APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
__________________________________________________________________
| CITATION: | Raisebore Pty Limited v Brendyn Wilson [2003] NSWWCCPD 40 |
| APPELLANT: | Raisebore Pty Limited |
| RESPONDENT: | Brendyn David Wilson |
| INSURER: | Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited |
| FILE NO: | WCC 2095-2002 |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 19 December, 2003 |
| PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: | Deputy President Gary Byron |
| DECISION UNDER APPEAL: | Application for Leave to appeal against a decision of an Arbitrator |
| DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: | 15 April 2003 |
| HEARING: | Decision made on the papers |
| REPRESENTATION: | Appellant: Stella Tarpouka, Goldbergs Lawyers |
| Respondent: Paul Keady, Paul Keady & Associates Solicitors | |
| ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: | The decision of the Arbitrator is confirmed except that order number 2 is revoked and the following order is made in lieu thereof: The Appellant Employer is to pay to the Respondent Worker, pursuant to section 38 of the 1987 Act, the sum of $1095.36 per week, subject to the provisions of section 35 of that Act, during such periods where the Respondent Worker was partially incapacitated, but the Respondent Employer failed to provide suitable employment. The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of this appeal, as agreed or assessed. |
THE APPEAL
On 12 May, 2003 Raisebore Pty Limited (the Respondent in the original proceedings and the ‘Appellant Employer’ in this appeal), lodged an ‘Application for Appeal Against a Decision of an Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’), against a decision dated 15 April, 2003. The Respondent to the appeal is Brendyn David Wilson, (the Applicant in the original proceedings and the ‘Respondent Worker’ in this Appeal). The Insurer is Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited, (‘the Insurer’).
THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW
The Certificate of Determination dated 15 April, 2003 sets out the decision of the Arbitrator as follows:
1) Respondent to pay the Applicant, pursuant to section 36 of the Act, the sum of $1259.20 per week for periods of total incapacity on and from 22 February 2002 for an aggregate up to a period of 26 weeks but subject to the incremental adjustments in the statutory limits imposed by s35 of the Act.
2) Respondent to pay the Applicant, pursuant to Section 38 of the Act, the sum of $1281.30 per week (subject to the incremental adjustments in the statutory rate prescribed in s35 of the Act) during such periods where the Applicant was partially incapacitated but the Respondent failed to provide suitable employment.
3) Respondent to pay the Applicant, pursuant to Section 40 of the Act, during such period where the Applicant was partially incapacitated but employed by the Respondent on reduced hours thus reflecting a reduction of his weekly earnings, the difference between his probable earnings of $1369.20 per week and his actual earnings during such weeks but subject to the appropriate statutory rate for a worker with one dependent child.
4) Respondent to pay the Applicant the sum of $1299.70 from 12 December 2002 (noting that the employer has refused to provide suitable duties) pursuant to Section 38(3)(b), and at the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Raisebore Pty Limited v Brendyn Wilson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWWCCPD 40
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the Appellant Employer was required to pay the Respondent Worker additional compensation for periods of partial incapacity when the Respondent Worker was not provided with suitable employment, as per section 42(6) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996. Another issue was whether new evidence, specifically a statement by Mr. Dave Hunter, could be admitted in the appeal process.
The Court found that the base wage, hourly roster rate, and bonus payment per hour were integral parts of the ordinary rate of remuneration for the Respondent Worker, and thus were not excluded under section 42(6)(b) or (c) of the 1996 Act. The rates applied generally to the classification of workers and were not "one-off" arrangements. Furthermore, the Court held that the Respondent Worker was employed to work 56 hours per week, contrary to the agreed average of 40 hours per week for rate-setting purposes. The Arbitrator’s findings were upheld, and the Appellant Employer was required to compensate the Respondent Worker for the periods of partial incapacity.
Consequently, the decision of the Arbitrator was confirmed, with the modification that the Appellant Employer must pay the Respondent Worker $1095.36 per week for the periods of partial incapacity. Additionally, the Appellant Employer was ordered to pay the Respondent Worker's costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
The decision of the Arbitrator is confirmed except that order number 2 is revoked and the following order is made in lieu thereof:
The Appellant Employer is to pay to the Respondent Worker, pursuant to section 38 of the 1987 Act, the sum of $1095.36 per week, subject to the provisions of section 35 of that Act, during such periods where the Respondent Worker was partially incapacitated, but the Respondent Employer failed to provide suitable employment.
The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of this appeal, as agreed or assessed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appeal was heard by the Commission constituted by a Presidential member. The Appellant had filed an application for leave to appeal, which was granted on 27 August 2003. The matter proceeded on the papers, with both parties consenting to this approach. The Appellant sought to introduce new evidence, which the Respondent opposed. The Commission was required to determine whether the new evidence should be admitted. The decision to confirm the Arbitrator’s decision, with modifications to the compensation amount, was made on 27 August 2003.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Australian Workplace Agreement that was signed by both parties in the instant matter, sets out in clause 10(a), the rates of pay that apply to the various classifications of work, being the base wage rate per hour, the hourly roster rate and the bonus payment per hour. At clause 10(b) it itemizes a range of factors that were taken into account in setting these rates. At clause 10(c) it states: The rates of pay provided for in (a) above shall be increased in line with any increases to the ‘Driller’ classification contained within the Drilling and Exploration Industry (AWU) Award (‘the Award’) which apply after the 1st July, 1999.” These rates have general application to particular classifications of workers and were not “one-off” arrangements for the Respondent Worker. They do not fall within the range of payments set out in section 42(6)(a). Having regard to the decision in Lismore City Council v Garland, and the reasons stated in that case, it is my view that the base wage per hour, the hourly roster rate and the bonus payment per hour have the same standing as the industry allowance in that case, that is, together they comprise and are subsumed into, the ordinary rate of remuneration routinely paid to workers in a particular classification under the terms of an Australian Workplace Agreement, and in line with the Award specified in that Agreement. Consequently, they are not excluded by the operation of s42(6)(b) or (c) of the 1987 Act. In a letter dated January 31, 2001 the Appellant Employer gave notice of a change in pay rate consequent upon what was effectively, a promotion to the next level of the same job, that is, “Driller”. However, the same considerations apply. The rates have general application across the classification of Driller Level 2. The base wage per hour, the hourly roster rate and the bonus payment per hour together, are integral to and were subsumed into, the ordinary rate of remuneration routinely paid to the Respondent Worker and others at Level 2. This treatment is reflected in the payslip of the Respondent Worker and no distinction is made between the three elements that make up his ordinary remuneration. This is the same treatment as for the industry allowance in Lismore City Council v Garland (supra): This is clearly the way the employer itself regards the allowance as demonstrated by the agreed fact that the pay docket of the worker contains no mention of the industry allowance. It is simply subsumed in the wage rate of the worker. It does not vary from week to week by reference to features peculiar to the hours worked or varying nature of the conditions of the work. Clause 9(a) of the Australian Workplace Agreement, provides: “You will be required to work in a roster which is determined as appropriate to meet the overall production requirements of each project. For the purpose of establishing rates of pay the ‘ordinary hours’ of work shall be deemed to average 40 hours per week.” Notwithstanding that a deeming average of 40 hours per week is agreed as (and limited to) the basis for establishing rates of pay, the fact is, as found by the Arbitrator on the evidence before him, that the Respondent Worker was actually employed by the Appellant Employer to work a roster of 56 hours per week, at the relevant time. These were his ordinary hours, as a matter of fact, regardless of the basis used for establishing “rates” of pay. On my reading of the Australian Workplace Agreement and on a consideration of the evidence, including the evidence put forward by the Appellant Employer, the Arbitrator’s conclusion in this regard was soundly based.