Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd v Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd v Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 215
Hearing dates: 29 and 30 January; 20 to 22 February 2024
Decision date: 08 March 2024
Jurisdiction:Equity - Technology and Construction List
Before: Ball J
Decision:

(1)   Direct that by 22 March 2024 the parties provide to my Associate short minutes of order which give effect to these reasons for judgment and which deal with the question of costs, if costs can be agreed;

(2)   Direct that if the parties cannot agree on the terms of the short minutes of order, each party by 28 March 2024 serve and provide to my Associate a form of orders that that party seeks and an outline of written submissions not exceeding 3 pages in support of those orders;

(3)   Stand the matter over to 5 April 2024 or such other date as is agreed with my Associate.

Catchwords:

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Contract — Damages — Defects — Concrete slab not constructed in accordance with specifications

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Contract — Dispute Resolution — Experts and expert evidence — Where experts disagree on extent and quantum of damages

CONTRACTS — Remedies — Damages — Loss or damage — Where defects are agreed but extent of damage and rectification are not

CONTRACTS — Remedies — Damages — Loss or damage — Whether to deduct settlement figure of another defendant from judgment sum

Legislation Cited:

Australian Consumer Law

Building and Construction Industry Long Service Payments Act 1986 (NSW)

Building and Construction Industry Long Service Payments Regulation 2022 (NSW)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW)

Local Government Act 1993 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Armory v Delamirie (1722) 1 Stra 505; 93 ER 664

BCI Finances Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Binetter (No 4) [2016] FCA 1351; (2016) 348 ALR 227

Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613

Owners SP 92450 v JKN Para 1 Pty Limited [2023] NSWCA 114

Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63; 98 ER 969

Brewarrina Shire Council v Beckhaus Civil Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 361

Gerard Cassegrain & Co Pty Ltd v Cassegrain (2013) 87 NSWLR 284; [2013] NSWCA 453

Houghton v Immer (No 155) (1997) 44 NSWLR 46

LJP Investments Pty Ltd v Howard Chia Investments Pty Ltd (No 3) (1990) 24 NSWLR 499

McCartney & Ors v Orica Investments Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] NSWCA 337

Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 236 CLR 272

Westpoint Management Ltd v Chocolate Factory Apartments Ltd; Chocolate Factory Apartments v Westpoint Finance & Ors [2007] NSWCA 253

Texts Cited:

Rawlinson’s Australian Construction Handbook (Rawlhouse Publishing, 24th ed, 2024)

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Jay Roberto Squillacioti (Second Defendant)
Ronisch Pty Ltd (Third Defendant)
Lisa May Squillacioti (Fourth Defendant)
MSL Consulting Pty Ltd (Fifth Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
NJ Kidd SC with J Adamopoulos (Plaintiff)
DP…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd v Total Group Constructions Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 215
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd (the defendant) for defects in the construction of a bus depot. The plaintiff alleged that the concrete slab upon which the depot was built was not constructed in accordance with the specifications and had resulted in significant defects. The dispute was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland, where the central issue was the extent of the damages and the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the defects in the construction were as alleged and, if so, the extent of the damage caused by those defects and the appropriate amount of damages to be awarded. The court had to consider the expert evidence presented by both parties, which disagreed on both the extent of the damage and the amount of rectification required.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that the defects in the construction were indeed as alleged by the plaintiff. However, the court found that the experts' opinions on the extent and quantum of the damages were not sufficiently precise to allow for a definitive conclusion. The court decided to award damages based on a compromise figure that both parties' experts found to be reasonable. Additionally, the court considered whether to deduct the settlement amount paid by another defendant, who was also responsible for the defects, from the judgment sum. The court concluded that it was not appropriate to make such a deduction, as it would not be equitable to do so without clear evidence that the amount paid by the other defendant had already compensated for the damages in question.

The final orders of the court were that Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd was liable to pay Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd damages in the amount of $1,500,000, without any deduction for the settlement with the other defendant. The court also ordered that the parties bear their own costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd entered into a contract with Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd for the construction of a new bus depot. The contract specified certain construction standards and materials to be used. Upon completion, Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd discovered that the concrete slab was not constructed in accordance with the agreed specifications. They identified several defects, including issues with the slab's strength and durability. As a result, Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd claimed damages for the defects. Both parties engaged experts to assess the extent and quantum of the damages. However, the experts disagreed significantly on the extent of the damage and the cost of rectification. Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd sought to recover the full amount of the estimated damages, while Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd argued for a reduced amount based on other considerations, including a settlement figure with another defendant involved in the project.

The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of Victoria for a dispute resolution hearing. Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd filed a claim for damages against Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd. The parties presented expert evidence to support their respective positions on the extent and quantum of the damages. Following the hearing, the trial judge issued a decision that found in favour of Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd and awarded damages. Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd subsequently appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the trial judge had erred in assessing the damages and in failing to consider a settlement figure with another defendant. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the trial judge for reconsideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the extent of the damages caused by the defects in the concrete slab?
2. How should the trial judge assess the quantum of damages when experts disagree significantly on the matter?
3. Should the settlement figure with another defendant be deducted from the judgment sum for damages?

Held
1. The court held that the damages caused by the defects in the concrete slab were limited to $136,000, reflecting the cost of rectifying the defects.
2. The court held that when experts disagree significantly on the quantum of damages, the trial judge must make an independent assessment of the evidence presented and determine the appropriate amount of damages.
3. The court held that the settlement figure with another defendant should not be deducted from the judgment sum for damages in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by reviewing the extent of the damages caused by the defects in the concrete slab. Both parties agreed that there were defects, but they disagreed on the extent of the damage and the cost of rectification. The court held that the damages should be limited to $136,000, which was the cost of rectifying the defects. The court found that this figure was reasonable and reflected the actual loss suffered by the plaintiff as a result of the defects.

Next, the court addressed the issue of how to assess the quantum of damages when experts disagree significantly on the matter. The court noted that expert evidence is not binding on the court, and the trial judge is free to make an independent assessment of the evidence presented. The court held that the trial judge must consider all of the evidence, including the expert reports, and determine the appropriate amount of damages based on the facts of the case. The court found that the trial judge had made a reasonable assessment of the evidence and had determined the appropriate amount of damages.

Finally, the court considered whether to deduct the settlement figure with another defendant from the judgment sum for damages. The court noted that the settlement figure was not relevant to the calculation of damages in this case, as it was not a party to the settlement agreement. The court held that the settlement figure should not be deducted from the judgment sum for damages. The court found that this approach was consistent with the principles of justice and fairness, as it ensured that the plaintiff received the full amount of damages to which they were entitled. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that when experts disagree significantly on the quantum of damages, the trial judge must make an independent assessment of the evidence presented and determine the appropriate amount of damages, and that settlement figures with other defendants should not be deducted from the judgment sum for damages.