Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited [2023] NSWCA 114
Hearing dates: 15 March 2023
Date of orders: 26 May 2023
Decision date: 26 May 2023
Before: Gleeson JA at [1]
White JA at [115]
Brereton JA at [116]
Decision:

(1)   Grant leave to appeal.

(2)   Appeal allowed.

(3)   Direct the appellant to file a notice of appeal in the form contained in the White Book within seven days.

(4)   Set aside the answers to separate questions (c), (d), (e), (f), (g) and (h) given on 19 July 2022, and in lieu, answer those questions as follows:

(c)   Not necessary to answer.

(d)   Not necessary to answer.

(e) Yes. JKN and Toplace breached the statutory warranty in s 18B(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW).

(f)   Yes.

(g) The Owners Corporation’s loss is assessed as the reasonable cost of removing the cladding and replacing it with cladding which is non-combustible within the meaning of that term in the Building Code of Australia.

(h) The defendants are liable to the plaintiff for the reasonable cost of having the cladding removed and replaced with cladding which is non-combustible within the meaning of that term in the Building Code of Australia.

(5)   Set aside orders (1) and (2) made on 27 July 2022 and in lieu, make the following orders:

(a) Pursuant to r 28.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the plaintiff’s claim, insofar as it relies upon the contentions in paragraphs 27A, 27B, 27C, 27F and 28 of Part C of the Amended Technology and Construction List Statement filed on 5 April 2019, be allowed;

(b)   Direct the parties to bring in short minutes of order before the primary judge in relation to the monetary judgment for damages in favour of the plaintiff in respect of the agreed cost of removal and replacement of the cladding.

(6)   The respondents pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the determination of the separate questions in the court below.

Catchwords:

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Contract — Implied terms — Statutory warranties — Whether building complied with Building Code of Australia (BCA) — Where performance requirements of BCA specified that external walls must be “non-combustible” — Whether external cladding met performance requirements for fire resistance — Where cladding did not comply with “deemed-to-satisfy” provisions — Where no “alternative solution” prepared prior to issue of construction certificate —Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), s 18(1)(c) — Where breach of s 18(1)(c) conceded

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Contract — Damages — Claim for reinstatement damages — Evidentiary onus of proving reinstatement would be unreasonable

Legislation Cited:

Building Products (Safety) Act 2017 (NSW), s 9(1)

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), s 109H

Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000 (NSW), regs 98(1)(a), 145, 198

Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), ss 18B, 18C, 18D, 18E, 18F

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 103

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWCA 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerned a dispute between Owners SP 92450 (the appellant) and JKN Para 1 Pty Limited and Toplace Pty Limited (the respondents) regarding alleged breaches of statutory warranties in relation to building works. The core of the dispute centred on whether the external walls of the building complied with the performance requirements of the Building Code of Australia (BCA), specifically concerning non-combustibility. The appellant conceded that the cladding did not comply with the "deemed-to-satisfy" provisions of the BCA and that no "alternative solution" had been prepared prior to the issue of the construction certificate.

The legal issues before the court included whether the respondents had breached the statutory warranty implied by s 18B(1)(c) of the *Home Building Act 1989* (NSW), which requires building work to be carried out with due care and skill and in accordance with the requirements of the Building Code of Australia. The court also had to determine the appropriate measure of damages, specifically whether the Owners Corporation's loss should be assessed as the reasonable cost of removing the non-compliant cladding and replacing it with compliant, non-combustible material. The court considered the evidentiary onus on the defendants to prove that reinstatement damages would be unreasonable.

The Court of Appeal found that the respondents had breached the statutory warranty under s 18B(1)(c) of the *Home Building Act 1989* (NSW). The court reasoned that the performance requirements of the BCA, mandating non-combustible external walls, had not been met by the installed cladding. The absence of a compliant "deemed-to-satisfy" solution or an approved "alternative solution" prior to construction meant the building work did not comply with the BCA. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, setting aside previous answers to separate questions and directing that the Owners Corporation's loss be assessed as the reasonable cost of removing the cladding and replacing it with non-combustible material. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and the determination of the separate questions in the court below.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Grant leave to appeal.

(2) Appeal allowed.

(3) Direct the appellant to file a notice of appeal in the form contained in the White Book within seven days.

(4) Set aside the answers to separate questions (c), (d), (e), (f), (g) and (h) given on 19 July 2022, and in lieu, answer those questions as follows:

(c) Not necessary to answer.

(d) Not necessary to answer.

(e) Yes. JKN and Toplace breached the statutory warranty in s 18B(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW).

(f) Yes.

(g) The Owners Corporation’s loss is assessed as the reasonable cost of removing the cladding and replacing it with cladding which is non-combustible within the meaning of that term in the Building Code of Australia.

(h) The defendants are liable to the plaintiff for the reasonable cost of having the cladding removed and replaced with cladding which is non-combustible within the meaning of that term in the Building Code of Australia.

(5) Set aside orders (1) and (2) made on 27 July 2022 and in lieu, make the following orders:

(a) Pursuant to r 28.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the plaintiff’s claim, insofar as it relies upon the contentions in paragraphs 27A, 27B, 27C, 27F and 28 of Part C of the Amended Technology and Construction List Statement filed on 5 April 2019, be allowed;

(b) Direct the parties to bring in short minutes of order before the primary judge in relation to the monetary judgment for damages in favour of the plaintiff in respect of the agreed cost of removal and replacement of the cladding.

(6) The respondents pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the determination of the separate questions in the court below.

Background

Background to the litigation

Owners Strata Plan 92450 (the Owners) engaged JKN Para 1 Pty Limited (JKN) to construct a residential building in Sydney. The construction was overseen by Toplace (an authorised building practitioner), who provided services under an agreement with JKN. The Owners entered into a contract with JKN for the construction of the building, which included a statutory warranty that the building would comply with the Building Code of Australia (BCA). The BCA stipulates that external walls must be “non-combustible.” The Owners alleged that the external cladding of the building did not meet the performance requirements for fire resistance specified in the BCA and did not comply with the “deemed-to-satisfy” provisions. Further, it was alleged that no “alternative solution” was prepared prior to the issue of the construction certificate, as required by the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), section 18(1)(c). The Owners filed a lawsuit seeking damages for the breach of the statutory warranty, claiming that JKN and Toplace had failed to ensure that the building complied with the BCA.

JKN and Toplace conceded the breach of the statutory warranty under section 18B(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW). The primary dispute in the case centred on the Owners’ claim for reinstatement damages, which sought to cover the cost of removing the non-compliant cladding and replacing it with cladding that met the BCA’s requirements. The Owners argued that the cladding posed a significant fire risk and that the reasonable cost of removing and replacing it should be awarded as damages. JKN and Toplace contended that the Owners had not discharged the evidentiary onus of proving that reinstatement would be unreasonable, as they had not provided sufficient evidence to support their claim. The case proceeded to a determination on separate questions, which addressed the statutory warranty breach and the assessment of the Owners’ loss.

The case of Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited involves a dispute under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) concerning the compliance of external cladding on a building with the Building Code of Australia (BCA). The matter initially came before the Local Court, where the Owners Corporation brought a claim against JKN Para 1 Pty Limited for breach of statutory warranties related to the construction of the building. The trial judge made findings in relation to the compliance of the building with the BCA, the breach of statutory warranties, and the assessment of damages. The defendants appealed the trial judge's decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which exercised its discretion to grant leave to appeal and heard the matter as an appeal from the earlier decision. The Supreme Court considered the submissions and evidence presented at the first instance and made orders setting aside certain answers to questions given by the trial judge, substituting new answers, and directing the parties to bring in short minutes of order before the primary judge in relation to the monetary judgment for damages. The Supreme Court further allowed the appeal, assessed the loss as the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding, and directed the respondents to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and the determination of the separate questions in the court below.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the external cladding of the building complied with the performance requirements of the Building Code of Australia (BCA) by being “non-combustible”.
2. Whether the breach of s 18(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) by the respondents constituted a breach of the statutory warranty.
3. Whether the Owners Corporation is entitled to reinstatement damages for the cost of removing and replacing the cladding.
4. Whether the evidentiary onus of proving that reinstatement would be unreasonable was discharged by the appellant.
5. Whether the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding is an appropriate assessment of the Owners Corporation’s loss.
6. Whether the respondents are liable for the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding in accordance with the Building Code of Australia.

Held
1. Whether the external cladding of the building complied with the performance requirements of the Building Code of Australia (BCA) by being “non-combustible”: The court concluded that the external cladding did not comply with the performance requirements of the BCA.
2. Whether the breach of s 18(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) by the respondents constituted a breach of the statutory warranty: The court concluded that the respondents breached the statutory warranty in s 18B(1)(c) of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW).
3. Whether the Owners Corporation is entitled to reinstatement damages for the cost of removing and replacing the cladding: The court concluded that the Owners Corporation is entitled to reinstatement damages.
4. Whether the evidentiary onus of proving that reinstatement would be unreasonable was discharged by the appellant: The court concluded that the evidentiary onus was not discharged by the appellant.
5. Whether the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding is an appropriate assessment of the Owners Corporation’s loss: The court concluded that the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding is an appropriate assessment of the Owners Corporation’s loss.
6. Whether the respondents are liable for the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding in accordance with the Building Code of Australia: The court concluded that the respondents are liable for the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding in accordance with the Building Code of Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited provided a comprehensive analysis on several pivotal issues related to the compliance of a building's external cladding with the Building Code of Australia (BCA) and the implications of statutory warranties under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW). Firstly, the Court addressed whether the external cladding of the building complied with the performance requirements of the BCA by being “non-combustible.” The Court found that the cladding did not meet the specified performance requirements for fire resistance as it did not comply with the “deemed-to-satisfy” provisions and no alternative solution was prepared prior to the issuance of the construction certificate. This conclusion was drawn from the explicit terms of the BCA and the statutory requirement for compliance.

In examining whether the breach of s 18(1)(c) of the Home Building Act constituted a breach of the statutory warranty, the Court held that the respondents, JKN and Toplace, indeed breached the statutory warranty. This was affirmed by the respondents’ concession, which aligned with the statutory requirement for compliance with the BCA. The Court emphasized the importance of adhering to statutory mandates to ensure the safety and quality of building works. The breach of the statutory warranty was thus established based on the respondents' failure to meet the BCA's performance requirements.

The Court further considered whether the Owners Corporation was entitled to reinstatement damages for the cost of removing and replacing the cladding. The Court held that the Owners Corporation was entitled to such damages, as the cladding did not comply with the BCA's requirements and thus needed to be replaced to meet the statutory standards. The evidentiary onus of proving that reinstatement would be unreasonable was also scrutinized, with the Court concluding that the appellant had not discharged this onus. The Court found that there was no substantial evidence presented to demonstrate that the replacement of the cladding would be unreasonable or impractical, thereby affirming the entitlement to reinstatement damages.

In assessing the appropriate measure of the Owners Corporation’s loss, the Court determined that the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding with non-combustible cladding, as specified by the BCA, was an appropriate assessment. This decision was based on the need to restore the building to a state of compliance with the statutory requirements and the principles of restitution in building contracts, which aim to place the building owner in the position they would have been in had the contract been properly performed.

Finally, the Court addressed the issue of whether the respondents were liable for the reasonable cost of removing and replacing the cladding. The Court held that the respondents were liable for the reasonable cost, as they had breached the statutory warranty by failing to ensure that the cladding complied with the BCA's performance requirements. The liability was grounded in the statutory framework, which imposes obligations on builders to ensure compliance with building codes and the implied warranty of compliance in building contracts.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that where a building's external cladding does not comply with the performance requirements of the BCA, the building owners are entitled to reinstatement damages to bring the building into compliance. Additionally, builders who fail to ensure compliance with the BCA are liable for the reasonable costs associated with rectifying such non-compliance, thereby upholding the statutory warranties under the Home Building Act.