North East Solution Pty Ltd v Masters Home Improvement Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL COURT
List c

S CI 2012 02700

NORTH EAST SOLUTION PTY LTD (ACN 129 466 851)
Plaintiff
v

MASTERS HOME IMPROVEMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (FORMERLY SHELLBELT PTY LTD) (ABN 21 066 891 307)

First Defendant

and

WOOLWORTHS LIMITED (ABN 88 000 014 675)

Second Defendant

---

JUDGE:

CROFT J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

18–21 May, 25–28 May, 1–4 June, 17–18 August and 16–17 September 2015

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

28 January 2016

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

North East Solution Pty Ltd v Masters Home Improvement Australia Pty Ltd

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2016] VSC 1

---

CONTRACT – Good faith – Enforceability of agreement to negotiate in good faith – Breach of obligation to act reasonably and in good faith – Relationship between obligation to act “reasonably” and obligation to act “in good faith” – Burger King Corporation v Hungry Jack’s Pty Ltd (2001) 69 NSWLR 558 – Construction of commercial contracts – Terms implied in order to give business efficacy to agreement – Incorporation of terms of earlier agreement into subsequent agreement – Different named parties in subsequent agreement.

DAMAGES – Quantification of loss and damage – Lost opportunity to develop and lease land – Date at which damages are assessed – Capitalisation of Income method of valuation not the most appropriate method of estimating loss and damage – Discounted Cash Flow method of valuation – Sellars discount – Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff P.J. Bick QC with
B. Gibson
Tisher Liner FC Law
For the Defendants P.D. Crutchfield QC with
N. McAteer
Minter Ellison

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction........................................................................................................................................ 1

Evidence............................................................................................................................................... 3

Approach to the evidence................................................................................................................. 5

Agreements between the parties..................................................................................................... 7

Contractual framework................................................................................................................... 16

Letter of Offer........................................................................................................ 16

Agreement for Lease............................................................................................ 23

Nature and effect of contractual obligations.............................................................................. 35

Factual issues.................................................................................................................................... 58

Letter of Offer..................................................................................................................... 58

Costing of generic design briefs...................................................................................... 59

Agreement for Lease......................................................................................................... 61

Events preceding negotiation of Landlord’s Works Costs.......................................... 61

Discussions regarding Masters’ contribution to Landlord’s Works Costs............... 67

The 22 April 2010 meeting.............................................................................................. 106

Events after 22 April 2010............................................................................................... 119

Plaintiff’s allegations of breach.................................................................................................. 121

Woolworths did not act reasonably to identify and resolve any differences......... 127

Role of Vaughan Constructions..................................................................................... 136

Woolworths did not act in good faith to identify and resolve any differences...... 146

Woolworths’ unwillingness to engage with NES.......................................... 146

The effect of Woolworths’ undisclosed budget............................................. 148

Other matters affecting Woolworths’ performance of its obligations..................... 151

Pursuit of the Hume & Iser site........................................................................ 151

Other considerations.......................................................................................... 159

Greater Bendigo City Council opposition...................................................... 159

Financial position of NES.................................................................................. 161

Agreement for Lease terminated by Woolworths for reasons not contemplated by its terms................................................................................................................................ 164

Conclusion in relation to liability.............................................................................................. 168

Loss and damage............................................................................................................................ 173

Applicable principles...................................................................................................... 173

What was the opportunity lost by NES?...................................................................... 180

Would NES have acted on the opportunity had it been offered?............................ 183

Did the opportunity have some (not negligible) value?............................................ 185

Would agreement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read North East Solution Pty Ltd v Masters Home Improvement Austr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] VSC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

North East Solution Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Masters Home Improvement Australia Pty Ltd, seeking damages for breach of contract. The dispute arose from an agreement where the parties intended to negotiate in good faith to reach a binding agreement for the development and leasing of land. The Central Australia District Court was tasked with determining the enforceability of the agreement to negotiate in good faith and whether there was a breach of the obligation to act reasonably and in good faith. The court also had to consider the relationship between the obligations to act reasonably and in good faith, as well as the appropriate method for quantifying the loss and damages.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the agreement to negotiate in good faith was enforceable and if there had been a breach of the obligation to act reasonably and in good faith. The court considered the implications of Burger King Corporation v Hungry Jack’s Pty Ltd and examined whether terms implied in law or equity could give business efficacy to the agreement. Additionally, the court deliberated on the incorporation of terms from an earlier agreement into a subsequent agreement, despite the involvement of different parties.

The court found that the agreement to negotiate in good faith was enforceable and that there had been a breach of the obligation to act reasonably and in good faith. It held that the obligation to act reasonably and in good faith encompasses a duty to engage in negotiations with a view to reaching an agreement, if possible. The court also concluded that the obligation to act in good faith did not simply mean acting honestly but also entailed acting in a manner that did not undermine the negotiation process. Regarding the quantification of loss and damages, the court determined that the Capitalisation of Income method was not the most appropriate, opting instead for the Discounted Cash Flow method. It further applied the Sellars discount in accordance with Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL, which required a reduction of the profit stream to account for the inherent uncertainties in the business.

The court ordered Masters Home Improvement Australia Pty Ltd to pay damages to North East Solution Pty Ltd, quantified using the Discounted Cash Flow method with the Sellars discount applied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established