SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY - GENERALLY
SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY - LOSS OR LACK OF CAPACITY AND STATUTORY WILLS
An application was made by the defendant's parents pursuant to section 7 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) for an order authorising the making of a will on behalf of the defendant. The defendant is aged 23 years and severely disabled as a result of an injury at birth. The defendant's condition is permanent with no prospect of recovery. Whether permission to proceed with the application should be granted. Whether the defendant lacks testamentary capacity. Whether the proposed will would accurately reflect the likely intentions of the defendant if he had testamentary capacity. Whether it is reasonable in all the circumstances that the order should be made.
Held per Gray J (authorising the making of the statutory will):
(1) There exist good reasons to grant leave to proceed with the application. Permission granted (at [13]).
(2) The defendant lacks testamentary capacity (at [16]-[23]).
(3) The proposed will reflects the defendant's likely intentions (at [24]-[43]).
(4) It is desirable for an intestacy to be avoided by the granting of an order allowing the application for a statutory will (at [44]-[49]).
In the Matter of SHAUN ARTHUR PICKLES [2013] SASC 175
Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction
GRAY J.
On 6 November 2013, in response to an application pursuant to section 7 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) and rule 98 of the Probate Rules 2004 (SA) I made an order authorising the making of a will on behalf of Shaun Arthur Pickles. The order included the following:
1.The plaintiffs have permission pursuant to section 7(1) of the Wills Act 1936 to make application on behalf of the proposed testator for an order authorising a will to be made for the proposed testator in the terms of the copy will annexed hereto.
2.The Court approves and authorises the making of a will on behalf of the proposed testator in the terms of the copy will annexed hereto.[1]
3.The will made pursuant to this Order (“the Will”) be signed by the Registrar of Probates and be sealed with the seal of the Court.
4.The Will be retained by the Registrar of Probates and not be withdrawn from deposit with the Registrar by or on…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of Shaun Arthur Pickles and more:
The case of In the Matter of Shaun Arthur Pickles involved Shaun Pickles, who was born with cerebral palsy and lacks testamentary capacity due to his condition. Shaun's parents, Mr and Ms Pickles, sought authorisation to make a statutory will on his behalf under section 7 of the Wills Act. The parents argued that Shaun's substantial estate should not go into intestacy, and the proposed will appointed them as executors with a substitution for the Public Trustee. Shaun's sister, KLP, who was joined as an interested party, did not oppose the application.
The legal issues before the court were whether Shaun lacked testamentary capacity and whether the proposed will reflected his likely intentions, making it desirable to avoid intestacy. The court found that Shaun lacked testamentary capacity and was unlikely to ever gain it. The court also determined that the proposed will reflected Shaun's likely intentions and that it was desirable to avoid intestacy by granting the application for a statutory will.
The court reasoned that Shaun's condition and the substantial nature of his estate provided good reasons to grant leave to proceed with the application. The court found no opposition to the order and acknowledged that the terms of the will may need reassessment if circumstances change in the future. The court concluded that the proposed will was in Shaun's best interests and granted the application for a statutory will.
The final orders were that permission was granted to proceed with the application, Shaun was found to lack testamentary capacity, the proposed will reflected Shaun's likely intentions, and it was desirable to avoid intestacy by granting the application for a statutory will.
Orders
Orders of the court
Held per Gray J (authorising the making of the statutory will):
(1) There exist good reasons to grant leave to proceed with the application. Permission granted (at [13]).
(2) The defendant lacks testamentary capacity (at [16]-[23]).
(3) The proposed will reflects the defendant's likely intentions (at [24]-[43]).
(4) It is desirable for an intestacy to be avoided by the granting of an order allowing the application for a statutory will (at [44]-[49]).
Background
Background to the litigation
My reasons for making the order authorising the making of a statutory will on Shaun’s behalf follow.Background Shaun was born on 20 October 1990 with cerebral palsy which affects his legs, arms and upper body as a result of an injury at birth. His condition is permanent with no prospect of recovery. He is aged 23 years. Shaun requires full-time care. He is not independent in any of the tasks of daily living and requires assistance with feeding, toileting, dressing and mobility. He also experiences additional difficulties with breathing and swallowing. Shaun’s ability to communicate is impaired. He has a very limited vocabulary and can only put three or four words together. Shaun does not attend school. He attends a private home each day at a Day Options Program for the disabled called Comrec. Mr and Ms Pickles are full-time carers for Shaun. Ms Pickles herself is on a disability support pension and is also considered a carer for Shaun for social security purposes. Mr Pickles is a full-time carer for Shaun and for Ms Pickles. Shaun has one sibling, KLP, who is aged 16 years. Ms Williams has been Shaun’s carer since 1995. Ms Williams has worked with children and adults with disabilities since the early 1990s and has been employed by Intellectual Disability Services at Mt Gambier and undertaken a course of certification. On 22 February 2010, in the District Court of South Australia, Shaun was awarded damages in the amount of $7,000,000.00 inclusive of both interest and costs. The Public Trustee was appointed manager to take possession of, and control and manage that part of Shaun’s estate. On 31 May 2010, Mr and Ms Pickles, were appointed full joint guardians and limited administrators of Shaun and his estate, pursuant to an order of the Guardianship Board. On 14 May 2013, a summons was issued at the request of Mr and Ms Pickles that the Court approve and authorise the making of a will on behalf of Shaun in terms of a draft will attached to their joint affidavit sworn on 23 April 2013, pursuant to section 7 of the Wills Act. The proposed will appoints Mr and Ms Pickles as executors, with substitution for the Public Trustee. The terms of the will are set out in the Schedule to these reasons. On 21 May 2013, Gaetano Aiello was appointed by the Registrar of Probates as guardian ad litem for Shaun. On 27 June 2013, Shaun’s sister, KLP, was joined as an interested party to the proceeding. KLP is represented by Ms Millard. The Application Section 7 of the Wills Act empowers the Court to authorise the making of a will on behalf of a person who lacks testamentary capacity. The legislation contemplates a two-stage process: an application for permission to proceed and, upon that permission being granted, an application for an order authorising the will.[2] In proceedings such as this, where the application is not obviously without merit, it is appropriate that leave to proceed and the substantial application be heard concurrently.[3] The purpose of a grant of leave to proceed is to provide a mechanism by which baseless or unmeritorious applications are screened out.[4] For the reasons that follow, the within application is not such a case. Shaun lacks testamentary capacity and is unlikely to ever gain that capacity. His estate is substantial. It is sensible that Shaun’s assets should not go on intestacy.[5] Accordingly, there exist good reasons to grant leave to proceed with the application.[6] [2] See Bryant v Blake (2004) 237 LSJS 23, 28.[3] Hoffmann v Waters (2007) 98 SASR 500, [10].[4] Hoffmann v Waters (2007) 98 SASR 500, [10] citing Monger v Taylor [2000] VSC 304, [22]; see eg Boulton v Sanders (2004) 9 VR 495, [11]; Bryant v Blake (2004) 237 LSJS 23, [28]; see also Re Fenwick (2009) 76 NSWLR 22, [119]-[125].[5] See Re Palmer [2003] VSC 21, [17].[6] See Hoffmann v Waters (2007) 98 SASR 500, [10].
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
GRAY J
Finally, it is to be reiterated that there was no opposition by any person to the order that was made. The parties acknowledged that should there be a change of circumstances in the future, it will be necessary to return to this Court to reassess the terms of the will.Conclusion On the bases described above, I am satisfied that the proposed will reflects Shaun’s likely intentions and that it is desirable for an intestacy to be avoided by the granting of an order allowing the application for a statutory will.ScheduleTHIS IS THE LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT of SHAUN ARTHUR PICKLES of 5 Veldarose Lane Mount Gambier in the State of South Australia authorised by an order dated the day of November 2013 made under section 7 of the Wills Act, 1936.1. I REVOKE all former wills and testamentary dispositions made by me.2.I APPOINT my mother KAREN LEE PICKLES and my father STEVEN ARTHUR PICKLES to be the executors and trustees of this my will HOWEVER if both my said parents predecease me or are unwilling or unable to act as executor and trustee of this my will then I APPOINT PUBLIC TRUSTEE of 211 Victoria Square Adelaide in the State of South Australia to be executor and trustee of this my will (hereinafter referred to as “my trustee”).3. I GIVE AND BEQUEATH:(a) A legacy of two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000.00) to my sister [KLP] provided that she shall survive me and have attained or shall live to attain the age of twenty-one (21) years.(b) A legacy of two hundred and fifty thousand dollars ($250,000.00) or ten per centum (10%) of the net value of my estate at the date of my death, whichever is the lesser amount to MARGARET JOY WILLIAMS provided she shall survive me .4.I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the rest of my real and personal estate of whatsoever nature and wheresoever situated UPON TRUST to sell call in and convert into money or such part or parts of my estate as do not consist of money with power to postpone such sale calling in and conversion or any part or parts thereof for so long as my trustee thinks fit and to retain my estate or any part of my estate in the same state of investment as it is in at my death without being responsible for loss and out of the proceeds of any such sale calling in and conversion and out of my ready money to pay my funeral and testamentary expenses and debts and all duties in connection with my estate (without apportioning or adjusting any of such duties between the beneficiaries under this my will) and to stand possessed of the residue of the monies produced by any such sale calling in and conversion and of my ready money and of such parts of my estate as remain unconverted respectively (“my residuary estate”) for such of my mother the said KAREN LEE PICKLES and my father the said STEVEN ARTHUR PICKLES as are living at my death and if both then equally between them.5.IF both my mother the said KAREN LEE PICKLES and my father the said STEVEN ARTHUR PICKLES predecease me then I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the rest of my real and personal estate of whatsoever nature and wheresoever situated to my trustee for my sister [KLP] PROVIDED THAT she shall survive me and shall live to attain the age of twenty-one (21) years.6.I DECLARE that if my sister the said [KLP] predeceases me leaving a child or children who survive me then such child or children will take and if more than one then equally between them the share in my estate which his her or their mother would have taken had she survived me PROVIDED THAT each shall have attained or shall live to attain the age of twenty-one (21) years. 7.I EMPOWER my trustee to apply at any time the whole or such part in each case as my trustee thinks fit of the capital and income of the expectant or presumptive share of any person in my estate for or towards his or her advancement maintenance education or benefit and either my trustee to apply the same or pay the same to the guardian or guardians for the time being of a person who may be a minor for the purposes aforesaid or any of them without seeing to the application thereof.8.I DIRECT that if the trusts for the disposition of my residuary estate totally fail or determine then subject to such trusts my trustee will stand possessed of the capital and income of my residuary estate UPON TRUST as follows:8.1 For the said MARGARET JOY WILLIAMS provided she shall survive me; HOWEVER8.2 IF the said MARGARET JOY WILLIAMS predeceases me then my trustee shall establish a fund known as the SHAUN PICKLES FOUNDATION (“the fund”) and to invest the fund as authorised by law and to apply the net income of the fund each financial year to any such charitable institution in Australia which at the time of applying the net income of the fund is registered as a Deductible Gift Recipient pursuant to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) in such proportions that my trustee thinks fit in my trustee’s absolute discretion to be used for the provision of wheelchairs, medical aides and equipment to support disabled persons in the Lower South East of South Australia and I DECLARE that the receipt of the authorised officer for the time being of each organisation benefiting under this clause shall be sufficient discharge to my trustee. 9. I EMPOWER my trustee to:9.1 Sell the whole or any part of my estate.9.2 Appropriate and partition any real or personal property forming part of my estate (and for such purposes to determine the values thereof) to or towards the share of any beneficiary or beneficiaries under this my will.10.I DIRECT that any capital gains tax payable in my estate is to be paid without any adjustment or apportionment as between any of the beneficiaries under this my will.DATED the day of 2013