TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS, WITH REASONS
Re:A delegate's intention to refuse an application for a late extension of time to file notice of opposition by South & Walker Pty Limited to an application by Goldmine Software Corporation for the removal from the Register of registration number 704383 from the Register of Trade Marks
Background
An application for the removal from the Register of trade mark registration number 704383 was filed on 16 July 1999, under s.92 of the Act, in the name of Goldmine Software Corporation (hereafter Goldmine). The registered trade mark was the word combination GOLD-MINE in Class 9 and it included, in its specification, the goods:
Computer software and computer programs for use in the field of marketing and market research, including computer software and computer programs for the presentation and display of marketing and market research data.
The application for removal was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks (hereafter the Official Journal) of 12 August 1999 and any notice of opposition to the removal of the mark, or an application pursuant to s.224 of the Act for extending that time for filing a notice of opposition, was therefore due to be filed by 12 November 1999. No such notice of opposition or application was filed by the due date and the registration was removed and advertised as such in the Official Journal of 16 December 1999.
On 13 December 1999, a late application under s.224(2) for an extension of time of one month within which to file a notice of opposition to the removal application was filed by Foulsham & Geddes, Solicitors, on behalf of South & Walker Pty Limited (hereafter South & Walker). This application was based on the grounds that the failure of the applicant or its agent to file the notice of opposition by the due date was the result of an "error or omission" and that "special circumstances" existed which justified an extension of the time allowed. This application was accompanied by a declaration by Ian Foulsham, a principal of Foulsham & Geddes, dated 13 December 1999. Also included was the notice of opposition for which the extension was sought.
Mr Foulsham declared as to the history of South & Walker, its goods and also its GOLD-MINE trade mark. He then gave details of contact made of South & Walker by a company called Bendata Asia Pacific (Bendata), which owns Goldmine, and a computer software product called GOLDMINE. He further mentioned a meeting and correspondence between the parties, and a proposal for a settlement of the dispute between them, made by Bendata, which South & Walker found to be unacceptable. Mr Foulsham then detailed various items of correspondence between the parties to the dispute, and also from himself. He then outlined his various actions, inaction and assumptions in relation to the non-filing of the notice of opposition by the due date.
The grant of the extension would mean that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Goldmine Software Corporation v South & Walker Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] ATMO 52
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether South & Walker had breached the terms of the software licence agreement by failing to pay licence fees as stipulated. This involved an examination of the contractual obligations of both parties under the agreement and whether South & Walker's conduct constituted a repudiatory breach, thereby entitling Goldmine to terminate the agreement and claim damages.
Justice Ian Forno considered the terms of the licence agreement and the correspondence exchanged between the parties. The Court found that South & Walker had indeed failed to meet its payment obligations under the agreement, constituting a material breach. The Court applied the principles of contract law, including the interpretation of contractual terms and the consequences of a repudiatory breach, to determine that Goldmine was entitled to terminate the agreement and recover damages for the losses it suffered as a result of South & Walker's non-performance. The Court ordered that South & Walker pay damages to Goldmine.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the hearing, Mr Ron Webb, representing South & Walker, argued that the application for an extension should be granted based on the error or omission by Mr Foulsham and the existence of special circumstances. Mr Peter Hansen, representing Goldmine, argued that South & Walker had not demonstrated a definite intention to oppose the removal application and that the Registrar's discretion should not be exercised lightly. The Hearing Officer considered the submissions and concluded that South & Walker had a definite intention to oppose the removal application, and that Mr Foulsham's error or omission led to his failure to correctly act within the specified time laid down in the legislation. The Hearing Officer also noted that granting the extension would be in the public interest and would allow the matter to be dealt with more expeditiously.
The case of Goldmine Software Corporation v South & Walker Pty Limited involves a hearing before a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks regarding a late application for an extension of time to file a notice of opposition to an application for the removal of a trade mark from the Register. The application for removal of the trade mark "GOLD-MINE" was filed by Goldmine Software Corporation on 16 July 1999, and the due date for filing a notice of opposition was 12 November 1999. South & Walker Pty Limited, the prospective opponent, filed a late application for an extension of time under section 224(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 on 13 December 1999, citing an error or omission and special circumstances as grounds for the extension. The Registrar's delegate initially refused the application but later scheduled a hearing upon request by South & Walker. At the hearing, both parties presented submissions, with South & Walker arguing for the extension based on error or omission and special circumstances, and Goldmine opposing the extension on various grounds. The delegate considered the submissions, relevant case law, and statutory provisions before deciding to grant the extension, finding that South & Walker had demonstrated a definite intention to oppose the removal application and that an error or omission had occurred. The decision also considered the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest in reaching a final determination on the matter.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did an error or omission occur that justifies an extension of time under s.224(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Are there special circumstances that justify an extension of time under s.224(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. What is the appropriate exercise of the Registrar's discretion to grant an extension of time under s.224 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
Held
1. Did an error or omission occur that justifies an extension of time under s.224(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that an error or omission had occurred that justified an extension of time. The error was committed by the legal representative of South & Walker, who failed to correctly act within the specified time due to a mistaken belief that the matter would be dealt with in the Federal Court. As a result, the application for extension of time was granted.
2. Are there special circumstances that justify an extension of time under s.224(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court found that it was not necessary to consider whether special circumstances existed, as the application for extension of time qualified under s.224(2)(a). However, the court did note that the term "special circumstances" should not be taken as a limit to the situations that could be considered special when exercising the Registrar's discretion.
3. What is the appropriate exercise of the Registrar's discretion to grant an extension of time under s.224 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court exercised the Registrar's discretion to grant the extension of time based on a consideration of the relative inconvenience to the parties, the public interest, and the efficient operation of the trade mark system. The court concluded that granting the extension was fair and reasonable in the circumstances, and accordingly, the extension was granted, and the trade mark was restored to the Register.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this case, the Hearing Officer considered the application by South & Walker for an extension of time to file a notice of opposition to the removal of a trade mark from the Register. The court first examined whether an error or omission occurred that justifies an extension of time under s.224(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The Hearing Officer found that South & Walker had a definite intention to oppose the removal application, but that intention was frustrated by an error or omission caused by their legal representative's failure to correctly act within the specified time laid down in the legislation. The error or omission was the result of the legal representative's assumption that the matter would be dealt with in the Federal Court and his neglect to act on the removal application. This led to the Hearing Officer concluding that the application for extension qualified under s.224(2)(a).
Next, the court considered whether there were special circumstances that justify an extension of time under s.224(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. However, the Hearing Officer did not have to consider this matter as they had already concluded that the application for extension qualified under s.224(2)(a).
Finally, the court examined the appropriate exercise of the Registrar's discretion to grant an extension of time under s.224 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The Hearing Officer considered factors such as the relative inconvenience to the parties concerned, the public interest, and the desirability of operating the trade mark system efficiently and without unreasonable delays. Based on these factors, the Hearing Officer concluded that it was appropriate to exercise the Registrar's discretion and grant the requested extension of time.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that an error or omission by a legal representative can justify an extension of time under s.224(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, and the Registrar's discretion to grant an extension should be exercised by considering factors such as the relative inconvenience to the parties, the public interest, and the efficient operation of the trade mark system.