Background
Background to the litigation
This is an application pursuant to section 7 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) for an order authorising the making of a will. Background On 25 September 2013, Bronte Malcolm Dennis filed a summons seeking an order that the Court approve the making of a will on behalf of his mother, Linley Joy Dennis. The application was initially brought for the purpose of rectifying an existing will during the lifetime of the testatrix to obviate the need for a rectification application after her death. However, it developed to include a number of other suggested variations and additions. Mrs Dennis is a widow with three adult children: Bronte, Sonya Lynne Peters and Verity Anne Dennis. Mrs Dennis has five grandchildren: Bronte’s son and daughter, Sonya’s three sons and Verity’s son. At the time of the application, Mrs Dennis was 69 years of age and suffering from dementia as a consequence of Alzheimer’s disease. On 26 September 2013, the Registrar of Probates made orders, inter alia, appointing a legal practitioner, Gaetano Anthony Aiello, guardian ad litem for Mrs Dennis. Sonya has an enduring power of attorney for Mrs Dennis. With her late husband, Mrs Dennis established a substantial family farming business. That business is now conducted by Bronte, with his wife Angela and his son Ashley. Bronte and his family derive their livelihood from the business. Mrs Dennis also owns investment properties and farming land. Mrs Dennis’ assets are substantial, comprising primarily of interests in real property. Mrs Dennis executed wills in 1990, 1998 and 2007. The effect of the 1990 and 1998 wills was that Mrs Dennis’ interest in the farming business and certain farming land would pass to Bronte, or his son in the event that he predeceased Mrs Dennis. It is the 2007 will that Bronte seeks to rectify. The 2007 will, inter alia, provides:3. I Direct that any farming land in my name must not be sold within ten years of my death. 4. I Give all my estate in each of the following:4.1 all my share in Lincolnfields Pty Ltd ACN 080 630 584, and4.2 all entitlements of whatever nature due or owing to me by or in respect of the Lincolnfields Family Trustto my son Bronte Malcolm Dennis subject to the provisions of clause 6....6.If my husband Malcolm John Dennis dies before me then my son Bronte Malcolm Dennis must assume liability for any debt that may be owing at my death in respect of the residence and land at 31 Olive Parade Kadina. 7.I Give all my estate and interest in the farming partnership business known as Lincolnfields Pastoral inclusive of all entitlements and monies of whatever the nature due to me by or in the respect of that partnership as follows:7.1 if my husband Malcolm John Dennis survives me for thirty days then for my husband,7.2 if my husband does not survive me for that period then to my son Bronte Malcolm Dennis....19.1If my son Bronte Malcolm Dennis dies before me then his son Ashley will take the share and interest under clauses 3 and 6 of this Will which Bronte would otherwise have taken but subject to Ashley attaining 25 years of age. Provisions were made for other assets to be distributed to Mrs Dennis’ daughters, Sonya and Verity.
Decision
Reasons for decision
GRAY J
The affidavit evidence of Bronte and Mr Aiello states that Mrs Dennis would not have reasonably been expected to make any charitable donations in her will. I accept this evidence. Conclusion I am satisfied that Mrs Dennis lacks testamentary capacity, albeit that she has the ability to express general views concerning her testamentary wishes. I am satisfied that an error arose in the numbering of the clauses in the 2007 will. That being the case, I am satisfied that it was Mrs Dennis’ intention in 2007 that Ashley should have the assets referred to in clauses 4 and 7 of the 2007 will. The evidence supports the conclusion that Mrs Dennis’ likely current testamentary intention in that regard had not changed. Insofar as some of the clauses in the proposed will go beyond the 2007 will, those clauses are consistent with the intention expressed in the 2007 will and they reflect Mrs Dennis’ likely current testamentary intentions. I have had regard to factors in section 7 of the Wills Act and the totality of the evidence. I am satisfied that the proposed order authorising the making of a statutory will in the terms set out in Schedule A is reasonable in all the circumstances. Schedule ATHIS IS THE LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT of LINLEY JOY DENNIS of Bute in the State of South Australia Widow authorised by an order dated the 31st day of October 2014 made under section 7 of the Wills Act, 1936.1. I REVOKE all previous Wills and testamentary acts.2.I APPOINT my son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS to be the sole Executor and Trustee of this my Will but if he does not survive me or if he is unable or unwilling to act then I APPOINT my daughters VERITY ANNE DENNIS and SONYA LYNNE PETERS and my daughter in law ANGELA MARIA DENNIS to be the Executors and Trustees hereof. I DECLARE that in the interpretation of this my Will the expression “my Trustees” shall refer to the Executor and Trustee or Executors and Trustees for the time being hereof.3.AS REGARDS “The Lincolnfields Family Trust” (“The Lincolnfields Trust”) , a trust established by Deed dated the 5th day of November 1997:-3.1I APPOINT my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS to be the Appointor of but if he does not survive me then I APPOINT my Trustees and my grandson ASHLEY SCOTT DENNIS to be the Appointor of The Lincolnfields Trust until my said grandson attains or shall have attained the age of thirty years and thereafter I appoint my grandson ASHLEY SCOTT DENNIS to be the sole Appointor of The Lincolnfields Trust provided further if my said grandson does not survive me or he survives me but fails to attain the age of thirty years then I Appoint my Trustees and my granddaughter TAMMYJANE DENNIS to be the Appointor of The Lincolnfields Trust until my said my granddaughter attains or shall have attained the age of thirty years and thereafter I appoint my granddaughter TAMMYJANE DENNIS to be the sole Appointor of The Lincolnfields Trust; and3.2I DECLARE that notwithstanding the abovementioned reference to the Deed establishing The Lincolnfields Trust, the said Trust Deed shall not form part of my Will to be admitted to probate.4.I DIRECT that any farming land forming part of my estate not be sold within ten years of my death.5. SUBJECT to the provisions of Clause 6 of this my Will I GIVE:-5.1 all my shares in Lincolnfields Pty Ltd ACN 080 630 584, and 5.2all entitlements of whatever nature due or owing to me by or in respect of The Lincolnfields Trustto my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS for his own use and benefit absolutely.6.I DIRECT that my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS before having any entitlement to receive the benefits referred to in Clauses 5 and 8 of this my Will shall pay and discharge any money remaining due upon the security of any mortgage secured over the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5766 Folio 612, being the house property at 31 Olive Parade Kadina in the said State (“the Olive Parade property”) and in the event he does not do this within twelve (12) months of the date upon which administration of my estate is granted then the benefits otherwise conferred upon him shall fall into and form part of my residuary estate. 7.I GIVE all my estate and interest in the Olive Parade property to such of my daughters VERITY ANNE DENNIS and SONYA LYNNE PETERS as survive me and if both then as tenants-in-common in equal shares, to the intent that my said daughters shall be entitled to receive the Olive Parade property free of any debt secured thereover.8.I GIVE all my estate and interest in the farming partnership business known as Lincolnfields Pastoral (“the Partnership”) inclusive of all entitlements monies and personal property of whatever nature due to me by or in the respect of the Partnership to my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS for his own use and benefit absolutely CONDITIONAL UPON my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS indemnifying the balance of my estate against any debts and liabilities of the Partnership .9.I GIVE my pianola and all the pianola rolls and accessories to my said daughter VERITY ANNE DENNIS.10.I GIVE all of my personal effects, jewellery, furniture and other personal chattels not hereby otherwise disposed of by this my Will to my Trustees UPON TRUST to divide and distribute among such of them my children grandchildren and great-grandchildren as shall be living at my death in such proportions as my Trustees shall in the absolute discretion of my Trustees think fit without obligation to distribute items to any one or all of my children grandchildren or great-grandchildren nor to ensure equality amongst them.11.I EXPRESS the wish (but without creating a trust or imposing any legal obligation) that my Trustees distribute my said items as they may know or feel to be in accordance with my wishes.12.IN THE EVENT that any of my aforesaid items shall not be divided and distributed as aforesaid within twelve (12) months of my death then I DIRECT that such items shall fall into and form part of my residuary estate. 13.IN THE EVENT that any item or items shall be set aside by my Trustees for any person under the age of eighteen (18) years then I EMPOWER my Trustees to deliver such item or items to the guardian or parent of such beneficiary and the receipt of such guardian or parent shall be a full and sufficient discharge to my Trustees who shall not be obliged to see to the application of the benefits hereby conferred upon such beneficiary.14.Subject to the provisions of clause 4 of this my Will I GIVE all my estate and interest in any farming land forming part of my estate wherever situated to my Trustees and I DIRECT my Trustees TO DIVIDE the same into two equal parts and to hold each equal part upon trust with each of my daughters the said VERITY ANNE DENNIS and the said SONYA LYNNE PETERS who survive me being the Primary Beneficiary of a trust for one such part;14.1IF my said daughters or either of them fail to survive me but leaves a child or children who are living at my death and have attained or attain the age of twenty five years then that grandchild or those grandchildren shall take and if more than one equally between them the part that would otherwise have been held upon trust with his her or their mother as the Primary Beneficiary;14.2IF there is a complete failure of the trusts concerning either of the parts referred to herein then the part in respect of which there has been a complete failure shall be added to the other part the trusts of which have not failed.15.The following terms will apply to each trust established under this Will in respect of which a person is nominated to be the Primary Beneficiary:15.1Once a Primary Beneficiary for that trust is determined pursuant to this Will, the relevant Primary Beneficiary (“the Trustee”) will be the Trustee of the trust.15.2The following words and expressions have the following meanings:(i) “Beneficiaries” means:-15.2.i.1 the Primary Beneficiary; 15.2.i.2any children and remoter issue of the Primary Beneficiary;15.2.i.3 any other child of mine; or 15.2.i.4any spouse, widow or widower of any of the persons named in this sub-clause (ii) “Eligible Beneficiaries” means:-15.2.ii.1 the Beneficiaries or any of them; and15.2.ii.2in the event there is no person or persons who come within the definition of Beneficiaries, my daughters the said VERITY ANNE DENNIS and the said SONYA LYNNE PETERS and any child, children or remoter issue of my said daughters.(iii) “the Trust Fund” means:15.2.iii.1the part of my estate which is to be held on trust for the Primary Beneficiary in accordance with my Will (“Initial Property”); and15.2.iii.2any income or capital added to the Initial Property or representing the same from time to time.(iv)“the vesting day” means the date the Trustee may by Deed or instrument in writing appoint to be the vesting day.15.3Until the vesting day the Trustee shall hold the Trust Fund upon trust to pay divide apply transfer or accumulate all or part of the income and all or part of the capital and all or part of the capital accretions of the Trust Fund to any one or more of the Eligible Beneficiaries in the shares and amounts and at the times as the Trustee may in his or her absolute discretion think fit without any obligation to make payments to all of the Eligible Beneficiaries or to ensure equality among those to whom payments are made.15.4Upon and from the vesting day the Trustee shall hold the Trust Fund or so much thereof as shall then remain and the income thereof for such of the Eligible Beneficiaries who shall then be living or in existence and in such proportions and such manner and for one to the exclusion of the other or others as the Trustee shall in his or her absolute discretion by instrument in writing determine and appoint.15.5If any part or parts of the Trust Fund shall not be effectively or validly disposed of by the trusts above declared in this clause then the respective Trustee shall hold the Trust Fund or so much thereof as then remains for the beneficiaries entitled to my residuary estate and to follow the trusts thereof.16.THE TRUSTEE shall have the following powers and authorities in relation to the trust established under this Will in respect of which a person is nominated to be the Primary Beneficiary, namely to:16.1appoint by Will or instrument in writing a new trustee or new trustees in the place of a trustee or in addition to the Trustee;16.2at any time by Deed add to or vary the powers and authorities vested in the Trustee.17.The Trustee may exercise or concur in exercising all powers and discretions given to the Trustees by the provisions of this Will or by law notwithstanding that the Trustee may have a direct or indirect interest of any kind in the mode or result of the exercise of any such power or discretion and notwithstanding any actual or possible conflict of interest in the exercise of such power or discretion.18.The Trustees and the Trustee from time to time of any trust established by this my Will shall not be required to comply with the provisions of sections 7(1), 7(3), 8(1) and 9 of the Trustee Act 1936 (South Australia) as amended.19.I GIVE all my real and personal not hereby otherwise disposed of to my Trustees UPON TRUST subject to the powers hereinafter contained and subject to Clause 4 of this my Will to sell call in and convert the same into money and to pay my funeral and testamentary expenses and debts any duties in connection with my estate and all charges payable in the administration of my estate and to hold the balance then remaining (“my residuary estate”) for such of my said children BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS, VERITY ANNE DENNIS and SONYA LYNNE PETERS as survive me and if more than one as tenants-in-common in equal shares absolutely PROVIDED HOWEVER:-19.1IF my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS does not survive me then subject to my grandson the said ASHLEY SCOTT DENNIS having attained or attaining the age of thirty (30) years AND complying with the requirements of Clause 6 of this my will, the said ASHLEY SCOTT DENNIS shall take all the share and interest in Clauses 5 and 8 of this my Will which his father would otherwise have taken if he had survived me;19.2IF my said son BRONTE MALCOLM DENNIS fails to survive me and my said grandson ASHLEY SCOTT DENNIS fails to attain a vested interest in the assets referred to in clauses 5 and 8 of this my Will then subject to my granddaughter the said TAMMY JANE DENNIS having attained or attaining the age of thirty (30) years AND complying with the requirements of Clause 6 of this my will, the said TAMMY JANE DENNIS shall take all the share and interest in the assets referred to in Clauses 5 and 8 of this my Will which her brother Ashley Scott Dennis would otherwise have taken if he had survived me and attained the age of thirty years and complied with the requirements of clause 6 of this my Will;19.3SUBJECT to the provisions of clauses 19.1 and 19.2, IF any child of mine does not survive me but leaves a child or children who survive me and have then attained or thereafter attain the age of twenty-one (21) years, those grandchildren shall take and if more than one equally between them the share or other benefit under this Will which his her or their parent would have taken if such parent had survived me.20. I EMPOWER my Trustees to:20.1subject to the provisions of clause 4 of this my Will, exercise all powers given to trustees by law;20.2enter into a lease or sharefarming agreement in respect of any real or leasehold property for such period and on such terms and conditions as my Trustees think fit with power to expend money in repairs and in improvements and to accept surrenders of leases or tenancies,20.3carry on, either alone or in partnership with any person or persons with whom I am in partnership at my death, any business in which I am engaged at my death during such period as my Trustees think fit and my Trustees shall have the fullest discretionary power in all matters relating to the management of that business and may employ engage or dismiss staff and agents and incur liabilities and borrow money and my trustees shall be indemnified out of my estate in respect of all losses or liabilities sustained or incurred in relation to that business,20.4invest any monies requiring investment under this Will in any of the investments that are authorised now or at any future time for trustees by the law of South Australia,20.5borrow money either with or without security and enter into any mortgage, charge, bill of sale or other security over any part of my estate, 20.6exercise all powers and discretions notwithstanding that they or any of them may have a direct or other personal interest in the mode or result of exercising any such power or discretion,20.7subject to the provisions of clause 4 of this my Will at such time, or times, in such manner and on such terms as my Trustees think fit, sell call in or convert into money any part or parts of my estate which do not consist of money,20.8appropriate any part or parts of my estate in full or part satisfaction of the share or interest of any beneficiary in my estate and for such purpose may determine the value of any asset to be so appropriated,20.9postpone the sale calling in and conversion of any part of my estate for such period as my trustees think fit,20.10retain for so long as my Trustees think fit my shares in any company and accept apply for or take up any bonus shares or other rights or benefits made available by any such company and vote in or act as a director or employee of any such company and may receive remuneration for acting in such capacity and my Trustees shall have the fullest discretionary power in all matters relating to my shares in any such company,20.11apply the whole or any part of the contingent or vested share in the capital and income of my estate of any beneficiary under this will for the maintenance education or benefit of that beneficiary and for these purposes may make such payments to the parent or guardian for the time being of that beneficiary without being liable to see to the application thereof,20.12use income, capital or both income and capital to pay capital gains tax levied on the disposal of any asset, and apportion liability for that tax,20.13exercise all discretions and powers in such manner as my Trustees in their absolute discretion think fit,21.I DIRECT that each of my Trustees is entitled to be reimbursed from the assets of my estate and its income for any money spent and liabilities incurred in or about the administration of my estate.22.IF the order of death, whether proved or presumed, of two people is uncertain then this Will is to be construed as if the older person died first.23.IN this my Will any reference to any beneficiary (whether referred to by name or in any other way) shall be deemed to be a reference to the beneficiary personally or at the option of such beneficiary to the trustee of any inter vivos discretionary trust of which such beneficiary is a potential beneficiary or at the further option of the beneficiary any company of which that beneficiary is a director or a shareholder and the option herein provided shall apply to all or any part of such beneficiary’s interest in my estate.24.I DIRECT my Trustees in respect of any gift under this my Will to a beneficiary who is a foreign resident of Australia for income tax purposes, to:24.1reduce the amount of the gift to the foreign resident beneficiary by the amount of any tax payable by virtue of Section 104-215 of the Australian Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 or subsequent corresponding legislation, or24.2obtain a reimbursement from the foreign resident beneficiary for the amount of that tax as a condition precedent to the transmission of the subject matter of that gift.DATED this day of Two thousand and Fourteen.REGISTRAR OF PROBATES