Jennifer Tyack formerly t/as Country Kidz v Cain

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Jennifer Tyack formerly t/as Country Kidz v Cain [2007] NSWWCCPD 119

APPELLANT:  Jennifer Tyack formerly t/as Country Kidz

RESPONDENT:  Sharmaine Cain

INSURER:QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC7179-06

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          8 September 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  23 May 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Procedural fairness; admissibility of late evidence; injury; whether decision supported by the evidence and weight of evidence; errors of fact, law and discretion; inadequate reasons for decision, and onus of proof of injury.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Deputy President Gary Byron

HEARING:Determined on the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant Employer: Bartier Perry Solicitors

Respondent Worker: Matthews Williams

Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator dated 8 September 2006 is revoked.  The matter is remitted to the same Arbitrator to determine afresh in accordance with these reasons, and the findings made herein.

No order is made as to the costs of this appeal. 

BACKGROUND

  1. Ms Sharmaine Cain, the Respondent Worker, was employed by the Appellant Employer, Jennifer Tyack formerly trading as Country Kidz (‘Country Kidz’), as a part-time shop assistant.  Country Kidz was insured by QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘QBE’) at the relevant time.

  1. Ms Cain commenced employment with Country Kidz in September 2004.  She alleges that on 8 December 2004 she suffered injury to her back and left leg as a result of tripping over while attempting to exit the window display area, in the course of her employment with Country Kidz.  Documents in the relevant Commission file indicate variously that both 8 December and 9 December 2004, are each the date of the alleged injury.  However, Ms Cain’s ‘Application’ filed in the Commission and the Arbitrator indicate that the date was in fact, 8 December 2004, and I accept that to be correct.  Ms Cain claims to have given notice of the injury to Country Kidz on the same day.  On 9 December 2004 she attended the Condobolin Medical Centre and consulted Dr M Kyrillos who prescribed analgesic and anti-inflammatory medication.  He issued her with a certificate for selected duties. She claims that she took two weeks recreation leave, and that her employment was terminated on 17 December 2004.   However, a fax dated 29 April 2005 from Country Kidz states that Ms Cain verbally resigned on 10 December 2004.

  1. On 4 January 2005 Ms Cain lodged a claim for compensation with QBE for injuries sustained on 8 December 2004, alleging injury to her lower back. On 6 January 2005 QBE wrote to Ms Cain and confirmed that although she was fit for selected duties, her employer, Country Kidz, was unable to provide her with suitable employment. QBE further advised that while seeking suitable employment, Ms Cain was entitled to receive weekly payments of $311.63 gross for a period of 52 weeks effective from 6 January 2005 in accordance with section 38 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’), and that, “In order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jennifer Tyack formerly t/as Country Kidz v Cain and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jennifer Tyack, trading as Country Kidz, filed an appeal against a decision rendered by an arbitrator, with the respondent being Ms. Cain. The central dispute revolves around the admission of new evidence in the appeal, specifically whether the tribunal should allow the introduction of a centre board that was part of the boundary of the window display in the Country Kidz shop and a statement from Jennifer Tyack. The appeal was heard by the tribunal, which had to decide on the admissibility of this new evidence under Practice Direction No 6.

The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the new evidence, namely the centre board and the additional statement from Jennifer Tyack, could be introduced in the appeal. This required the tribunal to consider whether the new evidence could not reasonably have been obtained earlier and whether its exclusion would cause a substantial injustice. The tribunal also needed to assess whether the procedural requirements outlined in Practice Direction No 6 were followed. Additionally, the tribunal had to consider the objection raised by Country Kidz’ solicitor to the Arbitrator’s questioning of Ms. Cain towards the end of the arbitration proceedings, and how this affected the admissibility of the new evidence.

The tribunal examined the procedural history and the rationale behind the introduction of the new evidence. It found that the centre board and the additional statement from Jennifer Tyack were relevant to the dispute and could not reasonably have been obtained earlier due to the inconsistencies in Ms. Cain’s accounts of her injury. The tribunal also noted that the failure to admit this evidence would result in a substantial injustice, as it would prevent the tribunal from making a fully informed decision. Furthermore, the tribunal considered the objection raised by Country Kidz’ solicitor and acknowledged the procedural unfairness that resulted from the Arbitrator’s questioning of Ms. Cain without Country Kidz’ presence. The tribunal concluded that the new evidence should be admitted as it was necessary to achieve justice in the case.

The tribunal allowed the introduction of the new evidence, granting Country Kidz’ application. It determined that the centre board and the additional statement from Jennifer Tyack were relevant and necessary to address the inconsistencies in Ms. Cain’s accounts and to ensure a fair and just resolution of the appeal. The tribunal’s decision was based on the balance of convenience and the need to prevent substantial injustice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Practice Direction No 6 sets out the process for seeking leave of the Commission to give ‘new evidence’ on appeal. It provides as follows:“New EvidenceWhere a party seeks leave to give new evidence in relation to the decision appealed against, that party must serve a copy of the new evidence on the other parties to the dispute when serving the Application or Opposition.In general, the Commission will allow new evidence to be introduced only where it can be demonstrated that the new evidence could not reasonably have been obtained by the party and tendered in proceedings before the Arbitrator and that failure to allow the new evidence would cause a substantial injustice in the circumstances of the individual case.” Practice Direction No 6 also provides that if new evidence is sought to be relied upon, the Application or Opposition to the Appeal must contain: Country Kidz’ solicitors seek leave to introduce fresh, or perhaps more specifically, “additional” evidence, in this appeal. The first item is the ‘centre board’ that formed part of the boundary of the window display in the Country Kidz shop, over which Ms Cain alleged, in responding to a question by the Arbitrator, she tripped on 8 December 2004. Country Kidz submit that this is the same centre board as shown in the schedule of photographs filed with its ‘Application to Admit Late Documents’ dated 10 July 2006. The covering letter states that copies of the documents were served on Ms Cain’s solicitors by letter, via express post, on the same date. The second item of additional evidence is a further statement of Jennifer Tyack dated 5 October 2006 confirming that the centre board, which Country Kidz seeks leave to introduce as fresh or additional evidence, is the centre board that was situated between the two pieces of lattice over which Ms Cain alleges she tripped and which is shown in photographs filed with the ‘Application to Admit Late Documents’ dated 10 July 2006. Country Kidz submits that the reason why this evidence, specifically the centre board, was not given during the proceedings before the Arbitrator, is that during the arbitration proceedings there were inconsistencies in Ms Cain’s evidence, including her various accounts of how she tripped, specifically, whether she caught her foot on the lattice at the end of the display or whether she tripped as she attempted to step over the centre board between the two pieces of lattice. Towards the end of the arbitration proceedings the Arbitrator indicated that he would ask Ms Cain some questions to clarify the circumstances of her alleged injury. County Kidz’ solicitor submits that he strenuously objected to any questions being asked at that late stage of the proceedings in circumstances where there was no representative of Country Kidz present to have the opportunity of investigating or responding to any evidence Ms Cain gave in answer to the Arbitrator’s questions. Nevertheless, the Arbitrator proceeded to ask Ms Cain questions about the manner in which she injured herself. In her answer, Ms Cain stated that she stepped over the centre board, and that her left foot was on the ledge on the interior side of the centre board. When she went to step out her right foot clipped “the lattice”. In responding to a question in clarification by the Arbitrator, she further stated:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established