Mad Keen Pty Ltd (April Cornwell) v Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by JENKAR DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD to an application under section 66 of the Act by APRIL CORNWELL and MAD KEEN PTY LTD to amend the notice of opposition to trade mark applications 1298177; 1298700 (39; 39 and 43) - MAD KEEN; MAD KEEN FISHING CHARTERS - in the name of JENKAR DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD

Delegate: Heath Wilson
Representation: Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd – Greg Finlayson of Grope Hamilton Lawyers.
April Cornwell – Dr Kevin Pullen, Patent and Trade Mark Attorney.
Mad Keen Pty Ltd – Written submissions provided.  
Decision: 2011 ATMO 91
Section 66 amendment: Application to amend notice of opposition – whether fair and reasonable in all the circumstances to allow amendment – Amendment allowed – limited costs awarded against Jenkar.

Background

  1. On 8 and 13 May 2009, Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd (‘Jenkar’) applied to register two trade mark applications (‘the Trade Marks’), the details being:

TM No. Trade Mark Class / Statement of Services
1298177 Mad Keen Fishing Charters Class 39: Boating, fishing, hunting and sightseeing excursions
1298700 Mad Keen Class 39: Boating, fishing, hunting and sightseeing excursions

Class 43: Hospitality services (accommodation); provision of temporary accommodation; provision of tourist accommodation
  1. The Trade Marks were advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 1 October 2009. An application for an extension of time to file a notice of opposition was lodged on 4 January 2010 by Mad Keen Pty Ltd, represented (at that time) by Dr Kevin Pullen, Patent and Trade Mark Attorney.  

  2. A notice of opposition to the registration of the Trade Marks was later filed nominating A. Cornwell as the opponent (with ACN 104 676 995) on 29 March 2010. However, the opponent in the proceedings was incorrectly recorded by IP Australia as Mad Keen Pty Ltd (the company that had filed the extension of time) rather than Ms Cornwell. The likely explanation for the oversight is that Mad Keen Pty Ltd remained recorded as the opponent following the extension of time to file a notice of opposition.  

  3. This anomaly was not identified until some time later. Subsequent correspondence from IP Australia, from Mad Keen Pty Ltd and from Jenkar all referred to the opponent as Mad Keen Pty Ltd. It was not until 6 January 2011 that Mr Finlayson of Grope Hamilton Lawyers acting on behalf of Jenkar brought to the Registrar’s attention that it was April Cornwell and not Mad Keen Pty Ltd listed as the opponent on the notice of opposition. I note that Mr Finlayson’s supporting statutory declaration of 25 January 2011 further confuses the issue by incorrectly referring to “a notice of opposition by A Crawford ACN 104676995 29 May 2010”. The name of the opponent and the date of the notice of opposition are both incorrect. The actual error in the notice of opposition was subsequently identified and steps were taken to rectify the situation.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mad Keen Pty Ltd (April Cornwell) v Jenkar Developments Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] ATMO 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a request by Mad Keen Pty Ltd to amend the name of the opponent in a notice of opposition filed on 29 March 2010. The original opponent was listed as A. Cornwell, and Mad Keen Pty Ltd sought to substitute its own name for that of A. Cornwell. Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd contested this amendment. The decision was made by Hearing Officer Heath Wilson of the Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether it was fair and reasonable in all the circumstances to permit the amendment of the opponent's name in the notice of opposition. This involved considering Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd's opposition to the proposed change and the implications for the parties involved.

The Hearing Officer found that the requested amendment was fair and reasonable. He noted that Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd had exercised its right to contest the issue and had therefore accepted the inherent risks. The Hearing Officer directed that the name of the opponent on the notice of opposition be amended from A. Cornwell to Mad Keen Pty Ltd within one month of the decision, with the corresponding Australian Company Number to be updated. In relation to costs, the Hearing Officer awarded costs against Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd in favour of Ms Cornwell, limiting the allowable costs to the Hearing Fee, attendance costs for Dr Pullen's appearance, and the preparation of the case for the hearing. The Hearing Officer also made directions regarding the amendment in the event of an appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Mad Keen Pty Ltd (April Cornwell) v Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd revolves around a dispute concerning the amendment of the name of an opponent in trade mark opposition proceedings. Initially, trade marks 1298177 and 1298700 were opposed by April Cornwell, who filed a notice of opposition on 29 March 2010. Subsequently, the respondent, Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd, contested the opposition and requested an amendment to the name of the opponent from A. Cornwell to Mad Keen Pty Ltd. This request led to the formal hearing, where the primary issue was whether the name of the opponent should be amended to reflect the actual party that had filed the opposition.

April Cornwell, represented by Mad Keen Pty Ltd, argued that the amendment should proceed to ensure the proceedings were conducted fairly and accurately. Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd contested the amendment, arguing against the procedural fairness and appropriateness of such a change. The hearing officer, Heath Wilson, noted the unusual nature of the request for a simple change of name and highlighted that Jenkar had chosen to contest the issue, thereby assuming the inherent risks. The officer's decision emphasised the need for the amendment to occur if no appeal was lodged, reflecting the potential implications for the parties involved.

The factual timeline began with the filing of the opposition by April Cornwell on 29 March 2010 and continued through the formal hearing where Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd contested the amendment. The case also involved considerations of costs, with both parties seeking an award if successful. Ultimately, the hearing officer directed that if the decision was not appealed, the amendment should occur one month from the date of the decision. However, if an appeal was lodged, the amendment would be subject to the outcome of the appeal proceedings. The officer awarded costs to April Cornwell, considering only specific allowable expenses related to the hearing and case preparation.

The matter of Mad Keen Pty Ltd (April Cornwell) v Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd came before the Trade Marks Hearings as an interlocutory application seeking the amendment of the name of an opponent in trade mark opposition proceedings. The application followed the opposition by Jenkar Developments Pty Ltd to the registration of trade marks 1298177 and 1298700 by Mad Keen Pty Ltd. Jenkar had initially opposed the application under the name of A. Cornwell, which Mad Keen sought to amend to Mad Keen Pty Ltd. The application was filed and heard as a formal proceeding despite the seemingly straightforward nature of the requested change. The hearing took place on 14 September 2011, with both parties presenting their arguments and evidence. The Hearing Officer, Heath Wilson, ultimately found it fair and reasonable to allow the amendment under specific conditions, should no appeal be made. If the decision were to be appealed, the amendment would be stayed pending resolution of the appeal. Costs were also considered, with the Hearing Officer awarding costs to Mad Keen Pty Ltd under the Trade Marks Regulations 1995, limited to specific allowable expenses.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Considering the above facts and circumstances, I find it fair and reasonable in all the circumstances for this requested amendment to occur. I also find it surprising that a matter of a simple change of name for an opponent has proceeded to a formal hearing. It is Jenkar that has exercised its right to contest this issue and has therefore adopted the inherent risks that follow. Decision If there is no appeal from this decision, I direct that the name of the opponent on the notice of opposition filed 29 March 2010 to trade marks 1298177 and 1298700 be amended from A. Cornwell to Mad Keen Pty Ltd one month from the date of this decision. It follows that the relevant ACN should be altered to reflect this amendment. If this decision is appealed, I direct that the amendment shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued, or in the event of a decision from the court, that the applications be subject to that order.Costs Both Jenkar and Ms Cornwell have requested an award of costs in the event of success in relation to the amendment request. An effect of my decision is that Ms Cornwell would no longer be a party to proceedings and would not be entitled to costs if Mad Keen Pty Ltd is successful in the substantive opposition matter. Ms Cornwell has been successful in the current matter and I award costs against Jenkar under Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995. I find that the only allowable costs for Ms Cornwell are the Hearing Fee, attendance costs at scale for Dr Pullen’s appearance and the preparation of the case for the hearing. Heath WilsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings14 September 2011

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found it fair and reasonable to amend the name of the opponent on the notice of opposition from A. Cornwell to Mad Keen Pty Ltd. The court was surprised that the matter had progressed to a formal hearing for what seemed a simple change in name. The decision to amend the name was made considering that Jenkar had the right to contest the issue and thus assumed the inherent risks.

The court’s reasoning hinged on the practical implications of the amendment. If there was no appeal against the decision, the name change would take effect one month from the date of the decision. However, if an appeal was filed, the amendment would not proceed until the appeal was resolved. This conditional approach ensured that the rights of all parties were protected while also maintaining the efficiency of the legal process.

Regarding the timing of the amendment, the court opted for a conditional approach, allowing the amendment to occur only if there was no appeal or if the appeal was resolved in favor of Mad Keen Pty Ltd. This decision balanced the need for certainty in legal proceedings with the procedural rights of the parties involved.

In addressing the issue of costs, the court awarded costs to Ms. Cornwell for the current matter against Jenkar under Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995. The court determined that Ms. Cornwell was entitled to specific costs, including the Hearing Fee, attendance costs for Dr. Pullen's appearance, and the costs associated with preparing the case for the hearing. This decision was grounded in the premise that Ms. Cornwell had succeeded in the current matter concerning the name amendment.

The court's decision also addressed the potential costs for Jenkar. However, given that Ms. Cornwell would no longer be a party to the proceedings if Mad Keen Pty Ltd succeeded in the substantive opposition matter, Jenkar was not awarded costs in relation to the substantive matter. This nuanced approach ensured that costs were awarded fairly and in accordance with the specific outcomes of the current matter.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's recognition that amendments to party names on notices of opposition can be made if fair and reasonable, provided the amendment does not prejudice the substantive rights of the parties. The court balanced procedural fairness with the practical implications of the amendment, ensuring that the rights of all parties were safeguarded. The decision also highlighted the importance of timely and conditional amendments, reflecting the inherent risks taken by the party contesting the issue. Additionally, the court’s approach to awarding costs underscored the principle of fairness and the need to align costs with the specific outcomes of each phase of the legal proceedings.