Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd [2008] FCAFC 38

LANDLORD AND TENANT – covenant not to alter demised premises – covenant to leave in repair or make good demised premises at end of term of lease

DAMAGES – lease – breach of covenant not to alter demised premises – measure of damages – no damage to reversion – whether cost of reinstatement recoverable – whether reinstatement is reasonable – meaning of reasonable – time at which claim is made by landlord – at or near end of lease – relevance of option to renew – relevance of whether option exercised – whether landlord must prove intention to use any damages awarded to restore premises – rule in Joyner v Weeks [1891] 2 QB 31

Abrahams v Shaw (1969) 72 SR (NSW) 225 cited
Anstruther-Gough-Calthorpe v McOscar [1924] 1 KB 716 cited
Atkins (GW) Ltd v Scott (1991) 7 Construction Law Journal 215 approved
Barton v Reilly (1878) 1 SCR (NS) NSW 125 cited
Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613 discussed
Birch v Clifford (1891) 8 TLR 103 cited
Black Creek Deer Farm Pty Ltd v ANZ (1996) V ConvR ¶54-549 referred to
British Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Company of London Ltd [1912] AC 673 referred to
CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172 applied
Chan v Cresdon Pty Ltd (1989) 168 CLR 242 cited
Commonwealth v Antonio Giorgio Pty Ltd (1986) 12 FCR 51 cited
Conquest v Ebbetts [1896] AC 490 discussed
De Cesare v Deluxe Motors Pty Limited (1996) 67 SASR 28 cited
Director of War Service and Homes v Harris [1968] Qd R 275 referred to
Espir v Basil Street Hotel Ltd [1936] 3 All ER 91 cited
Evans v Balog [1976] 1 NSWLR 36 distinguished
Eyre v Rea [1947] KB 567 discussed

Fitzgerald v Masters (1956) 95 CLR 420 cited

Gange v Lockwood (1860) 2 F & F 115 [175 ER 984] cited
Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 395 cited
Gates v City Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 1 cited
Gooderham and Worts Ltd v Canadian Broadcasting Corporation [1947] AC 66 cited
Graham v Markets Hotel Pty Ltd (1943) 67 CLR 567 followed
Hanson v Newman [1934] Ch 298 cited
Hill v Barclay (1810) 16 Ves Jun 402 [33 ER 1037] considered
Hyder Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd v Wilh Wilhemsen Agency Pty Limited [2001] NSWCA 313 discussed
Jacob & Youngs Inc v Kent 230 NY 239; 129 NE 889 (1921) cited
James v Hutton and J Cook & Sons Ltd [1950] 1 KB 9 discussed
Joyner v Weeks [1891] 2 QB 31 followed
Lambert v F W Woolworthand Co Ltd [1938] Ch 883 discussed
Lurcott v Wakely & Wheeler [1911] 1 KB 905 cited
Maggbury Pty Limited v Hafele Australia Pty Limited (2001) 210 CLR 181 referred to
Maori Trustee v Rogross Farm Ltd [1994] 3 NZLR 410 referred to
Parramatta…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bowen Investments Pty Ltd sought relief against Tabcorp Holdings Ltd for breaches of the terms of their lease agreement, particularly regarding renovations and maintenance of the leased premises. The primary dispute centred on whether Tabcorp was required to make good certain renovations it had performed and the condition of the premises upon the lease's conclusion. The court had to determine the specific obligations of the tenant under the lease terms, particularly regarding maintenance, repair, and the state of the premises at the lease's end.

The court examined whether Tabcorp's actions constituted a breach of the lease's maintenance and repair obligations. The lease stipulated that the tenant must maintain the premises in good and substantial repair, except for work of a structural nature unless caused by the tenant's act or default. The court concluded that Tabcorp's renovations, which involved substantial structural changes, fell under the tenant's obligations only if they were caused by the tenant's act or default. Additionally, the court considered the tenant's obligation to yield up the premises in good and tenantable repair, which was also tied to the exceptions outlined in the maintenance clause.

The court found that Tabcorp breached the lease by carrying out structural renovations without the landlord's consent, which was not unreasonably withheld, and by failing to maintain the premises in good repair. The court set aside the lower court's orders and instead ruled that Tabcorp must pay Bowen Investments damages of $1,380,000. The court emphasised the importance of construing the lease terms holistically and highlighted that the tenant's obligations under the lease were clearly defined and must be performed as stipulated. The appeal was allowed, and costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made below be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the respondent pay to the appellant damages in the sum of $1,380,000.

3. Costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the present case the evidence was that Bowen Investments was unhappy with Tabcorp’s renovations, standard of work and finish carried out in breach of the lease. Not only do I not find the reasoning in James [1950] 1 KB 9 persuasive, the Court is bound to follow the decision in Joyner [1891] 2 QB 31, approved as it was in Graham 67 CLR 567. Joyner [1891] 2 QB 31 sets out the general rule, as Latham CJ recognised: Graham 67 CLR at 582; see also Maori Trustee [1994] 3 NZLR at 417-420 per Cooke P, Casey and Tipping JJ. The New Zealand Court of Appeal said that the rule in Joyner [1891] 2 QB 31 was a prima facie rule which should be applied unless the lessee could show, by sufficiently cogent evidence, that both in the short and longer term, the lessor will definitely suffer no loss or will suffer a loss which can be definitely assessed at less than the prima facie measure: Maori Trustee [1994] 3 NZLR at 420.FACTUAL BACKGROUND On 30 October 1996, the parties entered into heads of agreement. They contained what the heads said was a ‘make good provision’ in the following terms:‘It is acknowledged that TABCORP will, at the expiration of its occupancy, be required to hand over the premises in good and tenantable repair at the time and to make good the premises subject at all times to the normal provisions of fair wear and tear and insured risks that may, in the event of dispute, be determined by President of the Royal Australian Institute of Architects or its successor if and when necessary.’ Although it was common ground that a clause in those precise terms was not incorporated into the executed lease, the parties appear to have treated its omission, in that precise form, as somehow governing the whole of the construction of the lease. Their arguments ignored construing the lease having regard to its actual terms as a whole. And, they beguiled his Honour into considering the case on the false premise that there was an absence of a ‘general’ make good clause. The parties later negotiated the terms of the lease. As might be expected, as executed the lease covered over 40 pages, instead of the pithier nine pages comprising the heads of agreement. The lease was executed on 23 December 1996 for a term of 10 years commencing on 1 February 1997. The demised premises were described in cl 1 as being the whole of the land ‘and all improvements thereon’, including the building at 5 Bowen Crescent together with the furnitures, fixtures and other chattels described in the schedule. The net lettable area of the office component of the demised premises was delineated on a plan attached to the lease. The plan showed that the net lettable area of the ground floor, on which the foyer was located, was 397 square metres out of a total of 8,521 square metres (cl 1.2). Clause 2 of the lease set out the tenant’s covenants, relevantly as follows:‘The Tenant DOES HEREBY COVENANT with the Landlord…2.10MAINTENANCE AND REPAIRSWhen where and so often as need shall arise to maintain repair and keep the whole of the Demised Premises in good and substantial repair working order and condition and in particular all fixtures fittings and things thereto belonging or which at any time shall with the approval of the Landlord be erected therein or thereon or any part thereof damage by Act of God, war damage and fire, fusion, theft, explosion, storm and tempest, lightning, subsidence or collapse, riot, strikes, impact by vehicles or aircraft, articles dropped from aircraft, sprinkler leakage, water damage and malicious damage reasonable wear and tear only excepted (save where any insurance moneys are irrecoverable by the Landlord by reason of the neglect default or misconduct of the Tenant) PROVIDED HOWEVER that nothing herein contained shall impose any obligation upon the Tenant to do any work of a structural nature except such as may be occasioned by the act neglect misuse or default of or by the Tenant or relating to the Tenant’s use or occupancy of the Demised Premises.2.11YIELDING UPAt the expiration or sooner determination of this Lease peaceably to surrender and yield to the Landlord the whole of the Demised Premises and every part thereof and the fixtures and fittings of the Landlord in good and tenantable repair order and condition in all respects (but subject to the exceptions described in Clause 2.10) and clean and free from rubbish in accordance with the Tenant’s obligations under the Lease. Any dispute under this clause as to the condition of the Demised Premises shall be determined by the President for the time being of the Royal Australian Institute of Architects (or its successor body) or his or her nominee whose decision shall be binding on the parties.2.12 TENANT’S OBLIGATIONS TO MAINTAIN PREMISESAt all times during the term without affecting the generality of the preceding two sub-clauses of this clause at its expense:…2.12.4MAKE GOOD BREAKAGESfrom time to time to make good any breakage or damage to the building or any part thereof or to any adjacent or adjoining building or any facility or appurtenance thereof occasioned by want of care misuse or abuse on the part of the Tenant or any person claiming through or under the Tenant or otherwise occasioned by any breach or default of the Tenant hereunder or by any other cause for which the Tenant ought reasonably to be responsible provided that nothing herein contained shall impose any obligation upon the Tenant to do any work of a structural nature or to replace any fixtures, fittings, plant, furnishings and equipment except such as may be occasioned by the act neglect misuse or default of or by the Tenant or relating to the Tenant’s use or occupancy of the Demised Premises.…2.12.7ON VACATING DEMISED PREMISESupon vacating the Demised Premises or immediately prior thereto to return all keys to the Demised Premises and at the request of the Landlord to remove any signs names advertisements or notices erected painted displayed affixed or exhibited upon to or within the Demised Premises and to make good any damage or disfigurement caused by reason of such erection painting displaying affixing exhibiting or removal thereof and on default the Landlord may execute such work and recover the cost thereof from the Tenant PROVIDED ALWAYS that either party may at its option in lieu of the Tenant’s obligations to redecorate the Demised Premises and/or remove all partitions and make good pursuant to this clause, require the Tenant (or agrees) to pay to the Landlord the estimated cost of such redecoration and/or removal of partitions and making good the premises and in default of payment the Landlord may recover the estimated costs thereof from the Tenant. Any dispute shall be determined by the President for the time being of the Royal Australian Institute of Architects (or its successor body) or his or her nominee whose decision shall be binding on the parties.2.13ALTERATIONS AND ADDITIONSNot without the written approval of the Landlord first obtained (which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or delayed) to make or permit to be made any substantial alteration or addition to the Demised Premises or to any Landlord’s fixtures or fittings therein and when applying for such approval to submit to the Landlord for perusal full and clear plans specifications and other details as the Landlord may reasonably require and to pay such reasonable fees and expenses as the Landlord may occur in obtaining reports and advice on such plans specifications and details from architects engineers builders and other professional persons and in having any works inspected and in the event of such approval being given at his own expense to cause the alterations or additions so approved to be carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner by a builder or other contractor approved by the Landlord and under the supervision of the Landlord’s architect. The Tenant must ensure that such alterations and additions do not void any warranties on any of the building works or installations the details of which warranties have been notified to the Tenant by the Landlord in writing. In the event that any of the warranties are so voided the Tenant acknowledges that it is fully liable in this regard.2.14PARTITIONSTo install in the Demised Premises internal partitions of a proper quality having regard to the condition of the Building by a builder or other contractor and under the supervision of an architect as may be nominated by the Tenant acting reasonably from time to time and not make any substantial additions or alterations to the said partitions except with the approval of the Landlord (which approval cannot be unreasonably withheld or delayed) and by a builder or other contractor and under the supervision of an architect nominated as aforesaid and the Tenant hereby agrees and acknowledges that:…2.14.6all damage done to the Demised Premises or the Building or services by reason of the installation or removal of any partition shall be made good by the Tenant and if the Tenant fails to do so the Landlord may make good all such damage at the expense of the Tenant.…3.2REMOVAL OF FIXTURES BY TENANTThat subject to Clause 2.14 hereof the Tenant may at or prior to the expiration of this Lease take remove and carry away from the Demised Premises all fixtures fittings plant equipment or other articles including partitions upon the Demised Premises in the nature of trade or Tenant’s fixtures brought upon the Demised Premises by the Tenant PROVIDED that the tenant shall in such removal forthwith make good any damage which the Tenant may occasion thereto and shall remove all rubbish and shall leave the Demised Premises in a clean state and condition.…’ (non-italic emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

It may well be appropriate for the Court to grant declaratory relief as to the proper construction of the lease in the events which have happened, so as to make clear the following:(a)the primary judge’s finding of the breach of cl 2.13 by Tabcorp in July and August 1997;(b)the breach of cll 2.10, 2.11 and 2.12 on 31 January 2006 or 2007 by Tabcorp of its obligation to make good.CONCLUSION For these reasons I am of opinion that the appeal should succeed, but I would have allowed the parties to address us on the relief that ought be granted. I would have directed the parties to prepare draft orders reflecting the results reached in these reasons and, if there were disagreement between them, those draft orders should have been supplemented by written submissions and, if necessary, oral argument.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

That emphasises the importance of construing the particular terms of the lease at hand to ascertain what state of repair the parties contemplated in cl 2.10, having regard to cl 2.13.CONSIDERATION The principal problem with the present proceedings, from their inception, is that the parties ignored the construction of the lease as a whole, searched for and did not find a particular clause reflecting exactly what had been included in the heads of agreement and sought relief to amend, or resist the amendment of, the lease so as to incorporate such a clause. However, the ordinary and natural meaning of the provisions of cl 2, which are set out above, reveal that the parties objectively intended that Tabcorp, as tenant, would have to make good structural changes it effected without Bowen Investments’ consent, unless that consent was unreasonably withheld: Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165 at 179 [40] per Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Callinan and Heydon JJ; Zhu 218 CLR per the Court at 559 [82]. Thus, cl 2.10 posed an obligation on Tabcorp, when, where and so often as the need would arise, ‘to maintain repair and keep the whole of the demised premises in good and substantial repair working order and condition’. In my opinion, the work that was done to destroy the newly built lobby, and then replace it, could not be characterised as falling within the compass of cl 2.10. That work did not maintain, repair or keep the demised premises. Rather it involved the destruction of a part of them and, then, its refashioning. In addition, cl 2.10 also provided that the principal obligation of maintenance, repair and keeping extended to all fixtures, fittings and things belonging to demised premises ‘… which at any time shall with the approval of the landlord be erected therein or thereon or any part thereof…’ (emphasis added). This made it clear that structural alterations for which Bowen Investments had given consent, such as under cl 2.13, attracted the obligation to maintain, repair and keep to which the introductory words of the clause referred. And, if the parties had not by then made their meaning plain enough, the proviso at the conclusion of cl 2.10 excepted from the obligations of the tenant, any work of a structural nature ‘except such as may be occasioned by the act … or default of or by the Tenant or relating to the Tenant’s use or occupancy of the Demised Premises’. The work done by Tabcorp in July-August 1997 fell within the latter description. It was structural work occasioned by the direct act of Tabcorp. The work related to its use and occupancy of the building. At the trial, and in the pleadings, no attention was paid to cl 2.10, nor does it seem to have been relied on before the primary judge. Rather the parties concentrated on the effect of cl 2.11. This provided relevantly that, at the expiration of the lease, Tabcorp’s obligation was peaceably to surrender and yield up to Bowen Investments the whole of the demised premises and every part of it together with the fixtures and fittings of the landlord ‘in good and tenable repair, order and condition in all respects (but subject to the exceptions described in Clause 2.10) …’. Once again, the obligation to yield up the premises at the conclusion of the lease was related to the exceptions referred to in cl 2.10. What was good and tenantable repair, order and condition in all respects was in part, at least, to be ascertained by Tabcorp’s performance of the obligation under cl 2.10 to maintain, repair and keep the whole of the demised premises in good and substantial repair working order and condition during the currency of the lease.