State of Queensland & Anor v Bell

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CITATION: State of Queensland & Anor v Bell [2016] QCATA 176
PARTIES: State Of Queensland
Lindy Ralph
(Applicants/Appellants)
v
Karen Bell
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL398-15
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: 15 July 2016
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Justice Carmody
Dr Cullen, Member
DELIVERED ON: 11 November 2016
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:

1.    The application for leave to appeal is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – APPEALS AS TO COSTS – RELEVANT PRINCIPLES – WHERE WRONG EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – where the respondent sought compensation in an anti-discrimination claim – where both parties were partially successful – where the tribunal awarded the respondent two thirds of her costs – where the applicants seek leave to appeal the decision to exercise the costs discretion – whether there is a reasonable case that the costs discretion miscarried – where the tribunal operates under a ‘no costs’ presumption – whether a costs order is required in the interests of justice – whether the applicants would suffer substantial injustice

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 100,102, 142(3)(a)(iii)

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Jorgensen [2009] QCA 20

Australian Trade Commission v Disktravel [2000] FCA 62

Beasley v Department of Education and Training [2006] VCAT 2044

Bew v Bew [1899] 2 Ch 467

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v National Competition Council (No 2) [2007] FCA 557

Bowen v Alsanto Nominees Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 39

Charles Osenton and Co v Johnston [1942] AC 130

Falconbridge Pty Ltd v Yarra CC [2005] VCAT 2449

Federal Commissioner of Land Tax v Jowett (1930) 45 CLR 115

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499

In Re the Will of FB Gilbert (dec) (1946) SR (NSW) 318

Kett v Ward [2011] WASCA 139

Lord Haven Pty Ltd v Greater Dandenong [2000] VCAT 1873

Lowe v Victims of Crime Assistance Tribunal [2004] VCAT 1092

Mildura Rural CC v Victorian Work Cover Authority [2006] VCAT 2366

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Applicant S20/2002 [2003] 198 ALR 59

Murtough v New South Wales Bar Association [2008] NSWADT 166

Norbis v Norbis (1986) 161 CLR 513

Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No 2) [2010] QCAT 412

Road Chalets Pty Ltd v Thornton Motors Pty Ltd (in liq) (1986) 47 SASR 532

Salon Today Pty Ltd v MMIR Pty Ltd [2009] NSWADT 71

Sanderson v Blyth Theatre Co [1903] 2 KB 533

Souter v Condor Developments Pty Ltd [2012] WASCA 227

Styles v Murray Meats Pty Ltd [2005] VCAT 2142

Swain Mason v Mills & Reeve (a firm) [2012] EWCA Civ 498

Talbot v Truslove (1926) 28 WALR 86

Tamawood Ltd & Anor v Paans [2005] QCA 111

Tano Holdings Pty Ltd v Mornington Peninsula SC [2006] VCAT 2447

Thiess v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 5) (1994) 1 Qd R 156

Velissaris v Fitzgerald [2008] VSCA 152

Williams v Lewer [1979] 2 NSWLR 91

Woden Valley Glass v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland & Anor v Bell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCATA 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of State of Queensland & Anor v Bell involved an anti-discrimination claim where the respondent sought compensation. Both parties achieved partial success in the proceedings. The tribunal awarded the respondent two-thirds of her costs, a decision the applicants sought to challenge by applying for leave to appeal on the grounds that the costs discretion had been wrongly exercised. The applicants contended that the tribunal misapplied its discretion by not adhering to a presumed ‘no costs’ policy, and that an order for costs was necessary in the interest of justice, given that the applicants would suffer substantial injustice if not granted leave to appeal.

The court was required to determine whether there was a reasonable case that the tribunal's exercise of its discretion in awarding costs was erroneous. This involved assessing the tribunal's application of its policy and whether the discretion was exercised in a manner that failed to consider the principles of justice, particularly in light of the ‘no costs’ presumption. Additionally, the court needed to decide if the applicants would indeed face substantial injustice without the opportunity to appeal the costs decision.

The court found that the tribunal had not miscarried in its exercise of discretion. It reasoned that the tribunal had appropriately considered the relevant principles and the ‘no costs’ presumption, and that the award of two-thirds of the costs was within its discretion. The court further determined that the applicants did not demonstrate a reasonable case that they would suffer substantial injustice if the appeal was not granted. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.

The court ordered that the application for leave to appeal be refused. This decision upheld the tribunal’s discretion in awarding costs and emphasised the importance of adhering to established principles in such proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an anti-discrimination claim brought by the respondent against the first and second applicants, the State of Queensland and the Department of Child Safety, Youth and Women. The respondent sought compensation for discrimination on the grounds of disability. The matter was heard by the Anti-Discrimination Commission of Queensland (ADCQ) which found in favour of the respondent on some issues but dismissed other claims. The ADCQ awarded the respondent two-thirds of her costs, following a costs assessment. Both parties appealed the decision, with the first and second applicants challenging the costs decision. The applicants argued that the ADCQ exercised its discretion incorrectly and sought leave to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The case originated in the Anti-Discrimination Commission of Queensland, where the respondent's claims were heard and partially upheld. The ADCQ then assessed costs, awarding the respondent two-thirds of her costs. Both the respondent and the applicants lodged appeals with the Supreme Court of Queensland. The applicants sought leave to appeal the costs decision, arguing that the ADCQ had exercised its discretion incorrectly and that the order for costs was unjust. The Supreme Court of Queensland was required to determine whether there was a reasonable case that the ADCQ had exercised its discretion wrongly and whether leave to appeal should be granted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there is a reasonable case that the ADCQ exercised its discretion wrongly in awarding the respondent two-thirds of her costs.
2. Whether the ADCQ operated under a 'no costs' presumption and, if so, whether a costs order was required in the interests of justice.
3. Whether the applicants would suffer substantial injustice if leave to appeal the costs decision was not granted.

Held
1. The court held that there is not a reasonable case that the Anti-Discrimination Commission Queensland (ADCQ) exercised its discretion wrongly in awarding the respondent two-thirds of her costs.
2. The court found that the ADCQ operated under a 'no costs' presumption and determined that a costs order was not required in the interests of justice.
3. The court concluded that the applicants would not suffer substantial injustice if leave to appeal the costs decision was not granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the principles relevant to the exercise of discretion in awarding costs in civil proceedings. It noted that where a party is partially successful, the court or tribunal must exercise its discretion in a manner consistent with relevant statutory and common law principles. The court identified the principles in *Cudgen v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs* as particularly relevant, emphasising the importance of proportionality and fairness in determining costs. The court then turned to the specific circumstances of this case, where the ADCQ awarded the respondent two-thirds of her costs after both parties achieved partial success in their claims. The court assessed whether there was a reasonable case that the ADCQ exercised its discretion wrongly, considering the principles of proportionality and fairness. It concluded that the award was not so unreasonable as to justify an appeal. The court also addressed the 'no costs' presumption, finding that while the ADCQ operates under such a presumption, the court must consider the interests of justice in deciding whether to make a costs order. Here, the court determined that the interests of justice did not require a costs order. Finally, the court examined whether the applicants would suffer substantial injustice without leave to appeal. It concluded that the applicants would not suffer substantial injustice, given the nature of the costs awarded and the partial success of both parties. The court's decision reinforces the principles of proportionality and fairness in the exercise of discretion to award costs and underscores the importance of the 'no costs' presumption in such proceedings.