL-16, dated 16 June 2021.Anthony Pasquale Guerrieri with exhibits APG-1 to APG-27, dated 15 June 2021.Judith King with exhibits JK-1 to JK-5, dated 15 June 2021.Evidence in replyMethmet Ӧzkan with confidential exhibits A and B, dated 8 August 2021. The declarations filed in respect of RealityKit (trade mark no. 2062975) are as follows:Evidence in supportVivian Tran with exhibits A to K, dated 24 December 2020.Evidence in answerThomas R. La Perle with exhibits TRL-1 to TRL-14, dated 31 March 2021.Anthony Pasquale Guerrieri with exhibits APG-1 to APG-27, dated 31 March 2021.Judith King with exhibits JK-1 to JK-5, dated 1 April 2021.Evidence in replyMethmet Ӧzkan with confidential exhibits A and B, dated 2 June 2021.Vivian Tran with exhibit A, dated 4 June 2021. The declarations filed in each opposition are substantially the same. I have not distinguished between the declarations filed in each opposition unless otherwise stated. A summary of the parties’ evidence is as follows. The Opponent’s Evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

Regulation 17A.34N of the Regulations provides the following:17A.34N Decision on opposition(1) Unless the opposition proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must decide:(a) to refuse protection in respect of all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA; or(b) to extend protection in respect of some or all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA (with or without conditions or limitations),having regard to the extent (if any) to which the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed have been established.(2) The Registrar must notify the International Bureau of the Registrar’s decision. The Opponent has not established any of the grounds of opposition it nominated in its SGPs. Given this, I extend protection to Australia of the Holder’s Trade Marks for all of the goods specified in them one month from the date of this decision. However if the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal to this decision before protection is extended, protection of the Holder’s Trade Mark(s) subject to the appeal shall not occur until that appeal has been withdrawn or discontinued. Otherwise protection of the Holder’s Trade Marks would be subject to any orders of the court. The International Bureau will be notified of this decision. Both parties asked for an award of costs. The general rule is that costs follow the event, and I see no reason to depart from that here. Accordingly, in respect of trade mark no. 2044272 I award costs against the Opponent under s 221 of the Act in accordance with the amounts specified in Schedule 8 of the Regulations. For trade mark no. 2047868 I award reduced costs against the Opponent under s 221 of the Act in the same manner as Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhard v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd.[31] Likewise for trade mark no. 2062975 I award reduced costs against the Opponent under s 221 of the Act in the same manner as Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhard v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd.[31] [2001] ATMO 78.Nicole WorthHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks2 September 2022

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.