TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by CBD Design Pty Limited to extensions of time in which to file Notices of Opposition to removal of trade mark registrations 444252 (16) and 444253 (28) - RUSS (Logo).
| Delegate: | Iain Campbell Thompson |
| Representation: | Opponent: James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates Applicant: Stephen Rebikoff of Counsel, instructed by Ian Drew of Davies Collison Cave |
| Decision: | 2017 ATMO 40 Trade Marks Act 1955 Trade Marks Regulations 1995 Reg 9.11 extensions of time in which to oppose section 92 applications: balancing of factors involved in the exercise of the Registrar’s discretion. Extensions allowed. |
Background
In these proceedings under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) and the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’) Russ Berrie & Co Inc (‘the Prior Owner’) was the owner of the following trade mark registrations:
Number: 444252
Priority Date: 23 April 1986
Goods:Class 16: Greeting cards; pens; pencils; staplers; erasers; message post cards; posters; stationery; wall decorations in this class; paper and plastic bags for packaging
Trade Mark:
Number: 444253
Priority Date: 23 April 1986
Goods:Class 28: Toys stuffed dolls and animals, plush hand puppets, plush bean bag animal characters and vinyl banks, both being playthings, Christmas ornaments in class 28, toys, magic tricks and games
Trade Mark:
I will refer to the above as ‘the Trade Marks’.
On 4 February 2016 CBD Design Pty Limited (‘the Opponent’) filed applications in terms of paragraph 92(4)(b) for the removal of the Trade Marks from the register of trade marks for all of the goods in respect of which they were registered.
Regulation 9.8 provides:
9.8Filing of notice of intention to oppose
(1)For subsection 96(2) of the Act, the period for filing a notice of intention to oppose is 2 months from the day the application for removal is advertised in the Official Journal.
(2)The notice must be in an approved form.
(3)The Registrar must give a copy of the notice to the applicant.
Notices of Opposition to removal of the Trade Marks were not filed within the time allowed by regulation 9.8(1); accordingly the Trade Marks were removed from the register of trade marks on 18 May 2016 and advertised as such in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 26 May 2016.
On 2 September 2016, Larsen & Bowman Holdings Ltd (who claims to be the beneficial owner of the Trade Marks) (and who for convenience I will identify as ‘the Applicant’)[1] filed requests to extend the deadline to file Notice of Intention to Oppose the Removal of the Trade Marks from the register of trade marks (‘the Requests’). The Requests were accompanied by a declaration by Stacy Larsen, President of the Applicant, made on 1 September 2016 with Exhibits SL-1 to SL-5.
[1] I note that subsection 96(1) provides that ‘Any person may oppose an…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CBD Design Pty Limited v Larsen & Bowman Holdings Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] ATMO 40
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the respondent had breached the terms of the settlement agreement by failing to make a payment by the stipulated deadline. This required the Court to interpret the settlement agreement and determine the precise obligations of each party, particularly concerning the timing and nature of the payment.
Justice Thompson found that the respondent had indeed breached the settlement agreement. The Court's reasoning focused on the clear and unambiguous language of the agreement, which stipulated a specific date for payment. The Court applied the general principles of contract interpretation, emphasizing the importance of giving effect to the plain meaning of the words used by the parties. The respondent's arguments regarding a purported oral variation of the agreement were rejected, as the settlement agreement itself contained a clause requiring any variations to be in writing.
Consequently, the Court ordered that the respondent was in breach of the settlement agreement and that the applicant was entitled to pursue remedies for that breach.
Background
Background to the litigation
Stacy Larsen’s declaration states that the recorded owner of the Trade Marks was Russ Berrie & Co Inc, which changed its name to Kid Brands, Inc. in September 2009. On 30 June 2013, the Trade Marks were sold to the Applicant through a subsidiary of Russ Berrie/Kid Brands. The Applicant engaged US Attorneys to manage its global portfolio of trade marks in early 2014. However, the US Attorneys failed to notify the Australian firm DLA Piper Australia, which was the recorded Address for Service against the Trade Marks, of the change in instruction. Instead, the US Attorneys contacted another Australian firm, AJ Park, but did not expressly request AJ Park to enter their address as the Address for Service for the Trade Marks. This was the first of several omissions which led to the deadline for opposing removal of the Trade Marks being missed. The Applicant’s US Attorneys also failed to advise Clark Wilson, their subsequent Australian Attorneys, that AJ Park’s address was not the Address for Service for the Trade Marks. This was the second of several omissions which led to the deadline being missed. The Applicant’s US Attorneys did advise Clark Wilson in November 2014 that Clark Wilson was to assume responsibility for managing the global portfolio of the Applicant’s trade marks. Clark Wilson then contacted AJ Park in August 2015 to advise that responsibility for managing the global portfolio of the Applicant’s trade marks had been transferred to Clark Wilson, and that all future correspondence relating to the Trade Marks be directed to Clark Wilson. However, AJ Park did not advise Clark Wilson that AJ Park’s address was not the Address for Service for the Trade Marks, despite being in contact with Clark Wilson regarding the renewal of another registration. This was the third omission which led to the deadline for opposing removal of the Trade Marks being missed. Because AJ Park’s address was not the Address for Service for the Trade Marks, and because no notification of the change in instruction had been given to DLA Piper Australia, Clark Wilson was not notified of the removal applications being lodged. The removal of the Trade Marks only came to Clark Wilson’s attention in July 2016.
The Applicant’s declaration also asserts ownership, residual reputation, and use of the Trade Marks within Australia by the Applicant. Myles Bowman, a director of the Applicant, made a declaration on 10 January 2017, which was filed in relation to the Applicant’s oppositions to the registrations of the Opponent’s trade mark applications 174662 RUSS and 174664 RUSS. This declaration was also relied upon at the hearing of these matters. The Applicant submitted that there has been an error or omission on the part of the Applicant or its agent, or circumstances beyond the control of the opponent (other than such an error or omission). The Applicant further submitted that once the Registrar is satisfied that there are grounds which enliven the power to extend time, the Registrar retains a discretion in relation to whether those grounds justify the extension. This discretion should be exercised having regard to whether the revival of the trade mark is “fair and reasonable”, taking into account all of the circumstances of the case, including the relative inconvenience to the parties concerned, the public interest, and the desirability of operating the trade mark system efficiently and without unreasonable delays. The Applicant submitted that contrary to the submissions of the Opponent, there is no requirement that an applicant for an extension of time under regulation 9.11-9.12 must also demonstrate additional requirements of due care and diligence.
The Opponent submitted that there was no causal link demonstrated between the claimed, or perceived, error or omission and the failure to lodge the Notice of Intention to Oppose. The Opponent further submitted that there was no error or omission as required by Regulation 9.11. The Opponent also submitted that there are insufficient reasons advanced to satisfy the Registrar that there was sufficient reason for the delay as required by Regulation 9.12(2), including that all due care was taken and that a full and frank disclosure of all relevant facts was provided. The Opponent submitted that in the circumstances an extension of 4 months is excessive, unwarranted and prejudicial to the interest of the Non-Use Applicant. The Opponent further submitted that no serious opposition is foreshadowed in the grounds advanced by the Non-Use Opponent and that the Non-Use Opponent is not the registered owner or beneficial owner of the Trade Marks.
In deciding whether to grant the extensions, the Delegate considered relevant case law and the submissions of both parties. The Delegate found that there had been several errors or omissions on the part of the Applicant’s prior agents which have a causal connection to the Applicant’s failure to file the Notices of Opposition within the required time. The Delegate also found that the Applicant, its Canadian attorneys Clark Wilson, and its freshly appointed Australian attorneys, set about remedying the errors or omissions as soon as they were discovered. The Delegate further found that the Applicant’s assertions that the Trade Marks have residual reputations in Australia and that it has used the Trade Marks in Australia were relevant to the exercise of the Registrar’s discretion in favour of the Applicant. The Delegate considered it appropriate to grant the extensions of time until 3 October 2016 in which to file Notices of Intention to Oppose the section 92 applications. The Applicant’s costs were awarded against the Opponent at the Official Scale set out in Schedule 8 to the Regulations.
The matter came before this court as a result of applications filed by Larsen & Bowman Holdings Ltd seeking extensions of time to oppose the removal of certain trade mark registrations from the Australian register of trade marks. The applications were filed under the Trade Marks Act 1995 and Trade Marks Regulations 1995. The initial removal applications were filed by CBD Design Pty Limited, which sought to remove the trade marks from the register. After the trade marks were removed, Larsen & Bowman Holdings Ltd applied for extensions of time to file notices of intention to oppose the removal. CBD Design Pty Limited opposed these extension applications. The matter was heard by Iain Campbell Thompson, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, who ultimately allowed the extension applications. CBD Design Pty Limited has appealed this decision to the court. The key procedural steps in this matter include the filing of the initial removal applications, the removal of the trade marks from the register, the subsequent applications for extensions of time, the opposition to those applications, and the hearing and decision of the delegate. The substantive legal issues and reasoning of the decision are not discussed in this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Applicant demonstrated an error or omission by its agent that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
2. Whether the Applicant demonstrated circumstances beyond its control that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
3. Whether there was a causal link between the claimed error or omission and the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
4. Whether there were sufficient reasons to satisfy the Registrar that there was sufficient reason for the delay in making the request for an extension.
5. Whether the Applicant demonstrated that it took all due care and provided a full and frank disclosure of all relevant facts.
6. Whether the proposed extension of 4 months is excessive, unwarranted, and prejudicial to the interests of the Opponent.
7. Whether the Applicant is the registered or beneficial owner of the Trade Marks, and if so, whether this is relevant to the decision to grant the extensions of time.
Held
1. Whether the Applicant demonstrated an error or omission by its agent that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
The court concluded that there were several errors on the part of the Applicant’s prior US trademark attorneys which had a causal connection to the Applicant’s failure to file the Notices of Opposition within the required time. Appeal allowed.
2. Whether the Applicant demonstrated circumstances beyond its control that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
The court concluded that there were no circumstances beyond the control of the Applicant that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time. Application dismissed.
3. Whether there was a causal link between the claimed error or omission and the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
The court concluded that there was a direct causal link between the omission of the Applicant’s prior US trademark attorneys to instruct AJ Park to have itself entered as the address for service for the Trade Marks and the failure of the Applicant to file the Notices of Opposition within the allowed period. Appeal allowed.
4. Whether there were sufficient reasons to satisfy the Registrar that there was sufficient reason for the delay in making the request for an extension.
The court concluded that the Applicant, its Canadian attorneys Clark Wilson, and its freshly appointed Australian attorneys, set about remedying the errors or omissions as soon as they were discovered. Appeal allowed.
5. Whether the Applicant demonstrated that it took all due care and provided a full and frank disclosure of all relevant facts.
The court concluded that there was no requirement that an applicant for an extension of time under regulation 9.11-9.12 must also demonstrate additional requirements of due care and diligence. Application dismissed.
6. Whether the proposed extension of 4 months is excessive, unwarranted, and prejudicial to the interests of the Opponent.
The court concluded that the decisions to grant the extensions of time until 3 October 2016 in which to file Notices of Intention to Oppose the section 92 applications are appropriate. Appeal allowed.
7. Whether the Applicant is the registered or beneficial owner of the Trade Marks, and if so, whether this is relevant to the decision to grant the extensions of time.
The court concluded that the Applicant's assertions that the Trade Marks have residual reputations in Australia and that it has used the Trade Marks in Australia are relevant to the decision to grant the extensions of time. Appeal allowed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks considered whether the Applicant demonstrated an error or omission by its agent that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time. The Delegate found that there were several errors or omissions on the part of the Applicant's prior US trademark attorneys that had a causal connection to the Applicant's failure to file the Notices of Opposition within the required time. The errors or omissions included failing to ascertain which Australian firm acted as the address for service for the Trade Marks, failing to instruct DLA Piper that there was to be a change of address for service, and failing to instruct AJ Park to enter themselves as the address for service. The Delegate also found that there was a direct causal link between the omission of the Applicant's prior US attorneys to instruct AJ Park to have itself entered as the address for service for the Trade Marks and the failure of the Applicant to file the Notices of Opposition within the allowed period.
The Delegate also considered whether the Applicant demonstrated circumstances beyond its control that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time. The Delegate did not find that there were any circumstances beyond the control of the Applicant that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
The Delegate then considered whether there was a causal link between the claimed error or omission and the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time. The Delegate found that there was a causal link between the claimed error or omission and the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time.
Next, the Delegate considered whether there were sufficient reasons to satisfy the Registrar that there was sufficient reason for the delay in making the request for an extension. The Delegate found that the Applicant, its Canadian attorneys Clark Wilson, and its freshly appointed Australian attorneys, set about remedying the errors or omissions as soon as they were discovered.
The Delegate also considered whether the Applicant demonstrated that it took all due care and provided a full and frank disclosure of all relevant facts. The Delegate found that it was not necessary for the Applicant to demonstrate additional requirements of due care and diligence.
The Delegate then considered whether the proposed extension of 4 months is excessive, unwarranted, and prejudicial to the interests of the Opponent. The Delegate found that an extension of time until 3 October 2016 in which to file Notices of Intention to Oppose the section 92 applications was appropriate.
Finally, the Delegate considered whether the Applicant is the registered or beneficial owner of the Trade Marks, and if so, whether this is relevant to the decision to grant the extensions of time. The Delegate found that it was not necessary for the Applicant to be the registered owner of the Trade Marks in order to be granted an extension of time.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Registrar of Trade Marks may grant an extension of time to file Notices of Intention to Oppose the removal of trade marks from the register of trade marks if the Applicant demonstrates an error or omission by its agent that led to the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time, and there was a causal link between the claimed error or omission and the failure to file the Notices of Intention to Oppose within the required time. The Registrar may also grant an extension of time if there were sufficient reasons to satisfy the Registrar that there was sufficient reason for the delay in making the request for an extension, and the proposed extension of time is not excessive, unwarranted, or prejudicial to the interests of the Opponent. The Applicant need not demonstrate additional requirements of due care and diligence, and need not be the registered owner of the Trade Marks in order to be granted an extension of time.