Partington & Anor v Urquhart (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Partington & Anor v Urquhart (No 2) [2018] QCATA 120

PARTIES:

PHILLIP PARTINGTON
EVELYN PARTINGTON
(applicants/appellants)

v

JOHN URQUHART T/AS HART RENOVATIONS

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL131-13

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL072-10

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

10 August 2018

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Howard, Presiding
Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.   The submissions filed by Phillip Partington and Evelyn Partington in July 2017 are struck out.

2.   Leave to appeal is granted.

3.   The appeal is allowed.

4.     (a)   Order 1 of the Tribunal decision dated 19 February 2013 is set aside.

(b)   In substitution for order 1 dated 19 February 2013:

(i)     The Appeal Tribunal declares that:

a.    John Urquhart t/as Hart Renovations is entitled to a quantum meruit in the sum of $160,162.89;

b.    Phillip Partington and Evelyn Partington are entitled to damages and interest of $171,938.50;

(ii)     The questions of whether interest may be awarded on a quantum meruit, and if so, whether it should be awarded, and if so, in what amount are reserved for further determination on the papers not before 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(iii)    The Appeal Tribunal directs that the parties may file in the Appeal Tribunal and serve on the other party written submissions limited to two (2) A4 pages in 12 point font about the issues referred to in (ii) above, by 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(iv)    The Appeal Tribunal directs that the parties must file in the Appeal Tribunal two (2) copies and serve on the other party written submissions limited to two (2) A4 pages in 12 point font about the form of the final orders to be made in substitution of Tribunal order 1 dated 19 February 2013, setting out details of payments made pursuant to the Tribunal order dated 19 February 2013 to be brought into account, by 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(v)     Further orders will be made in substitution of order 1 dated 19 February 2013 by the Appeal Tribunal not before 4.00pm on 24 August 2018.

5.   Order 2 of the Tribunal decision dated 19 February 2013 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – POINTS AND OBJECTIONS NOT TAKEN BELOW – QUESTIONS NOT RAISED ON PLEADINGS OR IN ARGUMENT GENERALLY – where matter remitted from Court of Appeal to Appeal Tribunal – where all issues not considered before the Appeal Tribunal as originally constituted – where newly constituted Appeal Tribunal to conduct rehearing

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – THE CONTRACT – PERFORMANCE OF WORK REMEDIES FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT – DAMAGES – MEASURE OF – whether enclosed stage completed at time progress claim made – whether non-compliant and defective works preclude stage from being complete – enclosed stage invoice not received – effect of variations not in writing – contract not properly terminated under clause 28 – whether contract terminated at law

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Partington & Anor v Urquhart (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCATA 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Partington & Anor v Urquhart, the Appeal Tribunal was called upon to review the decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) in relation to a dispute between the homeowners, Phillip and Evelyn Partington, and the builder, John Urquhart trading as Hart Renovations. The primary dispute centred around the completion of a building contract for the renovation of the Partingtons' residence, including issues of defective work, non-compliance with the contract specifications, and the termination of the contract.

The legal issues before the Appeal Tribunal included whether the enclosed stage of the renovation was completed as per the contract at the time the progress claim was made, whether non-compliant and defective works precluded the stage from being deemed complete, and whether the contract was properly terminated under the terms of the agreement. Additionally, the tribunal had to consider the appropriate measure of damages, including the cost of rectification by the homeowners and the builder's entitlement to a quantum meruit. The tribunal also needed to address the assessment of interest on the quantum meruit, if any, and the form of final orders considering any payments already made by the parties.

The Appeal Tribunal, after reviewing the evidence and the original tribunal's decision, concluded that the builder was liable for damages for non-completion, the cost to complete the work, and the cost of rectification, along with interest. The tribunal allowed the appeal and set aside the original order, substituting it with a declaration of the amounts owed by the builder to the homeowners and by the homeowners to the builder on a quantum meruit. The tribunal also reserved the question of interest on the quantum meruit for further submissions by the parties. Directions were issued for the parties to file written submissions regarding the quantum meruit interest and the final form of orders by a specified deadline.

The tribunal confirmed some findings of the original tribunal, while allowing the appeal on others, leading to the setting aside of the original order and the substitution of a new one. This decision reflects a comprehensive review of the contractual obligations, the performance of work, and the legal remedies available under the circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The submissions filed by Phillip Partington and Evelyn Partington in July 2017 are struck out.

2. Leave to appeal is granted.

3. The appeal is allowed.

4. (a) Order 1 of the Tribunal decision dated 19 February 2013 is set aside.

(b) In substitution for order 1 dated 19 February 2013:

(i) The Appeal Tribunal declares that:

a. John Urquhart t/as Hart Renovations is entitled to a quantum meruit in the sum of $160,162.89;

b. Phillip Partington and Evelyn Partington are entitled to damages and interest of $171,938.50;

(ii) The questions of whether interest may be awarded on a quantum meruit, and if so, whether it should be awarded, and if so, in what amount are reserved for further determination on the papers not before 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(iii) The Appeal Tribunal directs that the parties may file in the Appeal Tribunal and serve on the other party written submissions limited to two (2) A4 pages in 12 point font about the issues referred to in (ii) above, by 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(iv) The Appeal Tribunal directs that the parties must file in the Appeal Tribunal two (2) copies and serve on the other party written submissions limited to two (2) A4 pages in 12 point font about the form of the final orders to be made in substitution of Tribunal order 1 dated 19 February 2013, setting out details of payments made pursuant to the Tribunal order dated 19 February 2013 to be brought into account, by 4:00pm on 24 August 2018.

(v) Further orders will be made in substitution of order 1 dated 19 February 2013 by the Appeal Tribunal not before 4.00pm on 24 August 2018.

5. Order 2 of the Tribunal decision dated 19 February 2013 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In Harrison v Meehan[40] the Court of Appeal held that, in conducting an appeal by way of rehearing, the Appeal Tribunal was required to consider all of the questions raised by the applicant’s appeal.[41] In doing this however, each question did not have to be discussed distinctly. It was enough if the reasons sufficiently explained how the Appeal Tribunal reached its conclusion.[42] Accordingly, we consider below all of the issues raised by the appeal and discuss them as those issues logically arise. We return at the end of this process to make our conclusions regarding each ground of appeal.[40][2017] QCA 315.[41]Ibid [50].[42]Ibid.3. Background On 4 August 2008 the builder and the Partingtons entered into a building contract to raise, build-in under and renovate the Partingtons’ residence in Sherwood.[43] [43]Alteration, Addition and Renovation Contract (HIA QC3 2000) dated 4 August 2008 (Contract), clause 4. The contract documents comprised:(a) The Building Contract;(b) Plans by Nicole Western, architect, job no 0605102;(c) Specification by Nicole Western, architect, job no 0606-102;(d) Engineering by Morgan Consulting Engineers, job no 07M5034; and(e) DA Approval Ref: A001641081.[44][44]Contract, Schedule 1, clause 12. Under the contract, the builder was to be paid a price of $483,742.00. There was provision for the making of progress payments at the completion of various stages of the work.[45] The agreed Progress Payment Table was as follows:[45]Contract, Schedule 2, Part B. The following payments were made by the Partingtons to the builder: On 20 April 2009, the builder issued invoice no 449 for progress payment 5, being the enclosed stage (first enclosed stage invoice). The total amount of the first enclosed stage invoice was $151,669.41, comprising $145,122 (enclosed stage payment 30%) and $6,547.41 for variations. The first enclosed stage invoice was not paid. Instead, the Partingtons provided to the builder a document headed “List of items to be rectified before enclosed payment is made”.[46] They claim the parties agreed on 23 April 2009 that the builder would undertake those works before the enclosed stage payment would become payable.[47] The Tribunal found, and the Court of Appeal agreed, that the evidence did not support the existence of any such agreement.[48][46]Statement of Nick Newton, representative of Appellants, 12 August 2011, attachment “A”.[47]Response and counter-claim, 24 May 2010, [6].[48]John Urquhart t/as Hart Renovations v Partington & Anor [2016] QCA 87, [20]. On 7 May 2009, Mr Partington wrote to the builder to say he would like to see work done before he paid the “lock up payment”. On 11 May 2009 the builder wrote asking when the progress payment would be made. On 12 May 2009, Mrs Partington wrote to the builder to say she would authorise the financier to release the payment but still insisted that the outstanding items be attended to. On 13 May 2009 the builder told the Partingtons that he would recommence work upon receipt of the progress payment for the enclosed stage.[49] On 13 May 2009, Mrs Partington authorised the financier to release the payment. However, when the builder was not personally on site on 14 May 2009, she stopped the payment for the enclosed stage. [49]Affidavit of John Urquhart, 3 June 2011, [154].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons above, on the homeowners’ claim, the builder is liable to pay to the homeowners the following:(a) Damages for non-completion - $150.00(b) Cost to complete - $54,834.00(c) Damages for cost of rectification - $ 68,735.00(d) Interest - $ 48,219.50.TOTAL: $171,938.50Conclusions and orders For the reasons explained, we grant leave to appeal and allow the appeal. If there is no basis in law upon which interest may be awarded to the builder on his quantum meruit, the overall result arising from the contractual dispute will be that the builder pay the homeowners the amount of $11,712.61. Directions are made allowing both parties to make submissions about the Tribunal’s power to award interest on a quantum meruit; and if there is power, whether an order should be made and in what amount. Further, the Appeal Tribunal is unaware whether payments have been made by the parties pursuant to the orders of the Tribunal of 19 February 2013. Accordingly, the Appeal Tribunal invites further submissions from the parties on the final form of orders to be made on this appeal, which bring to account our decision and the effect of any payments already made. Those submissions are to be filed in the Appeal Tribunal by 4:00pm on 24 August 2018. At this stage, declarations are made confirming our findings of the amounts payable on the application and cross-application, save and except any amount for interest on the quantum meruit is reserved for further consideration by us, together with the making of further orders in substitution of order 1. Order 2 regarding the costs thrown away as a result of the adjournment is confirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Specification under Timber Weatherboard Cladding it provides:PreparationPrime all faces of boards prior to installation.Nails:Hot dip galvanised to non-corrosive timbersSilica bronze or stainless steel to corrosive timbers Nailheads: Treat visible nailheads as follows:In stained or clear finishes: Drive flush.In opaque finishes: Punch below the surface and fill flush with putty after the surface has been primed.JointsOverlapping joints: Lap boards at least 30mmEnd grain joints: Install boards so that butt joints are in compression.[87][87]Specification, 35, [3.3]. Drawings WD201, 202, 301, 302, 303 and 304 show where the hardwood is to be applied (indicated by WB). The only section to use pine (WB1) was the upper floor blade wall on the eastern side of the house.[88] We find that the contract provided for the use of hardwood chamfer boards in the areas identified, but that pine was used. Was there an effective oral variation to use pine chamfer boards instead of hard wood chamfer boards?[88]Statement of Evelyn Partington, 26 November 2010, [107]-[108]. The Tribunal at first instance found that the builder used the incorrect chamfer board. The Tribunal preferred Mrs Partington’s evidence on this issue to that of the builder.[89] However, in context, having regard to the overall evidence and the Tribunal’s reasons for decision, we are satisfied that the Tribunal’s finding was limited to the requirements of the contract. The Tribunal did not make findings about whether or not, having regard to a conversation between the builder and Mr Partington on 5 February 2009, there was an oral agreement to vary the contract by permitting pine chamfer boards rather than hardwood boards. (If we are wrong about the scope of the Tribunal’s finding, in any event, we would find that no reasonable arbiter of fact could have reached a different conclusion based on the evidence, discussed below, to the effect that it was common ground that the homeowners had agreed to the use of pine instead of hardwood chamfer boards).[89][2013] QCAT 133, [71](o). Any reliance on the Barac and Michelsen quotes as evidence was abandoned by the Partingtons.[162] Mr Barac and Mr Michelsen were not witnesses and the basis for the quotes they provided was untested by cross-examination. It is not now appropriate or permissible to consider their quotes on appeal as the homeowners are bound by the case they presented.[162]Reasons, [85] regarding the Barac quote; and Transcript of Proceedings, John Urquhart trading as Hart Renovations v Partington (QCAT, BDL072-10, Senior Member Oliver, 27 August 2012) 282-284, regarding the Barac and Michelsen quotes. Mr Bowman, the civil engineer engaged by the homeowners, considered that the slab could be replaced, ‘scrabbled back’ or just left alone.[163][163]Transcript of Proceedings, John Urquhart trading as Hart Renovations v Partington (QCAT, BDL072-10, Senior Member Oliver, 27 August 2012) 137-138. The principal reason for the Senior Member accepting the evidence of Mr Ray over Mr Groom in a number of respects is the fact that Mr Ray provided greater detail in respect of the costs and the work to been done to undertake rectification.